shewon.org
@shewon_org
Followers
1,032
Following
123
Media
30
Statuses
505
This account exists to record and celebrate the achievements of the female athletes who were displaced by males in women's sporting events.
On the podium
Joined January 2024
Don't wanna be here?
Send us removal request.
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
NUNEW AT IMPACT
• 446391 Tweets
LINGORM LOVE YOUR SKIN
• 279902 Tweets
Manchester United
• 100189 Tweets
TAITAITUAN LIVE WITH BUILD
• 56977 Tweets
ROOM IN CENTRAL BLOC
• 55310 Tweets
Mazraoui
• 54880 Tweets
De Ligt
• 52259 Tweets
#gangłysego
• 49345 Tweets
No.0
• 45036 Tweets
Leeds
• 36487 Tweets
ハートの日
• 32909 Tweets
#高校球児ランキング
• 24946 Tweets
#まぁいっかでいっか
• 17597 Tweets
Happy Qixi Day Patrick🩷
• 17475 Tweets
#キスマイ_みんなで誕生日会
• 12860 Tweets
リゼロコラボ
• 10611 Tweets
Pinned Tweet
Do you know of a female athlete who lost out on a medal, scholarship or other opportunity due to being forced to compete against a man?
Please DM us or submit it to:
16
287
422
@Lea_Christina4
@ABDanielleSmith
He rants and raves at you because you're the strong, accomplished woman he can never be. He's a pathetic loser of a man and deep down he knows it.
0
2
56
Veronica Garcia (née Donovan Brown), a male athlete who competes in girls' sports, would have placed 24th in the boys' division. Instead, he placed 1st in the girls' division, displacing the rightful winners:
- 🥇Lauren Matthew
- 🥈Andee Kroiss
- 🥉Naomi Taylor
👟Male track runner Veronica Garcia won the WOMEN's varsity 400m on Saturday in Washington.
@wiaawa
He's currently ranked 1st in the League & 4th overall for girls in the state. This is the teenager's 2nd name change (Donovan Brown ➡️ Davina Brown ➡️ Veronica Garcia)...🧵
167
383
986
5
20
51
We get that math is hard for you, but don't worry, we are here to help. As of today:
- 33% of women on the list would have won 1st place 🥇
- 30% would have won 2nd place 🥈
- 28% would have won 3rd place 🥉
@PhoTaeToes
@Skylark_twit
@CarilynJohnson
you know that 99.5% of ppl on that list would have still lost if the transwoman never competed?
meaning they did "loose their spot" or "lost their trophy" bc they would still have never got either of them
3
0
0
1
7
27
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
Leor is correct. You never address the argument that even though something may be relatively rare, it is still wrong.
It’s rare that your house gets burgled, as compared to all existing houses not getting burgled. It’s still wrong.
1
0
25
Another case in point of lazy keyboard warriors making stuff up without doing a modicum of research. is run entirely by volunteers and has received no money from outside organizations. Ours is a labor of love ❤️
0
3
23
A big congrats to the real winners of the New England Girls High Jump Championship:
- 🥇 Zoe Santos
- 🥈 Macy Daigle
- 🥉 Hannah Santos
Those were great jumps - well done!
1
3
21
@roegue7
@AMMcCormack2
@CarilynJohnson
@mcuban
@jordanbpeterson
What "advanced biology" do you have to share with us that will demonstrate that men who take hormones remove their male advantage in sports?
See below for some of these advantages.
3
1
21
@VeronikaSimms
@CarilynJohnson
What “statistics” do you have to share with us to support your position?
0
0
16
Male athletes don't always win in women's sports, but they do tilt the playing field and make a mockery of fair competition.
Drawing a conclusion about male advantage based on how often they win is a logical fallacy.
@shewon_org
@DaraMorefield
@LeorSapir
Trans women do not have an advantage, otherwise they would win more
3
0
0
0
2
17
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
Leor is correct that the website documents what happens to women’s sports when males participate. You’re harping on the fact that we can’t document every sporting event ever, when that’s irrelevant. The point is to address the very common argument of “this never happens”.
