I just submitted my design for flag and matching seal to The State Emblems Redesign Commission. I'm appreciating the thoughtful process on this quick timeline. Especially the part that incorporates revisions!
#newMNflag
@NewMNFlag
The State Emblems Redesign Commission is now accepting design ideas from the public for the state flag and the state seal. You can submit your ideas at the following link:
You’ll want to get your designs in in the next week or two.
#NewMNFlag
#mnleg
WOW! I'm simply thrilled that my flag received the most votes from the State Emblems Commission this evening.
I am very eager to work with the Commission to address their feedback and make the flag even better. Onwards to a
#newMNflag
!
@RepFreiberg
F29's journey has come to an end. Thank you all for your support over the past two weeks! It has been a whirlwind journey.
I look forward to seeing the
#newMNflag
fly over the Capitol this spring.
Here is how members of the State Emblems Redesign Commission voted on the six flag finalists:
F1953 (19 votes)
F2100 (15 votes)
F944 (12 stickers)
F1154 (10 votes)
F1435 (8 votes)
F29 (8 votes)
New MN flag is official now! I think this flag is a good design and it's growing on me. It's now up to the people of Minnesota if it becomes more than it's design.
Time will tell if we fly it and see it everywhere.
As confusing and uncertain as the road to this point was get here was, three of the revisions featured in this article would make a very good flag for our state. It's a major upgrade!
Congrats to Andrew Prekker, designer of the new Minnesota flag!
Snowflakes aren't weak. They cause us to slow down and change our plans - forcing us, as a state, to work together to clear them. They provide us recreation and beauty. Snowflakes should not be embarrassing or an insult.
However... This flag does NOT contain a snowflake. 1/
Ah, this flag just looks so great as a flag. I'm so pleased with how it turned out in the end. Grateful for everyone that has sent me kind words of encouragement today.
#starflake
I have so many thoughts about these. Thread.
1. These were produced by unnamed graphic designers at the request of the SERC (in-house/firm). The original designers have had little input. Generally, the SERC has not been eager to accept revisions from the actual designers.
For those who think the MN final six flag designs are boring, consider:
1. 🇯🇵🇱🇨🇧🇷🇨🇭🇧🇩🇨🇾🇭🇰🇰🇬🇸🇴🇲🇦 (center on solid field)
2. 🇺🇦🇫🇷🇯🇲🇮🇪🇩🇪🇮🇹🇵🇸🇿🇦🇹🇿 (rectangles, triangles, lines, and colors, you know most of these!)
3. 🇨🇦🇧🇧🇦🇷🇱🇧🇨🇳🇮🇳🇰🇪(More flags you may know)
Keep it simple!
After 12,167 votes and 5 rounds of tabulation, the results are in and…
Design F29 by Brandon Hundt is the winner of our ranked-choice flag design poll with 6,542 (55.3%) final-round votes!
View the full results here:
The "Snowstar" flag design now has a very light-hearted FAQ. I answer all your questions about symbolism, colors, combinations, and swallowtails...
(All I know is I feel better after doing this!!! It was very therapeutic.)
#newMNflag
I just submitted my design for flag and matching seal to The State Emblems Redesign Commission. I'm appreciating the thoughtful process on this quick timeline. Especially the part that incorporates revisions!
#newMNflag
@NewMNFlag
4. Had I received the Commission's feedback a few weeks ago that they felt green is a necessary color, I would have featured more revisions that featured two-color field options, like these. And I like these.
I too am excited for this seal, but it will make a terrible flag! Sorry
Think about viewing this flag from a distance, all the nice detail will be lost. How would it be distinct from the other 30 states with seals on their flags?
Keep in mind flags are flown, seals are stamped!
Many folks have asked if I am considering revisions to the
#starflake
F29 flag. Indeed I have. Revision is a natural part of the design cycle.
You can find my thoughts in a slide deck embedded in my blog. I also sent a similar version to the SERC.
