Syed Iqbal Simnani Profile Banner
Syed Iqbal Simnani Profile
Syed Iqbal Simnani

@SimnaniIqbals

Followers
1,950
Following
5,051
Media
237
Statuses
53,886

VP, Global Tech- leading global bank. Digital -Tech strategy. Enterprise AI. Geopolitics. Germany. Muslim-Jew unity. India-Pak peace. Mysticism. Views personal.

Europe
Joined February 2018
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
Pinned Tweet
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
6 years
“Nobody is superior, nobody is inferior, but nobody is equal either. People are simply unique,... You are you, I am I. I have to contribute my potential to life; you .. your... I have to discover my own being; you have to discover your...”- Osho, Indian mystic /Scholar
6
37
229
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
I disagree. There is nothing wrong about doing “Bhoomi Pooja” in a country 83% Hindu. It reflects the dominant culture of India and does not threaten anyone. It is this kind of strict textbook definitions of secularism which creates a Hindu backlash against liberals.
@MahuaMoitra
Mahua Moitra
4 years
In a secular multi-faith democracy a PM should lay the foundation stone of a new parliament building, NOT do a “Bhoomi Pooja” And no, I am not anti-Hindu to point this out, merely pro- constitution
3K
1K
11K
73
505
3K
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
Both facts are true. 1. Most Muslim kings in India were brutal in particular towards Hindus( which some liberals and some Muslims wrongly deny). 2. Today’s Indian Muslims cannot be held responsible for that( Some right wing Hindu groups want to take revenge on current Muslims).
367
207
1K
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Sorry. Easy to pontificate. Given India's resources and the kind of tradeoffs needed, India has done an excellent job. I an Indian living in Germany and so far I see better public policy on Covid in India than Germany.
@AmyKazmin
Amy Kazmin
3 years
India is paying a heavy price for its imprudence, as it reels from a new wave of Covid-19 via @financialtimes #COVID ー19 #COVIDSecondWave
79
80
174
16
270
1K
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
5 years
Delhi riots: Liberals/muslim media figures who selectively only highlight the muslim victims and violence on muslims( which has been very bad), but do not highlight the brutal murder of an police officer by muslim mobs risk losing their credibility. You will regret later.
65
434
1K
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
The controversial oxygen debate on Covid India: A thread. Though I live outside India, I have family in India and am writing this as people are losing loved ones and are genuinely outraged. Yet we must go by facts though when we lose our loved ones it is natural to be...
38
338
807
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I have my own ideas on India’s secularism and I am not a big fan of a section of the left liberal hypocrites. India positively needed a Hindu Renaissance, but if handled wrongly can lead to a deeply polarized country. Having said that many India upper middle class Hindus are..
@AsimAli6
Asim Ali
3 years
The way Vir Das has reoriented from an apolitical 'all politicians all bad' to a clear anti-govt stance in recent times is one indication of some sort of a political shift among his audience: young, urban,English speaking, upper class. Shouldn't over-read but a straw in the wind
Tweet media one
21
50
696
22
129
503
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
The Yogi Adityanath debate in India will go on. As I said before, he will likely win UP, he is a great administrator and he has good shot to be PM of India. Yet from his past (and speeches), Indian Muslims have much to worry from him. Hope power matures him. Record it.
45
29
343
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
@clairlemon @nytimes As a Muslim I am ashamed of this. This is barbaric, inhuman. My heart is broken. Agree a devout Muslim finds images of prophet offensive, but this is no way to settle the argument. We Muslims must do introspection, we risk becoming social outcasts of the civilized world.
