And Robbo if Shane Warne hates Waleed Aly - which I’m not certain he does - why is it racist if he hates Waleed & not racist if he hates you or me? Stop driving the race garbage for every single dispute or discussion. Soon there won’t be any discussion for fear of being tainted.
As an independent to both teams, Swans got a dream ride off umpires including the clincher late with Papley pushing Moore in back and dropping mark. Home crowd is a massive influence for umpire decisions.
Did I just hear Whiteley call the booing “foul”. His embellishment & sensationalism of minor issues is boring. Trying to be the moral arbitrator of society. He’s way above his head. Over-politically correct peanut.
If Goodwin had any dignity and character he would stay right out of any comments relating to the incident. Very poor from a club leader……100% would not have said that if they won which to me says he’s sooking.
I find it interesting how precious journo’s have immediately jumped into defence mode and challenging LB’s ability to coach. As for Caro suggesting a 6 figure fine…shows a complete lack of logic and rationale.
What on earth is all this garbage about booing at the presentation. It was evidently an awesome game with a classic finish and all media are squawking about is booing! It’s a fans right. Deal with causes and fix umpiring and the effects (booing) may subside somewhat.
Let’s get 1 thing straight! Caleb didn’t sling Max…..Max slung himself in an effort to earn a free kick for dangerous tackle but overcooked it. Daniel stood looking at him in surprise at his fake. That’s my reading.
Shouldn’t be in Security gear. Should be in AFL tracksuits. Fit. Healthy young people. Handing out memorabilia to young fans whilst keeping the peace amongst supporters. Helping elderly up aisles. Always smiling. Always helpful. Call them “Fan Aid”. Someone can sponsor them.
I’m interested to read the “god-like” references to Essendon recruiting “legend” Adrian Dodoro. I’ve witnessed first hand the stalling and destruction of most years trade weeks which usually start with an Essendon “deal” that holds up everything. Bombers renowned as worst to deal
Apologies for non-footy topic BUT….
The premier is disgusted, appalled & angry at vandals spraying her office window in Bendigo. Watch the news every night Premier and watch the completely unhinged out of control youth defacing the city, using machetes, car jacking, home
Look, seriously at the end of the day it’s just a Mickey Mouse competition…..a national pastime. It’s not that important. The real objective is funding a dozen AFL execs a million bucks a year. Only sport in the world that best performers are outstripped by execs administering
This competition is laughable. A player deliberately raises elbow and gets 1 week another jumps in the air in a desperate attempt to smother a kick and collided with kicker accidentally knocking him out and gets referred to tribunal (pathetically predictable) which will be
Can’t Shane not like Waleed Aly for other reasons? I mean after all he is immersed in Muslim countries through cricket. It really pisses me off when there is disagreement between 2 people & imbeciles immediately raise the red card & cry racist! It’s so pathetic & weak.
Matt “Bundy” Rendell one of the planets truly great people. Loyal, brave, honest, caring, considerate, great sense of humour…..an outstanding human being. So sad. Gutted. Love you Bundy❤️
More damming evidence that AFL is not a serious competition - it’s just a toy for spoilt sycophants in positions of power to meddle with & satisfy their ego’s. It’s manifestly unconscionable for administrators of game to implement ridiculous rule tests in “dead rubber” rounds
Whatley is such a disappointing person. His mindless defence & grovelling to his Geelong buddy is cringeworthy. Hocking clearly loads the gun & Smithers Whately fires the bullets. He has zero idea about the inner dynamics of AFL. So sad. Unconscionable.
Want to apologise to Michael Christian on tribunal. I’m now hearing he’s a merely a puppet for ex-Geelong man Steve Hocking who makes all decisions. Probably why Ablett (twice), Hawkins got off which has confused footy world with inconsistencies. Gut & jumper punches ok now too??
Completely understand Clarke’s decision. What a disgrace this process has been. AFL desperate attempts to be the moral compass of society instead of sticking to their knitting - football. Hope Clarko sues AFL for this process that has defamed him.
Why do umpires coach? “Don’t do anything you’ll lose the free”. Just let players play & adjudicate. Stay out of everything. No commentary, no advice, no coaching, just referee.
