An Environmental Scientist looking for the sweet spot - positive environmental policies that can be implemented in the real world, not simply flights of fancy.
To explain to those who keep asking:
Pragmatic Environmentalism is about working to achieve a fossil fuel free world without the benefit of pretending the impossible is a policy choice.
Pragmatic Environmentalists seek as much change as is possible as quickly as possible
I keep reading demands we lower the voting age, yet I don't read demands we similarly amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act. Under the YCJA gov't stipulates that youth lack the maturity to be held fully accountable for their actions. Shouldn't accountability go both ways
#bcpoli
Ms. May's argument is premature and is not based on any coherent combination of facts. To argue that oil is dead on a planet where 80% of our total energy supply comes from fossil fuels is simply unsupported by the facts at hand.
@ElizabethMay
@yfblanchet
Honestly, I have no time for the people who keep attacking
@FairQuestions
for her work uncovering the financing behind the campaigns against Alberta oil. She did the work on her own dime and more importantly has the paper trail to support her claims.
#bcpoli
#abpoli
#cdnpoli
1/
A quick note: by cancelling
#KeystoneXL
Pres Biden will not reduce GHG emissions since the pipeline was intended to move existing production.
Rather, the alternatives to
#KXL
will generate higher emissions, at higher risk, while pulling billions from Canada's economy
#abpoli
@gmbutts
I have to laugh at Mr. Butts since this is literally the Lumberjack Slam (with no hash browns) from Denny's or the Canadian Breakfast from Rickies. When I worked on the road half our crew would eat this exact breakfast every morning. That you don't know this is telling.
@drvolts
The suggestion that having trained specialist on the intricacies of their roles as regulators and then to fire them once they finally become effective goes beyond stupid & destructive to some higher plane of wasteful and irredeemable...
A reminder, due to our inability to get heavy crude to the West Coast, Russia is currently the second highest foreign supplier of oil to the US with most of that oil going to California/the Puget Sound. This helps fund their war machine
#TransMountain
#canpoli
#bcpoli
#stopTMX
@AstroKatie
@TheJeremyHaynes
Not to mention those of us trying to work from home while raising young children who have had their formal education interrupted. My spouse and I have far fewer free hours as we try to combine work, chores, shopping for us and parents and educating and entertaining our kids
@ClimateBen
What to say? Virtually none of these statements is correct. The oceans are not being killed, forest cover is increasing, fertile soil is at similar levels to what it was decades ago, the insect story is not true...apocalyptic claims do not help the fight against climate change
Does anyone out there believe that
@Greenpeace
doesn’t know the difference between “electricity” and “energy” or that solar panels cannot replace the liquid fuels moved through pipelines. This type of misinformation can’t be argued as accidental.
#bcpoli
#abpoli
#cdnpoli
#canpoli
There are seven countries already at, or very near 100%
#RenewablePower
. So why are we talking about pipelines again? RT if you want panels, not pipelines.
@gmbutts
When you are spending a day working physical labour this is the type of breakfast you eat and I'm guessing most of
@erinotoole
's voters recognize this as a typical breakfast before a hard day's work.
@TorontoStar
Words have meaning and the statue was never "defaced"...it was misappropriated but it was not "defaced". As journalists you should understand the importance of using the correct words because words matter.
@PnPCBC
@ElizabethMay
@yfblanchet
Ms. May's argument is premature and is not based on any coherent combination of facts. To argue that oil is dead on a planet where 80% of our total energy supply comes from fossil fuels is simply unsupported by the facts at hand.
In support of a fallacious declaration that "oil is dead" Ms. May cites an error-filled article that coincidentally she wrote herself.
It is a self-referencing cycle of wrongness
#cdnpoli
#bcpoli
#abpoli
A province with no oil and almost no natural gas decides to renounce the extraction of hydrocarbons on its territory....in other news I have renounced my claim to the throne of the Duchy of Burgundy...
Quebec Premier
@francoislegault
: "The gov has decided to definitively renounce the extraction of hydrocarbons on its territory"💥💥💥
This is the result of YEARS of organizing and a signal for other provinces, Canada, and the rest of the world, right before
#COP26
.
#cdnpoli
@MarkRuffalo
@RBC
It is a natural gas pipeline and they drilled 11 m under the river to avoid have any effects on the river. As for your claim about “the most pristine river” that is a joke. The area has been heavily logged by the very people you support. Basically everything you wrote is wrong
@PierrePoilievre
Seriously???? When we said we were looking for a different path we didn't mean to a pre-1950s medical establishment where kids lived their lives in iron lungs, babies coughed themselves to death and young women regularly died of cervical cancers....