51
20
264
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
@shahid_siddiqui Hindus had a better case on Ayodhya(except for the crimnal destruction of structure by violent mob). Ram is their greatest religions icon. By opposing temple, Congress in fact made right wing Hindu parties stronger. There was and is no dearth of beautiful mosques to pray in India
29
18
250
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...Plus the cryogenic tanks that hold compressed oxygen cannot be manufactured quickly. Each tank takes about four to six months to produce. So there was no magic wand- pandemics overwhelm system. Balance pls. Thanks to Forbes article:
12
76
238
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Dear @ShashiTharoor @JhaSanjay @PChidambaram_IN Since you three represent the intellectual backbone of Congress, addressing this to you as a concerned citizen. I think Covid second wave is going to fundamentally change the political discourse in India. This thread got...
42
58
243
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@EdwardGLuce I admire your sense of fairness and surely a debate can be had on idealogical leanings of India's current ruling party. But your assertion that the current PM of India ignored every scientific warning is a 'plain' lie. In fact on Covid, his 'initial' response was one of the best.
5
13
212
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
More than two thirds of so called media handles and experts on India have no integrity and no intellectual courage to see both sides. This is true on the left and right. Truth stands alone.
12
50
239
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I agree with commentators like Swapan Dasgupta that a course correction was needed in the political discourse in India and a partial rebalancing was needed by having a right of centre alternative in India(with some sensible Hindu Renaissance). In this sense I disagree with…
9
43
221
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...a bunch of unprincipled hypocrites. When once in a century event combined with our 70 years long broken health infrastructure and not very proactive preparation for the second wave ( government did excellent in first wave), and they personally got affected they suddenly...
2
23
188
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I have always spoken against some fanatics in my own Muslim community in India and globally. But India is dealing with a pandemic right now. If any Hindu right wing group now puts old pictures of a Hindu Muslim conflict etc to divert attention, I have no sympathy for them. 🙏
7
16
169
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
... started going against PM Modi. I am not amused. Principled opposition is something else. Let us not give in too simplistic narratives.
2
21
166
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...now to the oxygen issue. The reason for the shortage isn’t supply, it’s getting oxygen to where it’s needed. Pandemic has hit us once in a 100 years, similarly, nobody expected the requirement for oxygen to move such large distances to happen. Most factories that produce....
2
27
152
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
2 years
To my Indian readers. I get Hindu Renaissance- it was partly needed. But do not get obsessed with it. Otherwise you will end up being narrow minded and narcissistic like some Islamists who do not seem to believe in course correction or moderation. Still might not be too late. 🙏
62
15
162
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
India will overcome Covid. Lessons. Become a richer nation. Fix our governance and institutions (decouple from which party in power). Call out some liberal politically correct hypocrites. Stop religious polarisation, stop hysteria for votes. Ask proof of work, not just slogans.🙏
9
27
151
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...intuition that even if there was a second wave, it will be a small one. Look at this nature article , even they are baffled by the severity of India's second wave ( may be election rallies and Religious festivals did not also help). ....
7
30
143
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...oxygen in India are located in the eastern part of the country—more than a thousand miles from major cities like New Delhi and Mumbai. Inox group has been able to ramp up its oxygen production from 1,800 tons to 2,300 tons a day over the past few weeks. One of the biggest...
4
18
140
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...obstacles is that oxygen is not so easy to transport. Tanks of compressed gases can only travel by roads or trains and cannot be flown on planes. now these tanks have to travel farther than ever before to keep up with surging demand in the states in north and west India. ...
4
21
141
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 months
To angry Hindu Renaissance types. Hindu Renaissance was needed. Yet highlighting 24 hours some Muslim rulers 5 centuries ago were cruel (which they were) to Hindus will hit law of diminishing returns. Try reconciliation. Be smart. A diverse country like India needs pragmatism.🙏
146
10
144
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Tweet media one
4
6
138
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Isreal-Palestinian issue is complex. Despite peer pressure from co-religionists I refuse to see it as a Muslim issue, I will see it as a Human issue. Most people who are complaining do not know the complicated past history of middle east ( and I am not a scholar). Fact is Jews...
