“Fourth graders who used tablets in nearly all their classes scored 14 points lower on a reading test than students who never used them. Researchers called the score gap ‘equivalent to a full grade level’ of learning.”
@HKorbey
via
@techreview
#SoR
In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I review the first two episodes of
@ehanford
’s new podcast, “Sold a Story,” which homes in on the complicity of
@HeinemannPub
and four of its top authors in America’s flawed approach to teaching reading.
@MichaelPetrilli
A fair warning from
@rpondiscio
for
#scienceofreading
supporters, of which I count myself a member. If we don’t place enough emphasis on background knowledge for broad reading competence, we shouldn’t be surprised if and when
#SoR
is consigned to the ashbin of ‘failed reforms.’
The fierce ideological tug-of-war over reading has a long, tortuous history that dates back centuries. For the latest issue of
@NRO
magazine—a special “back to school” edition—I wrote a primer on the reading wars and the science of reading. Check it out:
“62% of Americans and 68% of students are reluctant to share their true political views... and a third of Americans say that they’re worried about losing a job or job opportunities if they express their true political views.”
@jon_rauch
via
@Peter_Wehner
“Police were called to his house 45 times before the tragedy. His mother’s friend called the sheriff’s office, telling them ‘this might be Columbine in the making’—but they never called her back.”
@DeAngelisCorey
#WhyMeadowDied
@AndrewPollackFL
@maxeden99
“We’ve poured hundreds of billions of extra dollars into education in just the last decade, and the money just sloshes around for the benefit of the education bureaucracy while the students fall further behind.”
@JonahDispatch
@thedispatch
If every school district in America could increase the amount of instructional time (summer school, after-school, lengthen the day/year) and recruit an army of capable tutors, it still wouldn’t be a strong enough treatment to make up for the academic losses kids have experienced.
The 10 Best Podcasts of 2023 via
@edockterman
Number 3: Sold a Story
“Journalist
@ehanford
, who has been raising the alarm about [the nation's reading crisis] for years, lays out how America got here in a show that plays like she's unwinding a mystery.”
School districts across the nation have been shuttering their doors this month on short notice to provide “teacher mental health” days. In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I look at how this troubling trend could play out.
#NoSchoolNovember
@MichaelPetrilli
In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I review
@ehanford
’s new documentary, which keeps the momentum going on an important nat'l conversation about curriculum reform & how our nation’s children are (or aren’t) being taught to read
@apmreports
@MichaelPetrilli
“Smartphones are basically kryptonite for learning… If kids have access to a phone, they will text. They will check their social media. They will not pay attention to the teacher or to each other.”
@JonHaidt
via
@megoliver
@analisanovak
@CBSMornings
LISTEN:
@teachcardona
on the "ay bendito effect" via
@ElissaNadworny
: "Oftentimes when we see students dealing with things in their life through poverty, there are lowered expectations to say, ‘Ay bendito, poor thing...’ That's the worst thing we can do.”
A bracing and sobering read by
@rpondiscio
via
@TheFP
on today’s classroom controversies. The upshot: What happens in classrooms is a black box… and will likely remain so for the foreseeable future.
@AEIeducation
“Good reading instruction isn’t boring for children. Maybe adults find parts of it boring. But this shouldn’t be about what adults want. It should be about what kids need.”
@ehanford
via
@apmreports
#SoR
#EIE22
“You cannot use poverty as an excuse. That’s the most important lesson. It’s so important, I want to shout it from the mountaintop. [What Mississippi teaches is that] we shouldn’t be giving up on children.”
@ProfDavidDeming
via
@NickKristof
@nytopinion
Thirty years ago, a nine-day teachers strike in Los Angeles “spread chaos” across the city. Will history repeat itself on Thursday? This potential shutdown might have been avoided with collective bargaining reform via
@educationgadfly
WATCH: “The inconvenient fact is that we need 4 million men & women to staff America’s public school classrooms. A number that large means that they will be ordinary people—not saints, not superstars.”
@rpondiscio
via
@SenBillCassidy
@GOPHELP
@AEIeducation
WATCH: “We have failed at our core mission. When parents send their children to our schools...there are 2 things that they should be able to expect & we’re supposed to be able to deliver. Their child should be safe & their child should learn how to read.”
