Benjamin Boakye
@benboakye
Followers
3,546
Following
145
Media
77
Statuses
814
Executive Director. Africa Centre for Energy Policy
Ghana
Joined June 2011
Don't wanna be here?
Send us removal request.
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
Cheney
• 316130 Tweets
Eagles
• 174959 Tweets
Uruguay
• 60662 Tweets
Suárez
• 51307 Tweets
श्री गणेश
• 48849 Tweets
#SmackDown
• 48519 Tweets
Saquon
• 44968 Tweets
Peacock
• 40904 Tweets
Giants
• 40803 Tweets
गणपति बप्पा
• 39104 Tweets
1 Day Left For Avataran Diwas
• 38793 Tweets
Jalen
• 37034 Tweets
Green Bay
• 32218 Tweets
Paraguay
• 28232 Tweets
Philly
• 27990 Tweets
#GaneshChaturthi
• 26876 Tweets
#GBvsPHI
• 26122 Tweets
#GoPackGo
• 16078 Tweets
Lord Ganesha
• 13754 Tweets
#二度と撮れない画像を貼れ
• 13025 Tweets
Jayden Reed
• 11662 Tweets
Fritz
• 11579 Tweets
Jordan Love
• 11108 Tweets
Tiafoe
• 10864 Tweets
BOSSNOEUL Q5 TBNW
• 10783 Tweets
Lucho
• 10740 Tweets
Lynx
• 10416 Tweets
Wisdom & Prosperity
• 10020 Tweets
Pinned Tweet
The conclusion that SML contract is “redundant” yet “beneficial” is incongruous. We showed through careful analysis of government’s rscords that NPA data was superior to GRA data used for Revneue assurance. Therefore, there's no Revneue jump attributable to SML
@BBSimons
4
41
66
1/ Ghana just lost its case again Eni and co. We are always here to help. We didn’t have to go to court on the ABC of the oil industry. But leaders were willing to risk it all for other interest: Ghana lost its place to Ivory Coast on investments.
@BBSimons
46
257
488
I understand that lawyers of my friend,
@bbsimons
, were told today that Fidelity has filed a libel lawsuit over his tweet about ECG buying forex at 13.95. We wait for service.
For those of us fighting to prevent Dumsor caused by financial mismanagement, this opens a new WARFRONT.
23
179
339
3 weeks ago CSOs were pumped about an illicit sale of GNPC’s assets to PetroSA. It turns out that PetroSA was being bankrolled by a local company for the acquisition. Btw, nothing would happen since the alarm & calls 4 accountability. We've moved on to a new scandal, TOR.
#IMF
22
183
303
1/The Ministry of Energy signed a sole-sourced relocation and operation contract to move the Ameri Power Plant to Kumasi for $71m, which PPA approved. When we exposed it, the ministry said there was no contract.
30
197
254
Can someone tell the AG that Ghana was sued because of point 4 of his statement- wrongful unitization. They didn't listen to counsel, went to court and lost. Even the claimants were willing to pardon Ghaan and withdraw the case but they didn't listen.
@BBSimons
8
121
234
KPMG has its integrity at stake if it accepts this job. It is a client of GRA and its investigation against the leaders of one of its LARGE portfolios is exceedingly suspicious. Simply unethical.
1/
For the record, the key civil society activists probing this SML contract reject the President's decision to ask KPMG to do a RUSHED review of Ghana's decision to hire a timber merchant at a fee that could top a $billion over time in the name of auditing commodity exports.
22
94
209
22
130
214
In the quest to ceaselessly milk consumers of petroleum products disguised as quality and revenue assurance, a new war front opens. Africa will move quicker to EVs cos of politicians and their “illicit tax” on the pple, not climate.
@BBSimons
@Manasseh_Azure
15
124
205
1. Wow! I haven't heard you make a scintilla technical argument about Agyapa, the entire machinery that sought to sell 49% of our gold royalties, from producising and pipeline projects, have evaded technical debate on the matter. The channel is still open if you have capacity.
Since the full judgment of the ECOWAS Court became public, I have read posts from certain persons that led the charge in misleading people about the Agyapa Transaction because of their basic lack of understanding of the transaction. These so-called experts chose not to go to
37
50
141
25
97
180
It appears you can only be a Commissioner General of the very demanding GRA job after pension 🤦🏾♂️
14
64
151
Are there filters in the newsroom these days? Can we see independent analysis from other media houses on this SML Thing? Or should we treat these as adverts?