11
15
134
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Have been lately occasionally watching @ShekharGupta ‘s cut the clutter on YouTube. He does a great job of explaining complex topics in simple terms and backed by good research. In an age of Information overload, Shekhar has found a good niche.
8
14
138
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 months
Rahul Pandita is not only a rare intellectual but a clear thinker and has a one in billion human quality- to not let a personal tragedy colour your judgment. Rahul is a Kashmiri Hindu ( Pandit) and history was very unkind to them and they were forced to leave their ancestral…/1
@rahulpandita
Rahul Pandita
4 months
Iqbal versus “Israel-type solution.” What does India need? My opinion piece in today’s @EconomicTimes
Tweet media one
48
87
357
7
13
137
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
6 years
@iamrana @Rezavi Hi Rana Safvi. You had today shared a link with detailed information on the source and authenticity of the orginal painting. But now your tweet is deleted. Did the source prove unreliable. I had distributed your link as proof to others. Kind of frustrating.
27
47
107
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Covid India: For oxygen, bed, hospital etc. Please also use app developed by IIT Kanpur:
2
87
122
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
You can troll me all you like. India’s long term internal and external security is best guarded by reassuring Indian Muslims that India also belongs to them and by resolving frictional issues smartly in an amicable way. Also whatever may be your personal or political opinion…
33
15
119
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...government had to a balancing act between building business confidence and putting more restrictions and where to do spend resources on. Plus unlike other nations , India was not hit by a second wave in November to Dec and some policy makers relied perhaps too much on their...
2
17
115
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...emotional. While there are some who point to data that worrying signs were already showing up in Feb /March and government should have picked up signals should surely be listened to and lessons learned, it was far from black and white. With India's economy battered, the...
3
15
107
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
I support farm laws in India. They are good for India. Sure people have right to protest peacefully. Yet many International celebrities commenting on farm laws are ignorant idealists who have no clue about reality. Indian government should win local support, use clever marketing.
2
17
119
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
6 years
@nntaleb Jeffry D Sachs said in two minutes all that is to say about Syria. Trump’s initial instincts were right, but then he listened to the establishment. Worth clicking.
@MarkWeisbrot
Mark Weisbrot
6 years
2 minutes of truth about US intervention in Syria from Jeffrey Sachs @JeffDSachs is worth more than 98 percent of the bullshit we are hearing on TV -- worth clicking on this:
280
8K
12K
6
52
106
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@siro_jaa To each his own. I admire Deng for the economic progress- but had I been living in China , I would probably been in a mental hospital, prison or have escaped to the west as an asylum speaker. I love speaking my mind and for that I love India( despite some tendencies to curb...
4
23
109
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
This is gratitude tweet to @UIDAI and @NandanNilekani . People underestimate how good UIDAI has been for India and how much it has contributed to make India an efficient state and how it has indirectly been a trigger to India’s digitalization journey.
4
19
117
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
It is one thing to say that justice has been met in convicting criminals in deadly serial blasts that killed many in Gujarat. It is another thing for BJP Gujarat deliberately put a provocative twitter cartoon showing Muslims in skull caps and beards being hanged en masse. I am…
31
22
111
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...turned from super efficient to useless in 3 to 4 weeks. These stories carry no credibility. Consistency matters to some extent.
6
11
98
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...they had opposed his policies or inefficiency on other occasions before the pandemic. Just opposing it during the second wave of Covid just because they were personally affected with lots of indications that the severity of second wave could have overwhelmed ant health...
1
13
99
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I personally do not care about any party as long as it makes India rich( very rich), is not apologetic about India’s Hindu traditions but does it without demonizing Indian Muslims - and brings values into business( a fault with unadulterated western capitalism).
@mavin08
marvin
3 years
@SimnaniIqbals @BJP4India This constant urge to give every damn credit to Modi is a slippery slope for a democracy (regional parties and Congress are even worse). I dread the day when Amit Shah becomes PM. He has been a disaster as HM. I want BJP to come but with a progressive outlook.
