BREAKING: Supreme Court, splitting 5-4, rejects challenge from California church to public gathering restrictions. Roberts joined the liberal justices to form a majority.
Breyer and Kagan start asking questions at the same time. Breyer proceeds.
Breyer: "We're probably going to ask the same question."
Kagan: "I doubt it."
NEW: A statement from Justices Sotomayor and Gorsuch:
"Reporting that Justice Sotomayor asked Justice Gorsuch to wear a mask surprised us. It is false. While we may sometimes disagree about the law, we are warm colleagues and friends."
I’ve covered five other Supreme Court confirmation hearings. None of them included anything like the chaos in the opening minutes of the Kavanaugh hearings this morning.
PACER charges 10 cents a page for electronic access to federal court filings. Actual cost of storage and transmission, by one estimate: $0.0000006 per page. What access to public records ought to cost: zero.
BREAKING: Supreme Court won’t halt Texas law banning most abortions after six weeks of pregnancy. The vote is 5 to 4, with Roberts joining the liberals in dissent.
A round of applause, please, for Calvin Duncan, a former jailhouse lawyer whose relentless advocacy led to a landmark decision today on unanimous juries.
Unnamed donors, sitting judges, secrecy pledges and loyalty oaths at Heritage Foundation “training academy” for law clerks. After questions from The Times, the passages below were deleted from the application materials.
Seth Waxman, at NCAA argument, call Justice Thomas “Mr. Chief Justice.” Thomas says he appreciates the promotion. Roberts responds that the job isn’t open.
BREAKING: Trump can’t block release of his financial records to NY prosecutors but lower courts must take another look at whether Congress may see them.
BREAKING: The Supreme Court will hear arguments by telephone in May, including in the Trump financial records cases. "The court anticipates providing a live audio feed of these arguments to
news media."
BREAKING: A new conservative majority at the Supreme Court reverses course on Covid restrictions on houses of worship. Before RBG’s death, the court approved restrictions by 5-4 votes. Now, also 5-4, court goes the other way, with ACB in majority.
A reader wrote to me suggesting a connection between the Manhattan hush-money trial and Thursday’s immunity argument at the Supreme Court. In slow-walking the immunity case, the reader wrote, the justices are engaged in their own catch-and-kill operation.
NEW: Supreme Court won’t stop limits on voting in Florida by ex-felons.
Sotomayor, dissenting: “This court’s order prevents thousands of otherwise eligible voters from participating in Florida’s primary election simply because they are poor.”
BREAKING: The Supreme Court blocks partisan-gerrymandering rulings from Michigan and Ohio that had required new voting maps. No noted dissents. The court will issue rulings on partisan gerrymandering in two other cases in the next few weeks.
BREAKING: Supreme Court rejects Texas’ election challenge, saying it “has not demonstrated a judicially cognizable interest in the manner in which another State conducts its elections.”
Justice Kavanaugh was at work on Sunday in Justice Alito’s old chambers, preparing for the week’s arguments with his four law clerks, all women (a record)
At the end of Justice Breyer’s last argument, Chief Justice Roberts grew emotional as he said goodbye. “For 28 years,” he said of his friend, "this has been his arena for remarks profound and moving, questions challenging and insightful, and hypotheticals downright silly."
JUST IN:
“Heritage is reevaluating the Federal Clerkship Training Academy. As a result, the program will not go on as scheduled.” – Greg Scott, director of media at The Heritage Foundation.
Unnamed donors, sitting judges, secrecy pledges and loyalty oaths at Heritage Foundation “training academy” for law clerks. After questions from The Times, the passages below were deleted from the application materials.
Thirty years ago, a Yale law student named Brett Kavanaugh called for vigorous efforts to combat race discrimination in jury selection. Next month, the Supreme Court will take up the issue in the Curtis Flowers case.
My editors tell me that my look at two of the leading contenders for the Supreme Court vacancy clocked in at 1776 words. Because I’m a patriot. Happy Fourth!