Interesting how we unfortunately hear about Clayton Oliver’s off-field trials and tribulations. Now part of his rehab program is to move into Captain Gawns house. I can only assume the coach had been living at Gawns as well then?🤔 Fish rots at the head. Pretty difficult putting
Be safe. Be funny - laughter is the elixir of life. If you can’t be funny, hang around funny people, if you don’t know funny people, find some, if you can’t find some, make some up, if you can’t do that just laugh once an hour at just living. Have a great Xmas AND hug your kids😘
Chris Fagan would hands down be the best coaching performance thus far. Ultra impressive what he has achieved. Super effort. Benefits of getting culture base right, team ethos, connected players & unconditional effort. Great to watch.
Bravo Bravo Dayne Beams. Extraordinarily selfless considerate, team first, honorable act to relinquish captaincy to Zorko under the difficult circumstances around his fathers passing. Great credit to you Dayne. Stay strong.
One of the most disgraceful decisions this year. FK against Howe for taking a screamer using foot to launch himself. Always legal for 150 years. AFL shit themselves about litigation & another spectacle disappears from our once great game.
This is an interesting incident to test AFL’s theory on concussion and accidental contact. One thing is certain……if it was an opponent in exactly the same incident they’d get 4-6 weeks.
Why would an umpire tell Viney to watch his legs when he gets up? Shut up umpire. If the player transgresses pay a FK. If not shut up. You are not a coach. You are there to apply the rules.
Why does Bailey Smith get suspended for 2 weeks because someone filmed him whilst every player the AFL has caught over the last 20 years gets a can of coke and a mars bar?🤔
What business over 100 years old is bankrupt after a 4 weeks with 90% of costs cut? This talks to the gross over-capitalisation & blatantly, innumerable resource overrun. If one good thing comes out of this it will be the rebuild of the infrastructure. Watch with interest. 🤔
The government’s decision has nothing to do with what Djokovic did or didn’t do….. it’s EVERYTHING to do with a perception message to Australian public like a political football for their own pathetic sake. We are now an international embarrassment on 2 fronts, Covid/Djokovic
Umpires too gutless or poorly directed. Why do they shift their interpretation as game gets closer. That was an absolute no-brainer free kick late to Pies for block/shepherd when Sheed kicked amazing goal.
I’ve officially now seen everything! Extraordinary. I was going to say the ADL have lost the plot but they actually never had it to lose! Love the way AFL seduce media sycophants to support their desired stance & hopefully sway fans. Pathetic.
Dangerous tackle is the memo to umpires this week. How stupid is this game of ours when nobody knows the rules & they change interpretation weekly? How can it be taken seriously as an elite sport?
So Tribunal leader Christian didn’t want to uphold decision and thought no case to answer but was trumped by new GM Football Laura Kane who sent it to tribunal on behalf of AFL. Christian should resign.
Why don’t the imbeciles running tribunal see the Lynch incident for what it was.....a deserved retaliation to Hurley for trying to hit his injured hand. Not one bit of reporting or reference to it. Lynch should get off and Hurley fined.
What an incredibly appropriate time to take Brownlow voting away from umpires (terribly inappropriate for a host of logical reasons) & appoint independent people assigned to every game to vote on most influential, impacting players (not just possessions & midfielders).
Can someone explain why Toby gets a fine for a head rub and hair pull and then a week for a face massage? That’s the AFL for you. Weak gutless pathetic. Let him off lightly then gets infuriated at him snubbing his nose by doing it again. This is a precious AFL message to players
Why is AFL rushing back? I just don’t get it. I understand most of population wants to see footy but surely that’s not the reasoning? Why are there preferential rules for AFL versus society, especially given most businesses won’t benefit from the restart? What am I missing? 🤔
Can someone explain how Alastair Clarkson - the doyen of coaches - is now under spotlight to move on and too old??? Insanity. Hawks should sign him for 10 years. He is only getting better as a person & coach. His performance is list/timing related.
Don’t know what’s in water @ Mt Waverley, car broke down, had a nice young guy stop & ask if he can help. Said he lived around corner & is happy to assist. Then a bloke Steve walks up with cold water bottle and 4 icypoles saying this will cool you down. Lived a few houses away👏
Sanity prevails. AFL still considering appealing against decision. So they disputed and overturned MRO decision and sent it to tribunal. Now they’re considering challenging their tribunal decision. All for the “look” as evidence against future litigation.
