Apar
@apar1984
Followers
41,599
Following
1,328
Media
564
Statuses
8,471
काल करे सो आज कर | Advocate practising in Delhi. Co-founder & former ED (2018-24) @internetfreedom . Fellow @Ashoka . Geek out on the law, tech and democracy.
New Delhi, India
Joined February 2010
Don't wanna be here?
Send us removal request.
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
É OURO
• 410570 Tweets
バニーの日
• 409332 Tweets
Bia Souza
• 310538 Tweets
Kyle
• 188091 Tweets
Canadá
• 187666 Tweets
Beatriz Souza
• 169310 Tweets
#แบดมินตัน
• 154769 Tweets
サッカー
• 103540 Tweets
Teddy Riner
• 101358 Tweets
#4MINUTES_EP2
• 90102 Tweets
スペイン
• 88871 Tweets
ELVISH INCOMPARABLE WINNER
• 85738 Tweets
オフサイド
• 77596 Tweets
Fermin
• 46844 Tweets
Emily
• 46728 Tweets
Gallagher
• 37905 Tweets
Ron Paul
• 34795 Tweets
Olmo
• 32048 Tweets
Ekrem İmamoğlu
• 26266 Tweets
Fresh News for $XRP Holders
• 24106 Tweets
異界入り
• 19756 Tweets
Game Informer
• 17756 Tweets
#LakshyaSen
• 17693 Tweets
シュート
• 16762 Tweets
$BCCOIN
• 16361 Tweets
ジャッジ
• 10907 Tweets
GameStop
• 10549 Tweets
Have recently seen a Podcaster/Youtuber interview several Cabinet Ministers in the Union Government. This piqued my interest and I found that in the description, the phrase, "Co-presented to you by
@MyGovIndia
".
As I regularly check government websites (one of my many weird
154
2K
5K
The internet wasn't shut down in Manipur for the security of the citizens. It was to maintain a national apathy. Do you care now?
36
1K
4K
Aarogya Setu was an illegal diversion of public funds and energy at the height of the pandemic. Nothing more than a digital quack that was coercively imposed and gathered vast amounts of personal data. This will be it's enduring legacy.
80
765
3K
Chief Justice Ramanna will retire without determining the Pegasus cases. Was expected to be listed this friday for hearing, but the computer generated date is now 02.09.22.
93
515
3K
Does our Prime Minister have a plan for 52.3 degrees celsius? I ask, as one should ask the gods.
259
324
3K
I hope today’s results allow hope, freedom and courage for more Indians to stand up to bullies and tyrants. Keep questioning and demanding accountability from those who wield power. We are a country governed by a constitution not a god king.
13
631
3K
While we focus attention on Ramesh Bhidhuri’s abusive speech the conduct of Harsh Vardhan and Ravi Shankar Prasad should not be ignored. Seated within close distance they had an obligation to restrain their colleague. Instead we see encouragement. This is only what fits within a
98
799
3K
Ranveer, the problem isn't your political leanings but an amoral ignorance, which you claim as an excuse, if not a virtue, for your actions. You are neither left, right, nor center. The truth is your leanings if any, are momentary, and wholly motivated by self-interest.
In the
The left wing thinks I'm right wing.
The right wing thinks I'm left wing.
The truth : I am a being in temporary human clothing standing on a fire ball flying around another fire ball in space.
I am here for a brief moment in time and I wish to gain Moksha in this life.
ੴ
1K
139
3K
44
411
3K
Multiple parliamentarians including
@priyankac19
and
@MahuaMoitra
are making public statements regarding threat notifications by Apple. These threat notifications are due to state sponsored attacks that use spyware such as Pegasus to infect their smartphone.
As per Apple,
99
994
2K
“It is the right of the citizens to question the Prime Minister of India.” Constitution of India
"It is the duty of the citizens to respect the Prime Minister of India:" Kerala High Court
@PMOIndia
#keralahighcourt
Read more here:
196
79
329
73
410
2K
To the many prominent people, even politicians who participate in TV Debates on
@TimesNow
, specially those chaired by
@navikakumar
. How do you feel enabling this? Is the platform you get, worth it?
Dramatic increase in demand for bulldozers. Are we increasing domestic capacity for manufacturing or will we have to depend on imports??
#JustAsking
. 😝😝😂😂
8K
2K
11K
50
461
2K
What is happening to Munawar Faruqi is unconscionable. It is a stain on all of us.
21
355
2K
The "freebies" that really need judicial attention are called "electoral bonds".
