‘Asking a politician “What is a woman?” has become a test of honesty. It’s saying to an elected representative, “Are you prepared to tell the truth, to say what we all know to be true, or are you going to be cowed by activists?’’ –
@andrewdoyle_com
on
#FreeSpeechNation
#GBNews
Yesterday, World at One
@BBCRadio4
() interviewed Colonel Jonathan Conricus (
@jconricus
), who is currently a reserve in the Israel Defense Forces, for which he has been International Spokesperson.
Conricus was interviewed by regular host Sarah Montague
Saying a non-black person cannot discuss Smith–Rock ‘is a form of “ideological gatekeeping”. People can talk about whatever they want. Your views are not based on your immutable characteristics [para]’ – Zuby (
@ZubyMusic
) on
@danwootton
#GBNews
@BBCR4Feedback
@BBCRadio4
Many
@BBCRadio4
journalists seem less and less interested in using their privileged position to help us, and themselves, understand the world.
No longer do they respect the our ability to think for ourseleves but tend to push issues they imagine more important than informing us.
@OwenJones84
Owen: Name any significant individual who is ‘gender critical’ – seeking to protect women’s freedoms or children’s bodies – who wants “Trans people [to] stop existing”.
Anyone? Anyone! State what they said and, in good faith, show their ‘bigotry’.
And good luck in your quest.
@AllisonPearson
Indeed. The Today programme news headlines lead on Rishi Sunak being called on to apologise for ‘Islamophobic remarks’ by Lee Anderson MP
#r4today
I can’t remember it leading on marches in London with antisemitic slogans and placards. Or antisemitic remarks by any Labour MP.
@gavinesler
Surely if you have to resort to attacking your opponents for earning a good living, rather than for what they say or do in politics, you are losing?
First pub lunch in 2 years,
@TheThreeColts
in Buckhurst Hill, Essex (Central line), an homage to publican Adam Brooks (
@EssexPR
), a doughty campaigner in the dark days of Lockdown for Freedom, democratic debate, and the hospitality industry.
And the roast pork is something else!
To the many critics of
@GBNews
– those who’ve watched it and those who have yet to – can you suggest a better current affairs, politics and society show than
#FreeSpeechNation
on Sunday evenings? Or a more capable and intellectually able host than Andrew Doyle (
@andrewdoyle_com
)?
@IncMonocle
“Nobody wants to see this” says Rayner – well, I want to see Hamas put out of action.
And a Labour-run UK will recognise ‘Palestine’ – but which of its governments?
As to prostrating yourself in front of a group of men who appear to exclude women from the (non-)discussion…
@BBCR4Feedback
@BBCRadio4
Many
@BBCRadio4
listeners have gone to stations, podcasts, and social media where biases complement the BBC’s; there’s more (niche) expertise and space for exploration; and more wisdom.
BBC Radio used to innovate, and take information and documentation seriously. But no longer.
Russell Brand has been ‘de-monetised’ by
@YouTube
based only on trial by media.
On
#BBCPM
yesterday host Evan Davis (
@EvanHD
) asked Caroline Dinenage MP (
@cj_dinenage
) if the Parliamentary Culture, Media and Sport Committee she chairs “may talk to those who still give a platform
Julia blasts YouTube for the “outrageous” suspension of the monetisation on Russell Brand’s channel.
“It’s not YouTube’s job to sit as judge and jury on Russell Brand! They’ve got no right to get involved in this.”
@JuliaHB1
|
@Tom_Slater_
‘If there is a lockdown in October we are going to see the biggest civil unrest we have seen [in recent years]’
‘Let’s follow the science Govt said, until the vaccines people [JCVI] said they weren’t prepared to support this’
@MartinDaubney
on
@JuliaHB1
#talkRADIO
#Together
@juliahobsbawm
@jk_rowling
I’m fighting to differentiate and distance myself from this callous movement. Over the decades I have fought for women’s rights to childcare, for control over their reproduction, and for equality of the sexes. I won’t easily let this be given up to people who deny women’s rights.
@MichaelLCrick
Sounds unlikely Michael, though you were there. In my my watching of
@GBNews
since launch I have found it the most open-minded channel offering balanced debate.