How long is Tennis Australia & International Tennis Federation going to put up with Tomic & Kyrgios? Don’t blame them - they’re just a reflection of a lot of youth in Australia at the moment. Self-serving, entitled, spoilt. I’d focus on the bodies that tolerate & allow behaviour.
Disgraceful. Firstly a wrong fk as Hawk fakes massively then Gunston & Mitchell standing in middle of ground talking to ump, see replay on screen and put their arms up….50m. I thought arms up lately was now acceptable?? Pick & choose. This will end in tears in a very big game
Are we not concerned that 3 All Australian key defenders, Moore, May & Maynard didn’t receive a solitary Brownlow vote between the 3 of them yet they are amongst the top echelon of value players in competition and All Australians.
Why on earth hasn’t AFL Commission approached Ed McGuire for a role on Commission. Media CEO, leadership, mainstream reporting, business acumen & success, AFL Club experience……the list is endless. Clearly the incumbents are intimidated & fearful of exposure with his talents. I
I really detest the way some players (Owies) milk free kicks and then smirk at conning gullible umpires. His first thought when tackled is always to dive forward.
This isn’t an April fools gag……..AFL have actually come out & said dissent free kick against Giants in Blues goalsquare late in game to basically devise game was………WAIT FOR IT!….CORRECT!!! 😂😂😂😂You think I’m joking. I’m deadly serious. AFL must think we’re all stoned😂😂
We either get right behind AFLW or we don’t. I’m a massive supporter of women’s footy for no other reason than it provides outlet and opportunity for women to express themselves and have fun. In 20 years it will he incredibly good. Be patient.
@Thomo_Grant
Thoughts on AFLW potential pay rise? I am staggered the men are going to give up $ for AFLW when AFLW don’t charge an entry fee to the games and TV rating are still poor.
Congratulations to AFL for selecting Sam Walsh as Mark of the Year. Courage personified. Usually seduced by athleticism & hangar which is awesome to watch but my vote is the one where angels fear to tread.
There has been zero impact on scoring since the introduction of the stupidity “stand rule” as well as the equally nonsensical protected area play on from a behind. Time to shelve both of them. The stand rule is nothing but a “painful” irrelevance that annoys fans.
I’m still shaking my head at that ridiculous umpire intervention with the Hawkins reversal - Selwood & Melcham. Umpires are lucky I’m. It in charge because that fool would never get another game. Completely inconsequential & contact instigated by Melcham. In a final it’s a sin.
Leave school @ 18 plays AFL for 12yrs then becomes an assistant coach for 5yrs then a senior coach for 5yrs & then is inevitably sacked.....what hope has he got? He knows NOTHING outside AFL & then enters real world. Like falling off a cliff edge for most. Completely unprepared
Extraordinary?! Why is everyone so amazed about something they already know??? This is insane. What’s extraordinary is the fact former players have to do the work of gutless, compromised media. In essence media are saying “Hell I wouldn’t say that!”
Extraordinary comments from Nick Riewoldt on
@SENBreakfast
- declaring drug use in the AFL "out of control" and saying players were "taking the piss" out of a policy that is too soft.
I’m gobsmacked Dil pushes a critical result-influencing decision to the side like pushing away his plate after dinner. It’s much more important than that Dil. You treat this game as though it’s a toy or plaything. You’ve single handedly trashed credibility of the people’s game
Don’t know why Teague’s manager Pickering is having a crack at Cripps saying “need more out of captain”. 1 of 2 things….untenable for coach or coach can’t manage/motivate him. Problem having a player manager in media…they are compromised. Make a choice. Media or manager.
Absolute classic example of interpretation by an over officious peanut. Many times that exact incident happens and sanity prevails. He wasn’t time wasting. Why can they pick and choose whether or not to pay a free kick for the same incident. It’s either 100% a fk or make it clear
Games are no longer being decided solely on players. I find it unconscionable that games can be so adversely affected because……..Nup that’s it, I’m not going to say it.
