![Benjamin YH Loh Profile](https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/1410788608009654272/ONKVvZYA.jpg)
Benjamin YH Loh
@ThatBenLoh
Followers
1K
Following
3K
Media
77
Statuses
2K
Digital media ethnographer | Malaysian Studies | Media Literacy Advocate | He/Him | Cat-dad 🐱
Kuala Lumpur
Joined April 2018
After 3 years, the book that @jameschin110 and I have been working on is finally out in digital form (Official launch on March 23): New Media in the Margins: Lived Realities and Experiences from the Malaysian Peripheries under Palgrave Macmillan
3
19
56
If you're wondering what the fuss is all about with public universities banning @kuasasiswa from giving his absolutely fundamental #KelasDemokrasi, it has to do with path dependency and the nature of political machinery in this country. Here's my take on the situation:.
10
642
1K
We DID NOT cyberbully the government. We engaged in rational, good faith public debate over a major policy issue. This is NORMAL and ETHICAL behaviour that EVERY Malaysian should engage in REGULARLY and not only when it looks like we can embarrass the government.
11
464
1K
It's very simple: The Indian community just wants you, the Prime Minister, to not say the word, in whatever setting because it is rooted in colonial trauma and remains a tool for present day marginalisation and oppression. If you say it, then it means others can too.
Saya bukanlah individu yang suka bermain sentimen menghina kaum dan agama sehingga mencetuskan salah faham melibatkan mana-mana pihak. Sewaktu “Sesi Dialog Perdana Menteri bersama Ketua Pengarang serta Pengarang-Pengarang Kanan Media Elektronik, Media Cetak dan Dalam Talian”
26
307
644
The government is making some very aggressive moves at restricting internet freedoms, faster than any of it's predecessors. The justification is often linked to protecting the public safety without acknowledging it's effects on political dissent.
6
404
534
No shade on KA or OP, but M'sians believe that running a country is like running a company so a CEO is the same as a PM. So when they see weak leadership in politics, they seek good leaders from anywhere regardless of whether those skills can translate. It often can't and won't.
Why do some ppl want Khairul Aming to become a politician? Why drag someone so widely admired n non-partisan into politics? He’s already creating real change with his business n charities. Let him keep helping communities thru initiatives tht stay free of political ties.
2
180
445
The @straits_times dropped this article early this morning and I don't think Twitterjaya has picked up on it yet. There's quite a bit of problems with it and here's my take on it:
9
168
340
Jika anda tertanya2 tentang kecohan dengan IPTA2 yang melarang @kuasasiswa menjalankan #KelasDemokrasi yang boleh dikatakan sangat fundamental, ia adalah berhubungkait dengan pergantungan laluan dan unsur jentera politik di negara ini. Inilah pendapat saya tentang isu ini:.
5
209
307
And @kuasasiswa's classes are disrupting this traditional mindset. If you teach your youth to think critically about politics, how to evaluate policies and ideologies, and the the true value of their vote, this empowers a new generation of voters to think beyond party machineries.
1
155
286
No offence to OP but this is a horrible way to govern: you waste resources, only respond wtih public backlash and make the public feel on edge constantly to fight Draconian policies. The best way would be to engage in open consultation BEFORE committing to these policies.
unpopular opinion (kot): I'm okay with government that U-turns. At least ada la nampak hasil kita bising dekat socmed. compared gov dulu-dulu, bising la banyak mana pun sampai turun jalan sekalipun, bukan nak dengar.
1
171
286
Amidst the media frenzy over Mahathir's ridiculous remarks today, I'd like to give kudos to @malaymail as the only one that bothered to fact check the statement and dared to use the term "falsely" in its first sentence.
4
122
279
Happy to get this out during Pride month. Here's my oped with @LyanaKhairuddin on how the LGBT+ community of Msia is attacked with western right wing rhetoric when they have little to no support from major political parties here. Stop the discrimination.
26
118
248
If I ran a child daycare chain with thousands of families as clients, and I acknowledge that CSA happens with kids under my care with such callousness (almost like it's inevitable) my business would cease immediately. Can't believe he felt this was an appropriate response.
