A based rating system assessing the credibility of projects within the Berachain Ecosystem 🐻⛓️ We check if project gud or not gud 💼 A
@0xhoneyjar
Joint
Since the start of the S&P Season, we've received 100+ ratings from 50+ community assessors, tysm!
This has given the team critical insights into key areas for improvement into the S&P System itself. We're taking a 2 week Operational Paws to implement some upgrades
🚴S&P Seaons
#0
: Week 1🚴
S&P Seasons
#0
is LIVE!
Our first project of the week is
@beradrome
📆Stage: Week 1
⏳Start: February, 12th
⌛End: February, 18th
You have a week to assess Beradrome and submit your rating! Link for joining below 👇
🐻S&P Seasons
#0
: Week 2🐻
This week's project is
@BeratoneGame
, an online multiplayer game building on Berachain
📆Stage: Week 2
⏳Start: February, 19th
⌛End: March, 3rd
You have a week to assess Beratone and submit your rating! Link for joining below 👇
☘️S&P SEASONS
#0
☘️
We're launching an S&P Seasons program designed to incentivize the community to assess projects of Berachain ecosystem.🐻
Become a Community Assessor, earn Honey Jar NFTs and compete for shards of 2 fractionalized Bit Bears!
Rules below 👇
☘️S&P SEASONS
#0
☘️
We're launching an S&P Seasons program designed to incentivize the community to assess projects of Berachain ecosystem.🐻
Become a Community Assessor, earn Honey Jar NFTs and compete for shards of 2 fractionalized Bit Bears!
Rules below 👇
At the end of the week, we'll present the official rating of Beradrome done by an S&P in-house assessor, along with a summary of submitted community assessments.
🚴S&P Seaons
#0
: Week 1🚴
S&P Seasons
#0
is LIVE!
Our first project of the week is
@beradrome
📆Stage: Week 1
⏳Start: February, 12th
⌛End: February, 18th
You have a week to assess Beradrome and submit your rating! Link for joining below 👇
☘️S&P SEASONS
#0
☘️
We're launching an S&P Seasons program designed to incentivize the community to assess projects of Berachain ecosystem.🐻
Become a Community Assessor, earn Honey Jar NFTs and compete for shards of 2 fractionalized Bit Bears!
Rules below 👇
The S&P System is divided into six sections:
- Project Development
- Bullish Berachain
- Team
- Background & Org
- Social & Community
- THJ Specific
- Non-Negotiables.
Henlo to all hard-working assessooooors 💼
🎖️ All S&P Season 0 participants received a special "OG Assessor" badge on the THJ dashboard!
Check here:
For all missoooors, see ya in the ████ ██████!
At THJ, our S&P Rating Services use an opensource 150-point system to assess project legitimacy, including criteria like Project Development and Team Background. Higher scores indicate greater effort and coordination (which may be a proxy for trustworthiness).
☘️S&P SEASONS
#0
☘️
We're launching an S&P Seasons program designed to incentivize the community to assess projects of Berachain ecosystem.🐻
Become a Community Assessor, earn Honey Jar NFTs and compete for shards of 2 fractionalized Bit Bears!
Rules below 👇
🐻 Proposed Method:
Assess a project's legitimacy through a comprehensive 150-point system.
🍯 Benefits:
- Quantifiable
- Objective
- Great DD companion
- Reference point before participating
• Social & Community: This section evaluates the project's community engagement and management, including its Discord and Twitter presence, and third-party verification of its legitimacy.
S&P is about giving a standard framework that can be applied across the ecosystem, giving good faith projects a clear framework and pathway to differentiate themselves from low effort scams.
We're also going to maintain a list of projects available for assessment and develop a list of guidelines for identifying an eligible project that is not on the list to avoid such confusion in the future.
We want to thank our community assessors and
@BeratoneGame
team understanding.
The reason why S&P Season has
#0
in its name is because it's a test drive of our rating system. So identification of a flaw so early on, will definitely make our system more reliable and resilient.
