Chartered Accountant ,Independent, Supports social activity dedicated for betterment of Nation. No Endorsement to blindfolded supporters irrespective of status.
So, let the Court & Karma decide the future of CA students. Anubha Mam, thank you for this. We have done our best and am assured Lord Krishna is listening to us & he will move this for us. 🙏🙏
#castudents
from 16 states and one Union Territory which includes disabled students as well, moves court against the
#caexams
which are going to be conducted by
#icai
during elections.
Several students have been requesting to reschedule it.
1. If you are not prepared, go for next attempt. Don't ask extension for exams.
Response: Sir, govt is not prepared to handle chaos during exams & students life will be endangered, we are asking extension for that. Many areas will have 144 levied.
Thread 😂🧵
Didn't find a single Council member tweeting on issue of Income tax site. 60% CA's practice in tax & losing health badly due to difficult situations.Same Council member will ask votes in Dec 2024 elections. Vote wisely. Vote silence or Vote leaders
@theicai
#IncomeTaxSiteIssues
Income tax Alert
Section 43B-any amount remains unpaid on year end to creditors, being micro/small entity, beyond 45 days or less,as agreed or 15 days if no agmt, shall be added to taxable Income resulting in huge additional tax liability.
Keeping such creditors unpaid is risky
Instead of representing strongly the matter, people are just becoming post masters of passing information from council.
We all know ICAI is not in mood, reason we are strongly representing. If
@theicai
had intent,why we be making noise.
Heights of
#Khamoshi
from ICAI members.
What's more amusing is, well educated or learned people are asking students to forget/waive their voting rights.Isn't it irony,that a democracy says,each vote is valuable,their elite citizens ready to forego lakhs of votes for ego of few. 😁
#nayi_umar_ki_nayi_fasal
#caexams
Thank you Sir for taking up the issue.
I have been a huge fan of your editorials & posts but now am also full of gratitude for escalating this.
@anubha1812
@sarcastic6666
FYI
Got a few emails from CA students demanding to postpone their exams that are coinciding with the elections.
The demand appears logical. Four lakh students, mostly your own voters, Shri
@narendramodi
, won't be able to vote because of exams.
Though voting dates and exam dates are
Dear
@ECISVEEP
CA Students shouting at the top of their voice of missing their voting rights this May'24 & you have been oblivious of this.
Then preach such messages. How does it match?
Kindly intervene.
#caexams
#castudents
परिश्रम पुरुषार्थ कितना भी कर लो,जब मां कैकई ने राम को १४ साल का वनवास देने का मन बना ही लिया है तो क्या करें लेंगे दशरथ?
बस यही हाल है
@theicai
३ लाख बच्चों के भविष्य को खूंटी पर टांग दिया है।पुतिन से बिडेन तक को सुझाव देने वाले CA भाइयों से अनुरोध है,परीक्षा की तिथि आगे बढ़ाए।
Sir,
J&K Bank issue - No Voices heard.
PMLA inclusion - No Voices heard.
Stat bank audit allotment - No Voices Heard.
CA Exams extension May 2024 - No Voices heard.
Law & Costing Preparation: No Voices heard.
No proper platform for voices to be heard.
@theicai
So basically game is, coming elections in ICAI. Guy who is holding up this entire fiasco will not be contesting elections this time as his 3 term is completed & he will contest in 2027. So wants this ruckus so that discontent remains. Ego nahi hai, game hai. फूट डालो राज करो।
Dear
@theicai
Please Intervene.
This is in swagat store Babhai naka, Borivali west
Reported by
CA Sunil Soni Borivali-west
Criminal complaint needed to be filed for breach of trademark and insult to the professional institute. My humble request.
Media houses talking about the issues, Politicians working on cause.
But but
@theicai
Council yet to even release the press news on same. Sad reality of one of the topmost autonomous bodies.
Friends, Chose leaders wisely.
The way NFRA is suspending/debarring CA's for lapses, am aure if they do this exercise in their ministries,half of departments will be sitting at home. Don't believe, look at lapses with GSTN, Income tax CPC, potholes on roads and more than that, the level of MCA portals. Period
Sir, the biggest injustice is with the students. I have more than 100 cases where a copy wrongly checked or carelessly checked, and zero and 1-2 marks are given to the correct answer as given in the study material or RTP. Even one of the foundation students got 96, 93, and 81 in
Central Council Members of
@theicai
openly canvassing for a political persons in respective constituency.
All Code of ethics,morality & integrity is only for poor chaps who are helpless & devoid of opportunities.
