Sean W. Anthony
@shahanSean
Followers
25K
Following
33K
Media
2K
Statuses
19K
Professor, historian, specialist in Mashriqī Studies at 𝕿𝖍𝖊 @OhioState University #GoBucks
Columbus, OH
Joined May 2016
My new book, co-authored with Stephen Shoemaker, has has just been released. It's published #openacess but feel free to buy a hardcopy, too!.
39
171
749
Not a personal slight to Mr. Anon here, but I find it odd how many Muslims love to boast about not being smart enough to understand the basics of Christian theology.
I came across this scene from the movie called “Passion of Christ” and noticed that the Christians can't help themselves but portray their “God” Jesus as seeking refuge in Allah:
106
618
16K
The only people being written out of history here are the Byzantines who actually preserved the Greek originals. [NB there's scant evidence that any *complete* work of Plato was translated into Syriac or Arabic, just fragments and epitomes].
The Enlightenment was possible because of Muslim scholarship preserving European texts. Yet Muslims have been airbrushed out of this story. @MehreenKhn . Listen to the full discussion with Mehreen Khan here:
39
269
2K
The 18th surah of the Qurʾan, al-Kahf, speaks of a figure named Ḏū l-Qarnayn, ‘the Two-Horned Man’. Who is he? Most modern historians contend that Ḏū l-Qarnayn is none other than Alexander 'the Great' of Macedon (Ἀλέξανδρος ὁ Μέγας, 356–323 BCE). This thread explains why…
68
544
1K
@abduallah_amin This is like saying that the soul cannot be immortal because the body is mortal. I don't believe in the immortal soul myself, but it's very easy for me to see why this is a bad argument.
10
3
1K
The story of how the young Salman Rushdie first encountered at Cambridge the classic story of the so-called "satanic verses" that eventually inspired the novel (published in 1988) is a pretty interesting one that he details in his memoir Joseph Anton (2012) .
11
293
1K
🧵A 9th-cent. historian of Mecca, Abū l-Walīd al-Azraqī, transmits several stories abt how the Prophet Muḥammad spared an icon (ṣūrah) of Mary and Jesus from destruction when he purged the Kaʿbah of the idols it contained. But if the icon wasn’t destroyed, what happened to it?
24
226
886
1/ Recently I’ve been revisiting the issue of the Ḥajj and the Kaʿbah in early Islam, and I started collecting the earliest historical attestations to Muslim reverence for the Kaʿbah and the Ḥajj. Here’s some of the results:
23
389
829
Sorry, but Muslim scholars did 𝒏𝒐𝒕 write about evolution, let alone natural selection, 1000 yrs before Darwin . "A Thousand Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing About Natural Selection" via @vice.
34
233
801
Forthcoming: Michael A. Cook, A History of the Muslim World: From Its Origins to the Dawn of Modernity (May 2024), 960pp.
20
173
741
My next book, Muhammad and the Empires of Faith, coming out April 2020 .
58
124
696
Seen this image before? If you’ve read abt Islamic history, I bet you have, but rarely is its significance ever discussed. It’s a library of sorts, but a very special sort. This image is one of the earliest depictions of a local *public* library in the Islamic world. A thread …
3
247
653
@DiogenisCynic @abduallah_amin Your inability/unwillingness to articulate it in a coherent way does not mean that Christian theology does not articulate it in a coherent way. As I said elsewhere, the incredulity is mostly performative and incurious.
5
6
695
This one's for all those Arabic teachers grading homework copied from Google translate
42
79
488
Well-known among historians is that Muḥammad was not the only seventh-century claimant to prophecy from Arabia. There are at least four others: three men (Maslamah, Tulayḥah al-Asadī, and al-Aswad al-ʿAnsī) and a woman (Sajāḥ).
13
154
430
This is a great work of social history by great historian of the Mamluk era. If you are under any illusions that vice was absent from, or a minor aspect of, premodern societies because they were traditional (etc.), this is a perfect book for disabusing you of that notion.
11
66
414
Seeing Palestinians burning alive in hospital beds tonight, I lost all hope for the hundredth time. Nothing will make these people care. They've already spoken to and shared tables with people far more capable of making the case than you and I.