@Citi973
@asaaseradio995
@TheGhanaWeb
@BBSimons
@Manasseh_Azure
24
92
146
The people who couldn't interpret 3 paragraphs of our laws correctly and subjected us to international shame for lack of capacity to interpret agreements are the patriots? Excellent definition,
@BBSimons
@lordcudjoe
ENI-Vitol Arbitration: CSOs are not working in the interest of Ghana.
What the CSOs (IMANI & ACEP) were hoping for:
- Ghana breached the PA with the issuance of the Unitisation Directives
- Damages of $7bn awarded against Ghana
- Interest on damages of $7bn awarded against
30
48
92
13
68
143
Accountability campaigns are not hate campaigns; keep your side of the truth and convince the public for them to make a judgement. If you can’t do that but focus on motives, you are protecting your lies.
2
68
117
Fighting for public interest is getting very difficult, particularly with Fidelity and SML jumping in with deep pockets:
@Manasseh_Azure
and
@BBSimons
being the latest casualties. It promises to be daunting and independent minds must step in to match the fight.
1/
Since the Fidelity Bank lawsuit in the wake of our attempts to hold ECG to account, many people have reached out offering donations for my legal costs. How generous! But
@benboakye
& others have an even more powerful idea: a Public Interest Litigation Fund!
85
461
973
8
89
117
When you read the $170m judgement debt on GPGC, you'll understand how people sleep on the Job to engineer financial haemorrhage. The Value of the contract was ~$134m if it worked, without discounting for my economic benefit. We don't know the accrued interest yet.
@BBSimons
10
65
117
MiDA was a significant part of the problem; Ghana had to lose so much when it decided to subsume operational decisions under overt and covert political manipulation. $192m is the tip of the iceberg. The totality of our loss is what we see in the power sector today; a
#mess
PDS scandal: US shuts down $190m compact with ‘no immediate plans to work in Ghana again’
#JoyNews
98
363
1K
6
75
110
I joined
#DumsorMustStop
cos I was confident I’d return home. A dangerous society is where you are either afraid or a patron of the system.
7
63
111
1. It's not every CSO against Agyapa that was in court.
2. The court would not know that the same lawyers that cooked the MIIF Act were the lawyers behind Agyapa.
3. Parliament that passed the MIIF act could not anticipate the trickery in the eventual sale of 49% of royalty
I wonder why Transparency International, Ghana Integrity Initiative and the CSOs who went to an international court over Agyapa have been quiet since July after their case was dismissed on all fronts. But, I thank them for that move. It is good for our democracy. And, I will urge
257
76
375
10
77
110
The thinking that GRA lacks capacity for DRM at the port, petroleum sector, mineral sector, and now domestic tax is a scam to syphon millions of Cedis from the budget. How did we conclude that we have recruited 7,000 tax men and women who cannot tax?
@BBSimons
@lordcudjoe
6
54
106
It’ll be interesting to understand the technical investment into such decision by PPA. Did they know that production is monitored by Petrocom/GNPC with meters calibrated by Standards authority?what proprietary tech. will count gold bars?
@BBSimons
@Manasseh_Azure
9
57
104
So
#ECG
says its revenue sharing data for October 2023, reported two months after expenditure was projections? If ECG says it procured the FX at ~11.8, not 13.95, to the cedis, then the money we are looking for is more than GHS90m for only October.
#Ghanacrimes
3
50
101
Fidelity opted for the spotlight rather than helping the public find GHS100m lost through exchange rate manipulation at ECG, arguably their biggest client today, in one month. Private business should help the public business as well.
Since it is Twitter (X) that landed me in the lawsuit, it is only fair to inform the Twitter crowd that the issues are now fully joined with Fidelity Bank. Public accountability work is a marathon not a sprint. So, let's take it slowly. 🙏🏽
107
512
985
2
85
99
This is a complete spin on the judgement. There was no $7b relief sought in the case. Here is the list of reliefs.
16
58
98
Ok, here is the response of the senior staff of TOR, who never responded to direct accusations of product theft, contributing to the company's losses. How did they conclude Torentco is the best option?