1
0
17
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
We have never tried to determine how many events in the whole entire world have ever had a male competing in the women’s category. The fact that you bring this up tells me you’re innumerate as well as illiterate.
1
0
16
Adult male beats 11 year old girl on the way to winning a national championship in women's snooker.
He's a man
"Hunter is the National Women’s Champion
Jamie Hunter defeated Mary Talbot-Deegan to win the 2023 Inter County Logistics English Women’s Snooker Championship"
#SaveWomensSports
92
153
719
0
1
15
@MalcolmSheppard
@SCMacNeil
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
Of the 300 men and boys listed on the site, nearly all of them are in college or older, not that it matters. We "track" them in order to disprove the common argument that "this never happens" as well as change policies that enable it to happen.
2
1
15
@PinchesLynne
Could someone please link to the full list of results? Who came 2nd, 3rd, etc. Can't find it on the website for some reason.
2
0
14
There is no evidence whatsoever that female athletes would perform as "equals" to their male counterparts after 3 years of testosterone.
Activists like the below have no problem making stuff up, though!
@Phildidgee
@lydlife
Again, your graphs are skewed because trans men have to immediately transition to the mens when they take T.
If they took T for 3+ years, you would see them as equals to cis men.
Trans have been allowed in the Olympics since 2004 and 0 have won gold.
3
0
1
0
2
12
@SamanthaBartosz
@Muttmere1
It doesn't matter why they do it - that's irrelevant. We want to change the rules so that they can't do it.
Female athletes (and our supporters) are rightfully angry about this injustice.
1
2
12
@hollybots24
@anne_joseypye
@Seeker66173291
@TatumT_WG
@Perlican3
@sharrond62
They are male athletes who competed against female athletes in a women's event. But sure, keep dismissing the point with semantics.
0
1
10
@mo73183
We're not sure if poker or eSports are affected by male sporting advantage. It's possible that eSports are, because of slight male advantage in hand-eye coordination and reaction times. It would be great to get more info on this.
That said, we want to document these niche sports
1
0
9
A slightly lighter man in a similar category in the men's competition lifted ~74kg in the snatch and ~94kg in the clean & jerk.
The man competing in the women's competition lifted ~55kg in the snatch and ~68kg in the clean & jerk. He would have come last in the men's
🏋️♀️ The "thing" they say "never happens" happened again... A male won a women's competition at the Masters National Weightlifting Championships in Nevada. Read more about it ⤵️
@Outkick
@ianmSC
@Riley_Gaines_
@PaulaYScanlan
@bfheartwarrior
@Lea_Christina4
26
65
210
0
4
9
@Winger_ren
@CarilynJohnson
@KatyMontgomerie
Men don't "statistically underperform in every [women's] sport at every level". That's just a bald-faced lie.
0
0
7
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
It's unfair because males have a physiological advantage over females, so we have defined a category in sports to exclude this male sporting advantage. Allowing some males to cross over into this category is unfair, even if a particular male is smaller or weaker than other males.
0
0
8
@MalcolmSheppard
@SCMacNeil
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
Tracking instances of men winning medals in women's sports = not creepy
Men getting changed in women's locker rooms = creepy
2
1
7
@oolon
@BohemianHarpy
@AlexSmith90014
@StrangelyCurio
@staysafe0325
@jk_rowling
Since you understand "basic logic", you'll surely address the fallacies inherent in your claims:
- Non sequitur (when the conclusion doesn't follow from the premise) and false criteria (using inappropriate criteria to make a judgment): just because men have not won medals in
1
0
6
People often stoop to the argument that because a cheater doesn't always clinch first place, his actions are somehow absolved of any real advantage. Male advantage doesn't guarantee victory, but it does tilt the playing field and make a mockery of the spirit of competition.
@kinjones29
@OccasionalIntel
@c0mput3r_V1ru5
@xroxip_magic
@PorazonyC
@AriDrennen
The trans athletes brought up in some of them literally don't win first place in many of them. If they truly had an unfair advantage, how come Trans-women athletes don't win 100% or above 90% of the time?
