Indo
@bhagwa_mattick
Followers
994
Following
322
Media
654
Statuses
2,936
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
WE LOVE YOU YOONGI
• 715313 Tweets
WE LOVE YOU AGUST D
• 609486 Tweets
#MyLoveMixUpTHFinalEP
• 597468 Tweets
MLMU LAST EPISODE
• 373193 Tweets
sabrina
• 364503 Tweets
#พรชีวันEP12
• 190644 Tweets
jenna
• 108503 Tweets
camila
• 79618 Tweets
ラストマイル
• 78789 Tweets
Saka
• 73173 Tweets
shawn
• 70413 Tweets
ジェンティルドンナ
• 67004 Tweets
Powell
• 60359 Tweets
Rodrygo
• 47095 Tweets
André
• 43201 Tweets
#ساعه_استجابه
• 38042 Tweets
#4MINUTES_EP5
• 25867 Tweets
Davo
• 25799 Tweets
バブルガムフェロー
• 25320 Tweets
#末澤誠也誕生祭2024
• 23643 Tweets
シングレアニメ化
• 21535 Tweets
Scraps
• 18602 Tweets
Ferdi Kadıoğlu
• 18040 Tweets
ネコバス
• 18016 Tweets
NO LONG BEANS FOREVER
• 14563 Tweets
メイちゃん
• 14296 Tweets
ラピュタ
• 13942 Tweets
Danilo
• 11431 Tweets
Pinned Tweet
“We are not fighting the Russian Revolution [...] The great historical significance of Lenin is no more questioned than the historical significance of Cromwell or Washington. It is only a question of removing the nightmare of history from people's brains”
— Anton Pannekoek, 1928
4
15
89
Marxists need to understand that 'Nation' is a very dangerous term. Nations can't be liberated. People can, only by their own effort
The idea of putting faith in the imagined nation as a naturally rooted and active thing to liberate, idelogizes it as the ‘spirit of the people’
12
84
563
Football today is one of the most commodified sports in the world. An arena where its stars are converted into commodities not meant to express convictions. This however doesn't mean cracks can't be created which tend to shake things up. Such was the case of Zanetti and the EZLN
7
68
568
🚨🇮🇱🇮🇷 Iran's IRGC just released an animated video depicting an assassination on Israeli PM Netanyahu when a time bomb planted under his desk explodes.
1K
4K
16K
7
31
279
Reply with your best post of the year. Not the one that did the best numbers necessarily but the one you’re proudest of
609
47
2K
2
12
176
Paul Mattick wrote about Marinus Lubbe:
"You can think whatever you want about the value or disvalue of his act, it was an act of conviction that he himself stood for."
The same statement today holds for Aaron Bushnell who refused to be complicit in the genocide of Palestinians
1
36
189
This is true though. Marx did not oppose materialism to idealism. He sought to overcome the opposition by focusing on society as the mediating term between the 'material' and the 'ideal'
Read Simon Clarke🥱
@SmashingUrFort
@BALDGANG1
hot take idealism vs materialism is a undialectical false dichotomy
4
1
21
9
20
170
@swagloescobar
I just did your homework blud
Detailed solution so that you can pass your test next time👍
7
18
133
Reminder that when Indian Communist MN Roy was imprisoned in India and abandoned by the 3rd International it was Anton Pannekoek with Henk Sneevliet who was making sure that Roy received his reading material and was also trying to get the British Authorities to annul his sentence
4
30
153
This is what happens when all you do is yap Marx quotes
Communists not being moralists have nothing to do with understanding how morals shape resistance against the possibility of renewed suffering. The latter is the simple point of Adorno's New Categorical Imperative
19
9
127
Not many know about this but a Council Communist was a direct member of the Frankfurt School. Heinz Langerhans; friend of Karl Korsch; Council Communist; KAPD/AAU member; driving force behind the journal Proletarier; student of Max Horkheimer; assistant at Frankfurt Institute.
6
17
137
In a statement, Zanetti declared:
"We believe in another world. To a more beautiful and non-globalised world. To a world enriched by cultures of its people. That's why we want to support you in your struggle. We are with you in this struggle to protect your ideals and identity."
2
10
127
There were talks to organise a match to draw attention to the EZLN's cause but it didn't materialise. Zanetti, alongside others like Johan Cruyff, Oleguer Presas, Lilian Thuram, Dr. Socrates, Cristiano Lucarelli and many more represent the cracks which need to be exacerbated
5
7
117
Through Zanetti, Internazionale grew closer to the Zapatistas, donating £3,500, an ambulance, football gear and a Nerazzurri shirt bearing the iconic No. 4 and Zanetti's name on the back. He further persuaded his teammates to help and they ended up collecting €250,000
1
8
110
This is very stupid and even dishonest way to argue against Palestinian natlib
Let's even ignore the question whether Palestine has a state or not. Still for Palestine to even fit the conditions it needs to have a free connection to the world market when it literally doesn't has
5
12
98
Bothered. Unmoisturized. Sad. Out of my lane. Unfocused. Decaying.