1
191
249
Truly dissappointing and a good reminder that just because you that did something good before, doesn't mean that goodwill is eternal. The mask can drop at any time and we as the public need to be ready to drop them like a rotten durian. CSOs and activists aren't always right.
FPP is a good step. 1. Specialist more income. Stay and serve in KKM. 2. Patient get better access to specialist level of care, fraction of cost at private. Win-win solution. Yg ckp pasal tak mampu ni cont lah treatment RM1 tu kan takde siapa cakap nak stop that service.
2
131
222
It didn't just "happen under my watch", you have literally been charged and found guilty of being involved. What a disingenuous apology since you're still not accepting the court's verdict nor admitting any wrongdoing.
“It pains me every day that 1MDB happened when I was prime minister and finance minister, and I would like to apologise unreservedly.” . Najib said in a statement read by his eldest son Datuk Nizar Najib in a press conference at the KL High Court today. 📹 Arjun Mohanakrishnan
6
203
225
Aside from the unnecessary snark, the Minister presents these "limitations" as incontrovertible features of gov, impossible to be overturned or not part of a government's ability to govern rather than just being policy decisions the gov chooses not to do. Let's take a look:🧵.
“Dude, you’re the PM. you have the power”. Bila kerajaan umum kenaikan gaji kakitangan awam, ada yang mencemuh. Kata mereka, kerajaan tidak menggunakan kuasanya untuk menaikkan gaji kakitangan swasta juga. Mereka kata:. “Dude, you’re the PM. you have the power”. Sebenarnya,
5
153
209
No other country in the world uses these terms to separate income classes for policy, so yes you literally make the rules. This all sounds like you are all just shooting in the dark and randomly throwing numbers behind the T and seeing which upsets people the least.
Anwar says the threshold may be narrowed to the T10 group or raised within T15 to include those earning RM15,000 or RM18,000 monthly. "Ini tidak! Dipertahankan pula T15 itu, sedangkan ada daripada mereka berpendapatan RM100,000 malah ada yang RM1 juta sebulan.". 🧵2.
3
99
188
My apologies for the QT, but I think we need to move away from using cyberbullying to describe "online citizen activism" that is directed at government apparatus. I know its more fun to think about it this way but this also means they can outlaw this kind of activity later.
3
102
188
I know I was duped by this excellent Onion level parody from @kuasasiswa. I could delete this and hide my shame as a media scholar and media literacy advocate. But I won't because is important recognise that mistakes happen and also the importance of satire mimicking reality.
MCMC: Post warning to ask the public to stop sharing an "insulting image". Also MCMC: Features image and ends with "Please share".
6
43
167
This right here is a perfect example of (partially) successful online activism or "ethical cyberbullying" and why the new social media licensing regulation could potentially ban this type of citizen activism. Let's take a look: 🧵.
1
102
161
This is a prime example of majority privilege and why the current gov is seen as derelict, in spite of the Madani slogan, and looks to perpetuate minority stereotypes and reinforce marginalisation. Let's take a look at the history of the "Estate Indian" and why this is so harmful.
Saya ambil maklum tentang penularan di media sosial satu tangkap layar dari aplikasi WhatsApp yang memaparkan mesej dari saya terkait keputusan @partisosialis (PSM) yang mengumumkan calon untuk bertanding di kerusi DUN Meru dalam pilihan raya negeri akan datang beserta ayat yang.
2
69
153
This raises so many issues. copyright infringement is usually a civil matter, unless its related to mass distribution (piracy), which again, the enforcement should be legal charges rather than just blocking access to the site. Where is the due process for any of this?.
I checked with @MCMC_RASMI - there was a request by @KPDN_HQ made directly to ISPs in June and copied to MCMC, for copyright violation. As this block request originated from KPDN, will have to check with them on this.
2
79
152
I know this is probably a cytro, but let's use this as a teaching moment. It's important to challenge these problematic sentiments. This tweet is comprised of the typical gaslighting arguments often used to dismiss political education in universities, so let's unpack it:.