Unlike the BBC and
#Newsnight
which was censured for its unbalanced discussion of
#GBNews
Laurence Fox and
@Ofcom
@DerbyChrisW
Which ‘British citizens feel very uncomfortable and unsafe’ as a result of this peaceful and legal protest in central London yesterday, Mr Williamson – can you name any others?
Good to hear broadcaster
@Simon_Reeve
give credit to Andrew Neil (
@afneil
) for the News International trainee programme he created for non-university kids; Reeve started in the post room and went on to become an investigative reporter
#BBCSaturdayLive
‘During the Pandemic we have been told to take all sorts of actions just to save one life, yet 1,000s of people in the UK might die as a result of not being able to afford to pay for heating [para]’ – Laura Dodsworth (
@BareReality
)
@iromg
#talkRADIO
on the
#EnergyStruggle
‘This thing will never end unless people start speaking out and taking a stand and saying “Hey, government, we want to have control over our own lives”’ – Dominique Samuels (
@DominiqueTaegon
) on Omicron and Lockdown
@TiceRichard
show
#talkRADIO
(cc
@TogetherDec
)
@PaulEmbery
“We can have a serious discussion” says Steve Bray to Nigel Farage.
In eight years I have never heard Bray take himself seriously, let alone the ideas he endorses.
I love Farage’s response: “You’ve got no manners”.
Rejoin politicians would never entertain such tolerance.
‘We’ve inverted our idea of public health and asked children to protect adults, when it should be adults protecting children.
‘How many adults are wearing masks for 8 hours-a-day? I think it’s despicable’
– Molly Kingsley (
@lensiseethrough
)
@UsforThemUK
on
@JuliaHB1
#talkRADIO
@MayorofLondon
“We’re doing everything”?! Not you, who jets around the world as you see fit.
Mr Mayor: You aren’t even sticking to the rules you require of
@c40cities
staff:
1: … C40 employees should avoid air travel if at all possible
2: … long-haul flights should be avoided in particular
Dr Alessandro Strumia’s paper at
@CERN
's High Energy Theory and Gender workshop may well be wrong, but it should be responded to scientifically, and politically, not removed as ‘highly offensive‘, which is a pre-scientific way of dealing with disagreement
@mariannaspring
Marianna: Why did
@BBCNews
at 6:51 PM Tweet without qualification about an “Israeli air strike on hospital in Gaza”?
Yet the report on
#BBCNews
notes “unconfirmed reports from Hamas”.
And where is
#BBCVerify
doing the hard work, and showing its workings?
@OwenJones84
The women gang raped for being Jewish, and their families, will never forgive a women’s freedom supporter and anti-fascist for denying and dismissing the use of sexual violence in conflict by Hamas ‘fighters’, then justifying it in the name of ‘resistance’.
#MeTooUnlessYouAreAJew
‘It’s no coincidence swearing has become acceptable at a time when the words we really want to speak have never been more policed… It’s like we’re being allowed to swear as a reward for lying’ – Julie Burchill (
@BoozeAndFagz
)
@spikedonline
@nickdixoncomic
Discussing with
@MarinaPurkiss
:
‘All you say when you disagree is that somebody is”lying” but this isn’t a proper political argument. You disagree with me but that isn’t the same as somebody lying. Disagreement is perfectly reasonable’ –
#GBNews
host and Tory MP
@Jacob_Rees_Mogg
‘Vaccine passports would almost certainly lead to authoritarian (digital) identity systems. And we don’t even know how they would work. It could be the biggest expansion of the surveillance state we have seen in Western democracies...’ –
@silkiecarlo
@BigBrotherWatch
#BBCPM
Caller Jackie from Manchester
@JuliaHB1
#TalkTV
on how
#NetZero
policies inhibit growth:
‘You can’t create wealth while you have radical “Net Zero” policies. And Labour is radical because they are doing to decarbonise the grid in six years time, ban diesel and petrol cars.
Many bad faith responses to Alison Moyet’s post on the effect on her neigbhours of the rise in antisemitism, including denying it’s a thing; diminishing it; arguing ‘something else’ isn’t antisemitic; noting others suffer more; and blaming the victims. Anything but taking it on.
Seeing my Jewish neighbours and friends shrink into themselves as antisemitism rears it’s head again on our shores is heart wrenching. Years now we have trumpeted the righteousness of protecting our nations minorities. We need to remember that need for all as the world hardens.