Seniors giving Gyan to CA members are tight lipped.Kalyug hai!! 😏
My humble request to seniors who can contribute for this cause.
Students with genuine intentions are fighting a battle. We need to stand by them.
Contribute whatever is possible.
Dear
@theicai
Kindly inform
@RBI
to sensitize banks not to ask "True copy" on ITR's anymore. DSA's & agents insist such attestation & create unwarranted issues on denial of such attestation. Else issue a press release to be circulated to branch managers.
@NITIAayog
@PMOIndia_RC
निर्बल की लड़ाई बलवान से, ये लड़ाई है दिए की तूफान से।
"Which law allows postponement of exams" hinted,Court didn't intended to intervene.
Huge thanks to
@advocate_alakh
for taking up.
It's ok to lose battle.Get up & get going. Study hard & crack exams.All the best 🙏🙏. Jai Ho!
Better to pay few thousand rupees as late fees then to pay million & half to hospitals for Corona disease.Fill govt treasury instead of cash rich Pharma.Sincere request to CA's to stay safe & not rush to deadlines to risk self.
@PMOIndia_RC
@PMOIndia
@PMO_NaMo
Extend R9 due date
India Wide Parents’ Association writes to Chief Election Commissioner raising concerns over upcoming exams clashing with Lok Sabha poll dates. Urges poll body to coordinate with agencies so as to ensure holding entrance, state/central univ exams after elections.
@anubha1812
Sitting in cosy cabins & giving Gyan!
No system of redressal of grievances nor any inclination to help students in this difficult time of elections where transport & resources are not available.
Institute of Chartered Accountants of India - ICAI
The journey to becoming a CA requires full dedication, strategic planning and continuous learning.
Here's CA. Ranjeet K. Agarwal, President ICAI sharing tips for aspiring Chartered Accountants to excel in CA Examinations.
#ICAIat75
#DRISHTI
@CaRANJEET
EY hamari list mein nahi hai. ~ response from ICAI Council.
CA toh aapki list mein hai ya woh bhi sirf voter list mein hai. Anna was a CA. We are asking justice for her. Political support pouring in.
ICAI Council woke up from slumber please.
I spoke with the heartbroken parents of Anna Sebastian, a bright and ambitious young professional whose life was tragically cut short by toxic and unforgiving work conditions.
In the face of unimaginable grief, Anna's mother has shown remarkable courage and selflessness, turning
2. Students will get extra attempt in Sept,so even if u don't clear,you will now 3 attempts in Exams.Don't ask for an extension for exams.
Response: Asking us to wait six months for next attempt,but not ready to extend the date for 20 days. Six months vs 20 days???? Think Sir.
Every hour 3 lac returns. Even CAG will have nightmares on auditing this portal. NIL Tax, but schema updated yesterday to include late fees on even on NIL tax on 31.12.2021. Tarun Bajaj Saab's confidence will call for Noble peace prize this year.
#Extend_Due_Date_Immediately
What's more amusing is CA's didn't support extension request,infact demoralised by sharing Chinese whispers of dining table talk.
Now,here to taunt the students for loss in Delhi HC.
Sir's you also lost extension petition in Courts,for ITR & tax audit & GST. Woh din yaad karo. 🥺
The bomb is dropped!!
The devil NFRA has started stinging the CA fraternity.
The only CA society which takes bureaucracy head-on is now made victim of vicious game plan by bureaucracy.
But we will fight this too.Not leaving any stone unturned.
#long_live_ICAI
#NFRA_se_NAFRAT
3. There is no problem,students can change exam centre,we reopen the forms. Please don't ask extension for exams.
Response: Sir,during elections,bus/transport is occupied by karyakartas for their campaign.Most facilities are blocked or over booked. How & where to plan?
Dear
@FinMinIndia
If site is working good,whats this clause of working at 8.00 pm.
Why can't scrap this crap & get us some seamless systems?
For levying taxes, you compare with developed nations, then such sites whom should we compare, B'desh/Somalia or Uganda?
@narendramodi
5. Met ABCD, they said no extension.
Response: Sir, Did you submit written document or mention our problems in paper & got acknowledged or was it just discussed as a whisper on dining table. Our problems carry weight.
Stop being messengers if you can't put weight on it.
@cbic_india
People are filing due to stress & avoid late fees & penalty. Quality filing can's be achieved with such approach Sir. Understand, the level of recon. Its sheer arrogance, that the team have been posting numbers as though dealers & consultants are at fault.
@PMO_NaMo
@PMOIndia_RC
The
@theicai
leadership has refrained this time frm representing for extension of dates.Neither GST nor Income tax.Many CA's are into tax compliances. CA's in job or practice, facing resistance need leader's who stand for them.