18
473
2K
After the Electoral Bonds judgement and today the release of Arvind Kejriwal on bail there are increasing attacks on social media against the judiciary. This goes beyond voicing anguish or a reasoned critique.
This trend is pronounced for supporters of the Prime Minister who
85
510
2K
Dear
@ECISVEEP
@SpokespersonECI
, how can an ordinary citizen and a registered voter file a MCC complaint?
For the better part of this evening I have been trying to login into the CVigil to file a MCC complaint against this tweet :
1. The online web
64
744
2K
Rahul Gandhi’s disqualification from the Lok Sabha for a conviction in a criminal defamation case is another blow against Indian democracy. One does not even need to be fond of him as a person or support his politics to understand it.
13
408
2K
Cannot imagine what it must feel like for any Indian Muslim. Each day their religious identity is increasingly open to attack, bigotry & threats on social media. From the margins, it is now mainstream, leading discourse. Sorry for all that is happening. Can only pray for better.
48
374
2K
Credit must be shared with Navika Kumar and Times Now for such international recognition.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs Summons the Indian Ambassador and Hands Him an Official Note on Qatar’s Total Rejection and Condemnation of the Remarks of an Official in the Ruling Party in India Against Prophet Mohammed
#MOFAQatar
2K
8K
23K
22
351
2K
Wait a minute... isn't a television news channel accessing and then publishing a draft standing committee report before it has been presented to the House or to the Chairman a breach of privilege?
60
577
2K
How did the Delhi Police get the authority to seize the smartphones and laptops of 46 people, mostly journalists at Newsclick? Why isn't the judiciary taking action against these deeply invasive breaches of privacy and self-incrimination? Dive into my analysis today at
45
711
2K
Delhi : Please do not do exercise in this toxic air. That means no jogs, runs or walks. It does not matter if it’s in the morning, afternoon or evening. As per consensus amongst physicians this can trigger immediate and long term health risks.
24
321
1K
Sitting judges of the Supreme Court may benefit from reducing the frequency of their public lectures. It is having a counterproductive impact to institutional integrity and stocking growing public cynicism. Words need to match work.
12
213
1K
The humour directed at the present Vice President, Mr. Dhankhar, nowhere compares to the years of organised slander against Mohammad Hamid Ansari. Yet, no prime time shows and no manufactured outrage. The reasons for this are obvious. He is an accomplished diplomat, scholar of
87
497
1K
Seriously, what Digital Public Infrastructure is being built in India? How can we possibly offer a model for the democratic world?
Yesterday personal data (Aadhaar, passport details, names, phone numbers, addresses) of 81.5 cr Indians was leaked by ICMR. Later at night Apple
45
601
1K
The registration of a criminal case and now the use of coercive police searches on the houses of the editors of The Wire deserves wide and unequivocal condemnation. Criminal prosecution is disproportionate to any breach of journalistic ethics or even law in the facts.
151
484
1K
How can we expect the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 to be enforced in citizen interest when the nodal ministry
@GoI_MeitY
sends unsolicited spam promoting the Prime Minister on your WhatsApp?
48
536
1K
While working at home, I was abruptly disturbed by loud noises from the street. At 7:45 PM on the main road of Kailash Colony, South Delhi, a rally featuring motorcycles and a car adorned with BJP flags and loudspeakers disrupted the peace. The speakers blared music and explicit
106
300
1K
The prosecution of Arundhati Roy demonstrates a continued effort to maintain the mirage of continuity in “Modi 3.0”. Displays of brute power must be continued for illusion to become reality. It is important for voices from civil society and the opposition to openly and loudly
81
449
1K
Sorry Times Now, in good conscience cannot join a show anchored by Ms. Navika Kumar or Mr. Rahul Shivshankar — beyond the contents of any broadcast — it is to mark solidarity against legal proceedings being used to stifle media critique.
13
150
1K
The Telecommunications Bill, 2023 which is listed for introduction and passage today in the Lok Sabha is another action to cement authoritarian control over the rights of ordinary citizens. Its impact will be felt directly in four clear ways.
First, there is a clear power for
42
637
1K
Twitter and the Government of India must release public statements and address these concerning allegations that Twitter hired an agent at the behest of the Indian government and gave the person unfiltered access to user data.
26
402
1K
Violence as a form of disgust is a product of hate speech. The loss of life and the shocking visuals from Assam is not an aberration but a natural outcome of an unrelenting political and media campaign. This is how nations tear themselves apart.