@ThatBenLoh @kuasasiswa I think generally ppl/parents are ok if someone wants to "teach democracy", but do it outside the campus pls. A youtube video could easily reach a much larger audience, can be played back repeatedly & more effective. No political motive? That's bull!! 🤣.
3
88
140
Due to strong urging from @MuniraMustaffa and some questionable practices over terror reporting last week, here's a thread on a couple of issues that took place last week and some recommendations for the media to do better in the future 🧵.
2
77
132
Aside from confusing the two Bornean states, they also shrink their size so that it's much smaller in comparison to the peninsular. These kinds of micro aggressions against East Malaysians needs to be called out and not taken lightly as "honest" mistakes.
National carmaker Perusahaan Otomobil Nasional Sdn Bhd (Proton) has apologised for mislabelling Sabah and Sarawak during a recent presentation at an event. "We deeply regret this mistake and understand the sensitivities it has stirred among our fellow Malaysians," it said. 🧵1
1
64
113
"if it is proven that this Government is using this regime to silence legitimate dissent, I will NOT HESITATE to speak out and do all in my power to stop it.". As you should, but you have the opportunity to fix it NOW before it starts, so why wait to voice out your concerns?.
I have fought for online freedom of expression for more than a decade. And I will continue to do so as evidenced in my Kamar Khas speech recently when I urged the government to amend S233 of the CMA. But I am in support of this move to licence social media platforms. There is.
5
61
111
Oh, NOW you're worried about the safety of the whistleblower, when they were literally highlighting that when asking for gov protections. The fact that we have a Whistleblowers Protection Act but you almost never hear of anyone actually using it should tell you enough
0
87
110
Alright, this post is obviously making the numbers (for problematic reasons), so I'd just like to highlight what transpired here. @malaysiakini, did in fact reach out to me to get my consent to use my tweets for an article of theirs (which they have done many times before) 🧵.
Academic Benjamin YH Loh said the recent online activity in which netizens highlighted the presence of Olympic Council of Malaysia (OCM) president Norza Zakaria’s family at the Paris Olympics was an example of “ethical cyberbullying”. Loh, a senior lecturer in media and
1
39
108
Sorry for the Qt, since the original is gone, but why do Malaysians assume that fair wage ratios (to reduce the disparity between the lowest and highest earners in a company) somehow don't apply to small businesses?.
If your business earns around 25k/month, why would you hire 5 staff at the first place?. Because you yourself don't wanna put the work in your own business?. That's just a bad business decision.
3
47
104
Good call finally, but given that this is like the third time this year where the government has tried to bulldoze policy without public input and given a sound beating, you guys should just include public engagement for all policy decisions as standard practice.
Isu jenayah dalam talian termasuk akses ke laman-laman web perjudian, persundalan, pornografi dan seumpamanya amat membimbangkan dan memerlukan usaha penyelesaian yang menyeluruh. Kerajaan tidak akan berkompromi dalam hal ini, demi menjamin keselamatan dalam talian buat rakyat.
1
45
101
Aside from the obvious patriarchal bias to this (also coinciding with IWD is a hell of a choice), this is a highly regressive move which is in stark contrast to the care economy model (where care work is recognised as labour) that everyone else is adopting.
1. Putrajaya will consider shorter working hours for women employees to enable them better care for their families, said PM Anwar Ibrahim. “Kalau bekerja 4 jam, mengikut kadar upah mungkin kurang, tetapi kita boleh manfaatkan wanita yang merasa terdesak untuk jaga anak-anak.”
3
45
94
We, as Malaysians, have to endure huge invasions of privacy (into our phones primarily) with our many laws so extending this to social media platforms means that we pretty much will no longer have the option to be anonymous online anymore.
Putrajaya is considering a legal amendment that will compel social media platform providers into revealing data about their users upon police request. Deputy Communications Minister Teo Nie Ching says the ministry plans to table a bill next month to amend the Communications and
1
67
91
MPs are responsible to their voters and not personal conscience, ya. Your personal demons don't vote for you and we never know if these demons love or hate your voters either.
Our conscience is crystal clear. @syahredzan.