$300,000,000 subsidizes approximately 60,000 vehicles or 20,000/yr. This in a market where they sell 2 million cars/yr
This is 1% of new car sales/yr
There are so many better ways to spend $300,000,000 fighting
#climatechange
than subsidizing EVs for the rich.
#bcpoli
#cdnpoli
To improve Canadians’ access to zero emissions vehicles,
#Budget2019
proposes $300m over three years for purchase incentives up to $5,000. This is in addition to existing provincial support.
#cdnpoli
The location is nowhere near "one of BC's major salmon runs" it is well upriver of the spawning grounds in a portion of the river that cannot be used for spawning and just downstream from the Othello Canyon where the salmon can't pass. Seriously false claims here
#cdnpoli
#bcpoli
Tragic...In one of BC's major salmon runs - while they're trying to migrate and spawn -
#TMX
work crews destroying their route. Truly devastating to watch. Destroying nature to expand oil&gas in 2022 is morally, scientifically and financially wrong
#stopTMX
About those 11,000 scientists who signed a declaration of a climate emergency.
Almost none are climate scientists.
Nor are the thousands of engineers who argue we can’t trust global climate models.
It is almost as if these types of nose counts are utterly useless
#cdnpoli
In what can only be described as deep irony
#TransMountain
pipeline protesters gather on the Columbia River to fight a pipeline that will reduce the number of rail cars carrying oil along the Columbia, greatly increasing the risk to that river.
#bcpoli
Note what Palmater does here. She realizes that she can't use her usual tropes on
@ellisbross
so instead switches over to making ridiculous claims about climate change.
Pretty much sums up how solid her case is when she won't/can't defend it against an informed opponent.
#bcpoli
A reminder to the people who keep tweeting "NO MORE tankers" to me. In our modern society "no more tankers" is not an option if you want food in your stores and ambulances on the roads.
The question is simply whose tankers and under what regulatory restrictions?
#bcpoli
#abpoli
@maxfawcett
I remain amused that all you appear worried about is "credit" as opposed to actual global emissions. By your logic we can all burn as long as Canada meets its targets
@MarkRuffalo
except the Supreme Court said that the Hereditary Chiefs are not the ones who need to consent. The Community is the final arbiter and they did not choose to allow the Hereditary Chiefs to speak for them.
@althiaraj
@WoodfordinDK
For those wondering this is literally an everyday occurrence in Vancouver and Victoria where campers set up tent cities with full cooking facilities and lots of propane cylinders all over our communities...and we have been told to simply accept it
@Adam_Stirling
For those people wondering what teachers are doing during this pandemic to justify their paychecks. My wife (a teacher) just stopped working on her new website built to let her to teach from home. I made her stop so she can have a few hrs of "weekend" to relax
@keithbaldrey
#bced
@jengerson
Strongly disagree. As someone who has broken up many bar fights, those who initiate these fights are generally physical cowards emboldened by numbers.
These fights almost always involves a larger group attacking a smaller group or an individual (the Kavanaugh scenario).
@ElizabethMay
Fracked Canadian gas does not have the same carbon footprint as coal. Your claim is painfully bad and indicative of absolute ignorance of the Canadian natural gas industry
When Leadnow says they stand with their "indigenous allies" is that
-120 Indigenous Groups (IGs) that support or do not oppose
#TMX
?
- 43 IGs who signed benefits agreements?
- the numerous IGs and Indigenous businesses who stand to benefit
-or a handful that oppose
#bcpoli
This is a bad and dangerous decision.
But no matter today's decision, we stand with our Indigenous allies, our movement stays strong, the fight continues, and we will win.
#NoTMX
#StopTMX
Ever notice how Ms. May carefully avoids acknowledging the recent research on the topic of diluted bitumen? Transport Canada has provided a comprehensive demolition of her talking points and she simply pretends the data is not out there
#stopkindermorgan
To those slamming teachers on
#bced
My wife just spent almost 40 minutes on a 1st term report card comment about a single child in her class of 29
Teachers care about their students they just want the time to give each the individual attention each child deserves.
@keithbaldrey
A reminder for anti-
#transmountain
activist:
heavy crude is a fungible commodity and blocking
#TMX
will do nothing to affect oil demand all it will do is move that demand to suppliers with lower environmental standards and higher per barrel GHG emissions
#bcpoli
@Tzeporah
@DGlaucomflecken
I am a CHEMIST.
I have the skills and supplies to make WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION.
