Let's do the *for every 10 likes, I will ask ChatGPT* thingy for GCbacklog
#JustForFun
Indian man in
#greencardbacklog
For every 10 likes, I will ask ChatGPT to make him more worried (given the lack of solution from Congress)
So
@USCIS
wants to keep
#H1B
*tied to employer* for years/decades and keep paying exorbitant renewal fees every 1-3 years, so that they can provide *work-anywhere* EADs to those crossing the border illegally to seek asylum.
Did I get that right?
Not a single person born in India, approved for EB2 (advanced degree category) after 5/1/2010, has received greencard yet. Thats ~11 years!
Meanwhile ~10 million people have received their greencards.
If this is not Indian Exclusion Act, then what is?
#StopAsianhate
#HR1044
#EAGLEAct
is daily callers's bill.
The real people (unlike bots & trolls from Iran) you see here CALL DAILY their Congress Reps to pass the bill.
Maybe
@PabloReports
meant that 🤣
Last several weeks of
#EAGLEAct
was a good eye-opener.
We not only have to be guarded against extreme right, anti-immigrants, nativists, but also the ultra liberal, woke progressives.
We not only have to counter lies & propaganda from Neil Munro, but also from Pablo Manriquez.
If .
@USCISDirector
is *really* struggling with resources to adjudicate petitions (I765, I140, I485), here's an idea - allow folks on
#H4EAD
who have been forced to be unemployed by .
@USCIS
itself, for adjudicating petitions.
You already take our money. Take our labor too 😂
An Indian doctor told me, she has been waiting 10 years to get
#greencard
but
@AILANational
crooks are lobbying to send her to back of the queue, saying they have to let rest of world get their greencards first.
Now, everyone knows that its primarily Iranian students who are opposing
#EAGLEAct
These are folks who have barely begun their education in the US, driving a campaign to deny greencards to Indians (& Chinese) who have been living & contributing to the US economy for 10+ years.
Starting year
#12
on
#H1B
while stuck in
#GCbacklog
due to country of birth discrimination in US employment based immigration.
In the meantime, ~12 million people have become permanent residents in the US.
I am a legal immigrant who came to the US as a grad student.
Graduated with 4.0 gpa, research papers. I work for a Fortune 50 tech company. I am paid well and have filed 10+ patents.
I dont have a greencard STILL even after 15 years in the US.
Reason: Per-country caps in
Played tennis with my friend Matija Pecotic today, he coached my sons. Former top 200 in the world. Concert pianist. Does a Rubik’s Cube in less than 30 seconds. Real estate investor at age 30. Played
#1
on Princeton’s tennis team, then went to HBS. Been in the U.S. for 15 years
This is the difference.
#S386
supporters are real people suffering. They will weather the rain & storm to seek justice & fairness.
Those opposing
#S386
are mere twitter sock puppets with no skin in the game. .
@SenatorDurbin
sides with them to block
#GreenCardEquality
bill
@AILANational
: We are Neutral on per-country bill as long as Scott amendment in
#HR1044
are removed 😇😇
#HR3648
= Scott amendment removed ❌️
AILA = Never mind, we still oppose
#EAGLEAct
😭
@PabloReports
is this worth a story in hypocrisy?
Super excited to receive my 6th
#H1B
renewal/amendment approval. Now I can continue to pay
@USCIS
to keep me in
#GreencardBacklog
(10+ years, but who's counting?) so that they can expedite open work permit EADs for those who recently crossed the border.
The key message out of USCIS I-485 data is not that they can't process the backlogged EB I-485s due to COVID. They can, they have processed most of the FB I-485s & choose to waste the EB GCs.
Prioritization & intention, comes from one place --> Biden/Harris admin .
@WhiteHouse
The great civil rights icon, late
@repjohnlewis
has voted YES to remove discriminatory country caps in last congress
#HR1044
@RepYvetteClarke
should issue an statement saying Hon Rep Lewis was wrong to support removing segregation.
I believe we can do better, and I believe we MUST do better. The
#EagleAct
is simply not the reform we've long hoped for, nor is it the change to our immigration systems we've long needed.
And that is precisely why I've opposed it, today.
Now imagine someone else just came in, but are checked-in promptly only because they were born in Maine.
If you protest, guard says if they check you in, you would be "jumping the line" & it would be unfair to the family from Maine.
So you must keep waiting.
#HR3648
Real people impacted by discriminatory per-country caps, who have been living & contributing to their communities for 10+ years.