@JohnSimpsonNews
Perhaps we would uncover the lies Hamas might be telling about civilian deaths, or find out how many are actually Hamas fighters? Or that Hamas is hijacking aid to Gazans? Or torturing and murdering Palestinian dissenters? Or that it is using civilians and hospitals as shields?
@hogotheforsaken
I agree, Bea, and feel as you do. I’ve never felt so alienated from a significant section of our society. Not least one which champions
#BeKind
, Diversity, Respect and anti-racism yet when an act of amoral barbaric butchery is executed chooses to ignore it, or blames the victims.
‘If working-class lads sat in the road and said, “We want the Millwall manager sacked” the police would wade in [and] they’d be locked up. [But] many officers are ex-students and almost empathise with these causes [para]’ – former DCI Mike Neville on
#JustStopOil
@iromg
#TalkTV
@OwenJones84
What would this change?
Is there a level of gang rape of women, brutalisation and butchery which makes Hamas’ actions more acceptable to you, or change how Israel should respond, Owen?
Health Secy
@MattHancock
@10DowningStreet
press conference never presents the +ve side of infection stats. Instead of telling us hospitalisations as high as previous peaks, tell us more people treated more quickly and discharged than at either! Doesn’t he trust us with good news?
@hugorifkind
@JuliaHB1
Immigrant groups tend to adapt to and adopt the prevailing culture – which is often what attracted them – and that culture is also to an extent shaped by the immigrant’s culture.
The problem is today we tend denigrate the prevailing culture, which disincentivises integration…
‘There’s something anti-human about people who want to turn off our heating and lighting, not least for pensioners this winter… It’s a horrible state of affairs when society’s come to this’ – Laura Dodsworth (
@BareReality
) with
@TVKev
on
#EnergyCrisis
and
#ClimateChange
#TalkTV
‘I’d rather make history than delete it. Rather than take down a statue, leave it up and explain who that person was. Otherwise, how will my grandchildren know that person was a slave-trader? [para]’ – Lord Taylor of Warwick (Lord_ofWarwick) on Neil Oliver (
@thecoastguy
)
#GBNews
@OwenJones84
What a heartless soul you seem to be, subsuming empathy for your fellow humans to your inviolable ideology.
1,400 mainly Jewish Israeli citizens – including children and babies – were brutally murdered by Hamas, many tortured. Have you no anger to express, or comfort to offer?
‘I hold accountable the Conservatives _and_ Labour, who wanted even more restrictions than
#PlanB
… I will be voting for the party that tells me they will never do Lockdowns again and will follow what we the people want done in our lives’ –
@ToniaBuxton
@iromg
show
#talkRADIO
‘There has been very little thought put into the after-effects of Lockdown – in the UK and across Europe – and now we’re starting to see those effects. The whole lockdown process is now coming home to roost’ – Iain Duncan Smith on
#CostBenefit
analysis
@JuliaHB1
show
#talkRADIO
@IanDunt
Ian: You hated
@GBNews
before this, probably from before it launched.
This is just an excuse for pretend moral outrage to shut down a channel that doesn’t tow the line on Brexit, Lockdown, social justice, etc, and attempts to give the plebs another view.
That must be galling.
@MayorofLondon
I never see evidence supporting your claims, Mr Mayor.
We aren’t all cowering, fearful subjects seeking your Leviathan protection.
We are confident, optimistic, freeborn citizens who can solve any problem – including protecting our infrastructure – if you’ll get out of the way.
‘President Macron said, “the age of abundance is over”… But why should it be? We’ve more technology, things are more modern. We should be aiming towards more Energy, more Convenience, more Prosperity, more Happiness’ – Laura Dodsworth (
@BareReality
) on
#Progress
@iromg
#TalkTV
‘I am really concerned about Government’s “anti-vax” rhetoric, where they are encouraging people to blame each other, which is an underhand technique when then have failed to prepare the NHS [para]’ – Laura Dodsworth on The Independent Republic of Mike Graham (
@iromg
)
#talkRADIO
‘We’ve got the jabs, we just need the arms to put them in…not just to save lives, but to keep your freedoms’ – Health Secy
@SajidJavid
@10DowningStreet
press conference
Sorry, ‘to keep your freedoms’?!