2
0
1
0
1
7
@oolon
@AlexSmith90014
@StrangelyCurio
@staysafe0325
@jk_rowling
The fact that men haven't yet won medals in women's events at the Olympics doesn't support the conclusion that there isn't a problem in women's sports more broadly.
0
0
6
@oftchance
@JNargent
@Kasandroid
@babybeginner
@bennite75
@murphy_ld
@Martina
@GovEvers
Please enlighten us how an unfit, middle-aged male weightlifter with relatively poor technique made it to the women's Olympics competing against fit, young women, where he'd have had zero chance of competing against men? Could it be a boost? Provided by male sporting advantage?
1
0
5
@SCMacNeil
@MalcolmSheppard
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
Yes, it happens a lot! Their position is indefensible so they have to lie, evade, distract, appeal to emotion, etc.
1
0
7
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
You seem confused about the arguments we are and aren't making. Male athletes competing in women's sports is unfair because they have a physiological performance advantage that has been well established and extensively documented. Therefore any instance of it occurring is unjust.
1
0
7
@MalcolmSheppard
@SCMacNeil
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
We object to them competing in women's sports, which, as you know, is not just "living their lives". And you think documenting their names and linking to public news articles about them is "stalking", which makes you a deeply unserious person. Get outta here with that rubbish.
2
0
7
@TracyExplains
Flippant response that shows you know nothing about the subject. If you allow men to cross over into women's sports where there are limited medals, scholarships and spots on the team (and whereas the reverse is virtually impossible) then you are taking "pie" away from women.
0
0
6
@HomoDorkimus
@MaudMaron
@sfmcguire79
Oh please - you don't even accept "male" as a word we can use. You've deemed our point of view hateful before the discussion has even started. Pointless.
0
0
7
@oftchance
@JNargent
@Kasandroid
@babybeginner
@bennite75
@murphy_ld
@Martina
@GovEvers
The site doesn't draw conclusions about male advantage from the data at all. The proof of male advantage is already established in the scientific evidence, as well as in common sense, which you seem to have tossed out for political purposes.
2
0
6
@DaneHave
@mason_garry
@CanadaKlr
@GlenandJuice66
@Fluffy07786365
@Martina
@sharrond62
@Daley_thompson
@mara_yamauchi
Let's start with this:
1. Begging the question (aka circular reasoning)
The statement assumes what it is trying to prove: that prioritizing fairness in sports inherently means neglecting the human rights of male athletes who identify as women. It does not prove why this must
1
1
5
Yes, we check every single name before publishing it to the website.
If you find any errors, please submit them to the website or DM us here.
0
0
6
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
We are not saying that all male athletes are "hulking giants that dominate women's sports." That's a straw man. We are saying that any and all male participation in women's sports is unfair. One instance out of *any* number of competitions is unfair to women.
1
0
5
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
You keep posting this comment as if you think it’s clever but you never answer: how many cases would it take for it to become a problem? Is there any amount?
1
0
4
Women deserve fair competition in all sports, even the "less obvious ones" that you scoff at, such as badminton, cricket and darts.
a transphobe recently sent me as evidence of how trans women athletes are taking over women’s sports with their “inherent biological advantage,” and aside from the less obvious sports, some of the ones they have on here.. LMAO
2
0
2
0
0
5
@hollybots24
@anne_joseypye
@Seeker66173291
@TatumT_WG
@Perlican3
@sharrond62
Your deeply deluded opinion that there's no male advantage in sports is based on a Pink News article which does not reference a "scientific report", as you claim, but an activist-driven screed that has been debunked time and again by actual scientists.
2
0
5
This is a fallacy. Males have an innate sporting advantage over females. Just because many male athletes don't succeed in women's sports doesn't mean they don't have an advantage. It just means that they are mediocre male athletes.
@twosillykittens
@SophieRunning
@jonathanliew
But you admit they won't win, so difficult to argue they have an advantage. They either have an innate advantage (and should therefore succeed) or they don't and there is no impact
1
0
0
0
0
5
This should be obvious but does indeed make the argument that men's participation in women's sports is unfair.
