Without even reading it, it takes so much guts to review game you know is guaranteed 9+ across the board for just existing and meet it honestly with critique you believe in.
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom is a great way to introduce yourself to the series, but might not be for those who didn't love Breath of the Wild.
Read our review here:
I have seen no story which reported this investigate what the abuse was, offer evidence, reach out for a quote, or mention the (quite important!) fact that just before he says he's "bummed out", he defends Roman Polanski, Michael Jackson, and calls trans people the "alt-left"
I know a lot of this 'drama' is 'Twitter bullshit', I know some trans people are fixating on this game and go too far, I know you want to stay out of it for an easy life. I know you might not agree with a boycott. Even with that, a lot of you have fallen way below par
I was going to avoid the review drama, but for IGN's review to state 'As critics, our job is to answer the question of whether or not we find the game to be fun to play and why' is a dismal misunderstanding of what a critic is. Whatever score was given, whatever people think 1/4
Wrote about the ‘protect kids’ crowd failing their own mantra as they rally against cancel culture to protect one of their own being outed as an an actual groomer
Right, new job tweet time. As many of you know, our Editor-in-Chief
@MckKirk
is leaving
@thegamerwebsite
at the end of the month, having fulfilled his purpose of giving Deathloop a perfect score. Starting then, I'll be taking over as TheGamer's Editor-in-Chief.
...the fact they scored the game well does not matter to me at all here. It's bigger than this game. It's extremely worrying that the biggest outlet in the world thinks our job is 'game fun? y/n', and just a week after explaining why big games all deserve at least 7/10
Exciting news: for the first time in our history, TheGamer has a full freelance feature budget. We’ll be paying between $75-250 per piece depending on the work involved. Mainly looking for timely and/or social oriented op-eds, or reported stories. (1/3)
...of the game and choose to review it is one part of it. So much broader is the biggest and most influential gaming outlet in the world not only believes fun factor is 'our job' as critics, but pushes that view onto their readers. I have read some excellent reviews at IGN 2/4
by a variety of fantastic critics. But surely this review was checked even more than usual, and this quote appears in a pullout box which would have the most scrutiny of all. It's a baffling and disheartening thing to read. Maybe I'm just shouting about nowt here, but 3/4
@schillingc
I could not disagree more, it scored 97! One of the highest scores of all time and everyone’s just going ‘yeah, sounds about right’. Everyone who got this review from the moment they started knew if they scored it below 9 they’d be an outlier
Pretty much everyone’s favourite World Cup is the one when they were ten years old, please I can’t take another nine months of arguing over the best ball/goal/match/logo/mascot/tournament/blades of grass without anyone acknowledging football was just more fun as a kid
Right, I'm not doing one of those 'record yourself changing your bio' things, but I've got a **new job**. From Monday 15th I'll be joining
@thegamerwebsite
as a features editor.
In lieu of flowers please send likes and comments such as "legend" and "you'll smash it"
It’s been a while since I tweeted this, so a reminder that TheGamer is open for freelance pitches. We’re mainly looking for analytical writing or reportage, and aim to help people get their first major byline, though experienced writers are welcome too. Rates etc in thread
I'm very proud of where TheGamer is today, but we have hidden from our problematic history too often.
As the site continues its efforts to move beyond those days, I thought it was important to address where we were, where we are, and where we're going
I feel very strongly about the Spirittea/paid coverage discourse and think it’s a sign that something quite bad has shifted under our feet while no one was watching.
@Calfixie
What extra context do you feel this adds? I state multiple times my issue is not with this game in particular or with the decision to cut JKR from score consideration. My point is that 'is this game fun' is an incredibly shallow question for a critic to ask
For
@gaymingmag
, I spoke to a few people from
@TellMeWhyGame
about creating Tyler Ronan, the first trans lead from a major studio; lead writer
@missdoomcookie
, consultant and GLAAD representative
@NickGAdams
, and Xbox narrative director Clay Carmouche
As a trans person who really connected with Lev’s story, I needed to write about how the discourse does him a disservice. As I say in the article, it’s perfectly fine to not like the story or ND, or to not want to play, but Lev is more nuanced than his discourse rn
@schillingc
Putting it that way implies gaming has a major problem with scoring everything too high, so when a game comes along that is expected to be the best in a generation we have nowhere to go when we routinely hand out 9s and 10s every month
@fperezroa
That's a fine way to think as a reader but you deserve better than 'is it fun?'. Is it challenging? Well paced? Does it reward risk/encourage conservative play? Too similar to existing games? And a million others. 'Fun' is too reductive and should not be in a definitive statement
An older woman leading a video game is already enough to get me on board, but if Selene being able to talk to her own corpses - past and future - isn't enough for you to pay attention to Returnal, I don't know what is...
