woke up one day last week with two papers due that I hadn't started; several reviews and clerkship letters; a mountain of exams and student papers. I want to declare
#academicbankruptcy
but will settle for reorganization rather than liquidation
In 1989 Cody's Books in
#Berkeley
was bombed for selling
#Rushdie
's
#SatanicVerses
. Owner Andy Ross had to decide whether to keep selling. “I stood and told the staff that we had a hard decision to make. We needed to decide whether to keep carrying [the book] & risk our lives /1
Looking like a massive defeat for the
#Chile
constitution. Two thoughts: the process undermined the coherence of the draft; and the "no" campaign, along with misinformation, was pretty effective. /1
Thirteen federal judges say that absent major changes at Columbia, they won't hire anyone who chooses to go there (undergrad or law school) following this year.
for what we believed in. Or to take a more cautious approach and compromise our values. So we took a vote. The staff voted unanimously to keep carrying the book... I realized that bookselling was a dangerous and subversive vocation. Because ideas are powerful weapons." /end
Wow, a surprise, I thought this wasn't coming out for another month. Thanks to
@CUP_Law
@ABFResearch
and
@UChicagoLaw
and especially to the great Arthur Wright of
#HydePark
who let me use his piece for the cover!
Democracies and International Law by Tom Ginsburg
@tomginsburg
Contrasts democratic and authoritarian approaches to international law, explaining how their interaction will affect the world in the future.
#internationallaw
One of the most gratifying things in my scholarly career has been a set of private communications from scholars in (unnamed) authoritarian regimes, engaging with my article on
#Authoritarianism
and
#internationallaw
. God Bless Open Access & thank you
@AJIL_Unbound
#openaccess
New AJIL Unbound symposium on "Authoritarian International Law" by
@tomginsburg
, edited & introduced by Katerina Linos, is now available online and always Open Access.
The section has given the award for Lasting Contribution to two publications this year. The first goes to Tom Ginsburg's 2003 book, Judicial Review in New Democracies.
RIP Ruth Gavison, who never shied away from the hardest questions about
#constitutionaldemocracy
. One of the most brilliant minds I've been privileged to encounter.
"All approaches to constitutional interpretation rely on unwritten understandings. Going outside of the text is essential to reading the Constitution," George Thomas writes:
Isaac Asimov: "There is a cult of ignorance in the U.S., and always has. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread...nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge."
we wrote this thing on comparative impeachment, thinking it would be hopelessly out of date by now. Congrats
@UChiLRev
--certainly first law review to publish an article on impeachment the day Articles of Impeachment are introduced in the House.
Articles:
"Stickiness and Incomplete Contracts" by
@JulianNyarko
"The Comparative Constitutional Law of Presidential Impeachment" by
@tomginsburg
,
@aziz_huq
, & David Landau
"Proximate Cause Explained: An Essay in Experimental Jurisprudence" by
@scottjshapiro
& Joshua Knobe
My testimony at in a nutshell: the Pope, the Dalai Lama, 12 apostles of the Mormon church, 28 monarchs and 9 supreme court justices are the only people on the planet who can expect to die in office f natural causes. US would never make this choice again.
Lessons for next time: don't allow anti-political impulses to dominate process. Independents shouldn't run on lists; 2/3 vote article by article made harmonization difficult; and more attention to the "engine room" of politics important as per
@Rgargarella
/end
Pleased to announce that the Comparative Constitutions Project has released an updated version of our chronology of constitutional events, now through 2019!
@ccpconstitute
hopes to have a new data release this year.
#RichardEpstein
has gotten a lot of criticism for his Darwinian pseudo-scientific analysis of
#COVID19
. I am convinced the New Yorker piece could not have talked to the real Richard because it says "He was initially wary of talking..."
For those who have followed Adrian Vermeule's integralist polemics, this great review says he "must choose between Schmitt’s unbounded executive and the Church’s vision of dignity and human rights. He cannot have both."
Three myths about
#CancelCulture
: it is new; it somehow restricted to the political left (remember the
#dixiechicks
?); and it is among the most important issues facing our society in an era of actual
#AmericanCarnage
.