0
0
2
8
10
92
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Mr Yogi, chief minister of Indian state of Uttar Pradesh is actually a good administrator, who is slowly fixing one of India’s worst governed states always had a subtle Muslim bias. Now he openly trolls Indian Muslims. It is shocking no one from his ruling party asks him to…
@PTI_News
Press Trust of India
3 years
Country has to decide if sweetness of sugarcane will grow in UP or Muhammad Ali Jinnah's followers cause mischief: CM Yogi Adityanath
69
160
2K
31
8
99
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Dear Hindu brothers- I love you all with the core of my heart. Let us all work together to promote love between Hindus and Muslims. Do not focus only on differences. Not advocating escapism, but remember no one ever got convinced by telling him you are wrong.
10
6
95
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
It is true unlike monotheistic faiths like Islam and Christianity, Hinduism has never embarked on converting people of other faiths. At the same time history is not static. What was true in seventh century is not true in 18th century and is not true in 2021. While…
11
16
94
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I have always spoken against some fanatics in my own Muslim faith. And will continue to do that. No ifs and buts. But I have no obligation to be an useful idiot to some far right Hindu groups in India who want to reduce Muslims as second class citizens to take historical revenge.
12
7
91
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
1 year
Thanks for highlighting this. K Kamaraj needs more credit than he is given. Good to highlight these things.
2
6
88
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
...to avoid misunderstanding. I am not making any judgement on if India rich Hindu middle class was right or wrong in supporting Modi. None of my business and I do not care about any party. All I am saying is that their opposition to Modi would have looked more genuine if...
1
11
87
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@SejalSud Climate, Many engineering colleges nearby, IIM, IISC, ISRO, DRDO, NRIs who saw Internet revolution from start, Kannidiga Tolerance, women’s safety and last but not the least best beer and pubs in India. 🙏
3
3
84
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Dear @omarali50 Just an appreciation tweet. I really value your balanced views, comments and feedback. Social networks need more like you. Adaab, Salam, Namaste. 🙏
8
3
80
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
We Muslims are very sensitive to any slight caused to us by non-Muslims. Any slight provocation and Muslim streets erupt in protests and often violence. Why is the Muslim street not rising up against the brutalities of Taliban. Sure they can rule Afghanistan as part of a…
7
19
81
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Infrastructure smacks of unprincipled opposition. Sure government could have prepared better to make the impact less severe, but you are not making that argument but the argument that approach was totally flawed. It is simply too much to say and believe that a government...
1
9
76
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Denying China’s unprecedented economic progress is like burying one’s head in the sand. Many in the west ( and some in India) cannot digest that economic models( or more likely the only single way to interpret them) have been proved wrong by China. Denying China’s progress...
@elonmusk
Elon Musk
3 years
@XHNews The economic prosperity that China has achieved is truly amazing, especially in infrastructure! I encourage people to visit and see for themselves.
6K
2K
12K
5
12
73
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
India Hijab row: To know the real story, one has to go to the ground. India is a huge country and there are a thousand things going on simultaneously. Yet a few thoughts as I think this issue will have important implications for policy making. So here we go. If a certain…
6
12
71
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
To make it clear. Somethings had been bothering me and I tweeted my opinions on them. I have zero interest in politics. I am not good at it. Plus I love my freedom to say what I like and peace of mind too much to be interested in politics. Thank you for reading my tweets. 🙏
3
0
75
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Farm laws in India. As usual the wise @gurcharandas had great advice for the government of India in the interview he gave to BBC Hindi. He rightly said just like the GST reform, central government should have given each state of India a choice if to implement the law or not…
8
17
77
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
It seems John Bolton does not have too many nice things to say about Nikki Haley. I have always regarded her as a cunning,confident politician who will do anything to succeed in politics. She is very power hungry, but also very over ambitious without any moral scruples. Dangerous
2
7
67
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Farnam street essays rarely disappoint.