#EagleAct
Not bots & trolls, from Iran, Istanbul & Slovenia.
@RepYvetteClarke
Shameful for you to support segregation on nat origin.
No reason two identically qualified immigrants should have disparate outcomes, purely based on where one was born.
Your opposition to equality lays bare your lack of confidence of any greencard increase in next 11 years.
So glad to see the reporting by
@PabloReports
being cited by so many now, including name brand orgs. Pablo stumbled upon
#GCbacklog
last year and has never looked back since.
Grateful for his committment to keep affected immigrants front & center.
Those who have privilege & right to vote, please vote!
I am a legal immigrant stuck in a lesser known immigration limbo. I came to US 11+ yrs back. Atleast 4-5 million people who came after me to US, are naturalized citizens now.
I am not, because of where I was born.
#S386
If Indian-Americans (US citizens) join forces with Indian-origin immigrants in
#greencardbacklog
to advocate for removal of per-country caps, it would make atleast an order of magnitude of difference in terms of impact & significantly improve chance of success.
There is ABSOLUTELY NO need to have someone be on
#H1B
visa after 6 years (which is max validity of H1B, but is circumvented via AC21 to allow infinite renewals)
If someone is already sponsored & approved for an employment based greencard, they have met all the criteria
If
#HR3648
#EAGLEAct
opponents want:
1. More greencards -> contact
@USCISDirector
, she has a stash
2. Diversity -> apply for
#DVLottery
3. Wage level
#H1B
reforms -> contact
@DickDurbin
, he has a bill in every congress
4. Segregation based on country of birth -> shame on you
So proud of the folks who turned up. The only way to create change is to be part of it. The fight is still ON.
Don't get distracted by who says what about bill "draft" - don't let your guard down. It's not done until it becomes law.
.
@SenSchumer
don't let us down.
#HR3648
So glad (& pleasantly surprised, to be honest) to see a lot of
#GCbacklog
folks who recently got their
#greencard
stay in the fight to remove discriminatory per-country caps.
May the tribe grow!
@RepYvetteClarke
@RepYvetteClarke
please have some SHAME and stop posting tone deaf tweets about fairness, equality etc. after actively KILLING
#EAGLEAct
in last congress that aimed to bring fairness & equality to employment immigration.
Anyone who talks about "cheaper foreign labor" because their heart cries for the "american people" should be questioned about their stand on $15 minimum wage.
cc: .
@ellengilmer
.
@PabloReports
New - Senate parl ruling on immigration that appears to close the door on including a pathway to green cards in the reconciliation bill. Key line: “Changing the law to clear the way to LPR status is tremendous and enduring policy change that dwarfs its budgetary impact.”
We should STOP saying that the greencard backlog for skilled legal immigrants from India is 150 yrs or 100yrs or 70yrs or whatever. No one lives that long.
We should rather talk about the defacto BAN on skilled legal immigrants from India to EVER become Americans.
#S386
.
@SenatorMenendez
remember few months ago you helped Ashu get back to US after he was stuck in India due to travel ban? Don't let that be just a photo-op.
You have the opportunity to provide him & million others like him, lasting relief. Include provisions 60002-4 in Senate bill
"Canada’s new program to entice H-1B visa holders to the country attracted so many applications that the 10,000 limit was reached in less than 48 hours...a warning sign to U.S. policymakers."
Does
#ImmigrationTwitter
think its hypocritical or unfair that pathway for citizenship in
#USCAct2021
is based on "undocumented" status? Ofcourse, they deserve relief, but why not give the exact same pathway to "documented" folks who are in US for years on temp visas like
#H1B
?
Note - Supreme Court did not **require**
@Harvard
to increase the number of students admitted, as a "pre-condition" to their decision ending race-based admissions.
Reminder -
@SenatorDurbin
wanted more greencards as precondition to removing country of birth based immigration.
@RepMariaSalazar
"We are a nation of laws"
Yet your bill has nothing for those who followed those "laws"?
Talking about the massive
#GCbacklog
due to arbitrary 7% country-cap on EB GCs. 1 million folks are living in US on temp visas (like H1B) contributing to the economy & community. Nothing?
In 2021 & 2022,
@USCIS
will waste close to 200,000
#greencards
, simply because
@USCISDirector
can't get her act together.
200,000 greencards which will get lost forever & any attempt in future to "recapture" them will just be virtue signaling by people like
@SenatorDurbin
Off late,
@PabloReports
has been providing opinion on things even when evidence is clear and infront of him, signal boosting lies etc. His main interest seems to be gotcha against IV, rather than objective reporting on
#EAGLEAct
.