While THJ offers official ratings, we also encourage community evaluations using the same system, promoting transparency and collective validation. Active members of the community who evaluate multiple projects can even become Official Community S&P Assessors.
• Bullish Berachain: This section evaluates the project's alignment with the Berachain ecosystem, including whether it is a native Berachain project, led by seasoned Berachain ecosystem members, and foundational to Berachain.
• THJ Specific: This section evaluates the project's relationship with THJ, including whether THJ is aware of the project, has co-hosted events with it, and participated in its minting events.
The Berachain ecosystem is booming! Since the launch of the testnet, new projects are sprouting up daily.
But not all of them can be trusted. That's where S&P comes in. We're here to help regular users navigate the space. And that's why we need community assessors.
2/ Users want allocation to credible and high-potential projects. Ramen will be working with an initial set of independent curators to bring on the best emerging projects on Berachain - this includes
@0xhoneyjar
and
@StandardAndPaws
. This curator set will soon expand.
• Team, Background & Org: This section evaluates the team's experience and qualifications, including their mix of talents, prior experience, and onchain scores.
If you just discovered S&P Season program, don't hesitate to join now. You missed the Week 1, which means that you can't get a max streak of 12 weeks, but only 11. However, you can easily compensate it with the amount of assessments you make.
Become a Community Assessor 🐾
Step 1: Choose a project from the Berachain ecosystem to assess. You can select one already rated by S&P from this list (but it's optional):
Or check the Bera eco list:
S&P Season
#0
will be a test drive of the S&P Community Assessor Program.
Over a period of 12 weeks community assessors will be competing for a chunk of Bit Bear. Top 5 with the highest score will get the prize..
Here is a brief overview of each section:
• Project Development: This section evaluates the project's technical development, including its roadmap, whitepaper, and tokenomics.
🔥STREAK🔥
Every weak we'll be choosing a featured "Project of the Week". Assessors need to evaluate featured projects to maintain a streak. If they miss a week the streak is broken.
As Season 1 is 12 weeks long the maximum duration of streak is 12.
Let us show you a couple of examples:
A game might not contain a financial component in a classic sense or implement tokenomics at a much later stage than some DeFi project.
Beratone doesn't require an audit with their current, product, yet have to rate them with 0 points.
⭐️SCORE⭐️
Score will be determined by 2 things
1) Amount of Paw Badges earned (1 assessment = 1 badge)
2) Streak Length
Amount of Badges is a score base and streak is a multiplier.
This decision is not going to affect community assessors. All Beratone assessments made properly will be granted with Paw Badges along with Honey Jar NFTs (if applicable).
Paw Badges earned for Beratone submissions will also be reflected in the Season's Leaderboard.
🍯 Community Assessor Program 🍯
We've developed a special Community Assessor Program where community assessors can earn reputation within the S&P and THJ and get rewarded for their output.
When it comes to a team mix, a game studio requires a selection of people different to a DeFi protocol. Our current system, pushes assessors to downgrade projects which don't have people covering certain fields.
Scams and rugs are an unfortunate reality of operating in the wild west market.
But here's where S&P steps in: we provide a standard framework for the ecosystem, empowering legitimate projects to stand out from low-effort scams with clarity and confidence.
you've heard of design by committee. well let us introduce you design by TL.
who out there is a certified typography autist? which of these fonts suits the mission of
@StandardAndPaws
.
write ur reasoning in a reply.
The Official Community S&P Assessor (OCA) is the community's voice.
Their profiles and assessments will be showcased, providing valuable reference points for reviewing and comparing official ratings.
🐻S&P Seasons
#0
: Week 2🐻
This week's project is
@BeratoneGame
, an online multiplayer game building on Berachain
📆Stage: Week 2
⏳Start: February, 19th
⌛End: March, 3rd
You have a week to assess Beratone and submit your rating! Link for joining below 👇
Although we designed the S&P rating system with intention to make it relatively universal, it turns out, it's much more suitable for rating DeFi and NFTFi projects compared to Web3 gaming and art projects.