But I spend most of my time CLEANING GLASSWARE.
I’m also very useful if you need something to CLEAN A SPILL.
If you don’t like it, I will look for an ALTERNATIVE SYNTHETIC ROUTE.
Time to put together a thread on the truth about the
@TransMtn
crossing at the Coquihalla River (formally called crossing BC-654) that the
#StopTMX
folks have been talking about. As we know some activists have claimed that "thousands" of fish were killed
@NBulowski
@NatObserver
I'm confused by the argument: "nuclear takes too long to build"
Building up renewables will take decades, then each turbine/solar panel needs to be replaced every 20-25 yrs.
A nuclear plant can last 50-70 years. How can nuclear be "too long" under those conditions?
#bcpoli
I'm a highly trained scientist with special expertise in evaluating science for its reliability and quality. I spend my days looking at scientific reports to understand what they actually mean, and I have no clue what the WHO's latest statements mean for transmission of COVID-19
There are times when Ms May really goes out of her way to demonstrate that she has no understanding of the Canadian natural gas industry. No serious observer believes Canadian natural gas has the same carbon footprint as coal. That claim has been completely debunked
#canpoli
Today in the oil market:
MAYA is $41.16
WCS is $15.73
Difference $25.43
Line 2 of
@TransMtn
would carry 540,000 b/d
That is $13,732,200 of lost value TODAY!
Were this to continue it would represent $5 Billion per year!
Time to build the
#transmountain
@MattWolfAB
#cdnpoli
@_CryMiaRiver
@YWCA_Canada
Two things can be simultaneously true:
1) trans individuals can exist and deserve accommodations and
2) male predators do exist and will lie and cheat to access spaces occupied by vulnerable women and girls.
Any policy to accommodate the 1st that ignores the 2nd is a bad policy
China can’t get enough heavy oil for their needs so they are converting coal-to-oil a process that uses massive amounts of water and generates massive amounts of GHGs. Aren’t we glad the activists are keeping them from getting Canadian oil
#bcpoli
#cdnpoli
So who wins and who loses if the
#TMX
doesn’t go through?
Losers: Canadians, the environment, salmon, the SRKWs (orcas), Canada’s fight against climate change
Winners: Activist NGOs, American refinery owners, and foreign dictatorships
#bcpoli
8/
I remain amazed at how shallow the anti-
@TransMtn
pipeline folks' arguments are. After all this time they simply can't answer the most obvious question: what is your alternative means to supply us with necessary fossil fuels?
#bcpoli
Who would you rather get your oil from: Canadian producers who pay Canadian workers, Canadian taxes and Canadian royalties that help pay for our social services and medicare or from Venezuela, Iraq and Columbia...
I am absolutely frustrated that literally years into discussions with activists fighting against Canada's oil industry and pipelines (like
@TransMtn
) that these activists literally don't understand basic concepts like density of oil and what the term fossil fuels means
#cdnpoli
I'm seeing a lot of chatter today about the Tides Canada/US Tides foundation link (The Exchange Fund) that
@FairQuestions
identified and was in the Allan enquiry report. Here is a quick thread to address the tax scheme I describe as a "maple filter".
#abpoli
Basically everything Mark tweeted is wrong. It is a natural gas pipeline (it won't "spill"). They are drilling under the river to avoid impacting it. The River is not "The most pristine river in the Northern Hemisphere" it is heavily logged and crossed over by bridges for logging
Like every other pipeline, they say they won’t spill & they always do.
@RBC
is responsible because they’re the ones funding these antiquated things. The most pristine river in the Northern Hemisphere on sovereign First Nation’s land has been fouled.
This is the tweet of a political leader unaware of the difference between electricity and liquid fuels and unaware that electricity cannot replace liquid fuels in our current technological state. Quite frightening from a policy perspective.
#bcpoli
#abpoli
#cdnpoli
@keithbaldrey
We must overhaul the review process for energy projects & invest the billions that would have gone into expanding the pipeline into clean, renewable energy that would help us meet our climate change targets. This would also create jobs for today’s workers & future generations.
Except the alternative to the pipeline is other tankers from less well-regulated jurisdictions and oil-by-rail which is much more dangerous to marine and freshwater resources. So your campaign puts us at greater risk of spills and environmental damage
#bcpoli
#abpoli
#cdnpoli
Have any of these supporters asked what the
#Wetsuweten
as people think of the project?
The elected councils (which represent the will of the people) agree with the project.
Those who oppose are a handful of powerful men....funny how progressives ignore this fact
#bcpoli
I have been asked what motivates me to behave the way I do on Twitter. My answer is simple. I am tired of sitting by while grandstanding activists make it harder to help Canada achieve its environmental goals.