@KatjaInTheAct
@AngelinaBlu35
@ProfDaveAndress
This is a propaganda website. It's not even making an argument that trans women's participation is unfair, it's literally just an argument for complete segregation, apropos of nothing
No trans woman has surpassed cis women in any sport on the planet
2
0
0
0
0
5
@CrunchAlias
@WeAreKETURA
They don't say "male woman" and "female woman" because the idea of it is so absurd that even they can't say it with a straight face. But it is what they mean. So, they made up a Latin prefix to obscure their absurd idea and they wriggle out of any direct confrontation about it.
2
1
5
@qb_eagles
@Martina
@kimobra
@jemelehill
@LurieFavors
How many events before it becomes a problem for you? Is there any number?
4
0
5
@SmilerTurner
@AmyBrewKnights
@geoffrey_best
@cathydevine56
@mPinoe
How many cases would it take for it to become a problem for you?
1
0
4
@SendDopaminePls
@Stephen_Fremel
@LarsonGantry
@Independent_46
@_FlutterGirl
@SM26152985
@KevlarKitten
@XxXSmokeyXx
@TheFamousArtBR
Without the sex category, we would see virtually no women in elite sports anywhere, ever. Are you arguing against the existence of the female category?
1
0
3
@hollybots24
@anne_joseypye
@Seeker66173291
@TatumT_WG
@Perlican3
@sharrond62
As an aside, three male athletes won medals in the 2016 Women's Olympic 800m. They won gold, silver and bronze, bumping three female athletes off the podium. I'm sure you'll now move the goalposts or explain it away with a flippant comment.
1
0
4
@DaneHave
@CanadaKlr
@mason_garry
@GlenandJuice66
@Fluffy07786365
@Martina
@sharrond62
@Daley_thompson
@mara_yamauchi
The site exists because we believe that allowing male athletes to compete in women's sports is unfair to women. You can feel free to disagree, but you should also provide a coherent argument for why. Calling people names is what doesn't help anyone.
1
0
4
@Stephen_Fremel
@LarsonGantry
@Independent_46
@_FlutterGirl
@SendDopaminePls
@SM26152985
@KevlarKitten
@XxXSmokeyXx
@TheFamousArtBR
This is a fallacy. Males have an innate sporting advantage over females. Just because many male athletes don't beat women "ALL THE TIME" doesn't mean they don't have an advantage. It means that they are mediocre male athletes competing against excellent female athletes.
1
0
4
@MattChenault
@Sac_TERF_Ca
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
The non-athletic competitions are in a separate table and are not counted as part of the total. Which ones are you accusing of being fake?
1
0
4
@CaraPac46808618
@kinjones29
@cathydevine56
@mPinoe
It’s not theory. The studies referenced above show actual data on male vs. female physiologies with and without hormones, which is what you asked for. On the She Won website, you can see hundreds of women who have lost opportunities to men. Are you done moving the goalposts yet?
1
0
3
@Coach_Schmitt1
@emitchell321
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
I understand how governing bodies work. I happen to disagree with the ones that allow men to compete against women. The fact that you call my position “hate-filled” just reveals your bias and inability to have a productive discussion.
1
0
4
@Coach_Schmitt1
@emitchell321
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
“Let the sporting bodies decide” and “this is a pretend issue” doesn’t answer the question. What should the sporting bodies decide? If you were being honest you’d admit it’s unfair for men to compete against women. But this issue has become so political that you won’t be honest.
0
0
4
@MalcolmSheppard
@SCMacNeil
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
You showed up in this thread with insults, accusations and willful misrepresentations of our arguments. You have nothing to say in, or about, "good faith".
2
0
4
@DaneHave
@mason_garry
@CanadaKlr
@GlenandJuice66
@Fluffy07786365
@Martina
@sharrond62
@Daley_thompson
@mara_yamauchi
You’ve just packed at least 5 logical fallacies into one sentence - it’s actually quite impressive!
1
0
3
@achickie
@IWWWallace
@AmyBrewKnights
@foodandphotos8
@bendreyfuss
Didn't you hear? Ian is the arbiter of what you, personally, are allowed to care about!