These are photos of Obama at a Palestinian community dinner in Chicago seated at a table with Edward Said, Ali Abunimah and Rashid Khalidi. The latter have both attested to his betrayal and how Obama used to always attend events in their community. In 1999, Abunimah introduced
6
80
406
Please tell me that there's an academic article out there that documents this stuff
24
71
378
Books that were published this year that I actually read and highly recommend
9
45
365
دوش دیدم که ملایک در میخانه زدند. گل آدم بسرشتند و به پیمانه زدند.coming soon from Rudi Matthee
10
41
366
[The Persian shah] Khosro said, "Make no city your home unless it possess these five things: a mighty ruler, a just judge, a fair market, a learned physician, and a bountiful river." .(Ibn Qutaybah, ʿUyūn al-aḫbār i 6)
3
71
365
This is obviously a braindead post. But don't even begin to imagine "the facts of the matter" matter here - it's pure ideological fairy dust. Islamic empires were further iterations in the long cycle of the Near Eastern *and* Western imperial tradition, not departures from them.
21
39
362
The 2nd-century pagan philosopher, Celsus, aiming demonstrate the utter incompatibility and incommensurability of the god of [Neo-Platonic] philosophy with the god of revealed scripture. Note his claim that it is the height of absurdity to say "God said. "
20
63
338
"Learn Arabic if you want to pursue a PhD in Islamic Studies" is apparently a controversial position in the US academy.
14
22
328
We don't.
Academic Islamic studies professors believe that the Quran was written by a committee of scholars in the deserts of Arabia fluent in several languages, including Greek & various Aramaic dialects, with access to the Talmud & the collected works of the early Church fathers.
18
27
330
A governor of ʿUmar II writes him worried about the number of persons converting to Islam to avoid paying the jizyah. The caliph’s solution? Require new converts to 1) be circumcised and 2) recite a few surahs before exempting them from jizyah. (From Balādhurī’s Ansāb al-ashrāf)
15
67
327
Advanced copy finally arrived! Thank you @ucpress for producing such a great cover design.
22
35
323
Many asked on this thread abt Gog & Magog (Heb. גּוֹג וּמָגוֹג; Ar. يأجوج ومأجوج) and if Alexander of Macedon/Ḏū ’l-Qarnayn was associated w/ them before the Qurʾan. The answer is a resounding, “Yes,” and the same Syriac sources again have a key role to play. I'll explain why ….
The 18th surah of the Qurʾan, al-Kahf, speaks of a figure named Ḏū l-Qarnayn, ‘the Two-Horned Man’. Who is he? Most modern historians contend that Ḏū l-Qarnayn is none other than Alexander 'the Great' of Macedon (Ἀλέξανδρος ὁ Μέγας, 356–323 BCE). This thread explains why…
11
113
321
-=[On the Origins of the Flying Carpet]=-.Many regard flying carpets as the quintessential symbol of the magical folklore of the Arabian Nights, but the flying carpet is quite rare in the Nights. Where then does this lore derive? A thread on the surprising answer …
9
115
305
After seeing this tweet I looked for an early account of this attempt to destroy the pyramids during the era of the crusades. It turns up in the writings of a contemporary, ʿAbd al-Laṭīf al-Baghdādī (1162-1231), in his Kitāb al-Ifādah wa-l-iʿtibār, which recounts his travels . .
At the end of the twelfth century al-Malek al-Aziz Othman ben Yusuf, Saladin's son and heir, attempted to demolish the pyramids, starting with that of Menkaure.
7
117
301
*important new discovery* An early, dated Arabo-Islamic inscription from Ḥismā. that mentions the the prophet Muhammad by name. This one is dated to the end of 80AH[=January 700CE]. A mere 7 decades after his death A quick English translation below:
بارك الله فيكم على ماتبذلونه من جهود في توثيق هذا التراث القيم. وهذه قراءة للنقش :. اللهم صلي على محمد النبي وتقبل شفاعته في أمته.وارحمنا به في الآخرة كما رحمتنا به في الدنيا.وكتب بكر بن أبي بكرة الأسلمي تمام سنة ثمانين . والله تعالى أعلم بالصواب
7
172
294
Forthcoming: Alain George, The Umayyad Mosque of Damascus: Art, Faith and Empire in Early Islam (June 2021).
