1/8 תגובה ראשונה של ועדת ונציה, בה חברה ישראל והפועלת במסגרת מועצת אירופה, לשינויים שהקואליציה מתכננת לערוך במערכת המשפט בישראל : הודעה מהיום (14.2.23) של נשיאת הועדה, קלייר באזי מולורי (חברה עד לאחרונה במועצה החוקתית של צרפת המשמש שם כבית משפט לחוקה):
Come work with us! Call for applications for post-doc positions in my new ERC project - Three Generations of Digital Human Rights - deadline for applications: 1/3/23.
Feel free to retweet...
@HujiLawOfficial
@HUJICyberLaw
@ERC_Research
A new SSRN publication on justifications for a new international human right to a human decision maker, emanating from a June 23
@3genDR
@EthicsInAI
workshop in Oxford (when less terrible things dominated the global agenda):
Congratulations, dear Yuji! A loss for the UN Human Rights Committee, a gain for the ICJ... I believe this is the third time a member of HRC makes the transition to the ICJ (Higgins and Buergenthal did it before)
4/8 למרות שהשפה דיפלומטית, הנשיאה יותר מרומזת כי חלקים ב״רפורמה המשפטית״ המוצעת אינם מתיישבים עם עקרונות בסיסיים של דמוקרטיה, שלטון חוק והגנה על זכויות אדם – למשל, פסקת התגברות, פוליטיזציה של הליך מינוי השופטים וצמצום משמעותי של היקף הביקורת השיפוטית על חקיקה.
New decision by
@UNHumanRights
Committee: by denying access to essential health services, Canada discriminated against migrant family w/o regular immigration status
2/8 ההודעה מדגישה שלוש נקודות: 1) מדינה דמוקרטית המכבדת את שלטון החוק ואת זכויות האדם צריכה לאפשר ביקורת שיפוטית על חקיקה על-ידי בתי משפט עצמאיים
2) בתי משפט אלה צריכים לפעול ללא התערבות פוליטית בעבודתם, במיוחד באשר להרכבם
6/8 קיימת גם אפשרות כי ועדת ונציה תחבר, בהמשך, חוות דעת מפורטת על הרפורמות בישראל. חוות דעת שכזו אינה מחייבת מבחינה משפטית, אך נחשבת כ״תו תקן״ בינלאומי לגבי חוסנן הדמוקרטי של המדינות החברות בוועדה (ישראל הצטרפה לוועדה בשנת 2008).
8/8 יש לציין, כי הצהרות נשיאותיות מטעם ועדת ונציה אינן מאורע שכיח. ההצהרה המתייחסת לישראל הנה ההצהרה היחידה שניתנה השנה, ובשנה שעברה ניתנו בסה״כ חמש הצהרות - 2 ביחס לרוסיה (בקשר לפלישה לאוקראיינה), 2 בקשר למונטנגרו ואחת בקשר לרפובליקה המרכז אפריקאית.
New text of Draft General Comment 37 on
#ICCPR
article 21 (right of peaceful assembly) as adopted by the
#HRCttee
on first readings is now out for comments by States, NGOs and other stakeholders. Other language versions will follow soon.
@UNHumanRights
7/8 האיחוד האירופי הסתמך בעבר הקרוב על חוות דעת של ועדת ונציה שנכתבו ביחס ל״רפורמות המשפטיות״ בהונגריה ובפולין והשתמש בהם כבסיס עובדתי להחלטות אופרטיביות ליזום סנקציות כלכליות ואחרות נגד מדינות אלה, אם לא יפעלו בהתאם להמלצות ועדת ונציה.
New article for the new year! Happy to see the advanced publication of an EJIL article co-authored by
@HUJICyberLaw
research fellow Dafna Dror-Shpoliansky and myself on digital human rights. Hopefully, 2022 will be kinder to online + offline human rights…
@UNHumanRights
#HRCtteee
launches its first ever predictable review cycle (PRC) for 2020-2027, scheduling reviews for all states parties to the Covenant, including non-reporting states
3/8 3) החלטות בתי המשפט העליונים במדינה צריכות להיות סופיות ומחייבות עבור מוסדות השלטון האחרים וכלל התושבים
היא קוראת לישראל לכבד את העקרונות הללו ולקדם שינויים במערכת המשפט בהליך משתף ובהסכמה רחבה.