1
19
72
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
6 years
@blinkist Non-sense. Non-sense. Real learning comes from curiosity. Real learning comes from deep study. Skimming never teaches you anything. Of course Blinklist reading can give you keywords for making Bullshit bingo power points. Your app will make lots of money, but it is still crap.
2
2
63
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
5 years
@SushmaSwaraj @IndiainDRC Honorable minister, of course countries are obliged to help their citizens abroad. But the speed and efficiency at which this was done is commendable. Head bows in respect. May India have dozens of humane responsible ministers like you. Salam and 🙏🙏🙏🙏.
1
4
63
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Farm laws in India: I am sad they were repealed, India needed them badly. Elections come and go.
1
2
67
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I agree fully. Though initially linked to Swaraj and Khilafat movements, it in reality turned into an open massacre of Hindus. Annie Besant and Ambedkar- both neutral observers have also written about the cruelty of the riots and violence on Hindus in the Mopla tragedy.
1
17
61
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I might trolled for this, but I will risk it. I watched the hate speech clips at Hardiwar ( India). To me those who made hate speeches did not look like committed religious ideologues. They looked more like some men and women having psychological problems; or in desperate…
11
6
66
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
It is difficult to change people’s beliefs, biases, world outlook which they learnt in childhood. Your brain is deeply wired to reinforce it. Even if given counter data, you will reject it. This applies to me. This applies to heads of institutions, prime minsters of nations.
6
5
62
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Let me say this bluntly. I do not care about any political party. I have always criticized Congress double speak on secularism and I am partly concerned with BJP sectarian politics. Yet on governance there is zero proof that Congress could have done a better job on...
2
24
65
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
@Reuters As a Muslim, I condemn this barbaric attack by my co-religionists. How brain washed, sad and mentally sick does one have to be to slit throats, behead innocents, and that too in a place of worship. Enough! We muslims must come out of denial. I ask ask all Christians forgiveness.
0
3
54
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
As a Kashmiri Muslim who was there when the exodus happened I agree with below. Whatever be your opinion on Agnihotri’s film making style, you cannot deny the exodus of Kashmiri Hindus. And pointing out that a much larger number of Kashmiri Muslim civilians were killed in…
@hganjoo_153
Himanish Ganjoo
3 years
This is the problem with Kashmir Files. Some people here will criticize it. Even incorrect criticism will get lapped up because ultimately it's a film by Agnihotri. I'm already seeing a few handles "debunking" that movie. Because accepting the Exodus bristles your conscience.
11
12
173
5
15
64
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
To be blunt. While I oppose the confused far right Hindu groups to impose their hegemony on Muslim identity on the Hijab row, I am acutely aware many Muslim hypocrite liberals have their own axe to grind- they want no reform in Muslim social mores. Sad.
4
7
63
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@fatimazsaid @UmmRuqaya The writing is beautiful. Emotion captured beautifully. Yet one clearly sees echoes of doubt. Also while I respect the discipline, I am not convinced that Allah loves those who do not wear Hijab less. Millions of Muslim women who wear no Hijab love Allah as well.
3
1
59
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
What a disappointing take. So much out of touch with reality. Western Europe and USA enjoyed their prosperity, but Indians and Chinese need to be in poverty to atone for our sins. It does not work like that. This is not how negotiations work!
@Convertbond
Lawrence McDonald
3 years
@MulkiShailesh per capita emissions are completely meaningless in a "crisis." One billion persons in India do NOT have air conditioning + 1 billion in China without an automobile, middle-class income growth in em (1400 coal plants) = carbon explosion, regardless of what the EU - US do.
159
1
20
0
16
57
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
2 years
@elonmusk @stats_feed @engineers_feed From where India started, India has done remarkably well relatively. It will get even better in India. And more transparent laws than in China for clean tech in future in India.