12
381
1K
Theft of an election is not a political stratagem. It is a fraud on a democratic process. It is illegal and immoral. Here, rather than questioning the perpetrators our TV news media contours it as a victory. How low have we fallen?
32
402
1K
Way back in 2021 I stated here on Twitter that I will not appear on Times Now and Republic. This was after shows called for the arrest of civil society activists and human rights defenders in India. I have consistently refused appearances where they have sought me out. I have
38
298
998
Oh yes, just like the "collaboration" between BeerBiceps and MyGov was, "organic", no? There is an entire investigative series waiting to be written how through threats, patronage and inducements the Union Government has exerted control on Indian influencers.
Dhruv Rathee aur Ravish Kumar ne poora RW ecosystem hila Diya.
Enjoy the meltdown 😂😂
601
3K
13K
18
192
999
Disha is a young, motivated climate change activist. If flash floods in Uttarakhand have taught us anything, it is we need more Indians like Disha who have the empathy to work on our collective future. Her arrest is are a direct outcome of TV Broadcast “news”. Shame on us. Shame.
14
250
985
Manipur right now is suffering the second longest (mobile) internet shutdown in India. It started on May 3, 2023, was restored on September 23, 2023 and after three days put back in place. Imagine 155 days without the internet.
36
477
990
I write today in
@timesofindia
, that the Draft Telecom Bill is not only a cause for disappointment, but alarm. It maintains a colonial control and visualises citizens as subjects by ignoring constitutional developments on privacy & free speech. 1/2
15
445
985
Are you comfortable with your RWA having the powers to expel you from your own house? Soch lo.
117
260
988
Rather than claiming victimhood and doing media management in weekend lectures the Chief Justice should list the electoral bonds case and many other politically inconvenient cases. Lead by action to address growing criticism. But will he?
26
297
972
Any court should not pass orders when it lacks intent towards their enforcement. It undermines public trust and is an invitation to wider lawlessness.
44
237
955
Its a new government, not a franchise movie trilogy and neither a new operating system. Call it NDA, not Modi 3.0. Grow up, news media. You do not need to always talk in brand and hyperbole.
18
222
952
The Telecom Bill is a system upgrade of a colonial law for a modern authoritarian state. I raise alarm on it in an Op-ed in
@TheHinduComment
.
25
462
947
We are tearing ourselves apart as a country.
16
134
922
Yesterday, I was invited for a 8:30 PM show on
@ndtv
yesterday hosted by
@maryashakil
by a guest coordinator for Deepfakes. The zoom link was also shared. At 7:20 PM I was told the show was cancelled.
While I enjoyed a leisurely dinner I did see the show go ahead. In my book,
24
118
941
This statistic has not left my mind since I first read it.
Two thirds of Indians are scared of voicing their political, social and religious online for fear of legal prosecution.
This is not the statistic. Read on.
People in states with the highest fear of legal prosecution
27
434
919
Our legal apparatus has transitioned from a failure to prosecute hate speech to now targeting those who document and report it. To such cheerleaders — competitive criminalisation will come to haunt one and all.
9
241
864
The Delhi Air is no cleaner that it was 5 years ago. This is a fact. Despite experts cautioning against gimmicks such as smog towers and guns the local government has spent sparse public funds on it. It is a national shame that the capital's AQI is close to 400-500.
27
182
841
What’s wrong with all of you outraging against the Uttarakhand draft UCC? Need to trust the State. After all it’s just a registration. They will make a digital public good such as an online form or an app. It will help live-in couples define relationships. What do you have to
64
174
846
The Haryana Police's display of drones equipped with tear gas for use against civilians is the implementation of a militarised technology in local policing. Its demonstration in advance and intended use on a peaceful protest is immoral and illegal.
77
401
827
The velocity of legal change should not surprise nor shock. It is in the nature of an autocratic regime to maintain a frantic pace of activity to prevent reflection and thought. An insight from Hannah Ardent’s work.
13
277
830
Just 307 views on TimesNow NewsHour after 30 minutes of posting on a channel with 5.3 million subs. Sorry, I added one to check how many people are still watching this garbage.
95
95
831
Since CCTVs in classrooms was not enough, live feed will now be given to parents. Again, this without any legal framework or studies conducted to assess the impact on children.
45
212
812
I am no fan of Arvind Kejriwal. But to make his political opportunism and/or ideological inconsistency a justification for the repeated attempts to browbeat an elected government is an insult to the democratic mandate by the people of Delhi.