If you don’t think this is chilling, you don’t understand or value freedom.
Health Secretary Sajid Javid: 'We've reached a milestone of four million top up jabs in England...we've got the jabs, we just need the arms to put them in...not just to save lives, but to keep your freedoms.'
“A threat to Jews is a threat to our society”
“Every single loss of human life is a tragedy”
“The chant ‘From the river the sea’ is a call for the destruction of Israel”
– Chief Rabbi, National solidarity march against antisemitism rally, Whitehall
#MarchAgainstAntisemitism
@mariannaspring
You say you are ‘investigating how the UK conspiracy movement has evolved and intensified’.
But journalism doesn’t start with a conclusion.
Might you have investigated and found something else, perhaps that our government misinformed us? If not, your approach is unjournalistic.
@OwenJones84
Owen: Can you give an example of ‘gay people ranting about trans people’? I can’t find any among the thousands of people I follow.
But I can find many ‘ranting’ about the effect on their freedoms and their identity of demands made by activists claiming to represent trans people.
@exRAF_Al
@AllisonPearson
@HowardWilkins56
If I were a steelworker at the Port Talbot works I’d be incensed at the callous way the Tories have facilitated my job being scrapped – in order to ‘Save the Planet’.
The electric arc furnace ‘strategy’ even makes Thatcher’s NCB pit closures look rational!
We live at a time in history in which the condition of humanity is better than ever.
And humankind’s potential – based on technology, fabrication, energy, medicine, communication, logistics – is greater than ever.
Yet Western societies are uniquely pessimistic and fatalistic.
‘On the Lockdown, no one remembers that they were the ones who called for a harder, longer lockdown… then the Opposition say “What about the plight of the children who suffered during the 2yrs of Lockdown?”… –
@Fox_Claire
on hindsight about Lockdown effects
#PMQs
@iromg
#TalkTV
‘In the Pandemic a dozen federal agencies pressured social media companies to suppress
#FreeSpeech
The judge in Missouri v. Biden case told the Biden administration and federal agencies to immediately stop pressuring social media companies’ –
@DrJBhattacharya
at
#Together
rally
British politics has abandoned even the most basic
#CostBenefit
balancing of objectives. For Govt, many Tory and most Labour MPs, such as
@ThangamMP
, Covid public health is the exclusive goal of government, and damn the economy, education, healthcare, life joys – and our sanity!
@williamnhutton
@FT
And one-in-six political commentators is unable to present an informed, logical argument, or recognise that correlation does not equal causation. Whose fault is that?
@mariannaspring
“I’m using X a lot less… because of trolls it triggers”
That is disingenuous, pejorative, and bad faith, Mariana.
You got many reasonable and informed critical responses from licence fee payers, academics and media experts.
But you never engaged. Instead you call us ‘trolls’.
@guyverhofstadt
What our Govt did in the Pandemic – restricting our Freedom of Movement and Free Speech, controlling news and social media – was terrible.
But almost every EU state did the same. And you and your EUcrats encouraged it.
You have a more in common with the Tories than you imagine!
@guyverhofstadt
Guy: You and the EC could help fixing 🇪🇺🇬🇧 relations by respecting our citizens and not regularly trying to do us down.
You will also find that EU citizens don’t like being talked down to, and if you keep doing it you and your out-of-touch EUcrats will be in for more shocks.
‘It’s far easier to police Tweets than to police streets; policing Tweets elevates Thought Crimes and belittles real crimes [para]’ – Harry Miller
@WeAreFairCop
on
@JuliaHB1
#TalkTV
If you think
#GBNews
is crass or
#RightWing
, observe how Andrew Doyle (
@andrewdoyle_com
) interviewing academic
@PeterBoghossian
is able as Devil’s Advocate to better present the arguments for the ‘woke’ university and culture than its actual advocates
Many will write off a 1,000 paying attendees at the
#Together
rally at Central Hall as full of conspiracy theorists, anti-vaxxers and climate deniers.
They should come and talk to the many everyday people here who their patronising dismissal motivated to stand up for themselves.
@Ryanair
Do you understand the difference between not trusting vaccines (which very few do) and having the freedom to make an informed choice about what you put into your body?
Djokovic is very clear he supports the vaccination programme, but that for now he doesn’t want the vaccine.
