Even in very mainstream economics (micro and macro), the moment you drop the assumptions of perfect markets/competition etc. price controls are an obvious policy implication. E.g., price controls fit perfectly well in DSGE models because they assume monopolistic competition. 1/4
Most European countries and the US have price controls. Switzerland (definitely not a communist country) has the highest % of consumer goods subject to price regulation. This has arguably helped to keep inflation relatively low in recent years.
4/4
This piece with
@SimonGrothe
just came out on the blog of
@INETeconomics
. A few points:
1. Profit-led inflation does not require an increase in the markups, and is compatible with the Structuralist/Kaleckian theory of prices and distribution.
...Rigidities cut different ways. The fact that most mainstream academic economists use these models but reject the use of price controls out of hand (and focus only on some of the models' policy implications) betrays an ideological bias more than serious analysis. 2/4
This is not to say that price controls are a panacea. However, their use on a case-by-case basis can be useful both for containing inflation and for improving income distribution. 3/4
Lance was one of world's best macroeconomists with a huge influence on all of us who were lucky to take his classes and work with him - and of course on many other people who studied his work.
We are saddened to learn of Lance Taylor's passing. His influence, in the field and among his students, will live on, and we are grateful for everything we learned from him.
The Journal of Post Keynesian Economics is delighted to announce the appointment of a new co-editor,
@mnikiforos
.
Explore theoretical research on contemporary economic problems.
Here:
#EconTwitter
This paper -"Notes on the accumulation and utilization of capital: some theoretical issues"- just came out in Metroeconomica. It discusses some issues related to the triangle between capital accumulation, distribution, and capacity utilization. (short 🧵)
This paper (co-authored with
@pacarrillom
) was just published-open access-at
@SCEDjournal
. We estimate the time varying effect of income distr. on growth. We find that the US economy became more profit-led in until the 1970s and has become less profit-led since.
Our MSc in the Political Economy of Capitalism offers a uniquely-plural approach to economics.
Two weeks left for the application deadline.
More details can be found here:
This policy report (co-authored with
@dbpapadimitriou
and
@GennaroZezza
) came out recently. We make 5 main points: 1. The current recovery has been an important macroeconomic success (accompanied by an increase in inflation and the the trade deficit).
Outstanding news! Bard's Levy Economics Institute has been awarded a federal contract to aid the Labor Department in its efforts to broaden how it measures the economic well-being of US households.
#bardcollege
@levyecon
Is it really that different though? The baseline neoclassical model remains the same. The fact that different type of market imperfections and rigidities changed the results was well understood in 1979 and way before that.
My paper "Induced shifting involvements and cycles of growth and distribution" just came out in the Cambridge Journal of Economics (advance access and for the moment unlocked). 🧵
"NAIRU tracks the actual un. rate sluggishly. When un. rises, analysts discover that the demographic ch/stics are deteriorating, or that the w-p dynamic has become unstable. When the u.r. drifts down, those flaws mysteriously begin to disappear, and a lower NAIRU is estimated."
This might be the most important development in the labor market: Estimates of the "natural rate" of unemployment have fallen from six percent a decade ago to four percent.
2. An advantage of the term profit-led is that it emphasizes the distributional source of inflation: profit margins are maintained while all the burden of the adjustment is borne by real wages. Ignoring this distributional aspect naturalizes the claim of corporations on output.
For connoisseurs of capacity utilization -and the theory of growth and distribution- here is a new paper that just came out in Metroeconomica:
It makes three points:
🧵
5. The piece is based on current and previous work but was inspired by Marc Lavoie's recent piece on inflation. We find profit-led inflation less controversial.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸 University of Geneva, today! Assembly of the occupation in solidarity to the Palestinian people. Impressive particaption (especially on a holiday Friday).
Tomorrow at 3pm ET on Zoom:
Join
@Claudia_Sahm
and
@socio_steve
for an hourlong session covering their latest white paper with
@Sidhya26
, "A Critical Review of Macroeconomic Models for a Guaranteed Income & the Child Tax Credit."
Register:
I have a chapter on "Demand, distribution, productivity, structural change, and (secular?) stagnation" in the new Handbook of Economic Stagnation (ed. by Randy Wray and Flavia Dantas). Overall great collection of papers. Check it out.
4. Has there been an increase in markups over the last three years? This is an empirical question. Using Compustat data we find that average markups kept increasing in 2022.
28/03 the Political Economy Seminar and the Advanced Research Seminar (Paul Bairoch Institute of Economic History) team up to organize a joint session with Clara Mattei
@claraemattei
@thenewschool
!
"The Capital Order"
We have addressed this issue in our INET piece (link below). In a nutshell
@RiccardoTrezzi
is wrong. Ironically his graphs makes the points nicely. Even with constant markups real profits do not increase but real wages halve. This is not a distributionally neutral process.