FYI - There are Starflake (F29) shirts and phone cases. I didn't mention it until now because I didn't want folks to think I was in it for the sweet sweet t-shirt money. (I wasn't and am still not.) Enjoy!
I want a
#starflake
hat
@BrandonHundt2
. Minnesotans want a
#starflake
hat, or maybe a t-shirt. We will carry your flag on our chests and on our noggins no matter if it flies on a state flagpole. Make it so.
Whatever you call it, "L'etoile du Nord", "Starflake" "F29" or something else, you can now officially voice your support for this as the
#newMNflag
:
Thank you!
P.S. This is the first time I'm seeing the requirement to use the MN color palette, AT THE END OF THE PROCESS. Wild.
MN green is a nice accent color on the dark blue in print - as a major color? On a flag in the elements? it will fade to white
Many folks have been asking me about Starflake and MPLS using it. I have another design in mind. I think this flag design has the deepest symbolism of any I've created.
The Minneapolis Waterwheel:
2. Elements of the three eliminated flags are very present. Dakota stars, Snowstars, 8pointers. I was not consulted on my opinion on this. Legally they don't have to. However, it would have been a nice gesture.
However, this revision needs to be binned now. "I'm looking for my missing piece. I'm looking for my missing piece" Or is it a hidden person who is hungry? The twists keep coming.
3. Honestly, I don't think my star works on these flags. the detail gets lost. A simpler 8pt, like the Dakota star or a simpler selburose without the dot work better.
I know this Valentine's Day you are in a committed relationship with the new MN flag, but damn, Starflake is doing its best to make you double-take tonight and causing you to wonder what could have been? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The Portuguese, Latvians and other cultures featured it widely too as far back as Mesopotamia (in the form of the Star of Ishtar)
It's not a snowflake. Its a star! /end
To the Nordics it is represented as the selburose, it has strong significance to the Dakota, and the 8pt star was used in Underground Railroad's hidden messaging through references to the North Star in quilting patterns. 3/
@alexschief
I'm quite upset that the SERC didn't offer the chance for Andrew to collaborate on revisions with the consultants. He should have been involved throughout.
This design is going to follow him for his life. Therefore, I'm glad he likes how it turned out, and it won't haunt him.
Flags are for people, not our occupations or even our geographic surroundings. Our flag should demonstrate what our shared values are, and what we want Minnesota to be.
That's why I like the North Star, it's a guiding light pointing us to this refuge of freedom, pointing home.
6. All this said, the SERC was put in a tough spot by the bill and some late appointments leading to some of these decisions.
Good final products come from good processes. Some of these flags ARE BETTER for these revisions, but there's so much more we could have seen weeks ago.
My own understanding of this flag has evolved since I first designed 8 years ago and especially during the last few weeks. I think one of the most significant realizations is my evolving understanding of the 8pt star - and its multicultural significance across the globe. 2/
5. So was the single color treatment of the flag eliminated or the star? This is where this process baffles me. Things are gone, then they are back. But we are only exploring the stars in one treatment.
I'll say it again, no one in this state has been a more vocal and consistent advocate for a new MN flag than Lee Harold. This is a nice piece honoring his work.
Beautiful tribute to Lee Herold from
@MPRnews
- From crayons to Capitol advocacy, a Minnesota flag enthusiast nears moment of triumph | MPR News
#NewMNFlag
@dbrauer
As an American with Norwegian ancestry, I am often baffled by my fellow Norwegian-Americans and their inability to see how much better off and happier actual Norwegians are today because of their progressive policies.
Maybe its because this dude isn't in Norway?
One more thought, I'm glad to see an 8-point star as the only star now being considered. With a nod to the Selburose, Dakota star, barn patterns, and the Capitol Rotunda, it's fitting!
The Mayor
@melvincarter3
's the
@cityofsaintpaul
State of "Our" City Address and everything is ready.
Everything, except for the lighthouse at the
@XcelEnergyCtr
. I thought it was supposed to be lit up for gamedays!