@QudsNen
You quoted Julia Hartley-Brewer (
@JuliaHB1
) out of context.
She had challenged Chiara Sarti that why, when children were starving in Yemen, or when President Assad was ‘bombing the hell out of his own people’ in Syria, there is ‘all the concern about the people of Gaza, the
On Raab resignation, caller Richard from Wakefield tells
@iromg
#TalkTV
:
‘The Civil Service has significantly changed. When I was a fairly senior civil servant you did what you were told. You might not like what you were told, but you did what you were told anyway’
#PublicLife
Wow, in Corrections and Clarifications re the BBC News Channel the
@BBC
admits that Weather ≠ Climate and that not all ‘extreme weather events’ are evidence of
#ClimateChange
and impending doom.
(As an aside, this is a kind of Web 2.0 page and it would be good if each
Off to the Stop the ULEZ expansion demo in Trafalgar Square to protest with
@Togetherdec
against the
@MayorofLondon
’s unjustified, un-democratic, poor-taxing,
#ULEZExpansion
to outer London ()
@SadiqKhan
’s contempt for most Londoners must be challenged!
As well as a
#NoDeal
Brexit, which would be unnecessary and damaging, I’m also worried by people pushing for a Second Referendum and Remain, who are taking a big risk of creating huge divisions which could last 30–40 years –
@RoryStewartUK
MP
#r4today
‘If the wealthy want to tackle climate change it should be left to the wealthy but none of them are practicing what they preach. They have to stop telling people poorer than themselves to take the burden of their little middle-class guilt trips’ –
@BelindadeLucy
@iromg
#talkRADIO
‘I want to live in a society where people have freedom over their bodies, not where threats and fear are the order of the day… I want to hear our Govt condemning illiberal mandatory vaccination measures around the world [para]’ – Laura Dodsworth (
@BareReality
)
@Iromg
#talkRADIO
‘The question you have to ask yourself is “If not now, when?!”. We were freer last summer, when we [didn’t have a successful vaccination programme], than we are now’ –
@Tom_Slater_
on
#FreedomDay
on
@JuliaHB1
show
#talkRADIO
‘The energy transition is like people jumping out of a plane and saying, “We are going to invent the parachute on our way down”.
But this is a very risky path, and not what you should do. First, you invent the parachute, then you build it, then you jump out of the plane. Same
Tony Sewell on how Jamaican and Afro-Caribbean kids love the classics, on
#FreeSpeechNation
@GBNews
‘I used to teach in Jamaica. And you know what the kids used to love? Chaucer’s The Wife of Bath, which they related to dance hall situations in Jamaica and could relate to her
‘Forget lithium, the key element in the energy transition is copper. The copper mining industries know there will be a run on copper in the next few years and then the world is going to abandon the energy transition. So they are buying smaller copper mines to deal with the run
@ProfBrianCox
You’re a champion of the Enlightenment aspiration of striving for Understanding and Truth, yet you say this.
If a perception isn’t the Truth, tell people!
If a Misunderstanding is abroad because an issue’s complex, then explain it!
Or is our perception of you all that matters?
@OwenJones84
Really, Owen? Since October 7th you’ve obsessively accused Israel of genocide:
genocide (from:owenjones84) since:2023-10-07
yet you haven’t bothered to define it:
(from:owenjones84) genocide AND define OR definition
let alone establish your case (which you won’t be able to).
@lewis_goodall
@fergalkeane47
@BBCNews
Yes, the suffering is terrible and
@FergalKeane47
did well to get inside.
But there was no mention of Hamas. No question about its possible role in stealing food aid. Let alone hiding in tunnels, forcing Gazans be ‘human shields’.
It’s all Israel for
@BBC
, Hamas has no agency.
@IncMonocle
It’s tragic. The Irish were among the first European nations to liberate themselves from their imperial masters. And, unlike the Greeks, achieved this with almost no external military support. They showed agency. But today their political class and leaders tend toward victimhood.
‘The whole point of the Climate Change Act [2008] is to put climate policy beyond democratic politics, so we can change ministers but actually nothing fundamentally changes as they are banned by the Climate Change Act’ – Green Tyranny author
@RupertDarwall
reflecting on comments
‘If
#MandatoryVaccination
goes through, what else can this Govt do at the stroke of a pen?’
