Made finals of RC DC and queued for the pro tour and worlds! Honestly a good lesson for myself about taking single events less seriously in prep and embracing the variance.
Deck was fine. I'm very happy with my play the whole weekend. Very excited to get to play more big events.
Wizards of the coast making a tournament series where 1st place gets $50,000+ and 2nd place gets nothing, and then cracking down hard on people doing splits is so fucked.
This is life changing money. Expecting people to do nothing and put it all on one match is insane.
My quick vamps sideboard guide, completely FREE (heavily inspired by CFB's but lists have changed a lot).
Still working on vamps and its matchups, but I have been grinding the deck enough to feel somewhat good about this:
@Stanley_2099
Oh wow this situation was far worse than I imagined. I assumed there was some benefit towards looking at the top card, like turns, but this is just ridiculous.
Rules always need some discretion and good judges use it. That ruling is disheartening and then the rest is disturbing.
Finished 7-0 in the Manatraders series day 1 with mono green.
Polukranos is great and I am very happy playing 4. Same karnboard as always. Am still mostly happy with it.
Matches were:
Engimatic 2-1
Gearhulk creativity 2-0
Engimatic 2-0
Heroic 2-1
RB 2-0
Mono G 2-0
RB 2-0
Was explaining to a friend that to avoid tilt, you have to overcome all 7 stages of grief before the next round.
1. Holy shit I lost to murktide
2. I lost to bad luck
3. Bad deck
4. If I did x I would've won
5. Dumb game.
6. I can still top 8
7. All that matters is the next game
Compared to the last six RCs, I've done so little prep for this one (maybe 10% of my usual).
Mental and play is great tho, so just going to carry this deck.
@mbgeekgirl
This really matches up with Julian's story. Just that the floor judges didn't perfectly hear the conversation they were eavesdropping.
I do think there are more problems with the tournament structure and rules than the judges that deal with them.
Won the MXP 5k, queueing for the MXP championship and the DC RC.
Went 7-1-1 total with vamps. Felt great beating up waste not.
2-0 waste not
2-1 lotus
2-0 spirits
2-0 waste not
0-2 niv
2-1 mirror
-
2-0 niv rematch
2-0 phoenix
No finals, top 2 got both invites. top 8 split 💵.
Just got my first showcase challenge top 8!
Almost same list as manatraders. +1 lair because beatdown plan is stronger with 4 polyk.
2-0 mono G
2-1 RB
2-0 enigmatic
2-0 RB
2-1 UW
0-2 angels (elves=much harder matchup)
2-0 greasefang
2-1 RB
2-1 5c BTL
Top8:
2-0 RB
1-2 RB
Did two more rcqs this weekend. Playing mardu. Deck not the ruthless choice but it's very fun.
Made the finals in both, conceding for credit in one (doubled queued) and then failing to dreamcrush
@selesneal
in the other, getting him his second invite.
35-7 now this rcq season.
Joined
@Stifle421
and 4-0d my first prelim with the scam zoo list that we threw together. Really wish that I had played this in the LCQs but didn't think about it until I saw blue zoo.
Yawg: LWW
Scam: WW
Scam: WW
Yawg: WW
After two sad quarter finals losses in challenges this week (with vamps), I won one. This time modern zoo.
Deck crushes scam. Not playing a surveil land is a huge spew btw. SB I played is bad
Scam x3: 6-0
Zoo: LL
Murk WW
Yawg WLW
Amulet WLW
Top 8:
Scam WW
Amulet WW
Creativity WW
Played three RCQs. Won two of them, lost in the finals of the other. All with Nadu. 18-3 total record.
Deck is miserable and I wont miss it. It is absolutely broken and a logistical nightmare. I am very happy to get both invites out of the way, I really dislike modern.
Got my 4th challenge top 8 of the week. Standard convoke, lost to esper in semis. Second time going "undefeated" in swiss this week. 6-0, then scooped ginger in. List was great except flare.
Analyst W
Toxic W
Dimir W
Toxic W
Convoke W
Temur analyst W
Top 8
Domain WW
Esper WLL
Feels so good to requeue after calling in sick for my first and only pro tour day 2 previously. Not gonna happen again 🙏
Also here's the list. Go blank and hearse are rly terrible, but leyline sucks too atm. Play neither? This list was guesswork but fairly happy with most of it
Top 8d the modern showcase with zoo while all the east-coasters were having fun playing paper magic.