What is a big political speech if not gameday? 💡
1. Ok, I'm not like an expert in soccer tactics, but
@MNUFC
never has enough numbers in attack. Even when they scored the goal, they were outnumbered 3-5 and it took a Nouhou misclear.
Abu Danladi needs to sprint to the back post
PPPPPPS: Now there's a second deck with fewer, but better revisions for two of the flags?? I'm still confused and the next SERC meeting will be wild.
However, this deck has some revisions for two of the flags that are really nice and improved the flags!
@TheJvandy
TBH, if the North Star Flag was meant to be, it would have happened in '92.
With the design talent in this state, we can do better.
My suggestion (but I'm open to others!):
Which Minnesota county or city wants it more? HA!
On a serious note, I'd be happy to work with any municipality on their new flag. Many will need to be changed after a new state flag. *Cough Hennepin County *cough.
3/3 The Snowflake: Winter We embrace it. Put on a sweater and stay warm. As a bonus this is also the shape of the star on the floor in the rotunda of the Capitol building in Saint Paul.
Confirmed. The flag on the right is indeed upside down. Possible that's an intentional choice as a sign of protest, but it would be an odd choice if the point is to promote the old flag.
@BrandonHundt2
@Flagged4Content
Darker colors fade first. So the blue would get lighter quickest. The green would turn a yelowish pale white over time I think.
@MNSteveSimon
These are posted by how many of the committee members included them in their Top 25.
Only one flag got 5 votes in the first cut.
@NorthStarFlagMN
and a few others got 4 submissions.
Commission members are now discussing how to proceed as they narrow it down from 216 to 5.
I also think this flag was a "canvas" the SERC could play with and they wanted to play. No other finalist flag went through more revisions or was better able to handle the "combinations" with other flags they talked so much about.
Flag
#4
, folks. You know what to do. 👍🗳️🙏
The MPLS Waterwheel flag, based on the original Starflake, is the most symbolically packed flag I've created.
Voting is live for our unofficial Minneapolis flag contest! Choose your favorites from all 16 submissions in the first round of voting, open now until early Friday.
@silvertongue39
@FlagsForGood
is working on it. Whether it makes it purchase is yet to be seen.
I do have the latest revision (final?) now available as a t-shirt!
2/3 The Directional Star: “L’etoile du Nord” The North Star. If you follow the North Star, you will end up in Minnesota. Gold represents the rich resources of the land.
2,600 designs for
#NewMNFlag
!!! Narrowing this list to 5 is the most critical part of this process.
When they are released, 1,200 of these will be WOOF, and another 1,200 will be BAD.
Brace yourselves and don't focus too much on the bad ones! It may spoil the gems.
Thank you for having me on
@WCCO
(again!) to show off my
#newmnflag
submission
@CaroRCummings
! Watch if you want to see the real deal version I got made.
I just submitted my design for flag and matching seal to The State Emblems Redesign Commission. I'm appreciating the thoughtful process on this quick timeline. Especially the part that incorporates revisions!
#newMNflag
@NewMNFlag
@DavefromDuluth
I think we avoided worst-case scenarios. I said "good" and not "great". Definite improvement. Rights a historical wrong.
If Minnesotans fly it, it can elevate it. Like Texas flag, its more than its design because people fly it and take pride in it.
Still TBD on this.
@natepentz
MPLS Voter's Guide 2022:
Find the street in your neighborhood with the most expensive single family homes.
Note the candidate yard signs.
Don't vote for those candidates.
Truth. FWIW, I attempted to fix this way back in 2017, and City Pages (RIP) picked up my blog post. Th MPLS Downtown Business Council seems uninterested in tackling this.
2,600 designs for
#NewMNFlag
!!! Narrowing this list to 5 is the most critical part of this process.
When they are released, 1,200 of these will be WOOF, and another 1,200 will be BAD.
Brace yourselves and don't focus too much on the bad ones! It may spoil the gems.