#bcpoli
#cdnpoli
You have to appreciate Ms May’s persistence in repeating these falsehoods after it has been explained to her repeatedly that her narrative is based on bad US data entirely irrelevant in the Canadian context. Her persistent ignorance and spreading of misinformation is impressive
It is impossible to have a reasonable discussion about pipelines when the other side relies on simplistic talking points and clearly doesn't understand the complex issues at play.
They literally don't know what they don't know and they aren't interested in learning
#bcpoli
@BlairKing_ca
@anjalih
@CAPE_ACME
There is zero rationale for increasing (or even maintaining) current levels of oil + gas use and export—not to mention tanker traffic that threatens our coastline—in a
#ClimateEmergency
driven by burning fossil fuels.
#TMX
is the furthest thing from safe.
Listened to
@AJWVictoriaBC
on the
@CBCStephenQuinn
and the number of errors he made was stunning. Alberta oils aren't even the dirtiest oil in North America that comes from California (Placerita oil field). The dirtiest oil in world is Nigerian (Bass oil field)
#bcpoli
#abpoli
1/
Am I the only one basking in the irony of The Tyee demanding the army be brought in to stop a political protest?
When protestors blocked access to BC's Legislature can anyone remember what the Tyee had to say?
I don't remember it being: "call in the army"
#bcpoli
#canpoli
.
@djclimenhaga
: End the occupation. Start with a perimeter around Downtown Ottawa. Give insurrectionists 24 hours to leave. Since police admit they’re incapable of doing the job alone, the Armed Forces should be brought in to assist.
#cdnpolitics
@coachblade
@iocmedia
@Olympics
In high school I did not medal in the BC boys provincials 1500M, my time would have medaled in the women’s 1500M in the Olympics that year. I was a boy…a testosterone-mediated puberty is a huge advantage for athletes
Amused at how many anti-nuclear Greens who have dropped into my feed to try to change the topic with respect to the German nuclear closure. None will address the point: Germany closed an existing, paid-for facility that was producing low carbon electricity in exchange for coal
Can any journalists explain why no one has designed a micro-payment system for access to individual articles at online news outlets. There are lots of individual stories I would pay to read but I simply can’t subscribe to every newspaper in North America
#bcpoli
#canpoli
This article is a combination of fiction and arguments not relevant to the Canadian context. Furthermore it ignores that our regulatory system strictly manages fracking fluids. At some point the Sun has to stop printing this drek.
In this day and age it is really hard to remain this uninformed. Every expert in this field has said the exact opposite for months and any interested observer knows the truth. What does this statement thus say about the leader of the
@CanadianGreens
?
#bcpoli
#cdnpoli
@TransMtn
I don't understand how 10 yrs into the
@TransMtn
@GlobalBC
can again and again credulously let anti-oil activists onscreen to make their ridiculous anti-scientific claims uncontested. Seriously
@GraceKeGlobal
how can you credulously report these claims
@keithbaldrey
#bcpoli
@maxfawcett
Oil royalties from Canadian oil go into paying for the Canadian social security system. Russian oil revenues are currently being used to pay for missiles that are murdering Ukrainian civilians....there is no comparison.
Have to love that the City of Burnaby approved construction of a school 300 m from a tank farm that had been in place for 30 years and Mike Hudema blames the tank farm for being too close to the school. The original buffer zone was there for a reason
#bcpoli
Just looked at the school calendar. For my Grade 7 son this “back-to-school” plan would mean him returning to school for a maximum of 4 days. There are 4 school weeks in June. Isn’t this a huge effort for almost no return?
#bced
@richardzussman
@keithbaldrey
@jillreports
#bcpoli
Here's a fun reminder, the only people who will work 4 day work weeks are professionals and civil servants on salaries not those working per hour jobs in retail, service industry or labourers etc...
Absolute shocker this
@CCPA
article omits the California market for
@TransMtn
crude, includes Phases 2 and 3 of the Sturgeon Refinery in refining capacity, relies on out-of-date data for Asian refining capacity, omits the transportation costs of Maya to Asia etc..
#bcpoli
#canpoli
A new think tank report argues the mix of competing pipelines, changes in energy demand and shifts in international prices could wreak havoc on the business case for the Trans Mountain expansion.
