Lived experience mental health researcher and NHS volunteer. Please share the article in my pinned tweet to raise awareness that EDs are not untreatable.
Spread hope for
#eatingdisorder
sufferers who are unfairly labelled as ‘untreatable’, 'treatment-resistant', or 'terminal'. Please share/repost my new article ('Terminal anorexia': a lived experience perspective on...):
The take-home messages include:
"A sufferer who protests that there is no hope left may actually need the clinician to hold the hope for them, until they can carry it on their own... They may need clinicians to give them permission to live rather than permission to die."
My new article on the harmful and unnecessary label ‘terminal anorexia’ has just been published by the Journal of Eating Disorders. Please read and share.
I received an acknowledgement from
@NHSEngland
of my letter of concern regarding 'palliative pathways' for ED sufferers. This is an important first step for demoralised ED sufferers who need to be heard. Please continue to share:
I am touched by the response to this quote from my first article. There is so much hope for sufferers who are given up on because some clinicians 'treat' them as untreatable. Many more clinicians hold hope for them. If you are one of them, please spread hope for them.
"A sufferer who protests that there is no hope left may actually need the clinician to hold the hope for them, until they can carry it on their own... They may need clinicians to give them permission to live rather than permission to die."
Surely, the role of a clinician should not be to "tease out" of a patient whether they really want to die, and whether their expressions of despair are 'authentic'? Death is not a game to be played with. Life is precious.
Please read my recent lived experience article, and share the hope for eating disorder sufferers who are unfairly labelled as ‘treatment-resistant’, ‘untreatable’, or ‘terminal’.
I co-wrote this letter with
@jamesldowns
and
@HopeVirgo
, who have campaigned tirelessly for ED sufferers for years. It responds to unsatisfactory reassurances from NHS England’s National Mental Health Director. (1/2)
Independent research is very difficult when you don’t have access to most journal articles because you are not part of an institution, and therefore have to pay more than most books just to read one article.
"... they have identities... that go far beyond their eating disorders. They should not have to feel that defeating their ED requires defeating their whole selves... they can and deserve to live (not just ‘exist’ or wait to die)."
#hope
#eatingdisorder
Letter of Concern to NHS England about 'Palliative Pathways' for Eating Disorder Sufferers
Follow-Up Letter of Concern to NHS England about Eating Disorder Care
“Limited progress in addressing the poor quality and effectiveness of eating disorder services is causing avoidable harm.”
@RobBehrens1884
warns Maria Caulfield that more action is needed to address the system for treating people with eating disorders.
I'm glad the label ‘terminal anorexia’ has in principle been withdrawn by Dr Gaudiani. Its dangerous misuse by professionals in the real world, and the heart-crushing concept, needs to die. People with eating disorders should never, ever have to die unnecessarily. (1/3)
#ICED2024
Trying to ‘achieve’ a perfect diet is not healthy eating. There is no such thing as a ‘perfect’ diet, despite what some people (often with self-interests) may claim.
"Research is not just read, seen, and heard about by the professionals who promote it. Vulnerable and conflicted ED sufferers, and their families, can be victims of theoretical academic discourse that has real-world, life-or-death implications." (2)
"Above all, we should be debating about how, as therapeutic allies, we can give
#eatingdisorder
sufferers the right to truly live – not just exist, survive, or wait to die."
“‘Terminal anorexia’: a lived experience perspective on the proposed criteria” is a follow-up to a related article (“‘Terminal anorexia’: a lived experience perspective”) that was published by the Journal of Eating Disorders earlier this year:
@autisticpuffin
I'm so sorry. This happens extremely frequently, so you are not alone in feeling this way. I briefly addressed some of these issues in a recent article (the link is in my pinned tweet), but of course every ED sufferer is unique, so what I wrote does not apply to all sufferers.
It always confuses me whether insensitive media reporting is due to their lack of awareness, or their conscious desire to make newsworthy stories regardless of the costs to vulnerable people.
I received an acknowledgement from
@NHSEngland
of my letter of concern regarding 'palliative pathways' for ED sufferers. This is an important first step for demoralised ED sufferers who need to be heard. Please continue to share:
“Above all, we should be debating about how, as therapeutic allies, we can give ED sufferers the right to truly live – not just exist, survive, or wait to die.” (3/3)
#ICED2024
Just a personal opinion - Some of the heart-crushing numbers and photos shared widely in news articles are not helpful for some individual ED sufferers, even though it may be in the name of raising awareness for all. Avoiding these triggers is not so easy when they are broadcast.