1
5
90
@oreknightVidya
There's a r*pe of a woman every 16 minutes here
49 offences against women every hour
Martial R*pe is legal here
Most of the time women don't report such cases because they think they will face societal "disapproval"
You can clearly tell how bad it is
1
2
86
In 2004, the EZLN or better known as the Zapatistas experienced counter-guerrilla attacks. This news reached Javier Zanetti through Inter's Press and Publication Relations Officer Bruno Bartolozzi who decided to get closer to the struggle in the Chiapas
1
4
98
What made this possible was Zanetti's background and his belief that globalization and neo-liberalism had badly affected the people living in the countryside. His working-class background made him see in the EZLN a rural movement reacting to these standards of deprivation
1
6
98
Waow, a historically left-liberal club(which stood against a right wing dictatorship) stands in favour of queer rights, so surprising omg
I swear half of Barça fans have no idea about the cultural significance or even the history of Barça
🏳️🌈 International Day against LGTBI-phobia in Sport.
We are working for sport in which gender and sexual diversity are respected equally and enjoyed in freedom.
5K
3K
28K
4
3
90
Good time to remind everyone that I am not from the west nor do I live there
4
2
75
How stupid do you have to be to not understand is mediated by and mediates the dynamics of accumulation. In households with children, one of the output of the production process is the intergenerational reproduction of the commodity labor power, raising a new generation of people
6
12
78
"The moment it [art] takes on the character of a commodity, the moment it is subsumed into the [exchange] relationship that transforms it into a commodity, its autonomy, the possibility of culture, has ceased."
— "Zur Kulturfrage" in KAZ, 1926, No. 10
3
14
80
Idk who is more dumb. The Leninists who believe that she has positions more or less similar to Lenin or the "libertarian" socialists who believe that she was "anti-authoritarian" of some sort
At best she is somewhere between Leninism and the Dutch/German Left
#OtD
5 Mar 1871 Jewish revolutionary socialist, Rosa Luxemburg, was born. A critic both of reformist socialists and Lenin's "ultra-centralism", she was murdered by right-wing paramilitaries on behalf of social democrats after the failed 1919 uprising
20
289
834
6
5
74
Everyday I thank God for giving me a brown skin
These insufferable leftoids on here can never brand me as a westerner or white guy
8
1
70
This is what I wake up to these days
Pure unadulterated lignite coal from Oreknight
0
0
64
*Democratic* Republic
> Argues in favour of separation of legislative and executive powers
> Argues against recallable delegates
> Argues against universal workers' wages
> Argues in favour of subordination of workers' councils to national assembly
“The only form of the state in which Socialism can be realized is that of a republic, and a thoroughly democratic republic at that.”
- Karl Kautsky, The Road to Power, 1909
20
18
154
4
7
77
I will never understand Western humour
Wtf is backshots? gyatt? ohio? Just be normal
15
2
66
I'mma be real with you bro, I expected one of those cartoons considering that you took so long to reply
Quite a weak response considering you took over 3 days to reply
2
0
61
This is such a ludicrous attempt at trying to prove that capitalism is "post-patriarchial"
Sure, Capitalist-Patriarchy can't be explained solely on the basis of "rule of fathers" but that doesn't mean it has been negated but instead relates to the concept of "men's league"
╔══ ୨˚̣̣̣͙୧ -- ୨˚̣̣̣͙୧ ══╗
࣪,, .⋆ 𝑤𝚑𝑦 ⁺ 𝑓𝑒𝑚𝑖𝑛𝑖𝑠𝑚 ,.
., ࣪ ₊𝑖𝑠 ,. 𝑏𝑜𝑢𝑟𝑔𝑒𝑜𝑖𝑠 ˚,⋅₊
╚══ ୨˚̣̣̣͙୧ -- ୨˚̣̣̣͙୧ ══╝
╰☆ ﹒𝑎𝑛 𝑒𝑠𝑠𝑎𝑦 𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑙𝑒𝑓𝑡𝑤𝑡 ⊹⁺˖ - ♡/ ↻ 𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑟𝑒𝑎𝑐𝚑
22
16
91
1
6
65
If one begins to really speak about the national spirit of the people, it is a national spirit by history and not nature. As such Natlib reduces history to nature or one can say reads nature into history. Then the struggle for natlib becomes delusional inasmuch as a people are...