#Extend_Due_Date_Immediately
@PMOIndia
@nsitharaman
6. ICAI said no extension needed. Pl. concentrate on study & forget SM warriors. It's not extending.
Response:Sir,we will study, but ICAI extended dates in May 2004, May 2009,May 2014 & also May 2019. So either council was wise then or it's wiser now in May 2024. Time will tell.
4. Students don't spend time or Twitter/SM. Study. ICAI has said, no extension.
Response: Sir, we are studying,but Council members are updating on SM the forms & details, if we don't check, we miss the info. If we check we miss study.
ICAI just gave one attempt before such a huge transition. This was a flawed execution of a so called integration to International standard exams. And as always "Nam bade darshan chote". Till ICAI is governed by uncles, this organisation will not achieve heights.
8. ICAI is well prepared. You concentrate on study, we will ensure exams go well.
Response: Sir,we will study,but if even one student loses the opportunity for not reaching the exam center or facing crisis while writing exams,will you allow him grace marks for losing six months?
7. ICAI knows what's it's doing. The new time schedule will need replan. No time for this.
Response :ICAI was well aware of Election matter,then booking dates with election dates,wasn't it ineffective & inefficient system. Imagine if a student is unable to reach exam center?
12. Finally, do whatever you want; we are not extending.
Response :Sir, we will study. Don't extend. Just that, we lose faith in Indian democracy & ICAI autonomy. Members who don't stand today for us,will never stand in future.We are assured. Indebted for this lesson. Jai Ho!!
Dear
@narendramodi
@narendramodi_in
ji,Hope you aware of the consistent demand of business community & tax experts 2 extend the date of Returns & audits. We not doing "Chakka Jam" ,"Dharna", breaking barricades" or "desh virodhi" slogans. We request extension asap.
@PMOIndia_RC
Returns filed yesterday with DSC are invalidated today by Income tax portal. System does not accept returns unless DSC attached, so how come invalid.
Dear
@nsitharaman
CBDT, request to get good Information technology team to rule out this daily glitches.
Dear
@Infosys_GSTN
what's reason of not giving 2B even on 16th of the month, when it was promised on 11th, 13, 14th of month. Defective systems of Ineffective
@Infosys
. Same for other forms & tabs. Then CA's blamed for non-completion of audit on time. Pathetic
@NandanNilekani
कोई CA अगर एक इस्तेहार दे दे कहीं गलती से, तो सारे CA बिरादरी के ठेकेदार नाश्ता पानी लेकर कूद पड़ते है,उसको उसकी गलती दिखाकर सबक सिखाने को।
पर मजाल है एक आवाज आई हो उन CCM के लिए,जिन्होंने पीयूष गोयल साहब के पीछे खड़े होकर कल अपना पूरा योगदान दिया।
हाथी के दांत,खाने दिखाने के।😜
The response from GST - Principal Director GST and my appeal to Nodal officer for enforcing due date on public holiday. Its getting exciting now. Need blessings of seniors
Lets keep fingers crossed 🙏🙏
9. Coaching CA's doing dharna for students for all undue reasons,but this,complete silent.
Response: CA student does not clear,coaching CA get fat fees.Make noise when admission rates drop in coaching not when students suffer.
#extendcaexams
#caexams
#मोदीजी_जनता_माफ_नही_करेगी।
एक
@NandanNilekani
ने GSTR 2 नहीं बनाया, इसलिए
@cbic_india
ने पूरे भारत के व्यापारियों को e-invoice वाले काम में लगा दिया।बात भी ठीक है,व्यापारी पर नियम कानून लागू होता है
@Infosys_GSTN
पर नही।एक सीधा साधा system नहीं दे सके।दुनिया भर के चोंचले ,८ डिजिट hsn, e-invoice, राम जाने
The
@theicai
is sending token of appreciation & gratitude to all CA's who have completed 25 years in practice.
I appreciate the gesture by ICAI & will suggest bringing more such initiatives to promote inclusiveness of CA members in CA society & strengthen the bond
Which law provides recommendations for extension?
Am amused at the request itself.
@Infosys_GSTN
instead of making the system efficient is accepting glitches & asking for an extension.
Koi penalty lagao re in par bhi.... 😁😁
Actions speaks more than Words. RTI filed with CBDT for undue & unscheduled maintenance yesterday midnight putting the entire taxpayer fraternity at stress. Let's not allow these low class software developers to take India & Indians for granted. Many more RTI's in making.