🇮🇹 Inflazione "da profitti" e salari.
Questo commento di Andrea mi da modo di chiarire un aspetto che avevo lasciato volutamente fuori dal 🧵 precedente: il conflitto redistributivo salari-profitti creato dall'inflazione.
Sottotitolo: "Riccardo di' qualcosa di sinistra!"
1/N
Very sad news. Crotty was one of the most important heterodox macroeconomists. I only saw him once in person-at the inauguration of the "Crotty Hall" (the building named after him) at UMass Amherst- but it was always a pleasure to read his work.
Just received news that Jim Crotty is gone.
I don’t have words to describe the pain of losing Jim . He was not only my mentor and a great intellectual inspiration but also one of my best friends.
He will be greatly missed..
Here is a new paper (with
@pacarrillom
). It is yet another paper trying to estimate the effect of changes in distribution on growth. Its originality lies in that it allows this effect to change over time. 1/3
Yes, but accouting decompositions reduce the degrees of freedom of causal analysis. This decomposition says that the wage-price spiral story-which is the main mainstream explanation for inflation and guides int. rates increases by the CBs-does not hold.
This tweet frames an accounting decomposition as a causal effect. When demand rises and supply cannot follow, prices and margins go up. That doesn’t mean that companies decided out of the blue to raise prices and make profits, thus causing inflation.
Also very important, when the tide turned he refused to join the "dark side" (that is how he once called during a class the new-Keynesians and neoclassicals!).
We shall miss him but always treasure his work.
Attending the Eastern Economics Association conference in NYC this week? UMass Boston Econ professors
@JFCogliano
@leilaedavis
@Kumar_EconIneq
are organizing 15 different panels over Feb 24-25 covering a range of topics in heterodox economics.
#EEA2023
...Over the last decades profit shares have increased in most developed economies and this increase has been accompanied by a secular increase in the markup of the firms. An increase in the markups that would amplify price shocks would be consistent with these trends.
Thrilled to be hiring a postdoc at the UMass econ department thanks to OSF funding!
I’m looking for someone with a PhD in social sciences, economics or history to join me in working out the economics of essential sectors for our age of emergencies.
3. In Structuralist/Kaleckian analysis, the *exogenous* markup does not mean that markups and profit shares are overall *constant*, but rather that they are determined by institutions and social norms outside of the economy along the lines of classical political economy...
A good summary by Kindleberger of New-Keynesian economics and their acrobatics: "I think you have provided a most ingenious solution to a non-problem" [i.e., reconciliation of the obvious inefficiency of the depression with the postulate of rational private behavior]
Congrats
@IsabellaMWeber
. At the same time I cannot help to mention that it is hilarious how in German translation of "How China escaped the shock therapy" becomes "The spook of inflation"!
BUCHPREMIERE ist wirklich ein schönes deutsches Wort. Der Vorhang öffnet sich, "Das Gespenst der Inflation" tritt hervor. Bin jetzt schon voller Vorfreude auf das Gespräch mit
@schieritz
! Herzlichen Dank an
@suhrkamp
@BoellStiftung
@IMKFlash
! Join us! 🍾🥂
He had a unique style of doing macro with a combination of sophisticated theory and applications/policy using broad strokes of data and orders magnitudes- along with history, institutions and the economy's structures (he was a structuralist after all).
2. Inflation is largely unrelated to the level of demand or the pace of the recovery and is mostly related to the disruptions due to the pandemic. E.g., Here is a graph with growth and inflation in several OECD countries; there is no correlation.
@heimbergecon
@spignal
@PhilippaSigl
These are the projections of the adjustments programs and their various reviews (in levels and growth rates). So, no, the collapse in GDP was not part of the plan. Given the projected growth rates GDP would recover to its precrisis levels within a few years.
We estimated the (very positive) macro effects of a (roughly) 2tn public infrastructure plan with a simulataneous increase in tax rates for corporations and rich households a couple of years ago here:
J'ai été interviewé pour cet article dans "Le Temps" de Genève sur l'inflation, ses risques pour la croissance et ce qu'on peut y faire.
I was interviewed for an article of Geneva's "Le Temps" on inflation, its risks for growth and what we can do about it
If we account for "base effects" for shelter inflation, the rate of inflation today is not different from what it was in the five years before the pandemic. This leaves with sources of inflation pretty much unrelated to the strength of the recovery in the US.
Here is a new working paper coauthored with
@SimonGrothe
entitled "Contractionary effects of foreign price shocks (and potentially expansionary effects of inflation)."
A small 🧵:
@jj_carloriv
@IsabellaMWeber
Thank you for your kind reply. Indeed, the exchange rate and other factors (such as less reliance on gas) also played a role but so did price regulations.