🚨There were 2,600 entries for the new Minnesota flag/seal designs submitted to the State Emblems Redesign Commission. Deadline was last night.
background:
Many have asked about symbolism. Here is what I submitted:
Blue: Minisota’ Sky-tinted water: The land of 10,000 lakes. The Great Lakes begin in Duluth. The Mighty Mississippi is formed in our state. If any state has a case to have a blue flag, it is Minnesota. 1/3
@FlagsForGood
Did you see the full doc? The problem I have is they've moved the goal posts yet again. These are the official state colors, not in the brief, and not mentioned until today.
Would have been good information to have.
@MNUFC
Loons when Dotson starts at winger: 0 wins/5 matches.
Dotson starts in midfield 12 results/13 matches.
Two young wingers on bench looking for an opportunity. Why not? Galaxy subbed teens for teens.
PLAY THE KIDS!
@BillLindeke
The Charter Commission is Minneapolis version of the unelected House of Lords, and even the UKs unelected House of Lords doesn't interfere this much.
Dear
@MPS_News
,
Getting hacked sucks. Hackers that target public school systems are the literal worst. It really sucks. There's no need to feel any embarrassment.
But please, please be more transparent so we all can take action to protect our data.
Sincerely,
A MPS parent
The Minneapolis Public Schools data breach is really bad. Much worse than we've been told.
This affects current & former staff, students, & parents. The district hasn't been forthcoming, so here's a 🧵 w/ facts about what's going on & concrete steps to take to protect ourselves.
@JKealing
@mrosemn
I'm live-streaming the meeting. These are not the only flags that are being considered for the top 5. The Commission is making it clear that any of the final flags will not be adopted as is. Revisions will be made.
They are voting for a top five now.
When I first started to imagine what a
#newMNflag
could look like, 8 years ago, I came up with this: two Loons over the north star. It's cool, but it's using
@MNUFC
exact logo - which is cheating. More for the
@MNWonderwall
or
@mnufc2
1/
Dear
@WIStateFlag
,
I think WI's license plate is tacky, but in the best way. b/c Wisconsin IS tacky in the most charming way. This is a compliment.
Don't change your plates. In fact, we can use it as inspiration for a new flag!
Your welcome,
A Minnesotan w/ deep ties to WI
@KyleHampelEsq
I've sloppily been referring to it as L'toile du Nord or F29. Northflake or Snowstar are fun!!! Whatever it means to you, call it that. 🤣
Congrats to Brandon and Rachel on the purchase of their next home! They were ready for more space and we were happy to find them this gorgeous classic in St Paul. Thanks
@AngieShererTeam
for helping us get it done and
@TWBakeryTweets
for another great cake! 🏡☀️
I'm proud of our work on the
@PRX
tech team to build a new website for
@TheWorld
that respects our visitors ⏱️time, 👍attention, and 🔒privacy!
🚫ZERO third party cookies. ⛔️ZERO third party trackers.
I went through the 2000+ submissions for
#Minnesota
’s new flag so you didn’t have to.
There’s great designs, funny stuff, and a clear trend…
@NorthStarFlagMN
@NorthStarFlagMN
@RepFreiberg
I want to acknowledge that we wouldn't have a State Emblems Commission without Lee Harold. He is a legend and a kind person. I feel a bit for him today.
It's really cool when people you don't know (or don't know who is behind the account) advocate for your work.
Keep spreading the word to ensure the
#newmnflag
is something good!
Ted Kaye, secretary of the North American Vexillological Association, said he thinks the six finalists are a "good start." But he also suggested one or more changes to each.
#startribunemustread
@JKealing
@mrosemn
I'm live-streaming the meeting. These are not the only flags that are being considered for the top 5. The Commission is making it clear that any of the final flags will not be adopted as is. Revisions will be made.
They are voting for a top five now.
@natepentz
I'm glad he's connecting it to the success of Scandinavia - arguably the highest taxed, yet happiest place on Earth.
The Scandinavian model used today can also trace its roots partly to the North Shore of Minnesota.
Book recommendation: