Cool thing happened today. My viral video - A Plan is Not a
#strategy
- just hit 3 million views in just over one year. And at the same time, became
#Harvardbiz
most viewed video of all time. Screen shot below & see video here if you haven't already:
The four books that I think are a must on strategy are:
The Prince by Niccolò Machiavelli
The Concept of Corporate Strategy by Kenneth Andrews
Competitive Strategy by
@MichaelEPorter
Business Model Generation by
@AlexOsterwalder
&
@ypigneur
@RogerLMartin
really love your concepts in strategy. I am starting my career on strategy thinking. Could you recommend great books or author like you on this subject?
I wasn't paying enough attention and missed the second anniversary of A Plan is Not a Strategy, which was on June 29th. In only two years, it is closing in on 4.3 million views - which is
#1
in the history of Harvard Business Review videos (thx HBR).
Peter Drucker was voted the most influential in 2001. I am honored to be on the same list in the same position 16 years later. He is the best management thinker in history.
#GPDF17
@rstraub46
"Strategy is what you do"
↳
@RogerLMartin
I am thus genuinely confused as to how someone can think OKRs = strategy
Unless you understand neither strategy nor OKRs.
Cool. Today A Plan is Not a
#Strategy
crossed the 4 million view mark. That is in less than 22 months. And almost a million views more than the next highest Harvard Business Review video. Happy to have had this positive impact.
I don't talk about strategy because it just causes confusion. I get them talking about the biggest problem they wished they could make go away - and we work on that.
@RogerLMartin
the senior leaders of these companies that would help create a 'aha' moment that encourages them to see strategy differently ? How to wake them up from this collective self-hypnotization ?
As you well know, Tom, I tried for 15 years as Dean. But I have to admit, I underestimated how hard it would be. A whole new pedagogy needs to be built to give folks the confidence to let go of the existing one. A big job!!
Our lives are organized by models. Once we have a model of something, the answers/decisions we come to are shaped by that model. And all models (per John Sterman) are wrong - otherwise they wouldn't be models. So having multiple
models available to look at a problem is critical.
@asmartbear
@RogerLMartin
Can't recommend this highly enough (in which Argyris writes about the thermostat and double loop learning)
It's a pamphlet rather than a book, readable with one cup of coffee ☕️
“A great strategy is unique, specific, and complete; it stands on the shoulders of a big idea; and it is owned by a leader who is ultimately responsible for its implementation.”
The majority of 'strategy consultants' don't even have a useful definition of strategy, let alone are able to consult usefully. If a client doesn't know a thing about strategy, they won't be able to distinguish between a strategy charlatan and a strategy advisor.
@RogerLMartin
I still hope the other founders will come to their senses (I mean If you don't see the value of strategy how are you supposed to convince clients to buy strategy advice from you????)
I just published my latest
#playingtowin
Practitioner Insights piece: It’s Time to Toss SWOT Analysis into the Ashbin of Strategy History Hope you enjoy.
#strategy
#SWOT
@RogerLMartin
What do you think will be generative AI’s impact on strategy and durable competitive advantage?
I have not convinced myself I know the right answer, just some initial theories
My new
@washingtonpost
editorial. The virus shows that making our companies efficient also made our country weak More to come in my Sep 2020 book: When More is not Better: Overcoming America's Obsession with Economic Efficiency
I just published my latest
#playingtowin
Practitioner Insights piece on Medium. This one is on Asking Great Strategy Questions Hope you enjoy!
#strategy
#questions
That is why Must-Have Capabilities & Enabling Management Systems are the reality check of
#strategy
If you don't do the reality check, your strategy isn't real.
Couldn't care less how old it is, the question is it any good? And the answer is that this is a terrific piece. Just terrific. Great work. I learned from reading it and encourage everyone to do so.
I heard your recent podcast with
@lennysan
, and I have a question,
@RogerLMartin
: If positioning is indeed a subset of sound strategy, how can companies be sure about their positioning and messaging, but not be sure about their overall strategy?
Most: user needs being targeted; value proposition; amount of cash the needs to be spent before getting definitive user reaction. Least: revenue forecast (it's made up); vision statement; advisory board.
@RogerLMartin
A related strategy question I am often asked by our executive team is how to “paint all of our employees into the strategy”? The concern is that only some employees will be directly involved in executing the strategy and the rest will feel left out. Thoughts anyone?
With respect to
@RogerLMartin
, if Strategy isn't a plan. Why is nearly all strategy out there...
a plan
Reminds me of how 'Marketing' had to be rebranded to 'Growth' in order for Silicon Valley to digest it for the last 20 years.