Call for Papers: The 16th Annual Minerva Conference on International Humanitarian Law
"Looking from the Outside In: Evaluating IHL from Other Normative Perspectives"; Jerusalem, November 9-10, 2021.
UN Human Rights Committee issues Views on the incompatibility with the Covenant of preventive detention as applied to two convicted sex offenders in New Zealand. This is the first ever case in which oral hearings were held before the Committee.
Congratulations and welcome, Andreas Zimmermann. Very pleased to see you joining the
#HRCtte
And many thanks to Anja Seibert-Fohr for her 5+ years of excellent contribution to
@UNHumanRights
We congratulate Prof. Andreas Zimmermann, the newly elected German expert sitting on the
#HRCttee
! He will contribute to the important task of monitoring the implementation of the
#ICCPR
. Thanks to Prof. Anja Seibert-Fohr for her dedicated work in the
#HRCttee
since 2013!
Here is my JC piece on the
@UNHumanRights
Committee - how it is different from the
@UNHumanRights
Council and what impact it has on the state of human rights across the world.
25 Israeli international law experts: involuntary deportations to Rwanda of African asylum seekers violate international law. Criticize reliance on secret agreement, indefinite detention to compel departure & Rwanda’s designation as de facto safe country
New Call for Papers for a history of international law conference co-organized by the Int'l Law Forum
@HujiLawOfficial
, Robinson Institute for the History of Legal Thought and Practice at
@HebrewU_heb
& Leibniz Institute for Jewish History & Culture, Dubnow-Institut Leipzig.
Is Israel turning to international law in response to escalating cyber attacks? New
@lawfareblog
@IDIisrael
@HUJICyberLaw
blog entry by Tal Mimran and myself.
Israel, Cyberattacks and International Law
Happy to announce a new Springer publication - collection of essays honoring Mota Kremnitzer (The Quest for Core Values in the Application of Legal Norms), co-edited by Khalid Ghanayim & me with chapters by Grimm, Weigend, Eser, Hornle, Fletcher & others
HU CyberLaw Tallinn Manual 2.0 Workshop: lively discussion over the Manual’s authority, sovereignty in cyberspace, due diligence, proportionality and long term resilience of state-based regulation of cyber operations
New General Comment for CAT Committee - GC 4 on deportation to torture. Barring dissuasive measures & policies which would compel protected persons to return to dangerous countries; diplomatic assurances can not be used as ‘loopholes’.
HU CyberLaw recruiting another researcher (post-doc) to work with Noam Lubell
@nlubell
and me on regulating military application of human enhancement technology and their related cyber security challenges. The work can be done in Israel or long-distance
New AJIL issue containing article on the rules governing use of force in cyberspace written by
@HUJICyberLaw
researcher Dan Efrony & me claiming governments tend not to invoke international law when conducting or responding to cyber operations, but that this may be changing
Here’s the program of this year’s edition of the annual
@minervahrhuji
/
@ICRC
IHL conference, focusing this time on detention law and practice. Should be interesting!
New post on the experience of the Inter-American human rights system in holding sessions away from HQ - interesting lessons for
@UNHumanRights
Treaty Bodies
Available from CUP bookstore as of this Thursday: A collection of essays on human rights law from a great line up of contributors, honoring Prof. David Kretzmer and marking different stations in his rich professional career. Promotion code available below.
Happy
#HumanRightsDay
! Our Petitions team is dedicated to making sure that your voice is heard and your rights are respected.
#StandUp4HumanRights
and reach out when you fear that your rights are being violated 👉
Félicitations à Yuval Shany
@yuvalshany1
@HujiLawOfficial
élu président du Comité des droits de l’homme
#HRCttee
. Une élection méritée pour un universitaire et un collègue exceptionnel. Le Comité est en de bonnes mains !
Tomorrow at
@HujiLawOfficial
's International Law Forum: Our annual international law & history Workshop on recognition & Israeli-Palestinian context, with panel in memory of Shabtai Rosenne. Should be interesting...
