Imagining A World In Which Trans Kids Are Free To Be Themselves

Cases of trans people losing access to their hormone treatment on the NHS (sometimes after years of receiving it) are on the rise

Unlike sex, gender identity is neither scientifically observable nor testable. In spite of the million word salads attempting one, there's no stable definition of gender identity. The term is variously but not exclusively applied to an innate certainty that one is not the sex one was born, to a constantly shifting sense of self that may be male, female, neither or both, to the extent to which one identifies with often regressive sex stereotypes, or to something akin to a gendered soul, which may be trapped in the 'wrong' body. Gender identity is an unfalsifiable idea, a socio-political construct, a quasi-religious belief. At bottom, it is defined by little more than a person's subjective feelings, or (more accurately) their claim to feel those feelings. We are told we must believe in the existence of those feelings and that those feelings constitute a new form of fact, even though in literally no other sphere of human life is it held that a person's self-perception must be accepted unquestioningly as true or real. Gender identity ideology is doing measurable, serious harm to some very vulnerable young people and to women. We're watching a medical scandal of terrifying proportions unfold in front of us, along with an assault on the rights of women and girls in the developed world that is unparalleled in my lifetime. I've read treatises on astrology that make more sense than the spiel written on gender identity and I believe that those who continue to push gender identity as 'real' or scientifically observable are guilty of causing widespread damage. The effects are being felt not only by vulnerable individuals, but in once-impartial and rational disciplines and institutions, which, like you, have embraced a form of faith-based fundamentalism masquerading as intellectual sophistication.