I cannot remember AFL having lower credibility or integrity than now. I have no idea who is advising them - Demetriou & Fitzpatrick must still be having coffee with Gil. It’s in their best interests to make these buffoons look worse than when they were in power - it’s working!!!
Why do umpires coach? Continually hear them saying “walk away”, “don’t do that in front of me”, “leave him alone”. It’s not their jurisdiction. Zip up & just referee game. Pay FK’s when necessary.
What about Stewart st 3/4 time “we’re going to take more risks this quarter.” They kick 3 goals in 5 minutes! Clear example of coaches strategy curtailing player abilities. When game is shot at 3/4 time coach says “take risks”! Laughable. 😂
Fine Toby Greene whatever you like $10K, $25K, $50K….whatever the severity of incident construed by authorities. Suspension of games should be reserved to king hits, elbows, punches, kicks, bites…..etc etc. Every other incident outside these should be a fine graded on severity
AFL drug policy is designed to protect AFL brand & minimise exposure of illicit drugs. If a player is caught but cites mental health issues it is not a strike against him. Save to say there is a shitload of “mental health” issues with AFL players.
“AFL’s game analysis team found trials of new set up in 3 VFL games resulted in 15% increase in scoring & 14% decrease in tackling”.
What sort of testing regime is that! This is inept garbage that embarrasses AFL & questions integrity. Watch 12 coaches in 18 teams rip it apart
What sort of half arsed, amateur game have we got when you can score a goal like Higgins fake handball from 50m and gets a shot on goal line. You can’t take this crap seriously.
Here’s a classic example of City Hall buffoonery. Tom Lynch says he’s going to Tigers. Shock horror! Where else would a star player go who’s starved of the holy grail - premiership?! AFL are so damn stupid it’s insane. They produce a system to equalise but it imbalances. Classic!
Be safe, be alert, care for others, be interested not just interesting, lend a helping hand, appreciate where we live (country), engage in social intercourse, communicate, connect, show affection, enjoy, live, dream & rest. ❤️👍😊
A player missing Grand Final because of a tackle that was in EVERY measure perfectly executed albeit momentum created a door opening for over zealous MRP. Pathetic. Really feel for Katie Brennan
So what was the motivation for the AFL to concoct an 8 day and 6 day run into Grand Final? They state that they want to give Richmond the best opportunity given they finished on top? When was this agreed. I concur with Ed. Rules on the run. Constructed, manipulated garbage
9fk V 19fk and as a Saints fan the umpires have definitely kept us in the game. I’ll say it again and again….umpiring has more influence on outcomes of our game than any other game on the planet.
I’m also laughing at the coaching from umpire in last quarter telling player “don’t kick it!” after a fk was paid. Let player play and pay 50m if it’s there. Stop coaching players on what to do and what not to do - just adjudicate. Since when are umpires players or coaches?
Teague sacked. Please provide the findings of this thorough internal review Carlton. Perhaps it might include questions around the people who appointed a person that inside 2 years is incapable of coaching????
I find it both inexcusable & appalling that our CEO would not only condone but support “hush money” payment with Fremantle alleged sexual harassment issue. Perhaps he has done the same thing himself or for the AFL. Maybe it’s how he thinks you solve problems? Misguided.
Firstly if AFL are serious about sending messages & brand they should’ve rubbed Hawkins our for 2 weeks minimum. How his act can be grouped with every other 1 week suspension is ludicrous. Secondly Greene either gets off with fine wk1 & fine wk2 or suspension wk1 & fine wk2 IMO.
Can you believe these f?&;wits on tv? They are trying to build a case against Devon Smith. Lingy give it up man. The world knows the tribunal only works off outcomes. If it’s incidental it’s nothing. If it drops player or stitches or comes off or stretcher it’s weeks.
I think there is ample evidence of inconsistent application of guilt. Everyone is classing it as a bump which is blatantly wrong - it was a collision and secondary to the primary aim of attempted smother. It’s akin to an injury whilst flying to spoil a mark and landing on top of
Anyone would think it’s his invention, his game & his toy or plaything. 150 years of tribal passion & he not only wants to destroy infield now he’s trying to completely shutdown fans. Pathetic