#UN
treaty body delivers important judgment for protection of journalists: congratulations to super courageous and persistent
@lydiacachosi
and to
@article19mex
for their support. Impunity will be defeated
My response to Laurence Boisson de Chazournes' article on plurality of international courts and the managerial approach now in the new EJIL Issue (see link to abstract)
#HRCttee
& other TBs recently informed by
@UNHumanRights
that future sessions might be cancelled due to budgetary reasons. This is completely unacceptable! Quasi-judicial monitoring of
#ICCPR
& protecting victims can't be held hostage to budget disputes
Assessment by
#UNHCR
of recent Views of
#HRCttee
on applicability of
#ICCPR
to asylum claims by individuals escaping countries seriously affected by climate change
UNHCR - UN Human Rights Committee decision on climate change a wake-up call: UNHCR
Israel Law Review
@CambridgeCore
- 50th Anniversary Volume (issue 3) - Benvenisti, Sender & Wood, Medina, Fatima and Cali revisit 5 landmark articles from the Review's first five decades.
UN HRC and CESCR Committee join forces today to exchange views ahead of 2020 review of the treaty bodies; decide to strengthen cooperation, and to explore concrete avenues for coordination of their activities. This is the third meeting in plenary of the two Committees in 2 years
'Stopping the deportation' - HU students organise impromptu 'Hyde Park' style lectures on campus to raise awareness to impending gov't deportations of African asylum seekers from Israel to Rwanda. Glad to have been asked to speak about the State's non-refoulement obligations!
New article by
@amichaic
and me in I-CON on the changing relations between human rights and the law of occupation in the recent caselaw of the Israel Supreme Court.
@ICONnect_blog
New
@lawfareblog
post from
@TShadmy
and me on the rather disappointing recent decision of the Israeli HCJ reviewing MOJ Cyber Unit's non-transparent 'voluntary' online law enforcement, involving content take down requests from online platforms.
@DemocracyIL
@HUJICyberLaw
"Protection Gaps in Public Law Governing Cyberspace: Israel’s High Court’s Decision on Government-Initiated Takedow...," the latest from
@TShadmy
and
@yuvalshany1
:
Please share with relevant candidates: Exciting short-term/flexible research position
@HUJICyberLaw
for PhD/post-doc/visiting researchers interested in attribution in cyberspace and/or int'l fact-finding. Deadline for applications extended to 1 Dec. 2018.
Very strong diagnosis of the ailments of the
@UNHumanRights
Treaty Body System by
@OFrouville
. Some of the changes proposed are highly thought provoking!
The treaty body system has been in crisis for at least thirty years. Will the year 2020 bring change?
@OFrouville
adds his contribution to our debate with
@ISHRglobal
on human rights treaty body reform.
📃
Lex Cybernetica - The first
@HUJICyber
Podcast is out, dealing with the Tallinn Manuals' impact on state practice. A conversation between Deb Housen-Couriel, Dan Efrony and myself. Moderated by Ido Kenan.
Guardian reports on Palestinian complaint against Israel under CERD. Might be first ever Inter-state case before UN Treaty Bodies.
Palestine files complaint against Israel under anti-racism treaty
#ESILRF18
Basak Cali deliver opening keynote speech: international law has been slow to internalize change but can generate fine grained analysis of developments re uncertainty and contestation; and avoid excessive generalizations.
Belgium 🇧🇪 warmly congratulates the 9 newly elected members to the Human Rights Committee from
🇹🇳 🇬🇾 🇫🇷 🇸🇮 🇬🇷 🇯🇵 🇺🇬 🇦🇱 🇨🇱
We wish them success with their important mandate monitoring the implementation of civil and political rights.
#ICCPR
@JTasioulas
Should be very interesting! Thank you
@JTasioulas
and
@EthicsInAI
for hosting this promising event, which also serves as a launchpad for my new
@ERC_Research
project on the development of digital human rights -
New issue of the German Law Journal on Int'l Law & Digitalization. It includes my article on digital rights & the outer limits of int'l human rights law. Congrats to special issue editors- Dana Burchardt &
@maria_varaki
+ thx to rest of the editorial team
#HRCttee
has endorsed most recommendations of its working group on the simplified (LOIPR) reporting procedure, allowing states to move from comprehensive reporting to focused replies to questions. This option will now be permanently offered to states.