Hip-hop stars including Chance the Rapper, Meek Mill, Killer Mike and 21 Savage are urging the Supreme Court to hear the case of a Pittsburgh rapper sent to prison for threatening police officers -- in a song
Domineque Ray, a Muslim inmate set to be executed Thursday, wanted his imam present. But Alabama said he could only have a Christian chaplain. Eleventh Circuit issues stay, citing "powerful Establishment Clause claim.”
Today at the Supreme Court: The case of Curtis Flowers, a black man tried six times for murder by a white prosecutor determined to keep blacks off of his juries.
When a lawyer fingers his client under oath while pleading guilty to serious crimes, the client is ordinarily in big legal trouble. Is President Trump?
The New York Times has a very deep bench. Once in a while, as
@DavidBarstow
once said, “the spotlight swivels and you're the man and you need to deliver.” The spotlight has been shining hard on Donald G. McNeil Jr., and man is he delivering.
Judge Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation to the Supreme Court was a triumph for the conservative legal movement. But it came at a cost to the court’s stature.
NEW: RBG heading home from the hospital. “The justice will return to The John’s Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore, Maryland, for follow-up outpatient visits over the next few weeks to eventually remove the gallstone non-surgically."
NEW: Supreme Court all of a sudden seems interested in Texas abortion providers’ motion to expedite consideration of its petition for cert. before judgment
NEW: A splintered
#SCOTUS
partly backs a religious challenge to Covid restrictions in California.
Kagan, dissenting: “In the worst public health crisis in a century, this foray into armchair epidemiology cannot end well.”
Chief Justice Roberts, on being asked whether the justices wore robes during telephone arguments: “I didn’t know if the person was asking 'judicial or bath?’”
From remarks at his son’s high school commencement:
Justice Clarence Thomas, in a relaxed and reflective mood, scoffed at rumors that he was planning to retire, in remarks to the Supreme Court Historical Society.
“I really don’t have a lot of stress,” he said. “I cause stress.”
Judge Don Willett (fka as
@JusticeWillett
) thinks better of his initial vote in Deray Mckesson’s First Amendment case, citing a classic Frankfurter opinion h/t
@howappealing
NEW: Splitting 5-4, the Supreme Court temporarily blocks a federal judge’s injunction that would have made it easier to vote by absentee ballot in Alabama during the pandemic. The court’s four liberals noted dissents.
NEW: Federal judge lambasts amendment to rename Confederate bases as “madness,” gets thoroughly bodied by clerk
Best reply-all battle victory ever, frankly
Judges appointed by Republican presidents give longer sentences to black defendants and shorter ones to women than judges appointed by Democrats, according to a new study from two Harvard Law professors
Chief Justice Roberts, at a Manhattan temple, says his colleagues bring their professional backgrounds to the bench. “And, of course, Justice Ginsburg brings her experience as a rock star,"
BREAKING: Justice Ginsburg has been hospitalized for treatment of acute cholecystitis, a benign gallbladder condition, at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore, Maryland, the Supreme Court said. She plans to participate in tomorrow’s arguments by phone from the hospital.
Supreme Court rules 6-3 that it’s OK to sentence juvenile offenders to life without parole without finding them incorrigible. Sotomayor, with Breyer and Kagan: "Today, the Court guts Miller v. Alabama and Montgomery v. Louisiana."
Sorry Chief Justice John Roberts, but you do indeed have “Obama judges,” and they have a much different point of view than the people who are charged with the safety of our country. It would be great if the 9th Circuit was indeed an “independent judiciary,” but if it is why......
A lesson in how to cite yourself in a Supreme Court opinion, from Justice Kagan in the CFPB case:
See, well, Kagan, Presidential Administration, 114 Harv. L. Rev. 2245, 2331–2346
John Maynard Keynes wrote to his mother after dining with Winston Churchill in September 1940. He said Churchill was “extremely well, serene, full of normal human feelings and completely uninflated . . . . I have never seen anyone less infected with dictatorial airs or hubris."
On the eve of the Federalist Society’s annual convention, a new group of leading conservative lawyers called Checks and Balances is speaking out about Trump’s attacks on the justice system and the news media.
NEW: Supreme Court, in 4-4 tie, lets stand a Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling allowing extra time for mail-in voting. Justices Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh dissent.