6
4
57
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
5 years
@ewarren I used to be fiercely pro-abortion in my early youth. After listening to both sides of debate, I realized that many pro-lifers were not blind born again Christians, but also neutral humanists. I am now anti-abortion( except rape, health). I am pro contraceptives.
3
2
52
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Sorry, you have blind spots. There is a ‘Hindu’ viewpoint and there is the ‘Muslim’ viewpoint. India did need a Hindu Renaissance. The weak institutions and religious intolerance in Pakistan was bound to create a backlash in India. On the Ram Janambhoomi Babri dispute, Hindus…
@tequieremos
Fidato
3 years
It was Lata Mangeshkar who sang the tune for L.K.Advani's ‘Rath Yatra’ for the demolition of Babri mosque in 1989 when more than 3400 Indians, mostly Muslims died. It brought BJP to the doorstep of power; from 2 seats in 1984 to 120 in 1991 and 161 in 1996. #RIPLataMangeshkar
77
649
2K
3
6
59
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
2 years
I am neither a trader nor an economist. Yet I will stake my reputation on one topic. I am Indian and do not currently live there permanently. Below is the tip. Invest in India, it has a great economic future. Frame this tweet and hold me to account in ten years.
4
3
53
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I am losing respect for some friends on social media from India. I am with them when they say foreign policy and morality do not go together, also agree USA etc have had double standards. I lose them completely when they try to assert Russian position on Ukraine is moral.
10
4
55
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
…concede that this shift to right has given some pride to Hindus in terms of civilisations pride, which is a natural yearning. Also the BJP government did in its last term do some fundamental changes in rural infrastructure, access of toilets, cooking gas , digitalisation….
1
3
57
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
2 years
For a long time, the fundamentalist, fanatics and crackpots in Pakistan sold pure hate against India / Hindus (India under Nehru etc was saner) - they were wrong. Now India is rapidly becoming the same in terms of anti-muslim hate and this is wrong too.
22
6
51
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Interesting - I always call out no context politically correct one sided leftist liberals in India. But that does not mean I endorse madness. Since I called out the dangerous confused madmen calling for Muslim genocide in Hardiwar, I lost many followers. State of things!
10
4
52
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Avoid mobs. It does not matter if they subscribe to atheism, Dawkinism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism - just stay away. Educated in mobs makes no difference. The online versions are more toxic. Beware!
1
6
53
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
5 years
I fully agree. He created a ‘holy’ mess. He played the Hindu card to get votes- BJP bet congress at its own game. That being said, I do support the construction of a temple- the Hindus have a better case- but Hindus should please do it without jingoism.
@zainabsikander
Zainab Sikander
5 years
The only thing I'll remember Rajiv Gandhi ji for is: The Ayodhya mess. It basically legitimised the sangh.The worst mistake in the hist of Indian politics was the shilanyas. It fetched no body anything but brought bigotry+religion into mainstream politics.
167
154
661
5
3
49
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
Fact is if yourself possess nuclear weapons, you have no moral authority telling others that you cannot have them. You might be right the country aspiring has evil designs, but still the fact remains you have no moral authority.
3
7
53
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
2 years
I will leave the finer points of the India budget 2023 to the economists. For me below is the highlight of this budget. Human dignity is above anything else and I am happy someone in the government thought of this. Thank you.
@IndianExpress
The Indian Express
2 years
Tweet media one
2
36
115
0
5
53
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@dhume With respect. Too simplistic. It is easy to argue post facto that the severity of second wave was easy to predict. Many advanced nations with all their feedback loops also could not pro-actively plan everything. Pandemics overwhelm systems.
2
4
49
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
…, extension of banking facilities to a very large number of people, reset the doctrine of no first use of military force and somewhat relaxed ease of business, tried to bravely push through farm laws( a pity they failed). Sure BJP also had some well meaning but bad takes…
1
2
52
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
I have no issues in admitting that the current government in India (central government) is the least corrupt perhaps after Nehru. However there are genuine, serious questions about the way their elections are financed - and that matters. Let us strike a balance.