If I were a treating professional, I'd rather give hope the benefit of the doubt - for my patient above all, but also for myself, to make sure I don't give up on her/him.
“Vulnerable and conflicted eating disorder sufferers, and their families, can be victims of theoretical academic discourse that has real-world, life-or-death implications.” (2/3)
#ICED2024
I'm really sorry, I should have said longstanding eating disorder (not just anorexia) sufferers in this tweet. All EDs (including BN, BED, ARFID, OSFED) deserve equal consideration, as they are all devastating illnesses. To all ED sufferers, please look after yourselves ❤️
"Patients with anorexia, he said, are often keen students of their disorder; they read the academic literature about it. As a result, for the first time in his career, he has had patients in their 20s ask about palliative care and assisted deaths." - Dr Philip Mehler (1)
Evil inflicted by murderous terrorists does not justify evil sanctioned or overlooked by international governments. My heart goes out to Israeli and Palestinian civilians who have been killed or had their lives ruined.
The article by
@katieengelhart
in
@NYTmag
on
#terminal
#anorexia
and
#palliative
care highlights the need for all perspectives to be heard during this tragic discussion. So, please read and share my concerns written in this article published last month:
@jamesldowns
James, your kindness always warms my heart. Your words mean so much to me, and they remind me not to lose faith when it feels like no one is listening :)
@_madi_faith
@AgnesAyton
@jamesldowns
I have been told quite a few different things! I think what really matters is that bone health can improve - whether or not the bone mineral density score (which I think is just a relative number based on age and sex) is in the osteoporosis or osteopenia range❤️
This article () by
@emmelclein
is the most powerful media article on ‘terminal anorexia’ that I have read. A very moving read. It reinforces everything I wrote in my two journal articles last year.
It is important that people like me with lived experiences (as well as clinicians and researchers, who may also have lived experiences) listen to others with lived experiences.
I admire researchers and clinicians who value the voices of those whose opinions they do not necessarily agree with, and in some cases, even encourage these voices to be expressed and heard.
"Remember, remember, this is now, and now, and now. Live it, feel it, cling to it. I want to become acutely aware of all I've taken for granted." - Sylvia Plath ❤️
I've always wondered whether it’s better to have a broken heart that has at least experienced love from another person, or a cold heart that has never been warmed by the love of another person, and therefore cannot be broken.
@gonefishin752
@AgnesAyton
@ChrisPalmerMD
@Metabolic_Mind
Please don’t be sad! I believe in recovery, whether or not this means being ‘cured’. Recovery means different things to different people. Every sufferer can recover according to their own definition of recovery if they are given the right support and treated compassionately.
@jamesldowns
@NHSEngland
I hope that because my letter has been publicly shared, and their response will also be, they do not send a default and impersonal response.
@AgnesAyton
In the short-term for someone with autism who can’t be flexible? Isn’t eating something less unhealthy than eating nothing? The lesser of two evils? 😟
@AnorexiaMyths
@JenH_EDSUK
I’m so heart-warmed to hear that your daughter is better. I’m sure there are many others who are blessed and inspired to meet her now ❤️
"Because she was on palliative care, Naomi’s doctors were prompted to indicate, after appointments, whether they expected her to live longer than six months. Sometimes they did, and sometimes they didn’t." ... Is this ethical and professional. Is it moral and humane?
@HadleyFreeman
@HarperCollins
Hi :). I quoted some emotive words from ‘Good Girls’ in an article that has just been published by the Journal of Eating Disorders.
@LouiseW_psych
Thank you Louise :). You are so right - hope and compassion are crucial. The article would have been worth writing even if only you and your loved one were the only readers.
"A sufferer who protests that there is no hope left may actually need the clinician to hold the hope for them, until they can carry it on their own... They may need clinicians to give them permission to live rather than permission to die."
@Katie_Bee86
@DavidViljoenED
@NHSEngland
@NHSEastEngland
Treatment has failed you, not vice versa. I want to try helping you personally, not just others. Can I write your question in a follow-up letter to NHS England? Your voice deserves to be heard, and your question deserves an answer.
@GraceHBDalton
Hi Grace :). I agree with you. I wrote in a letter of concern recently: "NHS EoE’s guidance suggests that at a given point in time, patients have a binary choice between ‘recovery’ and ‘harm-reduction’. However, these two approaches are not mutually exclusive...
@ehardyjb
You are absolutely correct - people who relapse "have not failed treatment. In fact, it is far more likely that treatment has failed them... patients who are given up on by professionals... are far more likely to give up on themselves also." (p.8)