@DOEChancellor
#NYCReads
“While children from poor families often enter school at a disadvantage when it comes to language comprehension, if they’re taught how to decode they’ve just been given their best shot at catching up”
@ehanford
via
@nytopinion
#elachat
#GettingReadingRight
“Excessive use of smartphones & social media is...damaging students’ academic performance...At this point, the question isn’t whether phones should be banned from classrooms, but why more schools haven’t done so already.”
@opinion
@TimOBrien
@TimothyBLavin
The number of uncertified teachers is beside the point. The real question is how many of
@HoustonISD
’s 10,000+ teachers are highly effective.
#txed
#HISD
Houston ISD has 2,097 uncertified teachers out of more than 10,000 teachers for 2024-25, according to district records first provided to and reported by ABC13 KTRK.
@Yamiche
"I submit that an individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for law." – MLK
Yes, it’s largely ceremonial, but still hard not to notice the states in which governors 𝘥𝘪𝘥 𝘯𝘰𝘵 issue a proclamation in support of
#SchoolChoiceWeek
.
“Black 11th-graders [in
@SFUnified
] fall just short of the threshold for being considered proficient in 4th-grade math and well below the cut point for demonstrating 5th-grade proficiency. The situation is appalling.”
@tomloveless99
#caedu
@recallsfboe
+1
“I still dream of the parallel universe where President Mitch Daniels is eating a bowl of soup alone at the Resolute Desk and people find that to be an outrageous sign of disrespect.”
@JonahDispatch
via
@JonahRemnant
@jdickerson
How heavy a hand should state legislatures take WRT the nuts and bolts of curriculum & instruction? In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I suggest that Colorado’s forceful attention to early reading is worthy of lawmakers' attention.
#edcolo
@MichaelPetrilli
The warning signs were in plain sight, but people kept looking the other way. Read this disquieting excerpt from the new book by
@AndrewPollackFL
and
@maxeden99
, and let's resolve never to allow such a dereliction of duty to happen again.
Hard to overstate this point: Journalists rarely delve into the minutiae of instructional practice. We need more, not less, of the in-depth focus
@ehanford
brought to bear in her outstanding podcast.
#SoR
#soldastory
WATCH: A Virginia state board member wanted to strike a line from the state’s annual report that said learning loss was most severe among kids whose schools were closed longest. She asserted that the evidence for this was “inconclusive at best.”
@arotherham
was having none of it.
“Groupthink married to an invincible & unreflective confidence that your side is always right led to all manner of mistakes [about shutdowns & school closings].
@ProfEmilyOster
was villainized & attacked for dissenting from the groupthink.”
@JonahDispatch
“A half century ago, a majority of the world’s people had always been illiterate; now we are approaching 90% adult literacy. There have been large gains in girls’ education—and few forces change the world so much as the empowerment of women.”
@NickKristof
“Men are sorely needed in America’s classrooms. As
@RichardvReeves
notes, there are more women flying U.S. military planes than there are men teaching kindergarten.”
@JonahDispatch
Mark August 6th on your calendars: That’s when
@apmreports
will drop what will assuredly be another stellar contribution by
@ehanford
to the ongoing debate about reading instruction.
@EducatePodcast
WATCH: “It's rare to see an intervention have a negative impact. It’s common to see [one] have no impact or very little impact… It’s rare to have a negative impact. And that’s what the research [on Reading Recovery] found.”
@ehanford
via
@KJWinEducation
“In a glorious piece of craft,
@ehanford
closes the series by having young children reading the credits. It reminds the listener what a vital exercise it is to learn to read, and that it should never be sacrificed to politics or business.”
@fiona_mccann
“The money in education follows the brick building, it doesn’t follow the child. I don’t care about the brick building. I care about the human life. We don’t get do-overs for our children.”
@WinsomeSears
via
@tunkuv
@WSJopinion
#vagov
#vaed
“In 1970, the U.S. had a student-teacher ratio of 27 to 1; today, it’s 16 to 1. If we’d invested in raising teacher pay rather than adding teachers… median teacher pay in the U.S. today would be north of $140,000.”
@rickhess99
@AEIeducation
@AEI
In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I lament New York’s shameful attempt to blind its parents and families to the gaps and shortfalls besetting its students. Lowering the bar is the very last thing states should be doing.
@SecCardona
@MichaelPetrilli
“In schools and classrooms, we should be seeing people make decisions based on evidence, b/c there really is no need to guess at this point. There’s no reason why we can’t teach most children to read.”