@BBSimons
@Manasseh_Azure
@norvan986
18
57
94
The open book accounting that has eluded the people- including the President - for years never got easier.
0
24
93
The entire relief in the suit is here. No $7bn was sought. The foundation of the case was wrongly unitisation orders issued to undermine basic industry practices.
@BBSimons
8
48
95
2/ the AG was buoyed by some ridiculous local rulings to compel the investors to go to arbitration. The Minister of Energy won’t hear any council and the president won’t acknowledge one- class act against public interest, and zero upstream investment.
7
54
94
1/ Details are emerging that KPMG extended its investigation to contracts awarded by NPA for activities similar (in every sense, if not worse) to SML’s. The lawyers of NPA say no. Hopefully, collateral damage benefits the people
@BBSimons
@Manasseh_Azure
#MorrowNoFar
5
31
89
In an analysis to show that ECG is doing better,
#KPMG
asserts that revenue grew 34%- from Jan- May 2023. This ignores that the tariff was increased by 66% to account for the exchange rate and other variables in the period. My Colleague says that’s a trumped-up analysis from KPMG
9
37
85
Take your tier two and three seriously. SSNIT is a state sponsored Ponzi scheme, with only a promise. We are only compelled, by law, to pay more.
@BBSimons
3
46
79
“If the problem is governance, the solutions cannot be financial or economic”… Prof. Bokpin. Me: the crux of the matter.
4
29
79
But ECG must keep all of them working, true or false? You collect the revenue, and when you fail to account for the revenue collected and collect far less than you should, the entire value chain suffers. That's why there's no fuel and the picture you should paint, honestly.
How ECG gets power and distributes it.
Electricity goes through multiple steps and players before reaching your homes or offices. It is important to understand that ECG does not generate electricity, ECG simply re-distributes.
#ECG
#GridtoHome
#GRIDCo
#VRA
223
217
917
3
46
77
And they start with a terrible spin on $7b claim which was never part of the reliefs sought. The declaration that the unitisation was improper was the case. And the court expected the govt not to have marshalled all of its brains in futility.
Wow wow wow!!!
The Attorney General has serious explaining to do!!!
@ImaniAfr
&
@AcepPower
will soon provide info on how millions of dollars have been wasted at the instance of the Attoney General when it was clear that the govt's position was NOT in the national interest!
19
184
296
4
37
76
IPPs in Ghana did not shut down as threatened- good news. But, the gas transmission from the west to the east was shut down at 05hrs this morning for a debt owed to WAPCO. WAPCO expected ~$15m, and GNPC could pay ~$1m. Political LCO merchants are smiling to the bank.
@BBSimons
10
46
74
@thebankofghana
's Exchange rate in October 2023 was less than GHS11.5 to the $ and commercial Banks ~GHS12. ECG was buying the $
@GHS13
.95, creating exchange losses above GHS80 million in one month for buying $43m. we will trend exchange losses for a year and report.
@BBSimons
12
50
73
You are exceedingly generous with the number of pages. In fact the relevant pages are 5. $100m to $1.3b in three years, look no further to understand a jackpot.
Ghana's Min of Energy has sent a strange request to Parliament to borrow $1.65B to invest in fields operated by Norway's Aker & AGM. The shockingly hollow 10-page memo contains none of the technical info lawmakers need to understand why Ghana should bear this risk at this time.
23
269
461
3
43
73
How much is GHS 1.06 billion in $s? Generating the discount factor for the past 5 years is some work. Also what other business(s) will give you GHS 1.06 billion in 5yrs with $44m investment.
#IMFOurHome
@BBSimons
5
36
71
One statement that got me into trouble with the political class in 2021 was to warn that it was not sustainable for the government to pay electricity bills and pretend all was ok.
0
35
71
@BBSimons
He's unfit to lead the people if he can't appreciate what they want or detests how they think.
4
15
70
If you build a gold refinery at $100m- enough to build a mine, it’s dead before it starts refining an ounce unless it’s free government cash that no one cares about.
The cost of refining in Ghana is about 2% of the value of the gold, compared to about 0.2% in other European
In 2020, Ghana had enough gold refinery projects in the pipeline to be adjudged sub-Saharan Africa's biggest gold refining hub outside South Africa.
This was of course entirely in line with its status as Africa's largest gold producer.