Do we need to rebrand Strategy too?
I am more sympathetic than not. MBA education is broken and I spent 15 years attempting to fix it. It will crater if it doesn't fix itself. However, I am not as enthusiastic as he is about engineer-CEOs - lots of good ones, but lots of bad ones. Not a panacea.
What it means to be a Canadian pursuing excellence: When you don't win ('11, '13, '15) Cdn media covers foreign winners. When you do win Cdn media ignores totally
@globeandmail
@TorontoStar
@nationalpost
Sadly I have none to recommend. Frankly, this question is a big source of business for McKinsey and BCG. They sell generic analyses of industries and make a lot of money doing it.
@RogerLMartin
what online or offline sources or reports would you recommend to understand industry analysis / dynamics. Objective is to understand their unit economics
Thx. Interestingly, the accomplishments below have been totally ignored by the Canadian press - I guess they don't like to acknowledge Canadian success
Nicely done Mahmoud. What I like the very best is your iteration. Most people do the equivalent of your Version 1 and think they are done. You kept going and going - and will reap the rewards of your efforts. Great stuff!
Product Roadmap is not a strategy.
OKRs are not a strategy.
Hope is definitely not a strategy.
In the past 9 years, I read 10s of books and tried several frameworks for creating a "Product Strategy", but all failed.
Thanks to the work of
@RogerLMartin
, I was able to create a
Cool.
@HarvardBiz
just dropped my second video - after the Planning v Strategy that is up to 1.1 million views. This one is on Loyalty v Habit
#strategy
With the clock ticking down to its May 3 launch, I wanted to let everyone know that I am very excited about my 13th book: A New Way to Think. Please pre-order it at
#strategy
#leadership
#Effectiveness
#Management
Dear
#CEO
, plaster this advice from
@RogerLMartin
’s to your bathroom mirror:
Every business function should have a
#strategy
, one that aligns with company strategy & decides for its context
- Where to play
- How to win
Filled with keen economic insight and advice for citizens, executives, policy makers, and educators,
@RogerLMartin
’s When More Is Not Better is the must-read guide for saving democratic capitalism.
Man, MBA programs are so deficient. I love your idea, Tom - mine was a Masters in Business Design. But on those top three, Tiffani, MBA teaches: simplistic problem solving, reflexive thinking and how to (accidentally) crush creativity.
I like this short interview from the
@thinkers50
European Forum done by
@BrightlineOrg
that briefly covers my most current views on management effectiveness
I do downplay the word 'strategy' in my work with clients. We solve their toughest problem by making choices - which is strategy whether it is called that or not.
@RogerLMartin
Viewing it as problem solving without complicating it under the guise of “strategy” might help. But it is vested interests and politics which prevent it from being what it is
Never use a SWOT analysis, says
@RogerLMartin
"They have at best, zero value. They generally are worse than nothing, because they get you thinking about all sorts of stupid things."
The fundamental conceit is that the measure designer thinks those measured will treat the measure in the way the designer desires rather than the way the measured desires. Hint: they don't!!!!
Goodhart’s Law: “When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”
Campbell’s Law: "The more a metric is used, the more likely it is to corrupt the process it is intended to monitor.”
What do you think?
@RogerLMartin
I’d gladly pay the Medium subscription just to read Roger’s work.
Interestingly, none of Roger’s posts are behind any kind of paywall, Siddharth.
@RogerLMartin
Been spending quite a bit of time looking at the word "bet" and its use in strategy & product mgmt in software (Spotify's DIBB). Recently found your HBR 2013 re: placing strategic bets. Do you remember your 1st use of bet / influences / adoption of that language?
Glad you are paying attention. That was a change a few months ago. Seemed to help clients understand better and focused them on the right thing: customers.
@RogerLMartin
@RogerLMartin
It seems you’ve slightly modified your def of strategy in recent writing. I could be wrong? The “integrated set of choices” is same, but target is now “customer action,” but used to be “positions the firm… to create CSA and superior value.” Am I right?
Is it right to equate intellectual rigour with data analysis? If the answer is no — as
@RogerLMartin
and
@TonyGolsbySmith
suggest in this article about
#management
being more than a science — then how should managers arrive at their decisions?
Yup. ESOPs. Going to see more of those. Drucker was always right. Takes time to play out. His Knowledge Workers of 1959 are finally spreading their wings and telling employees Drucker was right!
@RogerLMartin
argues against “designing jobs for low-skill, minimum-wage clock punchers”. Agree! What if all employees were salaried? What if they were equal owners? Is that possible? Yes ..
#ReThinkOrgs
#collaboration