I suppose queueing for the showcase gives me an excuse now to learn a better modern deck. Matchups below.
Fresh off taking down the Chicago Secret Lair,
@CanMack1
is back! This time with a 🌈 Rhino’s Sideboard Guide. He’s basically rich now so he’s giving it away for freeeeeeee!
@fireshoes
Top 8d first challenge with Nadu, 7-2. Deck feels so broken. If players were optimal it would be a much higher percentage of the meta online.
2-0 UB frog
2-0 living end
2-0 boros energy
2-1 Nadu mirror
0-2 RB Necro
2-0 boros energy
2-1 storm
Top 8:
2-1 boros energy
0-2 RB necro
Went 7-2 in the showcase with scaminator. Ended up at 14th.
Played 6 mirrors, going 5-1 in them.
2-0 eldrazi
0-2 lands
2-1 oops
(Not in this order)
Very curious to see if the deck will still be legal tomorrow.
Ended up 4th in manatraders. Lost to Raest and missed my match vs spirits in swiss, and lost to RB/UW spirits after winning quarters vs phoenix.
Am debating on the automaton slot. 2nd stone brain or leveler maybe.
Had a lot of of stuff I could've done better. Deck has a lot to it
B&R wishlist:
Standard: nothing. Balanced + fun in season format.
Pioneer: fable, cruise and Amalia. (Cruise/fable for balance, Amalia for play patterns)
Modern: Miserable format and would love to nuke it all, but mh3.
Legacy: Grief & beans 🙏🙏
I expect no changes: all formats
Went 7-1 in the legacy chally with URg delver. First loss to 4c🫘in the semis.
I am ashamed of my list tho. Blindly copied the first list without portent🤮but didn't check for surveil lands. Keep forgetting those and jeggy cuz people keep cutting them😵💫. Please stop, they are op.
First true RCQ of the season. 5-0-2. Scooped finals as I'm queued.
2-1 waste not
2-0 amalia
2-0 humans
2-1 niv
-
2-0 Amalia
@EmmettNeyman
Amalia felt quite bad in QF. Both of us had great 7s but for my good hand to beat theirs a bunch of stuff had to go perfect. New list.
@Retro_gamer_27
Played my first rcq yesterday and it was over 50% Nadu (17 players). I was one of them of course. Gameplay was miserable, although I never lost. Deck is so broken.
6-0-2 at first rcq for first queue with Nadu. Event was actually half Nadu (17 players). My list was kinda bad.
Looking forward to playing 2 RCs this season.
OTD Jeskai 2-0
OTD Eldrazi 2-0
OTD Jeskai 1-1-1 (2-1 w/o turns)
OTD Nadu 2-0
OTP Jeskai 2-1
id
OTP Yawg 2-1
OTD Nadu 2-0
Ended up 10-4 at 54th. Happy with the result. Will get back on PT eventually. Maybe with the showcase qualifier next month. I'm sure I missed some stuff day 1 due to being awake for 40~ hours, but there were no obvious punts at least.
Losses were RB sac, UBG Rona, mono G and UW
Top 8d the modern challenge today with mardu. 6-1 into top 8 but lost in the quarters to living end. Same list that I posted earlier. Lost to goryos in Swiss.
Turns out 3 trespasser isn't a great plan vs real graveyard decks....
5-0d legacy lcq with scaminator. Legacy meta is perfect.
2-0 Some sweet esper vial deck
2-0 scaminator
2-1 maverick
2-0 esper scaminator
2-1 scaminator
Playing 6/9 mirrors in the showcase was good prep.
5/6 of my matches in the MOCS modern qualifier were Nadu mirrors. Whyyyyyy couldnt we have emergency banned this deck? It is significantly above everything else going on in the format right now.
I went 3-2 in mirrors and then lost to mono b in the 6th round.
When we were chatting in Swiss and then in top 8 I asked him if we had played before and said that he looked super familiar lmaooo
(Great and very friendly player. I know nothing about Pokemon besides that story recently)
@angle_man
@Stanley_2099
Discretion is constantly used in rulings at the highest level of play. Context matters and the game is far too complicated to have every ruling planned out perfectly for every situation.
Compared to the last six RCs, I've done so little prep for this one (maybe 10% of my usual).