I am truly sad by this turn of events.
@PabloReports
@SpeakSamuel
For the last part, I can only say, that being part of any org is a choice. A reason, why I am not part of IV.
However, I can also be detached & observe/comment on things impartially.
It's been 2+ months since
@RepYvetteClarke
opposed & killed a bill that removed national origin discrimination (
#EAGLEAct
) under the pretext that "we MUST do better"
She should be questioned every day on what has she done *better* about in the past 2+ months.
I believe we can do better, and I believe we MUST do better. The
#EagleAct
is simply not the reform we've long hoped for, nor is it the change to our immigration systems we've long needed.
And that is precisely why I've opposed it, today.
After
#HR3648
#EAGLEAct
passes, it will take 11 years (roughly 3 Presidential terms) to completely eliminate per-country rac!st caps.
**11 more years**. Let that sink in.
Yet
@SenatorDurbin
is hell bent to not let it pass.
#DurbinIsRacist
.
@verified
Recommend verified badge (blue tick) for .
@PabloReports
for his stellar, and honest reporting on the ongoing immigration negotiations for budget recon bill & for relaying accurate info to the masses.
Their parents greencards are *NOT* bogged down in bureaucracy
Their parents greencards are held up for 50+ years, so that people born elsewhere (other than India) can get preferential treatment to get greencards in an expedited manner.
You know that, dont you
@SenAlexPadilla
?
@JajaLiao
Not H1B, but employment based greencards are capped by country of birth. But H1B is the main feeder to the employment greencard program.
Result is million of people are stuck in H1B status, while others born else where become citizens.
Opponents talk about "zero" sum
#EAGLEAct
in terms greencards, to hide their "zero" confidence of increasing greencards even in next 11 years (EAGLE transition period).
If they had any confidence at all, EAGLE would not be an issue.
They want to keep Indians indentured forever.
#HR1044
triples the fines for H-1B LCA violations. Fines increase from $1,000 to $3,000 for non-willful violations, from $5,000 to $15,000 for willful violations, from $35,000 to $100,000 for displacement of U.S. workers.
So why not
#PassHR1044
?
Of everyone opposing
#EAGLEAct
, hypocrisy from Iranians stands out
Iranians are themselves affected by discrimination in many forms (national origin, religious, gender), yet conveniently turn other way when it comes to US immigration, to preserve fast track access to greencards
A greencard is not just about freedom to work. At the fundamental level, it's about instilling sense of belonging to the place, where one has often spent significant number of years. To discriminate based on national origin & deprive one from this sense of permanence is immoral.
President Biden often says, “family is the beginning, the middle, and the end.”
By taking bold action to keep mixed-status American families together, he has honored that conviction and given these families hope.
Important & true.
RoW didnt advocate for BBB, or COMPETES, or NDAA or anything. They only oppose
#greencardequality
Something that immigration pundits & bystanding commentators completely ignore as they opine on winners & losers in
#EAGLEAct
@PabloReports
@SalilKulkarniMD
@BaldwinSpeaks
Strange. I'd say RoW hasn't done anything to gain backlog's trust. They have advocated/lobbied for zero bills to inc GC. Just coordinate attacks when the cap elimination bill comes. Hell, they haven't shed a single tear when a doc dreamer needs to self-deport.
Absolutely no reason to treat an Iranian engineer worth more than an German one, or Irish doctor worth more than an Indian one, or Russian scientist worth more than a Nigerian one, in SKILL BASED immigration.
Same skills, Same qualifications, Same outcomes.
#PassHR1044
#S386
History lesson
In 2005, Deficit Reduction Act passed Senate in
#Reconciliation
. It had provisions to recapture EB GCs, exempt EB dependents from limits & early AoS. These provisions were stripped in house version, that ultimately passed & became law.
**STAY GUARD**
#GCbacklog
My kid is learning the pledge of allegiance at pre-school and I am helping him remember it & recite it, and am emotionally confused.
#GCbacklog
#greencardbacklog
This September marks the completion of 14 years in the US - a pathway that has run through some of the best
@USCIS
"If you have the right combination of skills, education, and/or work experience, you may be able to live and work permanently in the United States by seeking an employment-based immigrant visa"
Fact Check: FALSE
Corrected version 👇
If you **were born in any country other than
Gentle Reminder.