‘The Health Secy has a duty of care to NHS workers too’
‘Unvaccinated workers are covering shifts of those who’ve been vaccinated who are off with Covid!’
–
@RWTaylors
@iromg
#talkRADIO
‘Lockdowns have been the greatest act of deliberate self-destruction societies have ever inflicted on themselves. Some of the economic mess we’re in now was predicted by QE and shutting the economy down’ – Laura Dodsworth (
@BareReality
)
@iromg
#talkRADIO
@Gail_F_Reed
Good interview by Oliver with
@_HelenDale
on Australia being a country of the jailed _and their jailers_; the history of repressive state behaviour in Victoria and Queensland, and the consequences of federalism; the excessive pandemic lockdowns and current police violence
#GBNews
@mariannaspring
Except you never respond to your critics, or address yourself to whether your employer might have been responsible for
#Misinformation
during the Pandemic or
#UkraineInvasion
But of course you’ll dismiss your critics as conspiracy theorists who’ve gone ‘down the rabbit hole’.
‘We won’t allow covid amnesia sufferers to forget damage their lockdowns did.
‘Making those in power own the mistakes of lockdown and ensuring they’re not repeated is a huge priority and that’s why I’ll continue to diagnose cases of Covid amnesia syndrome’ –
@danwootton
#GBNews
@arusbridger
My sense, Alan, is you tend to associate and fraternise with people who hold similar views to you.
And you tend to read and watch material with which you agree.
Perhaps reviewing
@X
is a discomfitting reminder there are people with good ideas you don’t have arguments against?
I’ll be on with
@JuliaHB1
at 9.50am
@talkRADIO
about what’s happening today as part of the fight against Digital Certification Vaccine Passports to participate in life
As N Ireland pushes today & we see the nightmare in Austria it’s vital all voices opposing are heard
#together
‘I neither have “Trump derangement syndrome”, where I can never see any of his good qualities, nor Trump sycophancy… He was surprisingly good on policy and passed some good legislation which would be liked by the Left if they didn’t hate the man so much’ –
@MegynKelly
#Newsnight
Isabel Oakeshott (
@IsabelOakeshott
) on The Independent Republic of Mike Graham (
@iromg
)
#TalkTV
on Lockdown Critics and Ministers’ secret unit to curb dissent during the Pandemic:
‘What we do know is that the government very definitely took a decision to actually employ a unit
@wesstreeting
Attacking Susan Hall for “racism in Facebook groups with links to Tories”, seriously?
Yet no attacks by you on the Jew-haters weekly on UK streets, some no doubt your party members!
As to Khan, he can’t say ‘antisemitism’ separate from ‘Islamophobia’. For him, Jews Don’t Count.
This is divisive and disgusting.
Sadiq Khan has repeatedly stood by London’s Jewish communities in the fight against antisemitism.
Susan Hall’s dog whistle politics have no place in London.
Will decent Conservatives ever call this out?
@Fox_Claire
On Twitter
@BBCR4Feedback
recently asked “Why has Radio 4 listenership dropped?” ()
There were some very interesting and thoughtful responses, but
@BBCRadio4
didn’t engage, let alone broadcast a
#BBCFeedback
item.
They then closed comments…
cc
@MerrynSW
We recently found out that
@BBCRadio4
's audience has been shrinking - especially in the case of its flagship programmes.
But why do you think this is happening?
Drop your thoughts in the thread below 👇
#BBCR4Feedback
@carolecadwalla
The inability of ardent Remainers such as Cadwalladr to gain insight into British society when yet again it experiences a political enema is remarkable; as is their ability to describe a 1/3 of voters as ignorant dupes. How many votes would your party get, Carole?
#EUelections2019
What’s the point of the British Parliament when it rubber-stamps legislation, including excess powers, which is already on the statute books – 16 ‘Nays’ – and prevents itself from reviewing it for 3 months?! Credit
@GrahamBradyMP
for calling, fruitlessly, for two interim votes.
‘We’re facing the consequences of the people who ran society [Civil Service, etc] refusing to accept that we were leaving the EU’ –
@Fox_Claire
on Brazier
#GBNews
‘This is what it feels like to live in a
#NetZero
world. We’re seeing what it would mean to not have transportation’