Why then do Ghanaians, their leaders and
11
159
288
7
46
70
Are there fears of contradictions between the report and the white paper? There must be something extra in the report only for the eyes of the president
#GhMatters
Someone at KPMG needs to print that report and conveniently leave it somewhere, anywhere. This is a matter of national interest.
19
445
717
2
27
68
Ei! Do we have to debate this too? Does the contract talk about net liability for the service? It was extraneous for KPMG to do net calculations. Tax responsibility on businesses and people is exactly what it is, unless exempt. I’ll share how SML discounts the GHS 1b for tax.
The assertion that the KPMG report indicates SML was paid GHS 1.4 billion is misleading. This claim has been circulated in news stories on
@JoyFmNews
,
@Joy997FM
, and
@JoyNewsOnTV
, as well as by my own friends,
@Manasseh_Azure
and
@BBSimons
.
Upon careful review, one will notice
107
45
173
6
36
67
Are we anywhere close to knowing why the KPMG report would not be released until now?
@lordcudjoe
@BBSimons
🤦🏾♂️
#ESLA
7
27
65
We are defenders of public interest. But in our line of duty, we’re often called upon to challenge professorial insights. Last check, one professor attacked us for not agreeing to a $1.65b deal. It was later sold for $1! Total replay, but now a flock of professors🤦🏾♂️
#SaveYaSef
Still on the SML saga.
It is normal for professors to be confused. But that shouldn't end up confusing policy decisions and the citizens on top. 🙏🏽
15
115
221
2
25
62
My claim is false cos you believe in the statement you shared?Those who wrote it know the $7b claim is false. I attach the reliefs for your information. Basic issues; wrong directives, waste of nation's time, misapplied industry's ABC, poor decisions, unimaginable losses in 6yrs.
This reportage from Mr. Benjamin Boakye is FALSE.
Below is the FACTS:
$7 BILLION CLAIM AGAINST GHANA, GNPC DISMISSED.
The International Arbitration Tribunal in the Eni & Vitol versus Ghana & Ghana National Petroleum Corporation (GNPC) arbitration has issued its final award.
30
20
52
9
32
63
When we said science gives effect to the law, this is precisely what it meant. And the tribunal was clear.
4
28
62
Summary of today's event: When governmence is poor, more money is not a solution.
2
23
56
2. You sit on the board of MIIF, technically a beneficiary of Agyapa. Take off that hat for a sec and explain to your readers what you wanted to achieve with the transaction. It's not enough to say you mean well. Anybody can say that - a very elusive approach.
3
24
52
Are there no finance experts around the speech writers?🤦🏾♂️
1
11
51
1/The thinking that private sector participation in the power sector will compromise national security is a higher level of “state enchantment” to keep the sector politically managed and the poor subsidising the affluence of political appointees.
@BBSimons
3
20
49
Few pages but a lot to think about. Telling the baby to clean himself, in essence. This conclusion did not require the expenditure of one cedi of public funds to investigate.
1/
According to Ghana's Prez,
KPMG says:
A. SML has been paid 1 billion cedis for claiming to stop fraud in petrol distribution in Ghana
B. It wants to be paid 5 billion GHS to monitor minerals & oil prod in Ghana
C. The contracts were given without proper approvals
25
220
420
2
24
50
Mantse lays out the issues clearly here. The unitisation was needless and devoid of any pursuit of national interest. The least Ghanaians deserve is an apology for freezing investments for years, with the attendant decline in oil production.
1/
By even the twisted, uncandid, statement issued by Ghana's Attorney General, it is clear that the govt suffered an embarrassing humiliation at the international tribunal.
It had a set of key reliefs & demanded punitive damages. Did it get them? NO!!!
17
86
205
2
23
48
The battle is certainly the Lord’s 🤦🏾♂️
1/
Ghanaians are being entertained with another scandal: a free wifi for schools project taken over by a shadowy group called Aguila Holdings. Initially awarded by Ministry of Educ in shady single sourcing style. CSOs visited dozens of the schools & found no free WiFi. 🤦🏽♂️
61
608
916
4
13
50
It’s Friday, and I’ve been unable to check on 3 significant things I noted in Gh: RFP for TOR was published last week with a 3-day window for investors, NPA Execs cooking a fund to pay drivers of privately owned trucks and KPMG report on SML. Pls, spare us next week
@BBSimons
3
16
48
Oh yes. The public donates the levies to politicians at the Ministry of energy. Street lights purchased on the market work; the government’s street lights last only a few months just to keep the sole-sourced procurement pipeline active 🤦🏾♂️