Do not pay attention to visa spillover distractions. Let that play out.
Eyes on the money - equality.
Hold .
@SenatorDurbin
accountable for his lies on Senate floor about bill
#S386
In the US, you can get a PhD from .
@Stanford
& go on to become CTO/CEO, yet you can't be a citizen just due to where you were born.
.
@SenatorDurbin
blocks discrimimatory country caps removal & .
@SenatorMenendez
dehumanizes those in
#GCbacklog
as serving "business interests"
It is a travesty that roughly 320,000 additional employment greencards available in last 3 years (due to
#COVID19
spillover) are *still* allocated by applying per-country caps.
Double whammy for those already caught in
#GCbacklog
due to national origin discrimination.
#HR1535
2008: Simple bill removes country caps in employment immigration
2020: Bill includes demands from ROW - 10 year transition, no harm, nurse/PT quota, H1B reforms, I-140 EAD, caps on H1B to get GCs.
ROW still does not want equality for India born immigrants & oppose
#HR1044
The form I-140 for employment based
#immigration
is for a WORKER, and *not* for a COUNTRY.
So, if its for an individual worker, who is seeking employment and/or has a job offer in the US, what is more important?
🚫 Where the worker was born
✔️ What are the worker' skills
How cute.
There are 1 million people in
#GCbacklog
living & working legally in this country for 10-15 years, yet they are sidelined for imaginary future immigrants, by killing bipartisan
#EAGLEAct
but yeah lets talk about dignity of "our immigrant neighbors"
I am shocked that anyone could be against ending segregation based on race/national origin. Denying anyone equal opportunity, merely because of where they were born is a disgrace.
#EagleAct
I am shocked (but not surprised) that anyone could vote against citizenship for our brave service members. These courageous individuals risked their lives to defend our country, and they deserve our gratitude and support. Denying them the opportunity of citizenship is a disgrace.
Those who say
#HR3648
#EAGLEact
will be unfair to others/ROW future immigrants, while completely ignoring that the current system is & has been unfair, dehumanizing & completely disastrous for those born in India, is all you need to know about them.
Probably the only good thing that has happened (or will) in 117th congress for immigrants is that no matter what immigrants group/type one belongs to, folks have woken up to the realities of the Democratic party & especially the self annointed immigration stalwart
@SenatorDurbin
.
@SenatorDurbin
After 38 years in politics, it's time to think of legacy, not votes.
Do the right thing & use power vested in you as chair of .
@JudiciaryDems
& whip of .
@SenateDems
to bring genuine relief to all immigrants, who have high hopes from budget reconciliation bill.
Heartening to see several Indian-origin immigrants (in
#GCbacklog
& those who have successfully crossed over the line) highlight the inherent challenges faced by India-born immigrants in employment greencard categories, thanks to the thread from
@ankurg90
1/n
If ~2yrs ago,
@RepZoeLofgren
had acted swiftly to pass
#HR1044
1. Bill provisions would have come alive only now i.e Oct 1, 2022 --> No impact to RoW for their extra greencards
#Covid
2. Anyone with 2+ years old PD would have got EAD/AP --> certainty for laid off
#H1B
workers
Bill
#HR6542
removes per-country caps for employment based immigration. Hope
@elonmusk
&
@garrytan
can advocate and push for passage.
Previous iterations have passed house & senate with overwhelming bipartisan votes, but the bill gets mired in politics each time.
My spouse is "essential" enough to receive
#COVID19
vaccine, but not as much to get consideration from the immigration bill for "essential workers" & has to rely on band-aids like
#H4EAD
to serve the community.
Q - Why?
A - Legal immigrant.
Under the same EB3 program, due to national origin discrimination, an Iranian dishwasher can get
#greencard
, but not an Indian born.
US
#immigration
is amazing 👇
While folks earning median $100,000+ are in EB2/EB3
#greencardbacklog
because
@RepYvetteClarke
wants *diversity*
Why is there a per-country cap (or any cap for that matter) for *national interest waiver* applicants in employment category?
What *national interest* does it serve to treat a doctor/engineer/scientist born in India different than one born in Ireland?
Why is ROW against new
#S386
?
With new language, RoW can:
- Stay in US & work on EAD until backlog clears
- No need to rely on H1B lottery, since EAD available if I-140 approved or pending >270 days
- Can travel in & out using AP
- Kids protected from age out
Lol, this guy is hailed as one of "immigration champions" 😂 And he was categorically against any relief to Indians in
#GCbacklog
during the
#BBB
negotiations.