2
0
3
@sudden_stars
@Caterin00138072
@fairplaywomen
@WomensRightsNet
@FemaleRunner
@mara_yamauchi
Volunteers vet each submission before it's published via a combination of sources: news articles, videos, rankings published on sporting org websites, our own eyewitness, etc.
1
0
2
@Kohaku_castor
@BLA042021
@Quibilah1
Your criteria are not relevant or applicable here. Every single case of males competing in women's sports (a category designed to exclude the well-documented male performance advantage) is important in its own right, as it documents a breach of ethical sporting conduct.
0
0
2
@SendDopaminePls
@Stephen_Fremel
@LarsonGantry
@Independent_46
@_FlutterGirl
@SM26152985
@KevlarKitten
@XxXSmokeyXx
@TheFamousArtBR
We structure the leagues so there is a category for female athletes. You seem to be arguing for a unisex category, which would cause women to disappear from virtually all elite sports. Doesn’t seem like equality.
2
0
2
@NotToday15032
@KnownHeretic
I suspect what's going on here is that you do understand (intuitively and rightfully) that it's absurd and unjust watching some of these obviously male athletes (no DNA test needed) smashing it in women's competitions. After all, as you say, you do support women's rights.
2
0
2
@Coach_Schmitt1
@emitchell321
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
If you have any evidence that She Won is “conservative” (whatever that even means in this context) or if you have any grounds for asserting the data is “dubious” please feel free to share it.
0
0
3
@RB6K
@Gablesgreen134
@BansheesRUs
@hypotaxia17
@Gemma_clark14
@jk_rowling
Hundreds of women (that we know of) have lost out on medals because of the false and radical ideology that men can be women. Feel free to scoff at it, pretend it's not happening, call us hateful bigots, whatever. You'll just look like an ignoramus while you're at it.
2
0
3
@krisfergohio
@PointyLeopard
@hoosiermomlove
@inmyownfashion2
@biologycounts
See to put things in perspective. High school boys routinely beat women's world records.
1
0
2
@krisfergohio
@PointyLeopard
@hoosiermomlove
@inmyownfashion2
@biologycounts
Men have performance advantages due to male biology. And yes, despite these advantages, an excellent, skilled female athlete can often beat a relatively mediocre male athlete. But, if we didn't have a female-only category, women would disappear from virtually all elite sports.
1
0
2
@hollybots24
@anne_joseypye
@Seeker66173291
@TatumT_WG
@Perlican3
@sharrond62
You keep asking this question as if you're making a clever point, but it just shows poor reasoning skills. The fact that few male athletes have competed in women's events at the Olympics (so far) does not disprove the overwhelming scientific consensus on male sporting advantage.
0
0
3
@MalcolmSheppard
@SCMacNeil
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
Please learn how to string together a coherent argument. We could teach a Logical Fallacy 101 class based on your last dozen or so tweets.
1
0
3
@Coach_Schmitt1
@emitchell321
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
Oh no, I guess I'll never know whether "Coach Schmitt" really thinks it's fair for men to compete in women's sports, or whether he's taken an untenable position due to his political leanings and must therefore perpetually dodge the question.
1
0
3
@PaulaCoyscot
@CarilynJohnson
@ClanPetrie
@FranannigansD
@Winger_ren
@KatyMontgomerie
You’re dismissing a possible source of evidence because you don’t like their Twitter account. Try looking up Ad Hominem to understand where you’re going awry. A hint is that one could apply this to *your* account and subsequently dismiss everything you say.
1
0
3
@SamanthaBartosz
@Muttmere1
I'm not attacking or demeaning anyone. You made a weak argument and I called you out on it.
1
0
3
@Kohaku_castor
@BLA042021
@Quibilah1
Again, you're misunderstanding how and when statistical significance is used in data analysis. It's not relevant how often it occurs relative to all sporting events ever. We're demonstrating that it does occur, and saying that when it occurs, it's wrong.
1
0
2
@thefemagend
@SwarbenBrickbet
@qb_eagles
@Martina
@kimobra
@jemelehill
@LurieFavors
This entire discussion you’ve:
- failed to make a coherent argument
- failed to provide evidence supporting your beliefs
- avoided direct, honest dialog
- evaded addressing the core issue
- lied about what you said & didn’t say
But sure, keep thinking you came across smart
1
0
3
@RB6K
@Gablesgreen134
@BansheesRUs
@hypotaxia17
@Gemma_clark14
@jk_rowling
What’s embarrassing is that you think there’s such a thing as a male woman.