@CBCDavid
So to argue that Vivian is getting it wrong is entirely backwards. The existence of the continued funding makes it absolutely clear that she is right. The continued funding by the Tars Sands Campaign demonstrates that they think the funding is worth it
#bcpoli
#abpoli
#cdnpoli
9/
Remember a “phase out of all fossil fuels” means no carbon fibre for windmills, asphalt for roads, plastics for medical uses, pharmaceuticals for health, or PVCs for water lines. Activists can’t identify ecologically-sound replacements but still demand elimination????
#canpoli
Our response to the draft
#COP28
text
We are calling on Canada to push for what is truly needed: a fair, fast & funded phase out of all fossil fuels – without any dangerous loopholes - that centers equity and provides the support needed to ensure no country is left behind
With the stoke of his pen Governor Inslee bans a practice that doesn't happen in Washington and wouldn't happen since Washington lacks any geological formations where fracking would be beneficial.
Next on his list...is a bill to ban unicorn hunting
#bcpoli
@keithbaldrey
After signing a bill that bans fracking for oil and natural gas within WA state, I shared how the emerging science emphasizes the urgency of
#climatechange
and the environmental impacts of natural gas make it clear that our state needs to invest in
#cleanenergy
infrastructure.
Watching
@GlobalNational
with
@DFriesenGlobal
and I am reminded that Canadian journalists need to be educated about "fossil fuels". Fossil fuels are a class of compounds that cannot be "phased out" any more than computers can be phased out in our modern society.
#canpoli
#bcpoli
Mike at it again: She isn’t a pipeline engineer. She WAS an environmental engineer 20+ years ago before major safety changes were implemented and the company was sold changing the corporate culture. Her knowledge of current practices is essentially nil
#bcpoli
#stopKM
#abpoli
If an activist tells you:
"I want to fight climate change but only using these select technologies"
Then they aren't really interested in climate change, they are just rent-seekers looking for gov't to pay for their pet projects
#bcpoli
#cdnpoli
@ShellenbergerMD
@nbennett_biv
@mogusmoves
What do you mean "we told you so"? The pipeline survived a storm that took out the rail lines and all the roads and the story is asking whether we should trust pipelines? Given we absolutely need to move the material I would argue that the results speak for themselves.
Let’s just put this out there again: a carbon tax with an associated progressive credit/rebate system to protect the poorest citizens is the best way to reduce our emissions. If you believe climate change is real and needs fighting and are free enterprise you can’t say
#AxeTheTax
Reading a lot of really bad hot takes on the final decision on
#KeystoneXL
. As I detail the loss of KXL will not substantially reduce oil sands production but it will decrease Canadian gov't revenues, while increasing the GHG footprint for the oil
#cdnpoli
A reminder, that U.N. Racism Committee is not the U.N., it is a single committee dominated by states seeking to distract the world from their own domestic racism issues.
They wander the world saying “don’t look behind our curtains”
#bcpoli
#cdnpoli
#SiteC
#TransMountain
I am a parent of 3 school-aged kids, the husband of a teacher and was the PAC President in a school that piloted the new grading and report card system in the Langley School District and have some thoughts about the new approach
#bced
@richardzussman
@RobShaw_BC
@keithbaldrey
🧵
I love the spin. The actually facts of the case are that two Canadian MPs were violating a lawful court order and were detained accordingly. We have a system of law in Canada and all citizens, especially MPs, are required to obey the law
@curious_founder
Your story is deeply flawed. It ignores the realities of mining and only looks at the outputs rather than the efforts necessary to achieve the outputs.
@cliftonaduncan
Living in a world where your mistakes weren't permanently recorded online, where you could escape the wider world without explaining why you were offline and where you could just exist without being connected to anything bigger than yourself and the world immediately around you
As a free market conservative who believes
#climatechange
is real, this headline is proof the Conservative Party has ceased to represent my views.
Small-c conservatives look for free market means to achieve goals. The carbon tax is the optimum tool for the job
#cdnpoli
#elxn43
So
@GlobalBC
did a feature on the effects of Pine Beetles on the Jasper fire featuring the UBC Forestry prof who specializes on the region. She blames Pine Beetles as a major contributor. But don’t worry
@maxfawcett
will call her a contrarian/not reliable
Some perspective: by 2020 China is expected to produce more emissions JUST MAKING synthetic natural gas from coal than the entire Alberta fossil fuel industry That doesn't even consider the emissions once that SNG is burnt in power plants. This is why they need our
#BCLNG
#bcpoli
I do love how any admission that getting to zero is hard somehow becomes “climate denialism”. The fact is getting to zero is going to be tremendously hard and fantastically expensive in the short term. To suggest otherwise is ignoring reality
#bcpoli
#canpoli