24
149
818
Why did Bill Gates do a long interview with the Prime Minister weeks before a general election? Was he not aware of its use as a form of political propaganda?
Let me flip this question and answer it from the perspective of our Prime Minister's historical courtship of silicon
22
294
807
This is precisely why V-Dem has rated India as an, “electoral autocracy”. Freezing the bank accounts of the principal opposition party weeks before a general election smacks of bad faith.
18
320
783
Twitter was a reliable and timely medium for farmers during their protests in 2020-21.
They issued official press releases, documented police excesses, built community and sympathy for their cause with hashtags. It became a vital informational pipeline for farmers to convey
28
360
777
How many of Rahul Gandhi’s policy proposals have been accepted? Can friends accept their biases and for a second acknowledge his (or, even his team’s) foresight and public pressure that is helping the Government course correct. And no, I am not picking sides but stating facts.
19
167
771
Being successful while fulfilling public interest should be celebrated. Newslaundary does fact driven reporting; carries critical and well researched reports; and has popular shows that critically analyse the television broadcast media. It’s funding comes from paying subscribers.
Kaunsi samaaj seva kar rahein hain? It’s a business model that works for them. Fine.
Sitting in a room watching TV and critiquing is not really fraught with risks in the world of reporting.
294
475
3K
14
102
756
Twitter's case against the Union Government's blocking orders is not an arrogant defiance of our laws. It is a petition to challenge a secret and unaccountable censorship power that is a threat to every Indian internet user.
51
294
753
The repeated adjournment of Umar Khalid’s bail hearing by the Supreme Court is a form of determination by judicial evasion since it causes a denial of judicial remedy. It squares poorly for a court that wants to overcome the legacy of ADM Jabalpur.
22
298
728
The flames of the Amar Jawan Jyoti being extinguished marks another public place in Delhi from childhood becoming a memory. A broken promise of an eternal flame that is extinguished.
11
153
721
Usha Ramanathan sets out the constitutional objection to Voter rolls and Aadhaar.
7
256
682
Aadhaar-Voter ID Linking is listed for introduction tomorrow in Lok Sabha. It is a dangerous law that will undermine electoral democracy; free & fair elections; individual privacy. We have no data protection law. The one under consideration is leaky as a sieve.
Aadhaar-Voter Linking: “Election Laws (Amendment) Bill 2021” will be introduced tomorrow in Lok Sabha for Aadhaar-Voter Linking. It violates our right to privacy by enabling voter profiling & linkage of data sets. Statement led by
@no2uid
on concerns. 1/n
17
384
583
41
399
650
How is this Modi 3.0? Why can't the government now be called by its real name. The NDA.
22
109
669
I offer no original insight or analysis. I pray that current trends hold for my country and its people. Regardless of the results, I hope the enduring work of upholding our constitutional values continues.
9
85
657
Two things for people who have questions on the X-Check story, first it will not take away from the credibility of
@thewire_in
’s journalism. They have with courage & integrity been a force for independent journalism in India. It is fair to question and continue support. 1/2
16
73
641
Just to be clear : The ability to debate on almost any subject is a vice, not a virtue.
7
52
641
The position of the Union Government on Pegasus is not merely evasive, it is obstructive. Causing an institutional gridlock where, Parliament, an Inquiry Committee & Supreme Court are prevented from action. Similar stratagems are evident beyond Pegasus to evade scrutiny.
7
186
629
The App will upload on a blockchain and the entire relationship history will be on an immutable ledger. It will be run by a non-government organisation that will monetise your data by selling it to flower vendors, cake shops (or, even groceries since it’s a live-in). Win, win!!
30
85
634
The difference in the reporting on the Uttarkashi tunnel collapse between print and television news is (also) by regulatory design.
I write in the
@TheHinduComment
today how the
@MIB_India
through the Broadcasting Services Regulation Bill, 2023 is constructing a *control tower*
18
254
620
24 hours: A CoWIN breach, government conference evangelising Digital Public Infrastructure & reports of coercion on Twitter to censor. To all three the response is denial and bluster. It fits within a pattern how state accountability and constitutional rights seem like old
12
266
617
Yesterday
@internetfreedom
revealed the Aarogya Setu Privacy Protocol was discontinued highetening concern that personal data may be stored in perpetuity. Based RTI work in which IFF files close to 400 applications a year and take them to the CIC putting in years of work. 1/4
3
163
586
The expulsion of Ms. Mahua Moitra from the Lok Sabha is an attack not only on an individual legislator but the people who cast ballots in her favor. There has been a clear lack of fairness by the Ethics Committee that has been emboldened by a coordinated smear campaign on social
31
179
589
The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting has finally made it clear it aims to regulate OTT providers just like it has regulated Cable and Television. A historic opportunity at liberalisation is being squandered and a paternalistic mechanism of censorship and government
19
296
582
Voter against the politics of hate in favour of social justice and liberty.