5
63
300
An inscription bearing the name of the Prophet Muḥammad's companion, Zayd ibn Thābit al-Anṣārī, the renowned scribe who recorded the Qurʾan codex of the caliph ʿUthmān ibn ʿAffān, the archetype for all copies thereof. Here's a translation:.1] God, pardon Zayd, son of Thābit . .
#نقوش_إسلامية تنشر لأول مرة #المدينة_المنورة :.كتاب مبكر جدا وبخط متقن وبديع.ويحمل اسم زيد بن ثابت رضي الله عنه.ويظهر لي من رسمه والله تعالى أعلم.أنه من خطوط منتصف القرن الأول الهجري.والذي اشتهر بهذا الإسم الثنائي في ذلك الزمن.هو #زيد_بن_ثابت_الأنصاري رضي الله عنه #كاتب_الوحي
10
88
307
Best books that I read in 2024.(mostly read old books this year)
4
26
319
People mock this girl, but she's right. It's the man who's being manipulative. She's referring to the standard interpreation of Q. 4:24 and what happened at after the battle of Ḥunayn . .
36
36
269
🤯evidence of bilingualism and knowledge of Greek among Arabian nomads in the pre-Islamic period
8
108
285
A really fascinating #openaccess collection of articles on the direct influence of Averroes and Avicenna on early Latin scholasticism .
1
76
318
One of my favorite translation errors. The Arabic, instead of saying "Made in Turkey", says "Made in a turkey 🦃 (literally, 'in a Roman rooster')." 😂.
8
89
281
Fascinating update on the Ḏū l-Qarynayn ("the Horned Man") = Alexander the Great front thanks to an amazing discovery reported by C.A. Stewart in “A Byzantine Image of Alexander: Literature in Stone,” Report of the Department of Antiquities Cyprus 2017 (Nicosia 2018): 1-45 . .
The 18th surah of the Qurʾan, al-Kahf, speaks of a figure named Ḏū l-Qarnayn, ‘the Two-Horned Man’. Who is he? Most modern historians contend that Ḏū l-Qarnayn is none other than Alexander 'the Great' of Macedon (Ἀλέξανδρος ὁ Μέγας, 356–323 BCE). This thread explains why…
15
95
273
Eléonore Cellard has made a truly remarkable discovery: a new Qur'an palimpsest probably dating from the late-8th/early-9th century CE. It's remarkable because 'upper-text' is the Qur'an and the lower text is biblical. That's unprecedented .
8
155
274
Early Arabic inscriptions by women from the environs of Medina-- important testimonies to women's literacy in early Islamic Arabia
#نقوش_إسلامية نسائية مبكرة من حاضرة #المدينة_المنورة وباديتها. هذه النقوش هي من الدلائل المؤكدة على انتشار العلم والكتابة بين شرائح المجتمع المدني في حاضرته وباديته وعلى مدى تعلق نساء الرعيل الأول رحمهن ﷲ وغفرلهن بالله تعالى فجل نقوشهم هي أدعية وتوكل وثقة بالله ﷻ.#الخط_المدني
4
166
262
I’m teaching a course of 1,001 Nights (alf laylah wa-laylah|ألف ليلة وليلة) this semester, so here’s quick thread on the earliest fragment of the work, discovered by Prof. Nabia Abbot and currently held @orientalinst in Chicago. Abbot is famous for her work on early papyri, but.
6
78
284
The 2nd-century pagan philosopher Celsus on the absurdity and hypocrisy of monotheism.
13
50
270
I have to say, this upcoming film about the Abbasid Revolution looks like it will be really good.
13
47
253
My timeline is full of folks annoyed/dismayed by the idea that Abū Hurayrah (d. ca. 678-80), was a controversial figure and, especially, that early Ḥanafīs – like Muḥammad al-Shaybānī (d. 805) – rejected the authority of his ḥadīth in fiqh.
28
50
257
The earliest description of Europe (أروفى|urūfā, not أوروبا; from Εὐρώπη) in Arabic literature comes from a book called *Routes and Realms* by Ibn Khordāḏbeh (fl. 800s CE), by the caliph’s head of the postal and intelligence service; it's quite fascinating (translation below)
14
100
256
It's said that the Umayyads’ governor of Iraq, al-Ḥajjāj ibn Yūsuf al-Thaqafī, denied that al-Ḥusayn ibn ʿAlī was the Prophet’s progeny because he only recognized patrilineal lineage and discounted matrilineal descent. When in public al-Ḥajjāj thus declared, “Ḥusayn is not. .
