![Farwan Irfan Profile](https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/1859522011375992832/aEN0XRGt_x96.png)
Farwan Irfan
@farwan21599
Followers
2
Following
0
Statuses
449
Joined November 2024
@_themusliim_ @MoroShafi2000 That's their contradiction. We say without contradiction: He is above the Throne and thats by necessity in a direction. Qurtubi narrated that the Salaf never denied direction (al-jiha).
1
0
0
@KItreal512 What is to you even the problem with so called addition? You believe that voice Musaa heard is a created speech in Hebrew.
1
0
0
@KItreal512 All the narrations on this subject shows that Allaah talked with his own voice in words, letters and sounds to Musaa orally, and Musaa heard it. The problem is with the Asharis, they think that Allaah is like mute statue.
1
0
0
@KItreal512 Also the belief of the Salaf is that Allaah spoke orally with Musa. So even if it would be a fabrication the meaning is correct. Check Suyuti's Durr al Manthur tafsir under Qasas 30 and you fill find similar narration about how Allaah talked with Musa. I think you are stupid.
2
0
0
@KItreal512 The muhaddithun declared him weak, others said he would lie also. Some contested whether he is a muslim or not.
1
0
1
@fawiddchannel @asharyte Won how? The only thing is to accept that ability does precede the act.
0
0
0
@asharyte The truth is that the ability precedes the act. Once one believes this, the jabari mumbo jumbo of Razi becomes a joke
0
0
1
@KItreal512 It is not surprising since Ibn Hajar was a Ashari. And even so, there are imaams who have far more jarh like A u Hanifa. So then to your standards we should say the same to the Hanafis that they should abandon Abu Hanifa...
1
0
0
@provingislam @lordDawar12 @bayhaqiyyah So you say God has a own language and the arabic Quran is a translation of that?
0
0
0
@KItreal512 as-Suyuti said: “I saw in the handwriting of Ibn Hajr in his notes to ‘Mukhtasar al-Mawdu`aat: “This false addition at the end of it is not present here and so it is clear that it occurs due to the poor memory of Ibn Battah.” This clears Ibn Battah of intentional fabrication.
1
0
0