1
2
64
"The abolition of capital is not an abstractly free, self-determining political action, but one that the workers are compelled to undertake as personifications of the alienated laws of movement of capital itself"
4
10
67
Mr. Bonefeld replied to my question of why the world market treats every national-state as equal
You can also definitely check out the books by Simon Clarke, Bonefeld and Holloway mentioned here
1
7
67
What is a good argument in favour of Dictatorship of the Communist Party??? I don't think I've heard a good one till now
15
3
67
"With Mattick’s sober post-war writings, it[Council Communism] comes very close to critical theory. Subversive endeavours today should draw on both currents in order to at least maintain the level of reflection achieved in the twentieth century."
1
11
67
“Marx's thesis that the real world determines consciousness, does not mean that present ideas are determined by present day society. Our ideas and conceptions are the crystallisation, the comprehensive essence of the whole of our experience, present and past”
— Anton Pannekoek
2
6
68
The task of materialism is not to outright reject morality but to see it as the life expression of determinate individuals in terms of its conditions of emergence and passing and in connection with the determinate historical forces. Materialism seeks to abolish existing misery
1
0
57
She's the one who helped me to live life to the fullest and broke the deadlock that seemed inescapable
Also wtf I still can't believe that she is older than me😭 Happy Birthday to her nonetheless, Ily❣️
4
0
52
When the neo-liberal says something so superstatist that you gotta hit him with the "Limitations of the National State" stare
1
3
59
*Flashbacks of reading about Japanese Maoist Militants beating the shit out of each other in order to be ready to accept genuine communist subjectivity* 💀
Here’s a largely unknown chapter in the history of international solidarity with Palestine that you’ve probably never heard of; the Japanese communists who fought alongside the Palestinian PFLP guerrillas.
🧵👇
10
562
2K
5
3
57
Yeah I'm convinced that none of the supposed new Leftcoms have read what Bordiga had to say about democracy. Bloody hell even I got swayed by the rhetoric that is so much prevalent among MLs and baby "Leftcoms" about him
Only at the end of the text did I notice his conclusion
4
3
55
A bit late but
Imperialism as a concept has no analytical efficiency. The relations between nation states is one of competition but the ultimate substratum is the exploitation of labour. This emerges as mere inter-state competition, as realism
What Marxist take will have you like this?
162
20
291
2
5
53
The Maoist brains are still trapped in the early 1900s. No idea of how the national and international, state and capital, production and circulation articulate in the modern world. Also absent is the idea of the nature of the state and how social relations conform to capitalism
1
3
51
With that being said, it is undeniable that de-colonialization is indeed a communist demand but such a step can be taken through nation or the national spirit as the point but only through mobilization of the revolutionary subject and a class war
2
2
57
forced to act as if they really are natural forces that have a national history and destiny. The imagined nature of a people depends on the existence of some indefinable Other as the abstract focal point of the, what Adorno calls, pseudo concreteness of the wronged nation
1
2
56
The situation here is genuinely not looking good. Today they blocked all entrances of the major muslim neighborhood here and installed screens to watch the Ram Mandir thing in Ayodhya, preventing anyone from going inside or outside for 11 hrs and everyone is turning a blind eye
2
6
51
"Democracy Against Capitalism" by Ellen Wood and "The State Debate" by Simon Clarke really reinforced my affiliation to Council Communism
The analysis of separation of economic and political along with Korsch's idea overcoming it with councils against their Leninist separation
1
7
55
Anton Pannekoek's letter to Ernst Bloch, 1948
Bloch had sent Pannekoek his article "Freedom and Order" which the latter found similar to his "Lenin as Philosopher" but also way more lucid. Pannekoek also mentioned that he agrees with most of the points made by Bloch
1
11
57
Fit check for today btw👉👈
Oomf just called me the leader of IMT😭
The Internationalist Mogging Tendency...
0
0
23
8
0
48
“Every revolution begins from its own penalty area and ends in the opponent's goalpost.”
— Letter from F. C. Internazionale Milano [today known as Inter-Milan] to Subcomandante Marcos
Football today is one of the most commodified sports in the world. An arena where its stars are converted into commodities not meant to express convictions. This however doesn't mean cracks can't be created which tend to shake things up. Such was the case of Zanetti and the EZLN
7
68
568
3
4
57
Decided to watch a lecture by Heinrich with my best friend after returning from home. Somehow I fell asleep and woke up to cuddling in his arms💀
11
1
50
No investigation, No right to speak they say huh
Hamas are not fascists, yall just see Islamic fighters and immediately think fascism
84
40
525
4
0
46
I'm guilty of this...