In some surprising (and perhaps enraging) news, I was on
@notaxation
’s recent podcast. My logic, which I’m sure some of you will disagree with, is that Moriarty reaches the sphere who think journalists are part of a cabal and therefore frequently send my writers hate messages 1/2
Making my
@launcher
Washington Post debut today with a piece on pregnancy in game development.
Spoke to a lot of fantastic devs and writers for this one with some important things to say about the games industry
Pregnant women working in the video game industry face extraordinary challenges — above and beyond the usual travails of game development.
Important new story by
@FiveTacey
.
@Xarallei
Maybe that’s the point, that these two entities can’t be separated. A bad year for devs is a bad year for gaming as a whole even if the pandemic backlog means we get more hits
Without revealing your age, who was the very first Serie A footballer you adored?
🇮🇹 𝐖𝐚𝐭𝐜𝐡 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝟐𝟎𝟐𝟏/𝟐𝟐 𝐒𝐞𝐫𝐢𝐞 𝐀 𝐬𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐨𝐧 𝐥𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐨𝐧 𝐁𝐓 𝐒𝐩𝐨𝐫𝐭 𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐒𝐚𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐝𝐚𝐲!
Working with Jade since she joined the site has been fantastic and I can’t wait to see what she does in the lead role.
Also, please correct me if I’m wrong, but I think this makes us the biggest gaming website ever to have two trans women in leading roles at the same time.
Once
@cianmaher0
flies the nest I'll be taking over as Lead Features Editor over at
@thegamerwebsite
.
I'm being given too much power but I'm so excited to help shape the site's vision even further alongside an incredible team.
Big shoes to fill so let's smash it! 🙌
That means new angles on evergreen games (Pokemon/Skyrim/Witcher etc) or interesting takes on new releases. Open to column ideas about fresh ways to play big titles. Email stacey.h
@thegamer
.com and jade.k
@thegamer
.com with pitches
TheGamer has given a lot of people their first editorial role and has a remote, global staff, so we encourage pitches from new writers and aim to publish a diverse range of voices. RT and encourage people to pitch!
I asked Geoff not to mention it, but the really big story of The Game Awards 2021 is that for the first time in our history,
@thegamerwebsite
was a member of the jury. All the good picks were us and the bad picks were someone else.
@JezCorden
We’ve been very lucky this year with major releases, but I do get the feeling it is just luck and this consistent quality cannot exist long term in an environment like this
@GenePark
It’s the opposite of the Academy though really, this panel would put Black Adam and Thor: Love & Thunder up for Best Picture because they made money and look flashy
This is just a very small sample of what you have to deal with if you criticise Harry Potter. JK Rowling knows she attracts these followers and never calls them out, she only offers dogwhistles and support while keeping her hands clean
You are on the side of the bad guys
People are getting completely the wrong idea from seeing what they want to see and not reading the article. The PR firm was specifically buying reviews from self-published blogs and then not using negative ones - actual professional critics are not part of this
Can’t believe The Last Of Us Part II really ends with an asteroid destroying Earth, leaving just two giraffes left
One of them turns to their friend and says ‘I guess we’re the last of us’
The other one says ‘Part two’
Truly the most beautiful moment in gaming
I’m so glad I got to write this today, I tried so hard to get someone to let me talk about the lake scene in Tell Me Why last year.
There’s no chance this will be my best performing post - even best today, probably - but I’m happy I finally got to put down thoughts on it.
We’re going to stop covering Activision and Blizzard games until there’s some real change and this gaslighting bollocks ends. We’ll cover the ongoing news regarding the current story, but we won’t be covering the games.
I’m so sick of this picture. It’s just a woman saying ‘tell me some cool games’. It’s embarrassing how many of you have opinions on it beyond just answering the question
Remember when I said I could write 1000 words doing a deep dive on Cyberpunk 2077’s posters? Oh, how we laughed!
Anyway, I went and did it for
@WIRED
. The posters are grotesque and garish and genius; they’re Cyberpunk 2077 in a bottle
With The Last Of Us 2 looming, I hope some places have queer women lined up to review it.