1. Ghanaians are mobilising for various donation drives to fix perennially broken street lights across major cities.
2. ACEP too has been shouting itself hoarse demanding accountability for streetlight levies paid by citizens & the various procurement gigs. People no hear. 😉
8
100
180
5
35
45
Aksa appears to be a master of the terrain. They got over $700m for delivering 16% of the contracted capacity, with an IRR of ~200%, by simply assembling 20-year-old plants for Ghana. They got paid ahead of the power plants that actually did the job—and handed an extension for
1/
Some readers may have seen news that a former high-flying Ghanaian Goldman Sachs banker is being prosecuted in the US for bribing Ghanaian officials. Unknown to some of you, the company he paid those bribes for - Aksa - continues to win contracts in Ghana TO THIS VERY DAY.
11
147
225
3
23
45
3/Interestingly, The PPA wrote back to say the information was exempt from disclosure.
Now, VRA has relocated the plant using its engineers, with support from Manning Group. It’ll still be relevant to know how much was spent on the relocation, particularly that;
3
26
43
2/ We requested information under the RTI from the PPA on the justification for the sole-sourced contract. The PAA wrote to us to pay 1000 cedis for the info. We challenged the payment of 1000 cedis because we thought it was inconsistent with the RTI and the Fees and Charges Act.
0
30
44
I’m frozen!
#KPMG
deliberated with the president on the audit?
Even when we did not have the Right to Information Law, President John Mahama released a white paper and released the full GYEEDA Report as well. The Akufo-Addo-led opposition NPP was the loudest in asking president Mahama to release that report,
106
537
1K
9
15
42
71% of Ghana’s GDP comes from the formal sector, according to GSS. A significant effort at revenue mobilisation targets the informal sector with PR overload on “expanding the tax net”. Is it not the case that the existing tax net is leaky?
E-levy 2.0 is still not a solution.
1
17
37
According to
#VRA
Senior Staff, VRA billed ECG ~GHS 1 billion. CWM recommended payment of 32%. But ECG could only pay 13%, creating a ~GHS 890m debt between August 2023 and March 2024.
#DebtFactory
6
16
39
Fighting IFF and money laundering never got this difficult. Just say it belongs to the dead when caught and leave the police to invoke the spirits 🤦🏾♂️.
6
12
38
1/You signed an International agreement with your eyes open and chose an international forum for dispute resolution. Then when the dispute arises, you reference your muscles to override the existence of the chosen forum, endorsed by local court.
@BBSimons
6
18
36
@BBSimons
Who art thou to speak against the direction of your father 😂. Perfect mood for aggrieved sons and daughters
3
1
37
The church fails to recognise that to the politician and their business fronts, it is a constituency with numbers, not God.
5
6
37
Corruption is the factory inequality
#PAC
#FightCorruption
Civil society and other key individuals are making a pledge. Will you?
8
97
230
1
23
34
4/1. We were told VRA engineers were not capable of managing the plant
2. It would have cost us $71M if Mytilineos had proceeded with the relocation and management contract.
3
21
37
Gh leadership.
"Why are we spending a $113,000 on spare parts, when we can actually get a brand new ambulance for that?"
-
@S_OkudzetoAblak
on Ambulance Spare Parts scandal.
#JoySMS
39
399
1K
4
12
37
Gold prospecting can be intense and deeply graphic in Ghana. And the regulator only writes to remind the prospecting companies of their sin.
#ComplicityRedefined
7
14
36
There’s no single fraudulent deal in the energy sector that has gone through parliament without his blessing. CSOs and the youth are his punching bag for intervening in some of the terrible deals he supported. Now, he turns it on his leaders. Who's left?
Parliamentary proceedings: Watch K.T. Hammond throw hands at Majority Chief Whip Frank Annoh-Dompreh.
#JoyNews
79
82
621
4
15
35
The Ministry of energy now speaks for Genser; what a country! Ghana Gas signs a calls options agreement with a private company without ministerial approval but requires Ministerial approval to exercise their right under the contract.
5
17
33
With the amount of data available to KPMG we are keen to see how much analytical power went into the exercise.