Mental and play is great tho, so just going to carry this deck.
Ninth on breakers in the super qualifier with convoke 😭. 7-2, lost the 9th round to temur analyst. Had the third best breakers but bolov jumped me.
2-0 esper
2-1 BW bronco
2-0 domain
2-1 mono red
1-2 convoke mirror
1-0 ???
2-1 4c legends
2-0 toxic
0-2 temur analyst
The whole x-2 not making top cut complaints are baffling to me. Like… yes, 8 people did better than you, so now everyone saves time and those 8 people that had the SAME OPPORTUNITY AS YOU to get there now get to battle it out for the win. Why are we complaining? Just do better.
@chillinoreo2023
The top 2 were not allowed to split. One person conceded to the other. What would happen after was not discussed.
Same as my finals match but we weren't as careful about it.
@arbitraryarmor
People have been so obvious, loud and careless at past secret lairs involving splits. They really seemed to turn a blind eye to it in the past.
Which might have been wrong for them to do, idk, idc. Ultimate issue is the structure which will always lead to it.
Lost a round in the MT series due to showing up at 7:55 after the round started 10 min early.
Feels silly to start early with a strict 5 min tardiness match loss with there being no notification. I have work to do between rounds. I'm not just staring at the webpage the whole time
@aquibian
I quite like it when my opponents make nuanced mistakes. Otherwise we'd just be flipping a coin. I do tend to see the game as just about making the least mistakes tho.
@Parmen10n
There's no reason why challenges have to be so net positive. Why not just lower the ev a ton and let us keep on playing? Remove the play point refund for top 32/64 which is basically a participation prize.
@IamActuallyLvL1
Discussing bad matchups and being met with play advice/anecdote is one of the most frustrating things in testing groups. It's hard to always find the time to get top quality testing so you have to rely on recognizing problems while winning and trust your teammates when they do.
@arbitraryarmor
So, to be clear, they just seemed to care way more this time and it felt like they made an example out of someone. I also heard from people that they were told to crack down but that's rumors.
This is all following the rules, but that's definitely not my point.
@1mrlee
No, but the second Monday after the pro tour is infamous or something. If there's an emergency ban for Nadu (as there should be imo), might be convenient to hit legacy too.
@Gnexists
Only if there's a lot of money on the line or I'm very unfavored going into my QF match.
Ex: the secret lair finals are completely ridiculous if you don't split. $45k+ for 1st, basically nothing for second. That's too much variance for me.
@BenFraley314
I would run third path iconoclast if you're running profts and fable. But yeah I like this list. I'm still undecided on how much I miss Drake but jegantha is a lot more impactful than everyone says imo.
@FrowningTable
The main thing I don't love about the number of challenges is that they're so much less exciting individually. I cared a lot more about them when there were only two, not five.
However the game is growing and I do think it's a good thing overall.
@jakoboffline
@selesneal
Something colorless. Like the temur eldrazi deck Richard Neal won with(selesneal) seems very strong right now. Big weaknesses to combo but beats energy and beat charmaw/blood moon. Breach maybe too
QT on a scale of 1-10 with how intimidating you think you are AS A PLAYER. Then have folks chime in with how accurate they think you are 😏
Personally IDK how intimidating I am but I think it's above a 5 because I always got people at work doin one of these
#WOTCstaff
Went 7-1 in the trials with bowmaster zoo, winning two byes. But I didn't do them justice and went 2(4)-3 in the main event. Not the best play, was out of it for some reason. Maybe due to barely sleeping on Thursday.
I am also completely off of bowmasters in zoo.
@argzax
I think the waste not matchup is reasonable but unfavored. It's high variance. Without waste not they are a worse midrange deck. My opps did have some timely waste not topdecks but when they did they weren't able to capitalize quickly. Normal games but consistency issues/mistakes
@Retro_gamer_27
Down to 0-2 FOW with scaminator or grixis delver. You should expect them to side entomb and haymakers out and prep for a grindy fair game. If they don't, then maybe reconsider.
With decks such as beans, they likely leave in entomb and haymakers, which I imagine changes things.
@fingers1991
I might rework the whole manabase. If you know the indantha + vents lists, I think those might be better. Cut basic plains and have a black shock accessible from every fetch.
Also unconfidant about the maindeck flex spots. Was testing EI and druid some, but idk.