I know there’ll be a lot of interesting crit to read afterwards, but I’m talking about ground level, going on the record, ‘our site is elevating a queer voice’ reviews.
For this piece, I spoke to two Inquisitors, a Hawke, Zevran, Josephine, Traynor, Jack, Reyes, Kesh, and FemShep to find out just how BioWare knits together its team so effectively.
This was the last freelance piece I worked on and I think it’s a pretty good sign off!
Enjoying
#MassEffectLegendaryEdition
and want to know how that squad chemistry came about? Voice actors from Mass Effect and Dragon Age spoke to us about how the
@bioware
magic was created
BREAKING: Harry Potter game discourse has closed
Hope you got all of those hot takes out of your system but it’s officially over
Remaining acceptable conversation topics include:
- Why you should play Citizen Sleeper
- Bayonetta voice actor stuff
- How TheGamer is very cool
It seems like ScarJo is right in her lawsuit, but her argument is that more poor people should have been forced to risk COVID to watch her in a comic book movie.
She’s not your feminist icon, she never was.
I started working in games media this year, and despite the disaster that is 2020, it's gone pretty well. I have a few things to wrap up before Christmas, but I think it's time for a highlight reel.
Let's start with baby's first feature:
I don’t always write for VG24/7, but when I do, it’s always about gender stereotypes and gets flooded with comments from people who haven’t read the article.
Looking to speak to any games developers/designers who worked on games while pregnant or as young mothers.
Working on a piece on motherhood in games, DM or email at address in bio
#journorequest
RTs appreciated
Not all the big games are the good games.
If films were judged to the same narrow standards as video games Suicide Squad would have won Best Picture.
We give too much respect to big budgets and care too little about what a game has to say.
I’m putting together a piece for
@thegamerwebsite
about the ways games developers have been influenced by the Tomb Raider series - devs, if this is you and you’re up for a short chat some time in the future, my DMs are open and my email’s in my bio
RTs appreciated
Making my
@gamingbible
/
@ladbible
debut today, with an interview with Red Dead Redemption 2's Micah Bell (aka
@TheBlomquist
) about why the camp rat might by misunderstood, and why being bad feels so good
Everyone who previewed Hogwarts Legacy and then slapped a sentence underneath it all about how trans people are valid, thank you for all that you do. You are the reason the community keeps fighting. Bless you all.
For PC Gamer, I wrote about transness in Cyberpunk 2077. Some parts are actually better than I expected, but then other parts are a lot worse.
I've written a few pieces on Night City's world building now, and it's certainly rich, but there are a lot of areas where it falls down
What a nice surprise to wake up to. I’ve read some great features this year, so winning for my Cyberpunk piece means a lot.
I’d especially encourage you to read Nat’s Latina’s In FPS’ and Liana’s Yakuza pieces as well.
In his first weekly column,
@MikeDrucker
welcomes you to Game Company, where HR does everything to protect its employees - especially those accused of things by other employees.
You're not getting a selfie for
#TransDayOfVisibility
, you're getting 1k word deep dive into one of my favourite characters from last year in one of the most polarising game. Enjoy
Far Cry’s director told us he didn’t want to make a “political statement about Cuba specifically,” unprompted, in a question not about politics. We reported that. Some seem to think we were unfair.
We’ll see next week how political the game where you recruit funny alligators is.
Far Cry 6 narrative director Navid Khavari accuses
@thegamerwebsite
's Jade King of misquoting him, cutting his quote in half to make it seem like he said "the game isn't making a political statement".
A lot of outrage emerged over that alleged misquote...
I wrote about how and why Barret is FF7R’s real star.
After the Aerith piece last week, just need to do a deep dive on Tifa and Cloud next! Goddamn this is a good game
If you're writing about sexism, racism, and bullying in the workplace, you should not be opening with two paras about how much you love the games. Just report the story.
Since I'm not a lil subtweeting bitch, I'm talking specifically about this coverage.
Mario Kart 9 is just a complete non-story, right?
Might start leaking that GTA 6 is “in development” and “will contain guns” or that EA is “actively working on FIFA 23” which “has some football stuff”
We can’t spend a week trashing Forspoken then jump out of our chairs for “you’re probably wondering how I got here…” waffle.
The bar for games writing is on the floor.