And even if we were to grant you this absurdity, the female category in sports exists to exclude male people, because of the extremely well documented and well understood *male* sporting advantage.
You
0
0
2
@DaneHave
@CanadaKlr
@mason_garry
@GlenandJuice66
@Fluffy07786365
@Martina
@sharrond62
@Daley_thompson
@mara_yamauchi
The website lists the names of hundreds of women who have lost to men in women’s sports. What specifically about it is a joke to you?
2
0
3
@Martina
@thefemagend
@SwarbenBrickbet
@qb_eagles
@kimobra
@jemelehill
@LurieFavors
This phrase "Simply being a man doesn't mean you have a natural ability in a sport/all sports" is a straw man and shows a fundamental misunderstanding of our argument. If she can't grasp at all where she is going awry here, then the rest of the discussion is pointless.
2
0
3
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
"People who dope are not some existential threat to sports. Dopers come in all shapes and sizes just like athletes who don't dope. Some dopers might win, others not. Therefore, we should accept dopers into sports."
1
0
3
@Kohaku_castor
@BLA042021
@Quibilah1
Our analysis does not need to address how frequently it occurs as a percent of total competitions, because that is not a relevant question. Any occurrence, no matter how rare, is a violation of sportsmanship and ethics, which is the critical point that you aren't addressing.
0
0
1
@lucy_thevegan
@Ajaygee71
A slippery slope fallacy occurs when an argument suggests that a small first step will inevitably lead to a chain of related, negative events, without providing evidence to support that inevitability. But Al *has* provided evidence - that the number of men claiming a female
0
0
4
@CaraPac46808618
@kinjones29
@cathydevine56
@mPinoe
The recent paper below refers to numerous scientific studies that demonstrate:
1. The extent of male performance advantage, and
2. That this performance advantage is not sufficiently negated by taking hormones
Reference:
1
0
3
@RB6K
@Gablesgreen134
@BansheesRUs
@hypotaxia17
@Gemma_clark14
@jk_rowling
This should be obvious but the person who thinks it’s good that men are competing in women’s sports is radicalized.
1
0
3
@krisfergohio
@PointyLeopard
@hoosiermomlove
@inmyownfashion2
@biologycounts
Here are 4 examples of prominent organizations defending, and/or filing lawsuits for, the inclusion of male athletes into women's sports.
0
0
3
@lucy_thevegan
@LeorSapir
The sex category in sports is designed to exclude male sporting advantage, thus anyone who is male should be excluded. If a height category existed in any sport, then I would support enforcing that category and not allowing tall people to self-identify into it.
1
0
3
@krisfergohio
@PointyLeopard
@hoosiermomlove
@inmyownfashion2
@biologycounts
Some women can beat some men but the best men will always beat the best women. The NFL, NBA, NHL, and MLB are open to both sexes, but only men are able play in them. That's why we protect the female category and not the male category.
1
1
2
@PlentyofFist
@Blackadder04181
@GeneNLeslie1
@FLEXjss
You asked for data and you got it. Do you have a legitimate criticism of the data or are you just going to toss around unfounded accusations of bias?
2
0
2
@CoachBobier
@pattif21
@qb_eagles
@Martina
@kimobra
@jemelehill
@LurieFavors
I understand English perfectly. You're just asserting things without providing any arguments for them. Why does sex not matter in youth or amateur sports? The only answers you seem to be capable of are "Because I said so" and "You're a bigot". Weak. Pathetic.
2
0
2
@Coach_Schmitt1
@emitchell321
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
I suspect even when we finish linking to *all* the sources, instead of just a few hundred of them, you’ll find other reasons to dismiss the site. Do you think it’s fine that male athletes are competing in women’s sports or do you think it’s unfair?
0
0
2
@AlienorDeDanann
@Aragona_Saarah
@Kashou_Kashou
@CParents04
@AlexandraDesgr
We include a tiny percentage of sports and games such as poker on the website because if there's a women's category then it should be for women, not for "women and some men".