If in Geneva next Monday, do join us in a UN HR Council side event on HR in Cyberspace, co-sponsored by the PM of Israel & Germany +
@HUJICyber
- and
@Geneva_Academy
Marking the 100th anniversary of the ILO - a joint statement by the two Covenant Committees
#iccpr
#icescr
reaffirming centrality of freedom of association to their respective mandates + underscoring the close relations b/w 2 Covenats &
#Hrcttee
&
#cescr
Good news from Florida: amendment 4 on restoring voting rights to 1.5 million disenfranchised ex-convicts goes a long way towards implementing 2014 recommendations of
@UNHumanRights
#HRCttee
on voting rights found in US concluding observations.
Interesting paper by Pawelyn and Hamilton offering a typology for exits of States from international tribunals. Unfortunately, Human Rights Treaty Bodies also have some history in this regard.
Exit from International Tribunals
@SSRN
New IDI publication (with Yad Vashem): Reducing Online Hate Speech Recommendations for Social Media Companies and Internet Intermediaries.
16 recommendations by int'l experts + 3 papers by Shwartz-Altshuler & Medzini, Eltis & Siatitsa, and Benesch
Thank you,
@AustHelmut
for organizing this very interesting workshop, which made me understand better the way in which the origins of the ECHR continue to shape its practice, and why the
#HRCttee
has opted in certain cases for a different legal approach.
Interesting development next door. Palestinians reportedly join the ICCPR 2nd Optional Protocol abolishing the death penalty, becoming 86th party thereto.
@HUJICyber
,
@DemocracyIL
,
@EssexHRC
joint workshop on on-line surveillance kicks off in Jerusalem. Lively discussion on duty of notification for targets of surveillance, and permissibility of bulk collection in light of recent experience in UK and ECHR
Two interesting new Views of the UN Human Rights Committee on the right to stand for election in Bolivia (unreasonable residency requirements) and the Maldives (impact of due process violations in trial against former president)
#HRCttee
also switching to questionnaire based one-stage simplified reporting as the default procedure for all state reports. States interested in maintaining the ‘standard’ two-stage reporting system would need to opt out from the new system.
My
@JPostOpinion
on Judicial Activism in Israel - for every case of alleged excessive judicial activism one can find many more cases of alleged judicial passivity
@HUJICyberLaw
/
@DemocracyIL
workshop on new cyber security bill, with National Cyber Directorate & Israel Tech Policy Institute: frank exchange of views b/w gov’t officials & local + foreign experts; strong concerns about breadth of bill and weak safeguards.
My Times of Israel piece on the negative effect on protection of basic rights in Israel of some of the proposed constitutional reforms considered by the next coalition government.
@DemocracyIL
A new
@HUJICyberLaw
@nlubell
podcast on human rights and military applications of AI - Prof. Noam Lubell | The Federmann Cyber Security Center – Cyber Law Program
My take in the Times of Israel on the legal debate around the immediate implications of the criminal charges brought against the PM: Remove Netanyahu right now on grounds of temporary incapacity
Thank you
@FleurEJ
for this very interesting introduction to the
@AJIL_Unbound
symposium on Dan Efrony and my ‘Rule book on the shelf’ AJIL piece, + insight that for some lawyers an act of war is not an act of war if not articulated as such.
@KingsCollegeLon
/
@HUJICyberLaw
Workshop in Jerusalem on attributing cyber attacks: lawyers think this can be done, technology experts warn against the unknown unknowns
A new contribution by Viljam Engström in Int’l J Const L blog to the debate over the binding/non-binding effect of Treaty Body Views following the recent Spanish Supreme Court decision in González.
A message from
@HujiLawOfficial
@HUJILaw
LLM Program in Human Rights & Transitional Justice re Lara Alqasem, who was supposed to start her studies in the program yesterday.