0
39
85
Why are you asking MPs to police random children and ignore their parents? What kind of advocacy is this? We don't need to add "helicopter parent" to the list of duties for MPs. As the communications minister, you can literally create policy campaigns that are aimed at parents.
Menteri Komunikasi, Fahmi Fadzil minta bantuan semua Ahli Parlimen yang bertemu dengan kanak-kanak bawah 13 tahun untuk memastikan mereka tidak membuka akaun media sosial. Katanya lagi, platform ini malangnya culas buat pengesahan umur pemilik akaun. #SisiTVParlimen #DewanRakyat
2
61
89
Our political leaders can't stop copying American rhetoric and now they're acting like our police are separate from federal authorities (they are not). This crisis of accountability is endemic across all major political parties and becomes 10 times worse when they get into power.
2
45
89
"mengkritik secara etika" (criticising ethically). Similar to "respectability politics", politeness and decorum are used as excuses to restrict and shut down valid criticisms and resistance against government ignoring that these are often necessary to draw attention to issues.
@kuasasiswa Ada perbezaan satira antara Zunar, Dato’ Lat, Senyum Kambing, Rossem dan kau @kuasasiswa. Satira Zunar, Dato’ Lat, Senyum Kambing, Rossem, mereka mengkritik secara beretika dan ini menunjukkan mentaliti mereka ini bersih dan dalam persekitaran pemikiran yang baik walaupun
1
62
87
Malaysia dropped quite a bit in the World Press Freedom Index and of course the gov is doing damage control as the opposition leverages it to shame them. Typical yearly song and dance that is quite normal. But, this particular statement is quite worrying and worth unpacking 🧵
2
61
87
I think you mean the liberalisation of healthcare but you won't call it that because they want to continue keeping Msians in the dark about creeping neoliberalism that's eroding our public services and demonise liberal values as the perpetual bogeyman to scare the conservatives.
The "uberization of healthcare" is a concept that uses modern innovative ideas and technologies to improve the healthcare sector. These technologies include: robotics, artificial intelligence, drones, sensing technologies, computer vision, and audio analytics. The term
1
85
88
It's disingenuous for the gov to promote PADU using this carrot approach when in reality it's a stick as you're threatening the loss of benefits for not adhering. There's still no clear direct benefit to the public to use PADU other than making it easier for the gov to track you.
Individu yang layak mendapat bantuan kerajaan tetapi tidak mengemas kini data dalam Pangkalan Data Utama (PADU) sehingga akhir bulan ini berisiko tercicir daripada pusingan pertama penentuan kelayakan bantuan selepas program subsidi bersasar dilaksanakan. Menteri Ekonomi Rafizi
3
51
87
Test what exactly? The current environment has heavily delegitimized media and propped up untrained and unethical influencers and clout chasers as worthy equivalents. If you really believe that then just say it rather than beat around the bush like this to seem neutral.
There are several videos and photos of a fire at Midvalley Megamall area being shared online now. Social media reporting faster than news outlet reporting. It's a good test to see the accuracy of the reports compared to traditional media reporting.
1
40
84
Additionally, if poor people use more healthcare, it's because they are in more vulnerable positions that exposes them to more health risks due to food, housing and income insecurity, which in turn increases stress and higher likelihood of getting ill.
@ZulaikhaZuren @barathiSelvam10 Kerajaan bukannya tak bijak nak handle golongan b40. Dah aplikasi subsidi bersasarkan untuk minyak. Bolehla aplikasi benda yg sama utk healthcare. Bukan takde solution pun. Mentaliti tu kena tukar. Free healthcare is not sustainable. Its a hard truth.
1
51
75
The worst part about this "announcement" is the implication that this is a standard security practice that doesn't warrant an actual explanation (it isn't). Also, this seems geared towards rich folks who change phones yearly and thus the registration is expected and not a burden.
Malaysians must renew their MyDigital ID annually, as the digital certificate expires one year after registration, with a 90-day renewal window after expiry. Deleting the MyDigital ID app invalidates the certificate, requiring cancellation at a kiosk and re-registration,
1
54
76
This new plan, while not the first attempt to regulate free speech on the Internet, is certainly a return to a more authoritarian and paternalistic approach by the Malaysian government. A clear return to authoritarianism in part due to the reduced effectiveness of cytros. 🧵.