She is the sweetest and prettiest girl ever
3
0
46
The situation reminds me of Benjamin's Philosophy of History i.e. how to pull the emergency break so that progress comes to a standstill. The only way to pull the break is a popular uprising against the warlords The alternative? History will be made, again, by the angel of death
1
2
49
“Engels was somewhat closer to bourgeois materialism [...]. If one reads all his statements in the "Dialectic of Nature", many flashes of genius but full of predictions that could not be fulfilled, a new proof that one cannot predict natural science with philosophy”
— Pannekoek
Pannekoek might've rejected Engels' views that dialectics can be applied to Natural Sciences later in his life
2
2
24
4
8
48
@Ya1hor
Nowhere did I claim that national oppression does not exist. I just argued against taking the nation as your point of departure for liberation
2
0
41
Actually crazy how much parallels are there between Adorno/Horkheimer and the KAPD Berlin on the topic of culture. The KAPD was also probably the first one to analyse culture in relation to exchange and commodity-form
The KAPD's work is present in KAZ, 1926, No. 10 and 11
5
8
50
Why are leftcoms using blanchardian terms on trans people??? Not only this but also the recent trend of cis leftcoms to declare themselves homophobic and weirdly getting backed by the queer ones. There are way too many people ready to project their inferiority complex on everyone
4
5
49
Being a science student, a commie and a wage-worker all at the same time is a tough task
6
2
48
The feature materialism discerns in the historical phenomenon of morality figure into its consideration on the condition of a determinate practical interest. It presumes absolutely no trans-historical authority behind morality
1
0
42
The communist position is that unions are organizations of capitalist assimilation which only place struggles at the point of production and make them local and particularistic, a feature of capitalism itself which corresponds to the separation of economic and political
3
2
42
Not many would know but the concept of "Interstitial Revolution", popularized by theorists like Holloway and Bonefeld, that everyday struggles in workplaces and local communities form the basis for a global class struggle actually finds one of its first pioneering in KAPD Berlin
3
12
49
Using art developed by Gerd Arntz, a Council Communist, in an article to justify a technocratic solution for the transition period. Have some shame ffss
Dónal Ó Coisdealbha analyzes the management and production system (TPS) developed by the Toyota Corporation, arguing that the cooperative effects TPS had on Toyota’s internal labor relations contain the seeds of a successful model of socialist production.
2
17
87
1
7
50
Marx originally envisioned to write six books on the the examination of bourgeois economics. Now there's a popular misconception that he successfully completed three of those. However, the three volumes of Kapital we have today are only a quarter of the first of the six books
3
3
43
I will do one more
"Primitive Communism" doesn't exist because the conception is a result of Engels' mistake of elimination of the distinction between consanguine and agrarian communes
What Marxist take will have you like this?
162
20
291
1
2
43
Communizers: CouncilComs must be rejected as they affirm proletarian conditions
Meanwhile KAPD in KAZ, 1928, No. 28:
"The proletarians do not affirm their situation in life. On the contrary, they deny it. They strive for a classless society where there are no more proletarians."
5
9
45
The Palestinian Economy is severely hampered by trade-related restrictions, high logistics costs, cumbersome procedures and institutional inefficiencies. It operates within an uneven Customs Union arrangement with Israel, and has accumulated an enormous trade deficit
2
0
37
So-called Marxists when you ask them to attack Capital instead of attacking personifications/personalizations of Economic Categories
1
3
42
Happened yet again but the guy ended with a broken nose and half bloodied face
Crazy how guys who harass women here will face no reaction whatsoever in public but as soon as you step up to defend them a constable comes and locks you up for almost 12 hours
2
0
14
1
0
35
@ASemjenow
This was genuinely disgusting. Especially the fact that he brought up Aliyah's child and her father who passed away
0
0
36
I've noticed that there's a misconception regarding the KAPD. The acronym "KAPD" is usually translated into Communist Workers' Party of Germany but the correct one should be Communist Workers' Party in Germany. The KAP, following Gorter, regarded itself as an International Party
1
8
46
“The fact that organizing labor is recognized as a business [...] completes the process of the reification of man. A worker's productive power today is not only bought by the factory and subordinated to the [...] technology, but is apportioned by leadership of the labor unions.”
1
8
47
Marx's work on productive forces has got to be some of the misunderstood one out there. Socialism is not some perfect development of productive forces as Dengists seem to suggest
1) Liberation of the productive forces as the key catalyst for the material foundations of a new mode of production (Marx)
2) Political primacy of the revolutionary vanguard party (Lenin)
3) Strategic use of foreign capital as an accelerator of development (Lenin)
2
11
214
2
0
36
Logging in back on twitter and the first thing is mutuals fighting over natlib
4
0
37