I just complete a two hour mandatory City of
#Chicago
harassment training for
@UChicago
. My main takeaway: never complement anyone on their hair. Let me just say that from where I sit, it ALL looks good.
Sorry state of legal education: “Coming out as a moderate was more difficult than coming out as gay at Stanford Law School.” With some of my fellow Stanford Law students, there’s no room for argument
Comment from last set of course evals: "One male student in particular raised his hand at least 4 times per class session so he could ramble and Ginsburg never stopped calling on him. It felt like a bad Tinder date." Ouch!~
Very excited to announce this virtual workshop series on Buddhism and constitutional law, which I'm co-organising with Tom Ginsburg, starting January 14, 2021. Join us by clicking 'join' on the website below.
📚
@tomginsburg
, experto internacional en constituciones y académico de
@UChicago
, visitará Chile para exponer sobre los puntos clave del proceso constituyente que enfrentaremos en los próximos meses.
👀 Cupos limitados ➡️
#BlackPeople
just saved American democracy, first is S Carolina by choosing Biden over leftier candidates, and now in Detroit, Milwaukee and Atlanta by turning out in difficult conditions.
#saveconstitutionaldemocracy
My take on job offer withdrawals: “The world’s very unjust, and students are trying to figure it out...They should be able to try things out and not carry the weight of their future selves with their speech experiments"
@thechicagoforum
@UChicagoLaw
In episode 3,
@cfloed
and
@tomginsburg
talk to Chileans in Santiago about Chile’s new draft constitution, soon up for vote.
Why do Chileans want a new constitution and what would it mean for equality in Chile?
@HoffProf
@HarvLRev
well said. I once got a rejection from a law review, and i had to write them back my own rejection of their rejection, because they had published the piece the previous year!
with all the insanity going on about campus free speech in the US, I wanted to share an image from
@UChicago
. This blackboard has gone undefaced for weeks, apparently. We
@thechicagoforum
want to take the next step to provide folks with opportunities to talk through the issues.
This was an amazing event. The papers were very strong, we met scholars from all over the region. We felt utterly safe, and were dancing in the streets to celebrate
#Iraq
victory over
#Japan
in the
#AsianCup2023
. Baghdad is back, baby!
Something completely different and new happened in the field of comparative constitutional law last week: an international academic conference on democracy and populism took place in Baghdad, Iraq and was attended by guests from all the continents and from 25 different countries.
My congrats to my friend
@Rgargarella
--it was an honor to engage with your work. In English, my piece is called "Notes on a Continuing Conversation" and can't wait to continue at our next meeting.
Today was the day we first heard a friend got COVID 19. She has all the symptoms. This being the United States, her insurance will not cover the test, so she will never be in any statistics, unless she has to be fully hospitalized or dies. But hey,
#freedom
!
Roberto Gargarella reviews the book from Tom Ginsburg
@tomginsburg
and Aziz Huq “How to Save a Constitutional Democracy”, in the last number of Revista de Derecho del Estado Law Journal 2018
Applause broke out in Senate chamber as Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson became the first Black woman ever confirmed to sit on the nation’s highest court.
Read more on the historic confirmation:
"Democracy as compared with other ways of life is the sole way of living which believes wholeheartedly in
the process of experience as end and as means;"--John Dewey, Creative Democracy (1939). Thx to
@AgnesCallard
for pointing me to the essay.
“It’s time for Japan to bid farewell not only to Mr. Abe but also to his nationalist rearmament agenda,” writes
@knakano1970
, a political scientist at Sophia University in Tokyo, in a guest essay.
One of the most important and impactful books in constitutionalism in over a generation. It opened an exciting new world of possibilities for constitutional studies.
Breaking News: In a major defeat, Rep. Steve King of Iowa lost his Republican primary for a 10th term. He has long made racist comments and was disciplined in 2019.
"One would not err much in thinking that the strategic problem of the "founders", pretty much everywhere, was how to construct representative government for the elites while protecting it from the poor"--
@AdamPrzeworski
in Crises of Democracy
TOMORROW at 8 A.M
Check out ABF Research Professor
@tomginsburg
in
@horizontalchile
's virtual forum on, "The Chilean Constitutional Challenge: Lessons from International Experience."