@TheFCRR
’s
@TheDrPT
via
@mandy_mclaren
@kymyona_burk
“Virtually all kids can learn to read — if they’re taught with approaches that use what scientists have discovered about how the brain does the work of reading. But many teachers don’t know this science”
@ehanford
“Phonics alone isn’t enough to turn children into skilled readers—they also need to acquire broad knowledge & vocab. But if we don’t [provide] all children w/ the skills to decode words, most h.s. grads [won't be] proficient readers.”
@natwexler
@ehanford
“When districts or schools that had some of the lowest [proficiency] numbers [see] almost 100% of their kids ready & passing our third grade gate, you can’t unsee that. So now that you know it’s possible, there’s just no excuse.”
@kymyona_burk
@NickKristof
“Only about half of 3rd graders perform at grade level on state assessments. It is even lower for poor & minority students. This is both horrific & unnecessary. Studies show that ‘virtually every student could be reading on level by the end of 1st grade.’”
Kids are already back in school in much of the country, thanks in part to red states and
@GOP
governors. In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I examine the question of how to engender similar movement in deep blue states with strong unions.
@MichaelPetrilli
“For a long time no one really knew how people learn[ed] to [read]. But now we know. Hopefully the [reading] war is finally coming to an end, as more people understand [the] scientific research about reading and how it works.”
@ehanford
via
@WhitebdAdvisor
Choice proponents risk making a tactical error if they allow choice to become a brand of one party rather than a 𝘷𝘢𝘭𝘶𝘦 deemed worthy of protection by both.
Educational choice is the way to diffuse the culture war, not inflame it. Choice lets everyone win. While I respect the authors & know they support choice, this is not the way to get it done imo. My Northstar is choice for all regardless of politics, culture or anything else.
“Mississippi has shown that even if you don’t solve child poverty, even if you don’t solve racism, then you can still get kids reading by the end of third grade.”
@NickKristof
via
@MichelMcQMartin
#SoR
“The most important trend in the world may be the revolution in child mortality, the enormous decline in global poverty, and the vast increase in literacy that many people seem unaware of...”
@NickKristof
via
@nytopinion
“I hunger for someone to take responsibility for the many for whom it’s too late, those lifelong floundering readers whom Jack Fletcher calls ‘instructional casualties,’ who did not receive the ‘needed instruction early in development.’”
@kendrahurleynyc
“Millions of blacks are relegated to some of the worst-performing schools… In [many] cities, most black students cannot read or do math at grade level. Standardized tests aren’t causing these disparities, just revealing them.”
@jasonrileywsj
#AssessmentHQ
“Working families should not be forced to pay taxes to fund a public-school system that is not providing full-time public school, and pay for the cost of (additional) school or child-care on top of it through no fault of their own.”
@JoeBorelliNYC
@nypost
To wit, per
@rpondiscio
: "At $14.99 per book, you could buy 10 copies [of 'Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons'] for every Title I elementary school for less than $3M—not even a rounding error on the $120B schools [received] from Uncle Sam..."
Teaching kids to read could be done very cheaply, and if we focused on that, even at the expense of other skills, we would be better off.
The amount of money wasted in education is astounding.
“What Florida and Mississippi have in common is a long-term commitment to eradicating illiteracy and the willingness to strengthen their policies and implementation efforts to achieve it.”
@kymyona_burk
via
@ExcelinEd
#SoR
#KnowBetterDoBetter
“If ever there were a school year when teachers, policymakers and parents need as much data as they can get to fully understand what is going on with education for the next generation, this is the year.”
@Suntimes
#AssessmentHQ
Ed officials in California are playing politics w/ test score data from exams taken by students last spring. In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I examine their bad behavior, and how the feds have made matters worse by turning a blind eye.
@MichaelPetrilli
“Dems have 𝘢𝘯 𝘦𝘥 𝘱𝘰𝘭𝘪𝘤𝘺 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘣𝘭𝘦𝘮. Right now, the Biden Administration is trying to curtail charter school growth. This is an odd position for an Administration that says it wants to ‘center’ Black & Hispanic Americans.”
@arotherham
#BackOff
The most dangerous anti-charter bill in Colorado’s history went down in flames today. Hats off to
@ReadyColo
,
@COCharterSchool
, and all of the champions who came out today on behalf of our children and families.
#edcolo
#copolitics
#coleg
The principle of school transparency has undeniable appeal, yet we can’t avoid asking about the motives behind these efforts. In my latest for
@educationgadfly
, I interrogate the theory of action behind the burgeoning transparency trend.
@MichaelPetrilli