According to The Straits Times, Malaysia is reportedly in the final stages of implementing licensing for social media platforms. The move, aimed at imposing a content code that includes regulations on political content, has allegedly been approved by the cabinet. 🧵1
1
63
74
The last time a major Islamic cult made headlines here was Sky Kingdom and it was crushed so swiftly despite being small. At the scale and integration of GISB into our social fabric, this is going to impact almost every part of Msian society and the fallout is going to last years.
Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Religious Affairs) Mohd Na’im Mokhtar said there have been issues determining the lineage of the children rescued from charity homes recently. He said the main issue was that the National Registration Department (JPN) could not
1
52
73
As horrible as this is, it's the perfect case study of whether our proposed anti-cyberbullying laws would actually work. So, let's take a deep dive into it. 🧵.
look at how Malaysians are behaving Shinji Nakano’s instagram profile. some are outwardly racist, insulting, and stupid. some even dragged his mother, some insulted his eyes, a lot of Malaysians were name calling him with a bunch of insulting names. Shame on you, Malaysians.
1
27
69
Hey @fmtoday, are you guys seriously drip-releasing segments of your PM interview like its content? It's been 3 days since the first segment and we're getting one question each day, to spread out the engagement, where the common way is to just release the whole interview at least.
Malaysia’s federalised system of government here to stay, says Anwar. #FMTExclusive #FMTNews #FMTEng
3
19
64
I'd like to know who in government has made it standard practice for the last year or so to rollout new Draconian features with hyper short timelines and no obvious stress testing done beforehand. Shorter timelines don't mean less time to complain but just means more intense ones.
Starting October 10, Malaysians without a MyDigital ID can no longer log in to the MyJPJ app as it will now require a single login via MyDigital ID. JPJ has urged all users to register through the app to prevent any login issues. 🧵1
1
48
62
This government somehow believes that it absolves them of the responsibility of their policies if they mention "stakeholder engagement". They never address the actual criticisms raised by stakeholders in public and think they can get away with "keeping it behind closed doors".
1. Putrajaya has given the green light on the proposed amendments to the Federal Constitution related to citizenship. “The ministry will continue to engage stakeholders regarding the amendment," says Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution.
0
54
62
As long as this code is used to determine who gets media passes, then it remains a form of state control over media. Just because it's an (unnecessary) "update" of an old practice, doesn't mean you can pretend that it isn't "new" because state control is still present.
Selepas saya lancarkan Kod Etika Kewartawanan pagi tadi, ada pihak yang timbulkan persoalan kenapa Kerajaan cuba kawal media. Ini langsung tak tepat. Kod Etika ni dah wujud sejak tahun 1989. Hari ini kita cuma tambah baik dan rakan media turut serta dalam perbincangan tersebut.
3
46
61
Hey, we're getting even more regressive media restrictions and still no media council in sight. Obviously this push to regulate online media seems to be coming when cytros are failing badly so rather than innovate new political Comms, go back to 40 year old practices instead.
So, according to press groups, there are rumours of online media licensing, through an amendment of the printing presses and publications act - courtesy of Anwar's gomen. "Surprise, surprise".
0
54
56
Since the Malaysian government is still exempt from the PDPA (in spite of the recent amendments), this would literally be the world's first modern social media that would not be data regulated. Congratulations on another world first if this goes through.
The government may develop a social media app specifically for Malaysians, The Edge reports. Communications Minister Fahmi Fadzil said this is because some social media appl providers are profiting off Malaysians but fail to ensure user safety. 🧵1.
1
43
59
Do not confuse media with cytros. Attacks from media are in the open and are part of public discourse. To counter these narratives, engage with them directly. Cytros have destroyed trust in the our digital spaces, calling for more deepens this communications arms race.
Good morning Malaysia. The attacks have begun. Don't think we are too good not to respond. I expect a cytro team established ASAP @fahmi_fadzil. For those not familiar, this portal is owned by Azmin. Most bursa stocks went up, see how this is framed? Optics. Narrative.
1
34
55