He will discuss lessons about comparing constitution-making processes.
Important new
#ClimateChange
provision in
#Tuvalu
Constitution: "The baseline coordinates...shall remain unchanged, notwithstanding any regression of the low water mark or changes in geographical features of coasts or islands, due to sea-level rise or other causes.
@ccpconstitute
A list of 100 Democracy Books. Some are classics, while others are contemporary. I really felt this was missing for new scholars. I'm hoping to add some more book lists soon. Below I am tagging authors included in the list.
@GroupDemocracy
When I see an older white male authority figure joke like this and see how the faculty and students laugh, it reminds me of how I was not seen as equal growing up in the US, and how Asians are easily written off and ridiculed. But it’s just a joke, right?
Amazing news from
#Chile
that if the constituent assembly option is chosen, it will be composed of 50% women. well done to
@pfigueroarubio
and others pushing for equality in constitution-making
Estamos FELICES porque ¡HICIMOS HISTORIA! 👏🏽🙋🏽♀️Es importante entender en qué consiste el mecanismo que asegurará una
#ConstituyenteParitaria
👀 A continuación les dejamos la gráfica de
@latercera
que lo explica:
#ParidadYa
#Constituci
ónConMujeres
The University of Chicago Forum for Free Inquiry and Expression will launch this fall, deepening the University’s longstanding commitment to these elements of its culture. Prof. Tom Ginsburg and Tony Banout will serve as the Forum's inaugural leaders.
The President of the United States has spent all morning tweeting about "critical race theory", fun! You may ask, gentle readers, what exactly is that, how can I learn more, and does it have any relevance to me? Sounds really interesting, no? It is! A few points below.... /1
Trump's speech not only attacked the Supreme Court and electoral officials of both parties, but the Republican Party. Good luck to both the GOP and the MAGA Party, may the best team win.
I decided to delete my tweet about the President's
#pardon
because of a factual error about Mr Gallagher, though it is truethat the President was a "fortunate son" who deferred military service. In any case, the
#MAGA
twitter people are really friendly & I hope to stay in touch.
Great piece by
@tarunkhaitan
: in an era in which everything has been politicized, the academy will not long last unless we get our collective house in order and take inquiry seriously.
"Website under maintenance" after Columbia Law Review Board delays piece by
@RabeaEghbariah
. seems an outrageous w autonomous law review operation as well as academic freedom.
Timely new article “Toward Nakba as a Legal Concept” by Rabea Eghbariah in Columbia Law Review seeking to “transcend existing legal limits and imagine new ways of apprehending the Palestinian condition in law…”
In "How To Lose A Constitutional Democracy," Profs. Aziz Huq &
@TomGinsburg
discuss the threats of democratic backsliding and the comparative risks our
#democracy
faces in the modern day.
So I wonder if we have something to learn from
#Kenya
and the need for fundamental constitutional reforms in the aftermath of electoral violence?
@Olez
@JTGathii
@Int_IDEA
Good piece on our approach
@UChicagoLaw
and how it differs from the competition. there is more to say about why our students--who are as smart passionate as those at Yale and Stanford--understand and create a culture of free expression
“Secession is back in style.”
And, as Profs.
@tomginsburg
of
@UChicagoLaw
and Mila Versteeg of
@UVALaw
argue, constitutions may be the cause.
Check out why here:
There is a way in which this old book of mine is very relevant right now. A powerful judiciary that protects rights can reduce the stakes of electoral loss, making the loser more willing to concede. There have been no gun-toting
#GOP
mobs out trying to overturn the
#Democracy
My latest blog reflects on the judiciary with a review of a modern classic from
@tomginsburg
, "Judicial Review in New Democracies: Constitutional Courts in Asian Cases." I reflect on the role of judicial review and the courts in democracy.
Fantastic symposium
@AJIL_Unbound
on
@tomginsburg
’s recent article.
Shirley Scott’s contribution is especially 🔥: “It was thus not necessarily the United States that was functioning as the imperial power within international law, but civil society.”