As announced on Monday, we have made the difficult decision to stop paying wages and premiums for healthcare benefits for employees who are striking. Up to this point, we have continued to compensate our faculty and staff who have chosen to exercise their right to strike.
4. It argues that when it comes to the normal rate of utilization it is the expected growth rate of demand that matters, and not the level of demand. This insight provides a more straightforward way to link the adjustment at the micro and the macro level.
@Lprochon
@IsabellaMWeber
But is this really a "reply" or just a clarification (that increasing profit shares don't require increasing profit margins/markups)? I don't think that the story of
@IsabellaMWeber
is incompatible with constant markups.
His work on macroeconomics, his insistence that macroeconomics is necessarily monetary, and his advocacy for policies that would promote full employment and social justice have been a great inspiration for many non-mainstream economists.
Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) presses Biden’s pick for currency comptroller Saule Omarova about “you used to be a member of a group called The Young Communists.”
Omarova explains, because she was born in the Soviet Union, she was part of school youth programs mandated for students.
---Call for Papers Alert ---
Join us for the 5th Pluralumn Workshop from August 6-8 at the University of Duisburg-Essen dedicated to connect young scholars with a pluralist approach to economics.
Deadline: May 19
Further info and submission:
It makes four main points: 1. It explains why utilization is a crucial variable for the theories of growth and distribution, and their ability to combine an autonomous role for demand (along Keynesian lines) and an institutionally determined distribution (along classical lines).
We find that the US economy became more profit-led in the first postwar decades until the 1970s and has become less profit-led since; it is slightly wage-led over the last fifteen years. 2/3
In Dec 2008 we had occupied the building that stood in the place of the university center-with similar demands. 14 years and 2 administrations later the situation at
@TheNewSchool
seems to be worse. Solidarity to the strikers and the students.
With great grief and sadness I announce the passing of my PhD advisor Prof. Dr. Peter Flaschel
@unibielefeld
, 2006 Heuss Professor at
@NSSRNews
. The profession loses a great & prolific scholar as well as a kind & humble human being, and I lose a dear friend. May he rest in peace.
@odavis_
@vebaccount
There is disaggregated data (see table), but no sector seems to be running too hot. I think the bottlenecks/constrained sectors story is correct, but these constraints come at this point outside of the US economy.
2. It responds to some recent criticism by Girardi and Pariboni (2019) and I explain that their interpretation of the model in Nikiforos (2013) is misguided, and that the results of the model can be extended to the case of a monopolist.
4. Because of the fragility of the corporate balance sheets and the overvaluation of the stock market, tightening monetary policy risks causing a financial crisis, with severe consequences for the US economy in terms of output and employment.
@Lprochon
@IsabellaMWeber
In the abstract and the paper they write that firm protect their margins - and some even expand them. Of course, the fact that rising markups is not a prerequisite for higher profits shares does not mean that there have not been rising markups. But this is an empirical question.
Presents our forecasts for the US economy, and shows why an infrastructure and families plan could have positive macro effect.
And argues that concerns about a sharp increase in inflation spurred by the fiscal stimulus are unwarranted.
Some preliminary analysis shows that the increase is not as broad based as in 2021. Some of the increase is due to firms with higher markups increasing their market share. More details coming soon.
@ProfDavidFields
@Lprochon
@ReviewofPE
@RicardoSumma
Rudi, Marcio and I have different takes on the profit-led story (I believe that the demand regime changes over time). But this is a different debate. And I do not find convincing a story where the cycle is driven by autonomous (exog.-to-demand) fluctuations in resid. investment.
The more the two classes prioritize the increase of their income share over economic activity, the more possible it is that the economy is unstable (lambda=degree of wage-ledness, pi=profit share).
@JWMason1
@EconBerger
@andrewelrod
@rortybomb
Here are two more papers which might be relevant. The decrease in util. over the last 3 decades can only be explained by lower demand. All other factors have moved in a direction that should have increased it.
He continues: "If one believes in rational expectations, a nat. rate of un., efficient markets,...there is not much that can be explained about business cycles or financial crises. For a *****Chicagoan*****, you are courageous to depart from the assumption of complete markets."
16/05 Next session of the Political Economy Seminar! We are pleased to welcome Thomas Fergusson
@INETeconomics
!
"Industrial Structure and Politics in the New 'New World Order': The Case of the US"
@CFlowMuzik
"because of discrepancies in source data, timing differences, and difficulties in adjusting the source
data to remove holding gains from reported revenue or
changes in positions." See page 14 in this documentation of the IMAs:
@heimbergecon
@spignal
@PhilippaSigl
The forecast was that austerity and "reforms" would have a marginal effect on consumption, a medium run positive effect on investments, and would lead to a boom in net exports.
On the other hand, as the profit share increases, the economy tends to become more wage led. There are good theoretical and empirical reasons that justify this (think of the decoupling of investment from profits over the last decades).