1
0
1
@CaraPac46808618
@kinjones29
@cathydevine56
@mPinoe
You’re like the sad sack who said that since no man has won gold in a women’s Olympics event, we’re all just scaremongering. You’ve been provided a list of 100s of injustices, which you refuse to acknowledge, and you think your question makes a cogent point, which it does not.
1
0
2
@SmilerTurner
@AmyBrewKnights
@geoffrey_best
@cathydevine56
@mPinoe
There is no way to count every sporting event. Why do you think it’s relevant or useful to do so?
1
0
2
@hollybots24
@anne_joseypye
@Seeker66173291
@TatumT_WG
@Perlican3
@sharrond62
They are male athletes who competed against female athletes in a women's event. But sure, keep dismissing the point with semantics.
0
1
10
0
0
2
@MalcolmSheppard
@SCMacNeil
@CarilynJohnson
@VeronikaSimms
You objected to Carilyn's post above:
Each of her 4 claims can be backed up with extensive evidence. But it's clear now that if we provide said evidence you'll just accuse us of hate and stalking.
@VeronikaSimms
Not true.
First, TRAs claimed men were being excluded by not being able to compete in the women’s category. Open categories were created. They refused to participate in them.
Second, they claimed it was just a few men who were beating women, so what was the harm?
@shewon_org
3
4
54
1
0
2
@krisfergohio
@PointyLeopard
@hoosiermomlove
@inmyownfashion2
@biologycounts
Yes, actually, many people are suggesting that males athletes should be able to cross over into women's divisions.
1
0
2
@krisfergohio
@inmyownfashion2
@PointyLeopard
@hoosiermomlove
@biologycounts
Female athletes playing "up" in male sports is accepted because women have no sex-based advantage. Male athletes playing "down" in female sports is considered dishonorable.
Just like a lightweight can choose to compete in the heavyweight division but not vice versa.
0
0
2
@lucy_thevegan
@DaraMorefield
@LeorSapir
The denominator is not relevant to the argument, as has been explained to you multiple times. Drawing the conclusion that "men don't have an advantage over women because they do not always win" is a fallacy.
1
0
2
@oftchance
@JNargent
@Kasandroid
@babybeginner
@bennite75
@murphy_ld
@Martina
@GovEvers
No. I would like to clarify: we track male winners in women’s sports to the extent that we can. Obviously we can’t track every sporting event ever, so we don't make claims about the relative frequency.
1
0
2
@PisseArtiste
@better_in_dubly
@TraceyKent
@ShaneMackenzie_
We’ve demonstrated that a small number of male athletes can disrupt the integrity of the entire women‘s category. As female athletes it does affect our lives. You have provided no facts or evidence of any kind, probably because you’re an incoherent, insufferable fool.
0
0
2
@CoachBobier
@pattif21
@qb_eagles
@Martina
@kimobra
@jemelehill
@LurieFavors
Aww sad, Coach left before he could answer the question 😔
2
0
2
We vet user-submitted info before publishing and are gradually adding primary and secondary sources so that you can see them for yourself, even if you're willfully determined not to believe them.
@babybeginner
@phileriksennz
This is obviously not a reliable source by any standards. Data gathered by user submitted info as they do on the site is anecdotal at best. Considering 0.35% of the population indentify as trans your numbers can’t be right.
0
0
1
0
0
2
@DaneHave
@CanadaKlr
@mason_garry
@GlenandJuice66
@Fluffy07786365
@Martina
@sharrond62
@Daley_thompson
@mara_yamauchi
It’s clear that you think the site is a joke but you haven’t explained why.
2
0
2
@CThalloo
Oh ok, it’s just a hobby and not at all sexual which explains why your timeline is filled with naked cartoon animals
1
0
1
@Coach_Schmitt1
@emitchell321
@mcdowell_is
@RealDanZak
The site has hundreds of links to corroborating news articles and ranking data published by sporting orgs. We obviously don’t let random strangers publish on the site, though we do accept tips that we follow up on and verify.
0
0
2