3
1
52
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
There is a genuine concern about crushing of dissent in India lately. But do not mix it with farm laws. They are good for India. Many International celebrities commenting on farm laws are ignorant idealists who have no clue about reality. Win local support, use clever marketing.
4
13
50
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
We all are rightly concerned about the bad Covid situation in India currently. But all kind of commentators on Twitter indulging in irresponsible talk as if they had a magic wand and crystal ball which PM Modi deliberately threw into ocean. Pandemics can overwhelm systems and...
5
7
50
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
2 years
Indian opposition parties should stop targeting its external affairs minister @DrSJaishankar . He is an able man. The man is not a politician. He is trying his best to protect India’s interests ( and doing it well). Foreign policy is not a saint’s job, and that is not his fault.
4
6
49
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
This is a gratitude tweet to my country of origin ( India). I studied in a state funded Government engineering college- which partly enabled me to have the life I have. Thank you. 🙏
3
1
47
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
…well read and well meaning people like Tharoor and Amartya Sen (economics Nobel Laureate) that all of India’s right wing Hindu movements are intolerant narrow minded political movements( at least they do not qualify it clearly if they mean anything more nuanced). I will also…
3
2
47
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
India’s decision to support the UN security council resolution calling for ceasefire between Israel and Palestinians was wise. Both from a foreign policy objective and from a humanist objective.
2
6
44
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
India’s home minister Mr Amit shah has narrow minded and regressive views. It does not matter how many followers he has. He is neither a statesman, nor a performer. Thanks to the safeguards of Nehru, Hinduism tolerant ethos, India’s constitution, modern democracy ( a side…
5
5
44
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Let me put this straight, even if I get trolled for this. UP has been terribly governed over the years. Competitive politics did improve it marginally in last 3 decades. I have said it before - Yogi Adityanath is a good administrator. Even before Covid, he had slowly begun to...
7
9
41
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
Many in the Muslim Twitterati hate me because I am not a big fan of many Islamists who block any reform in interpreting Islamic traditions and some of who are simply filled up too much non-sense and bigotry for non-Muslims. The centre of right Hindus and far right used to…
1
3
46
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@siro_jaa ...frank dialog on India’s past colonial and some cruel Muslim invader kings. What is also problematic is also holding India’s common Muslims responsible for those barbaric Muslim king invaders of the past. What is problematic is also not being able to say that “a Muslim group...
2
7
45
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
4 years
I supported caution and lockdowns at beginning as this was a new unknown threat. At same time, the worst case scenarios in Sweden did not materialize. We need to keep an open mind and learn from facts. Fear mongering does not help.
@jeffreyatucker
Jeffrey A Tucker
4 years
Sweden never locked down. Schools stayed open and so did restaurants and theaters, etc. Lower deaths per M than Belgium, Italy, Spain, UK, and Peru. And now look.
Tweet media one
81
541
1K
1
18
45
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
@KanchanGupta @ak_retd After BJP lost in Bengal, I condemned the poll violence on political opponents by TMC supporters. I again condemn it and agree with Kanchan. We must not be selective in condemnation, otherwise free press loses credibility.
6
8
46
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
5 years
@MoeedNj Many muslim kings destroyed hundreds of temples. I agree mob demolishing structure was wrong. India needed to have Hindu Renaissance of sorts, for Muslims it was one of millions of mosques, for Hindus it was like Mecca, birthplace of lord Ram. Court judgment was thorough, fair.
9
1
41
@SimnaniIqbals
Syed Iqbal Simnani
3 years
…Though we cannot say this is the official BJP policy, PM of India too often remains silent on the open hatred being preached against Indian Muslims ( the themes are to punish them for misdeeds of Muslim rulers of 500 years ago, or punish Indian Muslims for the happenings…
11
2
44