@DoubleDumas @AtomsksSanakan @kissingtruth @ctsbillc @priscian @NdabaningiMoyo @ejwwest @jemmm85517813 @DenisDaly @Konrad_Chapman @JamesWest12 @TMGFlorida @AutumnMandrake @PoyetPatrice @idummkopp @MusicFrom90 @kevhof52 @Proemed45 @Robert76907841 @MarcEHJones @Rebecca74083947 @25_cycle @patfrank830 @Visitor51171015 @rwerkh @Anvndarnamn5 @COrepKdeGraaf @DaleGribble_666 @greenartdf @zebedeem @BennoList @Willard1951 @LxxResearcher @waynejv1973 @VoteBlueUrban @military_1776 @TWTThisIsNow @BrknMan @RCownie @ICcrapdaily @ClimateRetorts @CymaticWave @DarrenDrpage @SGMTrailbuilder @CyfraithEcocide @MarkOgge @JrmeBrwnCt @TheDisproof @judithcallagha9 Flipping low temperatures upside down counts as Mannipulation.

@sjsimmons @PushFourLeft @MLeiter42 @TrixX306 @phlannelphysics @Mark_A_Lunn @jimdtweet @Michael_D_Crow @jgatta06 @Kenneth72712993 @dafalgoutDennis @JJ9621073059835 @WHPAAD @priscian @BubbasRanch @jgorman2424 @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @LexWaters7 @CDCollins5269 @BobPartridge16 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @JamesAbbott2013 @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 If you exclude the bristlecone pines (as recommended by the NAS panel), there are no hockey sticks left to mine for.

@sjsimmons @PushFourLeft @MLeiter42 @TrixX306 @phlannelphysics @Mark_A_Lunn @jimdtweet @Michael_D_Crow @jgatta06 @Kenneth72712993 @dafalgoutDennis @JJ9621073059835 @WHPAAD @priscian @BubbasRanch @jgorman2424 @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @LexWaters7 @CDCollins5269 @BobPartridge16 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @JamesAbbott2013 @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 You don't get a hockey stick if you remove the North American tree ring data from the MBH98 data set.

@sjsimmons @PushFourLeft @MLeiter42 @TrixX306 @phlannelphysics @Mark_A_Lunn @jimdtweet @Michael_D_Crow @jgatta06 @Kenneth72712993 @dafalgoutDennis @JJ9621073059835 @WHPAAD @priscian @BubbasRanch @jgorman2424 @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @LexWaters7 @CDCollins5269 @BobPartridge16 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @JamesAbbott2013 @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 They don't. Doing it correctly means excluding the bristlecone pine data.

@sjsimmons @PushFourLeft @MLeiter42 @TrixX306 @phlannelphysics @Mark_A_Lunn @jimdtweet @Michael_D_Crow @jgatta06 @Kenneth72712993 @dafalgoutDennis @JJ9621073059835 @WHPAAD @priscian @BubbasRanch @jgorman2424 @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @LexWaters7 @CDCollins5269 @BobPartridge16 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @JamesAbbott2013 @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 None of the "CENSORED" PCs is a hockey stick.

@PushFourLeft @sjsimmons @MLeiter42 @TrixX306 @phlannelphysics @Mark_A_Lunn @jimdtweet @Michael_D_Crow @jgatta06 @Kenneth72712993 @dafalgoutDennis @JJ9621073059835 @WHPAAD @priscian @BubbasRanch @jgorman2424 @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @LexWaters7 @CDCollins5269 @BobPartridge16 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @JamesAbbott2013 @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 Fun fact: The "CENSORED" results Mann deleted when M&M examined his work were among the files released in the Climategate hack a few years later.

RT @AMAZlNGNATURE: This is why I pay for the internet

RT @AMAZlNGNATURE: Dog Shocks Itself On Fence, Donkey Laughs About It😂

@sjsimmons @BobPartridge16 @jgatta06 @jimdtweet @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @BubbasRanch @LexWaters7 @MLeiter42 @CDCollins5269 @Kenneth72712993 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @JamesAbbott2013 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 I said that he *added* a linear trend to the data.

@sjsimmons @BobPartridge16 @jgatta06 @jimdtweet @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @BubbasRanch @LexWaters7 @MLeiter42 @CDCollins5269 @Kenneth72712993 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @JamesAbbott2013 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 Already done.

@sjsimmons @BobPartridge16 @jgatta06 @jimdtweet @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @BubbasRanch @LexWaters7 @MLeiter42 @CDCollins5269 @Kenneth72712993 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @JamesAbbott2013 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 It's unclear what you're asking for.

@sjsimmons @BobPartridge16 @jgatta06 @jimdtweet @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @BubbasRanch @LexWaters7 @MLeiter42 @CDCollins5269 @Kenneth72712993 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @JamesAbbott2013 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 He added a linear trend to the data after 1750.

@BobPartridge16 @sjsimmons @jgatta06 @jimdtweet @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @BubbasRanch @LexWaters7 @MLeiter42 @CDCollins5269 @Kenneth72712993 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @JamesAbbott2013 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 Mann also included the data Briffa "corrected" by adding a linear trend after 1750 to hide the decline.

@PushFourLeft @sjsimmons @patfrank830 @jgatta06 @jimdtweet @isaacscradle @MLeiter42 @BobPartridge16 @WHPAAD @LexWaters7 @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @BubbasRanch @JamesAbbott2013 @Kenneth72712993 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @CDCollins5269 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 Tim Osborn advised Mann not to tell lies but was ignored.

@sjsimmons @BobPartridge16 @FreeSpeech4U_Me @jgatta06 @TrixX306 @LexWaters7 @patfrank830 @jimdtweet @isaacscradle @MLeiter42 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @BubbasRanch @JamesAbbott2013 @Kenneth72712993 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @CDCollins5269 @TypicalDeviant @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 Mann used Tiljander's data upside down. Kaufman did it too, but unlike Mann he acknowledged the error.

RT @babadoookie: It’s almost been a year so imma tell the story bout how I watched my roommate die from stage 4 lung cancer

RT @DudespostingWs: Dude just invented a new wealth hack. Online gurus don’t know about this yet

RT @VertigoWarrior: The terrifying beauty of the Ocean. A thread ⚠️Thread NOT suitable for sensitive people