5
74
260
If you'd like to read more about the satanic verses story in the Islamic tradition, I recommend the book *Before Orthodoxy* (HUP 2017) by the late Shahab Ahmed - which is not only brilliant but also dispels all sorts of popular myths about the story.
6
39
251
Islam is undeniably a key part of the history of Europe as a geographical entity. But Europe as a cultural unity/identity seems to be a Christian idea, invented (?) by Pope Pius II in a famous book called Europa. Who are the first Muslims to call themselves Europeans, I wonder?.
I’m tired of people saying Islam is not a European religion but Christianity is. Christianity is not native to Europe, paganism is. It’s a middle eastern religion based on worshipping a middle eastern man. Why is Islam incompatible with Europe? I genuinely want to know.
16
26
260
In ca. 703-4, the Umayyad governor al-Ḥajjāj b. Yūsuf completed a project to (re)codify the Qurʾan, refining the codex of the caliph ʿUthmān. What was the project, and what did it entail? .The question is difficult to answer.
11
67
260
Out this month: Hugh Kennedy’s new translation of al-Balādhurī’s Futūḥ al-Buldān.
3
48
249
Twitter gives me the sense that ½ of Muslims keen to debate religion on this website are desperate to show that the canonical hadith corpus *is* true+authentic in order to preserve their faith; and the other ½ that it is *not* true+authentic in order to preserve their faith.
20
33
241
Thank God I'm American
25
26
233
The Umayyad caliph ʿAbd al-Malik (r. 685-705) is famous 4 reforming the currency of the early Islamic empire. Most famous of these coins are the briefly minted ‘standing caliph’ series (left) issued 73-77/693-697. But eventually they become aniconic (right).
4
105
228
Apparently medieval citrus trees were generally not grown for their fruit? Ibn Khaldūn relates how the proliferation of gardens with citrus trees was regarded as sign of a city’s impending ruin, so much so that many people avoided planting them around their homes. Why? Because.
4
34
239
Amazing - a treatise about why there can be no anal sex in heaven because the inhabitants of Paradise don't have anuses.
Shaykh al-Islām Zakariyyā al-Anṣārī (d. 926)'s great great great grandson, Sharaf al-Dīn al-Anṣāri (d. 1092), wrote a fantastic book on homosexuality in Jannah.
10
47
228
A very interesting and learned book on adelphopoiesis, a "brother-making" ritual between men, which emerged among monastics in late-ancient Egypt and Syro-Palestine. Adelphopoiesis is strongly reminiscent of the muʾākhāh oaths between the Anṣār and the Muhājirūn after the Hijrah
7
32
242
@Sturgeons_Law This is one of the most persistent artifacts of medical beliefs about alchohol from ancient and medieval worlds. But now I want to know whether it's worse to sit down with a can of Coca-Cola everynight or a can of beer.
9
1
227
One of the strangest stories transmitted by Ibn Isḥāq (d. 767) appears only in the Tārīkh of Abū Jaʿfar al-Ṭabarī (d. 923): the story of how an Anṣārī find the tomb of Jesus Christ on a mountain nearby Medina with an epitaph written in Pahlavi.
18
56
223
Qurʾan refers to “the believers, the Jews, the Christian, and the Sabians (allaḏīn ʾāminū wa’llaḏīna hādū wa’l-naṣārā wa-l-ṣābiʾīn)” (2:62, 5:69; cf. 22:17). Who are these Sabians? Scholars offer many answers, but I think the most interesting one comes from the ḥadīth corpus.
18
66
233
Preparing notes for the early Arab conquests in N. Africa, it strikes me how little we know really about what actually happened and its scale. Let’s look at numbers given in Arabic sources for captives enslaved during the campaigns of Mūsā ibn Nuṣayr in the early 700s .
8
39
240
@Autodidation That's fine. I feel like I have a pretty good grasp of Marxism, but I don't believe it absolutely. I don't believe Christian either.