To maintain high assessment standards and keep the S&P Season competition dynamic, we will pause to clear the backlog, expand our team, and speed up the verification process before resuming the Season.
As we're well-familiar with the
@BeratoneGame
team and know they're a member of the
@buildabera
incubator which has quite high standards, we can confidently state that Beratone is building a legit high-quality multiplayer game.
🍯Rewards🍯
As a bonus for early community assessors, S&P will reward the first 42 successful assessments with Honey Jar (Gen 2) NFTs. HJ Gen2, apart from being tickets to a Mint Mania game with a prize fund of $50K+, will also play a crucial role in
@ApiologyDAO
.
🔥STREAK🔥
Every weak we'll be choosing a featured "Project of the Week". Assessors need to evaluate featured projects to maintain a streak. If they miss a week the streak is broken.
As Season 1 is 12 weeks long the maximum duration of streak is 12.
☘️S&P SEASONS
#0
☘️
We're launching an S&P Seasons program designed to incentivize the community to assess projects of Berachain ecosystem.🐻
Become a Community Assessor, earn Honey Jar NFTs and compete for a piece of 2 Bit Bears!
Rules below 👇
Therefore, we have decided not to publish ratings of Beratone made during week 2 of the S&P Season and abstain from rating game projects until we adjust our rating system.
However, game studios have different business models compared to DeFi projects. Beratone is bound to score as low as a memecoin project in our rating system.
Obviously, such a rating won't be reflecting the real level of trustworthiness and quality of Beratone.
Paw Badges 🐾
For every approved assessment, the community assessor receives a 🐾 Paw Badge. The number of badges an assessor owns determines their status and proficiency within the S&P ecosystem. By accruing 5 Paw Badges, you become an official community assessor (OCA).
✨Perks✨
1. Special OCA role at THJ Discord
2. Access to a private chat for community assessors.
3. Special role in the future Apiology DAO (Incubated by THJ)
4. Bonus rewards from THJ and partners
Nevertheless. S&P intends to raise the expectation of quality from the wider ecosystem by providing a clear framework projects can adopt and follow, which can be peer-reviewed in an open source way by anyone in the wider ecosystem. Rising tide of honey lifts all bears.
S&P officers are super busy verifying all these ratings now. If your name appears on the S&P Assessors table, we've received your assessment and it's awaiting verification now.
Assessors table:
The total score is calculated in the following way:
Total Paw Badges Earned * Streak Multiplier = Total Score
Example: assessor X earned 10 Paw Badges and had a streak of 6 weeks. They're going to have the following total score:
10 * (1 + 0.25 * (6-1)) = 10 * 2.25 = 22.5 pts
⚠️ It should be noted that malicious actors can also use the open source framework to create more complex scams. Therefore, S&P gives no guarantee of safety.
🏅 Competition 🏅
By submitting assessments, participants earn Paw Badges. By consistently participating in the S&P Season and rating the featured week's project every week, assessors extend their streak, which works as a multiplier for their total score.
Step 3: Join the THJ Discord and wait until we verify your assessment. You'll be notified in a specialized Community Assessor channel about the result.
🍯REWARDS🍯
What's more,
@0xhoneyjar
jar has provided a reward fund of 42 Honey Jar (Gen 2) NFTs to reward community assessors.
First 10 accepted assessments will be rewarded with 2 Honey Jars each.
Further 21 assessment will be granted with 1 Honey Jar
🍯REWARDS🍯
What's more,
@0xhoneyjar
jar has provided a reward fund of 42 Honey Jar (Gen 2) NFTs to reward community assessors.
First 10 accepted assessments will be rewarded with 2 Honey Jars each.
Further 21 assessment will be granted with 1 Honey Jar
Each assessment is 1 Paw Badge. Each extra week in your streak is 0.25 extra points to the multiplier.
The total score is amount of Paw Badges you earn multiplied by the streak multiplier. The max possible multiplier is 3.75 (12 weeks).
🏅WINNERS🏅
5 assessors with the highest score by the end of the S&P Season are going to split chunks of 2 fractionalized Bit Bears.
Prize is split following way: