Defaqto analysed the returns of 261 portfolios used by UK advisers over the 3-year period to 31st May. 9 of the top 10 were passive.
The average return was 10.19%. The best performer, Timeline Tracker 100, returned 29.14% 👇
@Timeline_Tech
#Investing
Hedge fund manager James Simons earned $4,657,534 *per day* in 2017. That's about £3,531,528, or almost €4 million. Per day. All three of his funds comfortably underperformed the S&P 500. That's how crazy this industry is
None of the investment portfolios run by the leading 60 US university endowments have outperformed a basic equity index fund over the past decade. That’s ZERO out of SIXTY
@CharlesSkorina
@chrisflood_FTfm
#EvidenceInvesting
Jack
#Bogle
has saved Vanguard investors $175 BILLION over the last 45 years. Add to that the money he saved for customers of other firms who lowered their fees to compete with VG, and the total must be in the trillions. Quite a legacy
@Neil_Irwin
Vanguard has saved investors $175 billion in fees since it was founded in 1974. This is based on the historical difference between the asset-weighted average expense ratio of an active mutual fund versus that of a Vanguard fund.
"You can pay 0.03 per cent in annual fees to Vanguard for a fund linked to the S&P 500, which has returned 45% in five years. Or you could pay roughly 30 (THIRTY) times more for Mr Woodford’s flagship fund, which has fallen 1% in the same period"
Warren
#Buffett
yesterday: “In my view, for most people, the best thing is to do is owning the S&P 500 index fund. There are huge amounts of money people pay for advice they really don't need”
#Investing
Here's a great explanation of how compounding from
#investing
is huge, but you won't see the benefits for long time. It’s not until 35 or 40 years of saving that it finally begins to overwhelm the amount saved
@awealthofcs
Same old story. Fund manager outperforms and is anointed as a star, so investors pile in. The manager reverts to the mean, and investors pile out again, locking in their losses relative to the index. The only winners are Woodford himself and brokers like Hargreaves Lansdown
Ritholtz Wealth Management is one of the fastest growing advice firms in the United States — and it's not yet five years old. This is how it got there
@ReformedBroker
@ritholtz
We did it!
Thank you to everyone who’s read our book.. and helped us spread the word about evidence-based investing and proper financial planning.
Let’s change
#Investing
for the better 💪
#How2Fund
The waiting is finally over.. Invest Your Way to Financial Freedom is published today.
Thanks to
@harrimanhouse
and my co-author Ben Carlson for all your hard work.. This book will change lives for the better.
@awealthofcs
#Investing
#Pensions
#FIRE
A warning to my fellow journalists tempted to run this "story": it's complete claptrap, and totally at odds with the peer-reviewed academic evidence. Happy to explain if you want to get in touch.
It sounds like a joke, but it isn’t.
US large-cap equity managers would have delivered higher returns over the last ten years if they’d been on holiday the entire time and not placed a single trade.
#Investing
#Stocks
#ActiveManagement
@syouth1
Every client of St James’s Place Wealth Management should read this report and ask, Is my financial adviser really acting in my best interests?
@yodelar
#SJP
I suppose it was inevitable, but I’ve finally been blocked by Mark Dampier, the former head of “research” at
#HargreavesLansdown
who became a multi-millionaire off the back of promoting fund managers like Neil
#Woodford
😏
"Every piece of financial news you read should be filtered by asking the question, 'Will I still care about this in a year? Five years? Ten years?'"
@morganhousel
😫Just seen a case of an investor advised in 2013 by a large advice chain to spread their money over more than 20 active funds. The client made £70k; if they'd invested in a simple index fund portfolio they would have made about £240k. That's how much bad advice costs.
5 years ago, you could have bought a global equity index tracker (yellow line), or followed the advice of Hargreaves Lansdown and many pundits, consultants and advisers and invested in the Woodford Equity Income fund (black line). The market return is always there for the taking.
Most people outside the West Midlands won't have heard of Ed Doolan. But for those of us who live and work here, he was a radio legend — a first-rate consumer journalist who spoke truth to power.
Thanks, Ed, for standing up for us!
#EdDoolan
#Birmingham
It is with great sadness that we have to announce the passing of our friend and broadcaster Ed Doolan.
Our thoughts are with his wife Chrissy and his family. Rest in Peace Ed.
“Nothing in life is as important as you think it is while you are thinking about it.” Daniel Kahneman
Great post by Joe Wiggins on how investors get far too worried about things they probably won’t even remember in a few months’ time
#BehahviouralFinance
If Mark Dampier and his colleagues in the
#HargreavesLansdown
"research" department really could identify winning fund managers in advance, you would expect the HL's flagship Multi-Manager fund to have trounced the global equity index. In fact the opposite has happened
Beware of anyone claiming they can capture the upside of market volatility and avoid the downside. It pushes all our emotional buttons but it's an illusion
@Ritholtz
#Investing
#Markets
Sadly, this is how many people view the financial advice profession today. The good news is, there’s a growing number of evidence-based, fiduciary advisers who genuinely do put their clients’ interests ahead of their own
@ST_Money
#FinancialAdvice
"Constructing a good enough portfolio isn’t nearly as difficult as the
#investment
industry often makes it out to be, but overseeing our portfolio while managing our emotions is probably still harder than we give it credit for."
@MichaelBatnick
The ugly truth about much of the
#investing
industry: "Whether they are trying to sell you a product, or get you to watch, listen or click on something, the giant bullshit industrial complex is working against you"
@ritholtz
The sad thing is the Telegraph used to have one of the better money sections. Ever since it launched a joint "financial advice" business with St James's Place Wealth Management it's been churning out misleading nonsense like this
#SJP
#Investing
The oldest trick in the book. Underperforming funds? Simply shut them down or merge them with other funds. The secret is to ensure there are just enough funds outperforming at any one time to maintain the illusion of skill
When a fund manager earns £16.6 million a year for underperforming a simple index tracker, is it any wonder that investors are deserting
#ActiveManagement
in their droves?
@siobhan_riding
“There is nothing wrong with being rich. But there is quite a lot wrong with ostentatious displays of wealth if your success is being funded by clients who may have little understanding of the true cost of what you’re charging them.”
@jimconey
A candid interview with the world’s most famous investor, in which he acknowledges how hard it now is for active stockpickers to beat the market. $1 invested in Berkshire Hathaway 10 years ago is worth about $2.40; the same dollar in an S&P 500 tracker fund is worth $3.20.
This is simply untrue. The data shows, time and again, that investors are no better off in active funds than they are in passive funds when markets fall. In many cases they’re considerably worse off
#EvidenceInvesting
Active managers better at managing downside - some good comment from Richard Ivers, whose Prime Value Emerging Opportunities Fund tops its peers for recent performance:
Financial advisers don’t manage money, they manage people. That’s why behavioural coaching is arguably the most important aspect of their job description
@MetisIreland
@RegisMedia
(Video 5 of 5)
#ValueOfAdvice
Just heard from an adviser who was was approached by a consolidator about buying his firm. When he told them he was evidence-based, fixed-fee and fiduciary, they told him they were no longer interested. I wonder what clients would make of that 🤔
Depressing to see so many tips for active funds in the newspapers today 😞 Have we learned nothing from
#Woodford
? Readers need to be told that they’ll almost certainly achieve better results by indexing, at a tiny fraction of the cost
#EvidenceInvesting
The 10 US stocks least owned by actively managed mutual funds outperformed managers’ top 10 picks by a record-breaking 17% in 2019
@RobinWigg
@ftfm
Morningstar nails another myth about indexing. If anything, passive fund providers take corporate governance more seriously than active managers.. and their commitment to
#ESG
is growing
If active funds want to remain relevant, they have to cut their fees, and that includes reducing salaries. Paying managers £15-20 million a year for underperforming the market is completely unsustainable
@OwenWalker0
"This paper should finally stop
#ClimateChange
deniers claiming that the recent observed coherent global warming is part of a natural climate cycle.”
@ProfMarkMaslin
Sorry, but a “financial education” hub run by St James’s Place is not the right place for young people to go to for impartial information about
#money
and
#investing
#SJP
advisers aren’t happy to be missing out on their luxury cruises. According to
@AlihussainST
in
@ST_Money
some are threatening to stop selling any more investments until they’re compensated
Eugene Fama on building a financial business today:
"Cut the staff down and go passive. I’ve been saying that to the university’s endowment for 50 years. They’ve never followed my advice, and it would be a much bigger endowment now if they had."
The problem with index funds, we’re often told, is that in a market rout they fall in line with the index. The problem with actively managed funds is that the vast majority fall further still
#Markets
#EvidenceInvesting
"Emotional intelligence has a much bigger impact on the success or failure of investors than where they went to school or how complex their investment strategy is"
@awealthofcs
Sensible advice here for young investors. I’ve just persuaded my student son to invest each month in a 100%-equity index tracker from
@Vanguard_UK
and forget all about it. He’ll thank me one day
@awealthofcs
Love this article. Of those investors who identify, in advance, the one fund in a hundred which will outperform long-term, most don't stick with it long enough to benefit. Even investors in Peter Lynch's Magellan fund lost money on average
@kirkchisholm
MP Johnny Mercer was paid £85,000 a year for four hours' work per week by a company which marketed a failed bond scheme that lost savers £236m
@JohnnyMercerUK
#LCS
Excellent graphic showing the failure of active managers around the world to outperform the index.. even over very short periods. The longer you invest for, the greater the likelihood of underperformance
@SPDJIndices
Hat tip
@mfgtas
#ActiveManagement
.
@Freakonomics
has re-broadcast this excellent podcast on evidence-based
#investing
from last year. If you haven't yet done so, do yourself a favour and listen to it >
"The investment business is perhaps the only area of the economy that can rival health care in complexity, low quality, opacity and unreasonable cost"
@jasonzweigwsj
“Investors encouraged by Hargreaves to plough money into the
#Woodford
Equity Income fund on launch have lost £91 for every £10,000 put in, yet also forked out £455 in fees. Woodford pocketed £240 of that; Hargreaves creamed off the other £215”
"There are so many smart people in the markets competing with each other second by second. Their intelligence cancels out, and the only edge that’s left for normal people is patience"
@michaelbatnick
@abnormalreturns
Most investors have never heard of Dimensional Fund Advisors, but it’s attracted more funds globally over the last 5 years than any other active manager. (It’s not, in my view, an active manager, but either way it’s a huge achievement)
#EvidenceInvesting
Here's a classic example of misleading marketing from a well-known UK advice firm. The index returns shown are the capital return not the total return (i.e. including dividends), which in both cases is far higher.
@TheFCA
has got to get a grip on this
#Transparency
Funny how analysts tend to downgrade funds and remove them from "best buy" lists AFTER they've underperformed. It would be more helpful to flag their concerns BEFORE they flop, so investors could do something about it
#2020Hindsight
Last month Hargreaves Lansdown research director Mark Dampier was telling investors Neil
#Woodford
was about to turn the corner. At the same time he was selling £600k of HL shares, just before they plummeted in value