2
0
237
5 canonical prayers (al-ṣalawāt al-ḫams) constitute a mainstay of daily piety for millions of Muslims worldwide. But why 5 prayers? Why this particular number? Historians have sought to answer this question in numerous ways. Here's one take on a potential answer.
10
87
223
An amazing find by Prof. Muḥammad al-Ṭabarānī, who is a great scholar and a first-class editor: The Kitāb al-Maghāzī of Mūsā ibn ʿUqbah, one of the earliest biographies of the Prophet Muḥammad ever written and much preferred by Mālik ibn Anas over Ibn Isḥāq’s Maghāzī.
بحمد الله، شرع في طبع مغازي الإمام موسى بن عقبة المدني المطرفي (ت 141 ه)، وهي أصح سيرة وأقدمها بإطلاق، بعد أن أعثرنا الله على نسختها الفريدة، ووقع تحقيقها وتخريج أحاديثها؛ وهذا بلا ريب فتح في المعلم السيري، نسأل الله النفع به.
13
61
230
#openacces LAMINE 3. Scripts and Scripture: Writing and Religion in Arabia circa 500–700 CE | The Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago
2
62
228
In the early 1960s (?) the Egyptian scholar Muḥammad al-Bahī published a small tract called *Missionaries and Orientalists and their Stance towards Islam*. Though a mere 26 pages, it caught the attention of the German journal Die Welt des Islams, which.
5
61
224
The Christian Arab poet al-Akhṭal (d. c. 710 AD) is a figure whose poems and observations on early Muslim society are woefully understudied by western scholars. Here’s an entertaining story about him and the caliph ʿAbd al-Malik:.One day al-Akhṭal went to see [the caliph] .
6
39
232
What I found esp interesting that he wasn't actually taught by an orientalist or even a historian of the Islamic world. The person who offered him the course was a medievalist named Arthur Hibbert who, I think, gave him a nice piece of advice worth its weight in gold.
4
16
210
The Qur'an (simply put) is, in terms of early manuscripts, likely the most well-attested and accurately preserved text of the first millennium. Miraculously preserved? No. Extraordinary well preserved compared to its peers? Yes, without a doubt.
UPDATE: We present a massive update of the article "Concise List Of Arabic Manuscripts Of The Qur'ān Attributable To The First Century Hijra". This ninth interim update is the biggest update since the article was initially published on the 17th July 2009.
15
58
218
Jerusalem’s sanctity in Muslim belief is well known, and most famously expounded in a genre called ‘The Merits of Jerusalem (faḍāʾil bayt al-maqdis)’. But most collections of these traditions date after the 11th century AD. Are these traditions therefore late? Definitely not …
3
64
229
Sunnis blamed Jews for Shi'ism 🤦.
Your PhD thesis in five words. Go!.
16
14
215
The Abbasid caliphs weren't fond of their predecessors, the Umayyads, be it the caliphs or just the Banū Umayyah in general. They claimed that Q. 98:3, “The Night of Power is better than 1000 months,” is a direct condemnation of the Umayyad caliphate, which lasted 1000 months.
8
49
216
Recently published in English: Muna Tatari and Klaus von Stosch, tr., Mary in the Qur’an: Friend of God, Virgin, Mother, tr. Peter Lewis (Feb 2022), 350 pp.
3
38
216
I’m not gonna lie. I never saw this version of horseshoe theory coming.
exmuslims takfiring people from.exmuslimness what a time to be alive.
6
39
217
In the Syriac NT, Judas Iscariot is called "Judas the Betrayer (Īhūdā Mašlmānā|ܝܗܘܕܐ ܡܫܠܡܢܐ)." Since "Muslim" is also rendered into Syriac as *mašlmānā*, some Syriac authors polemically referred Judas as the forefather of Christian converts to Islam. (Matt 26:25, 27; John 18:2,5)
10
34
204
@Qasim51065629 I find it very sophisticated and entirely sufficient. These objections are at the level of "So who created God?".
1
2
206
I shudder to think of the web without these folks. Thanks for all you do.
0
33
200
Ummmmm, no . In 1009 it was destroyed on the orders of the Fāṭimid caliph al-Ḥākim, which I am pretty sure counts as being "indefinitely closed".