16
16
553
A special session of parliament will pass legislation to circumvent a judgement of the Supreme Court in order to capture the power for appointments in the Election Commission. Two institutions will be damaged to cement control of the Union Executive. Another instance of
11
193
538
Travelling in delhi localities noticed the ubiquitous presence of the national flag. Felt conflicted. Always loved it and flew tiranga coloured kites in Ajmeri Gate as a child. But somehow, today the displays feel forced, with compulsion & social judgement. Will still fly kites.
25
49
535
Seizure of a journalists phone and digital devices is a wider trend that requires reform and safeguards. Important for us to remember earlier this year the raid at the BBC India offices. At the time I wrote on it in the Hindu. I am quoting from it below:
“Since 2018, there have
18
322
524
Internet censorship won’t douse the fires raging in Manipur. It requires truth, justice and reconciliation. Shame on our institutions of governance and public officials for having failed its people.
8
194
529
I cannot help but feel sad how far back our country has regressed from progressive values. Not only in their realisation but even in the ability for the softer voices in our society to ask for greater freedom and social justice. There is a lack of aspiration to do be better for
64
159
528
(1) Inviting bids for procurement through a public tendering process by itself is not a complete measure of transparency. There are tenders, and then there are tenders -- the terms matter. Here its is important for the bids, decision and financial outlays to be pro-actively
11
112
521
Has the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India responded to the joint letter by the 18 press organisations regarding the raids on NewsClick? Just checking in as I deeply admire his commitment to freedom of speech, institutional autonomy and a clear understanding of digital technology.
26
176
514
The State Government of Manipur has reportedly "lifted" the Internet Shutdown in Manipur. I would urge journalists to scrutinise this claim especially how they craft their headlines.
The internet has not been "partially" lifted but to a, "small" and "negligible" number of users
8
272
511
The juggernaut has been stopped. It now needs to be rolled back. This requires the patient, hard and long work of constitutional practice.
13
80
513
Specific provisions of the Telecom Act, 2023 have been notified by the Union Government to take effect from June 26, 2024 as per a gazette notification dated June 21, 2024.
1. The Gazette notification states, "The Central government hereby appoints the 26th day of June 2024, as
9
198
488
Are we one step closer to a surveillance state? The Telecom Bill, 2023 grants the government sweeping powers over OTT applications, encryption, surveillance, & internet shutdowns. Discover it's dangerous implications in my latest video at Amaltas Talks.
9
293
488
True liberation from a colonial mindset will be when the Prime Minister resides in a modest, functional apartment or house rather than any palatial monstrosity.
17
108
468
It is ridiculous for any Court to observe that case pendency prevents social protest. It makes little sense in law or reason. The Court itself has often expressed inability to enter a policy thicket and progress on it is often made through assembly, advocacy and the ballot.
6
130
470
Where is the report by the SC Committee on Pegasus?
When was the last time the case was listed?
Will there ever be any accountability in India for illegal surveillance?
14
182
462
The term "Modi 3.0" used by the news media is intended to convey a sense of continuity with the new Union Government. This framing device emphasizes the Prime Minister's personality as the focal point for all analysis. However, this approach overlooks the significance of the
21
137
449
In many ways the welcome that foreign dignitaries for G20 are getting to Delhi speaks to the practices and values of, "New India".
A capital city has been be shut down for three days to give a pretence of security, cleanliness and order.
What will they not see? A thriving yet
16
145
441
A cabinet minister being "upset" is not a legal ground for interference with the functioning of a regulatory body such as the Central Board for Film Certification. At best it can commence action under a revisional power rather than eroding the functional autonomy of the CBFC.
7
103
440
It is easy to dunk on Sam Pitroda's statements. To mock him and his contributions to our country. He is one of India's foremost technocrats and if not respect does deserve a holistic public assessment.
For a moment, I hope some consider and read this excellent paper he wrote on
115
101
442
Yes, I admit I felt glee when I heard Kangana was slapped. But then I also felt sheepishly guilty. Well, yes, slapping vile people -- those whose entire personalities are about verbal attacks and dehumanising individuals and minorities --- may give momentary satisfaction, an
23
83
438