Karma is a .....
BREAKING: United States Sen. Bob Menendez, D-N.J., has been indicted by a federal grand jury in New York.
The investigation focused on a luxury car, gold bars and an apartment allegedly received by Menendez and his wife.
The latest:
.
@SenatorDurbin
If you really cared about immigrants and making the system FAIR for all irrespective of where they were born, you could re-allocate ALL the FB to EB spill over in 2020/2021 to ROW.
The fixes are not rocket science.
It does need a clear conscience.
#S386
One can
✔️ get degrees
✔️ upskill themselves
✔️ earn higher wages
✔️ get awards & accolades
One can NOT
❌️ change where they were born
This is why
#EAGLEAct
#HR3648
must be passed!
The new
#S386
language has 9 years transition vs 3 years earlier. Why isn't there a single tweet to appreciate that, from those who oppose S386? Because those who oppose, are not looking for a solution, unfortunately. Status quo works for them.
🚨 Please call .
@SenatorDurbin
🚨
HR5921 [1st per-country bill]
✔️ Remove cap in EB & 15% in FB
❌️ No transition, no nothing
#HR3648
✔️ Remove cap in EB & 15% in FB
✔️ 11 yrs transition
✔️ EAD/AP in transition
✔️ New arrivals & nurses carveout
✔️ H1B reforms
If this does not satisfy opponents, nothing will.
Hello country cap removal bill - not only it's widely bipartisan, it has actually passed house several times with 350+ votes & has also passed the Senate previously with 100 votes (UC)
If
@TheDemocrats
were serious about immigration, it would take 1 day to pass
#EAGLEAct
#HR3648
Not every non-Indian EB immigrant is a PhD.
Not every Indian EB immigrant is an IT worker.
As long as two people qualify under same EB criteria, they should be treated equally.
#PassHR1044
If one has issue with EB classification, its a topic for another bill.
Why should people from different nationalities have different wait times for greencard, for the same qualifications?
@AILANational
asking for 1 million friends stuck in
#GCbacklog
Why should
@USCIS
Service Centers have different processing times for the same applications?
@UrJaddou
asking for a couple thousand friends stuck in Texas….let’s work together and fix this.
#GCbacklog
folks, born in India,are ready to begin citizenship journey & start assimilating into american society *after* 150 years.
Thanks in part to
@USCISDirector
prioritizing RoW applicants, after wasting 70,000 greencards.
Are you ready to begin your citizenship journey, or are you preparing for your naturalization interview and test?
Watch episode 1 of our new Naturalization Interview and Test video series to learn more about what to expect:
When opponents of
#EAGLEAct
claim that it *blocks* others from getting
#greencards
, it couldn't be farther from the truth.
No one is purged from the line, at the end of FY. If they were, then there won't be
#GCbacklog
. One just needs to wait their turn, just like any other line.
Its not really a surprise to anyone.
60-80% of STEM graduate students in US universities are international students (mainly Indian, Chinese), but have no pathway to stay & work long term in the US due to 👇
🚫 H1B visa is a stupid lottery (~15% chance) & tied to employer
🚫
The semiconductor industry warns that there won’t be enough engineers, computer scientists and technicians in the US to support a rapid expansion this decade via
@technology
@VivekGRamaswamy
Care to explain what you mean by *gutting* the
#H1B
system?
If your intent is to completely move the current H1B system from a lottery based to a points based (based on skills, education, wages), that's actually great! This is what even the high skilled immigrants stuck in
Apoorva, born in India, immigrated to US as a 4 year old kid.
She should become the poster child for
#documented
dreamers
@ImproveTheDream
& help highlight the unnecessary cruelty facing those, whose lives are upended even after following the law.
@USCIS
In the spirit of transparency, you should be publishing weekly update on how many I-485s have been approved and how many GCs are still at risk to go waste.
@mayemusk
@elonmusk
Maye, I am a legal immigrant who came to the US as a grad student.
Graduated with 4.0 gpa, research papers. I work for a F50 tech company, paid well, have filed 10+ patents.
I dont have a greencard STILL even after 15 years in the US.
Reason: Per-country caps in employment
#EAGLEAct
#HR3648
is exceedingly bipartisan with almost guaranteed chance of success AND provides talking point to both
@SenateDems
&
@SenateGOP
for the fast approaching midterms.
D -->
#Gcbacklog
, age out, family separation
R --> merit based, no immigration increase