Jerusalem’s Church of the Holy Sepulchre, which is believed to contain the holiest Christian sites (Jesus’ crucifixion, burial, resurrection), has never been indefinitely closed in a millenia and a half, except.•In 1349, Black Plague.•Today, Coronavirus.
5
46
191
Islam originated in Petra and Dan Gibson is a first-rate scholar.
18
16
188
What a find! 2 lines of Arabic poetry - often cited in Abbasid-era belles lettres as being pre-Islamic and 𝐶ℎ𝑟𝑖𝑠𝑡𝑖𝑎𝑛 - found north of Mt. Arafat near Mecca. It's dated (!) by the inscriber, Abū Jaʿfar ibn Ḥasan al-Hāshimī, to 98 A.H. (716-17 C.E.). Here's what it says. .
#نقش_نادر مؤرخ بسنة ثمان وتسعين للهجرة في شمال عرفة ،لبيتين من الشعر الجاهلي منسوبةٍ لقس بن ساعدة ، وقيل لغيره، ونصه:.أفنى الجديدَ تقلبُ الشمس .وطلوعها من حيث لا تمسي وطلوعها بيضاء صافية .وغروبها صفراء كالورس. وكتب أبو جعفر بن حسن الهاشمي سنة ثمان وتسعين. #نقش_اسلامي .
4
47
188
The earliest Greek translation of the Qur'an (c. late-8th cent) explicitly identifies with Dhū l-Qarnayn with Alexander and attests to the reading “hot spring (ʿayn ḥāmiyah)” rather than “brackish spring (ʿayn ḥamiʾah)” for Q 18:86.
19
34
201
One of our earliest chronologies of the plague (al-ṭāʿūn|الطاعون) in early Islam comes from the Kitāb al-Taʿāzī (Book of Condolences) of Abū l-Ḥasan al-Madāʾinī (d. 225/840). He notes, “The famous great plagues in Islam were five …” Here’s his list:.
3
76
190
I've posted a pre-print version of my article, “Two ‘Lost’ Sūras of the Qurʾān: Sūrat al-Khalʿ and Sūrat al-Ḥafd between Textual and Ritual Canon (1st-3rd/7th-9th Centuries),” soon to appear in the next issue of Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam.
13
58
198
A common question in the historiography of early Islam: How early did the communities of the 7th-century Near East perceive Arabian conquerors as possessing their own faith community with distinct laws and beliefs? .Here’s insights from John bar Penkāyē (ܝܘܚܢܢ ܒܪ ܦܢܟ̈ܝܐ) . .
6
66
185
Everyone in MidEast Studies in the US academy should follow this like a hawk.
14
92
173
Nice, early attestation to the name of the Prophet's father, 'Abdallāh.
أنا مسلمة بن عبيد.أسل الله #الجنة نزلاً . بسمـ الله اللهمـ اغفر.لمحمد ابن عبدالله #النبي_الأمي.وصلِّ عليه وسلمـ.واغفر لمن #قال آمين من المؤمنين.لا إله إلا الله وحده لا شريكــ له.له الملكــ وله الحمد.وهو على كل شيء قدير
5
29
186
Modern scholars, "Pre-Islamic Arabia was much more monotheistic than once thought.".Ibn Taymiyyah, "I told you so.".“The pagans of Quraysh and others … affirmed that God alone created the heavens and the earth” (Majmūʿ al-fatāwā, 1:155).
32
35
188
Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq said: Three persons deserve mercy: the rich who become poor, the renowned who become disgraced, and the learnèd who become laughingstocks of the ignorant. قال جعفر الصادق: ثلاثةٌ يجب لهم رحمة: غني افتقر وعزيز قوم ذلّ وعالم تلاعب به الجهّال.
4
50
186
The pagan emperor Julian "the Apostate" on why he reveres, and is more faithful to, Abraham and his god than are the Christians (Against the Galileans, §354)
8
35
186
Atheism is definitely not a sign of a great intellect. (Just in case you still thought so. Do such people still exist on Twitter?).
We know that Jesus Christ was a fictional character created by the Council of Nicaea in the year 325 AD and modelled after Julius Caesar to pacify the poor in the Roman Empire. We know this to be true from independent historians born in the same time period, hold no records.
16
18
170
"The tyrant dies and his rule is over, the martyr dies and his rule begins." This famous quote of Kierkegaard hits differently in context
2
46
183