The tragic loss of CA Anna Sebastian reminds us of the critical importance of mental health and well-being in the workplace. It’s a call for us to be more compassionate, supportive, and understanding of our colleagues and loved ones. Success should be measured not only by
Don't think there is intention of any extension by dept. Stay to be taken against this deadline.
When people are getting infected with Corona and entire state is under lockdown, department expects us to file a GST Audit report and sign off financial. Sheer arrogance
@cbic_india
पूरी दुनिया चांद पर पहुंच गई।
@isro
वाले मंगल ग्रह पर पहुंच गए।पर
@Infosys_GSTN
वाले ५०० के ऊपर अगर invoice है तो आपको ,पतली गली से रास्ता ले कर ऑफलाइन dump लेकर काम करना होगा और सही data आने की कोई गारंटी नहीं है।बताओ अगर चार हज़ार करोड़ मे क्या सफेद हाथी बना दिया है सरकार ने।
Dear
@nsitharaman
Mam,this level of bias & hatred towards a specific section of professionals is totally uncalled for.Heading a prominent ministry & making such statements is preposterous.I condemn this.
@narendramodi
ji,this needs to be deliberated & statement to be withdrawn.
Centre to probe death of young EY employee Anna Sebastian.
Union Minister of State for Labour & Employment Shobha Karandlaje tweets that
@LabourMinistry
has officially taken up the complaint.
“A thorough investigation into the allegations of an unsafe and exploitative work
GSTR ४ की आखरी तारीख ३० अप्रैल है। हर कंपोजिशन डीलर के खाते में नेगेटिव कैश दिखाई दे रहा है। ३० के बाद १० ��जार देरी शुल्क लगेगा। अब या दुगना लगान भरो,या RC खारिज करने को तयार हो जाओ। बिजनेस एसोसिएशन के मुखिया ने आंखों पर पट्टी बांध ली है गांधारी जैसी।कोई मसिहा नही गरीब का।
#GSTR4
10. ICAI Council has full rights to take decision.Election Commission will not intervene. Pl. study &forget extension
Response : Sir,we will study, coming ICAI elections, when u write to election commission for all types of menace in ICAI, pl dont expect it to intervene either.
All those Big Gyani CA's talking of ethics & passing strictures on young CA's seem to be completely oblivion on Gurugram mishandling case of 2 CA's. No tweet neither any representation. We will have to fight this battle on our own.
@theicai
@AniketTalati
#JusticeforCA
Jeff Bezos is planning to travel to space. Tom Cruise is planning to make movie in space. Elon Musk helping Nasa with SpaceX. Hamare Infosys se ek Income tax ki site nahi ban rahi. 😁😳😃.MNREGA walon se kraatey tab bhi thik thak ban jati.🤣🤣
#Whatever
#मोदीजी_जनता_माफ_नही_करेगी
कौनसी आसमानी किताब में लिखा है के पिछले साल की सालाना विवर्णी नही भरी,तो गत वर्ष की भी नही भरने दी जायेगी।शायद,
@Infosys_GSTN
वाले
@cbic_india
की लुटिया डूबा कर ही मानेंगे।
@GST_Council
ने तय कर लिया है के लघु उद्योग, देश से सीधे बांग्लादेश निकल ले। फिर कहेंगे व्यापारी ही चोर था।
11. ICAI President has mentioned to allow UK & Canada CA's to practice in India. We lack 30 lacs CA's in India in next decade.
Response: Sir, we will study,but imports seems inclined & therefore create roadblocks with poor Indians CA students, so that imports become seamless.
Dear
@Infosys_GSTN
let us know what changed in one minute,that the validated utility is turning grey while submitting the form. Gap of only one minute in validation of JSON on utility & submission. Digitisation was never that painful. "Infosys desh ki sehat ke liye hanikarak hai"
"If compliance falls on holiday, then as per Section 10 of General Clauses Act,1977, the next working day, will be actual due date".
However
#DigitalIndia
ignores this. Requesting Hon. Courts to take suo-moto cognizance of this & help taxpayers with adequate relief.
@barandbench
From 18/03 to 20/03 ,all 3 non-working day. Form GSTR 2B released on 14th March'2022 post 2.00 pm.
Within 3 days,match Form 2B with Books for all GSTN ID's in PAN & file,else late fees,Interest notices will be inevitable.
Superhumans in making!!
#GST_Golden_Goose
@PMOIndia_RC
Dear
@cbic_india
Request to review the GST Acts on your website and get them updated to recent changes. We are in FY 23 and the pdf file found on website is only updated till 31.08.2021. Kindly do the needful. Snap attached for your perusal.