If
@KPMG
allows itself to be used in a whitewashing machine for projects that lose Ghana billions, whilst the country is borrowing billions from the
@WorldBank
&
@IMFNews
, investors are being shafted, & some banks are on the brink, its reputation won't be spared.
#LeakTheReport
22
221
433
0
14
33
Our report couldn't be better summarised! Why there is deep poverty in Ghana can be explained by Many of these deals & the behaviour of the “dealers” in protecting the public purse. I've seen many terrible things go through Parliament- that report competes with Agyapa
@BBSimons
THE 5 FATTEST LIES OF ATTA AKYEA’s GENSER REPORT
A 🧵:
Two renowned think tanks in Ghana, IMANI (
@ImaniAfr
) and ACEP (
@AcepPower
),launched an investigation in September 2022 into why valuable natural gas owned by Ghana was being sold donkomi by GNPC to a company called Genser.
14
119
133
2
26
34
4. You were selling 49% of gold royalties forever, valued at $500m.
5. Since the aborted efforts, Ghana has made more than $500m for the share you were selling forever.
6. There ars about 5 pipeline projects that would’ve been part of the transaction to benefit the investors.
2
11
34
Sifting the data from rhetoric. The hard truths cannot tarry in the face of economic adversity.
1
14
34
They threaten, they call, they text, all in the service of a country. Congratulations
@Manasseh_Azure
. Inspire us to write our account.
My family wanted me to quit journalism. There was a day my wife was weeping, saying "I'm too young to be a widow"... - Manasseh Azure Awuni (Investigative Journalist / Writer)
#StarrChat
#StarrFM
@starr1035fm
#GHOneTV
13
128
822
0
10
33
ChatGPT tells us about the governance challenges in Ghana’s oil industry. Does the robot know us well enough? I think so!
3
9
32
Ghana’s new policy position is to award all available Oil Blocks through direct negotiation. Sad day!
14
18
32
Horizontal power dynamic; otherwise how?
After ECG, Ghana's state owned electricity utility, snubbed auditors appointed to collect critical data about ECG's operations, the powerful regulator, PURC, has stepped in. PURC says ECG must produce all the data, allow access to bank statements, & publish a dumsor timetable.
20
267
522
2
10
32
3. I can pay for a live tv for you to tell Ghana at least how you understand the transaction-real questions.
4. It'll be helpful to compare your purpose with current context after the people pushed against it. You value the royalties @ $1b forever. Ghana made over $1b in 3yrs
4
13
32
5. This post show that you either didn't read any technical analysis put out by CSOs or you feigned ignorance of counter arguments to advance benefits other than the interest of the state. The best you do is to expose the intellectual flaws in our arguments. None so far- sad.
1
12
31
Exciting times ahead as Aker and AGM now prefer to be treated as distinct entities. It is curious, though, when AGM realised that developing the Nyankom discovery would be challenging when they wanted to sell same to GNPC only 18 months ago and could value the asset at $700m.
3
13
31
Going through my archives, I find the headline of The Economist a perfect summary of the demands of CSOs in August 2021. Fast forward, Aker gets a $1 upfront payment for the asset they wanted $1.3 billion upfront from Ghana.
@BBSimons
2
19
30
And the “Jujufication” of the masses 🤦🏾♂️
1
12
30
Your haircut will not be the same in 2024. Meanwhile, only a few honest ones Will pay their bill, and ECG will discretionary abuse whatever is collected.
@BBSimons
2
18
30
Numbers don't lie. So, we spent time doing the needful
@BBSimons
@lordcudjoe
While politically sensitive, the GRA-SML deal, which could be characterized as the final scandalous exposé of 2023, is technically straightforward.
#ACEP
&
@ImaniAfr
offer a brief note to refocus discussions on the essentials.
More:
#The3BillionCedisLie
2
42
63
2
16
30
If it’s all hazy in your head, get it sorted with this piece. The absolute public interest in the 5G rollout is how it gets done effectively, timeously, and competitively for the Ghanaian. We were late with 4G; we are late with 5G and still want to experiment with 5Fs.
"5Fs for Ghana's 5G Policy" by Bright Simons
- a must-read for anyone concerned about state capture and the harm to Ghana's telecom sector.
#Ghana5GFail
#StateCapture
@NCAGhana
@BBSimons
2
21
38
0
17
28