Yeah, see this is why any Rowling-led remake of the book series is going to fail utterly. Because popular as the books were, so much of what we remember from the franchise is colored by the adaptations which featured so many of Britain's greatest living actors in the roles.
prisoner of azkaban is probably the best harry potter movie. getting to see gary oldman, alan rickman, david thewlis and timothy spall acting their asses off together here was legendary
Jonathan Glazer’s “Jewishness” is probably just going to a Jewish deli once a month. Nothing but something he can wear as a costume. Go fuck yourself with refutations.
Prisoner of Azkaban is the only film of the series that comes close to true greatness, but even the worst of the series is bolstered by a great cast and Steve Klove's screenwriting.
@_WOMBATMAN_
Honestly, I almost want a new series to go forward and fail so that everyone sees how much those actors were vital to the public perception of the characters.
@awilderthing
@ganglads_
I feel like a lot of age gap rhetoric ends up being really ableist, because it assumes that everyone is at the same place in life at the same age and if you're disabled or ill you know that that's very much untrue.
There are still definitely going to be men getting off on this; it's just that part of being attracted to women means at a certain point you've got to accept that you're going to be horny to something a man might also be turned on by.
"Love Lies Bleeding sexualizes lesbians for the male gaze" there is an intimate scene where Kristen Stewart gives her bodybuilder girlfriend a testosterone injection. I don't think straight men could even comprehend the sex in this film, it was not made for them
@bitterkarella
The justification in the book is that he "fell in with the wrong crowd", which is a sketchy enough defense when you're dealing with petty criminals who join neo-Nazi gangs. It doesn't make much sense when you're making a direct analogue to the Nazis.
@T_L_Seigler
@Spearhafoc_
Yeah, but even if you know nothing about Poe's life, it's pretty obvious that The Raven is not a poem about really liking ravens.
@CaramelKaiteki
Honestly a lot of that was a good thing. Like imagine if they’d actually adapted the SPEW plotline, where the conclusion we’re supposed to come to is “it’s stupid to try to free the slaves; just be a benevolent master like Harry”.
@KMRTMoose
@Brizzletrips
Well they tried banning it but all that really did was give organized crime a new venue to make money and lead to the creation of the FBI. You can't really adequately tackle addiction as long as people are going to make money off of it.
I appreciate that the media is finally covering what happened to Amber Heard but it still feels like too little too late. I'm sick of yet another discussion about how society has failed women; if the media had actually done their job properly, things might have been different.
@cursed_monk
Yeah, see I was sympathetic to her at first (it's depressingly normal for men not to pull their weight around the house) but this is just passive aggressive.
@badgyalpinky
@Imani_Barbarin
I feel like so many of the problems in cishet marriages are a result of society expecting spouses to be the sole provider in each other's lives (with men as the economic provider and women as literally everything else).
@theoceanblooms
The crazy thing about his mom is that she was a dirt poor immigrant from the Isle of Lewis. Like she's this immigrant Cinderella story with a depressing ending.
@MatzeB92
@BrndnStrssng
He got fired because he lost a libel case. Warner Brothers were perfectly willing to ignore Heard's accusations until Depp started drawing attention to them.
@scumbelievable
@TyDurgen
Also, Jewish descent is generally considered matrilineal! To the point that Jews who have only patrilineal descent are often forced to convert to be accepted!
I'm sorry but this thread strikes me as very shallow and bad faith criticism and people patronizingly reposting it with "even if you disagree, this is a Very Important Thread" are being almost as racist as the "Shut up, you people are never satisfied" jerks.
This whole Depp v Heard trial has really exposed how performative and impermanent MeToo ended up being. Regardless of whether you like Heard, it's clear she's being subject to a massive smear campaign, and barely any figures of the MeToo movement have stood up for her.
@NeoWestchester
@ellieredpath
I mean she was barely writing about magic in the first place. Magic in Harry Potter is basically just a form of technology; there's no real philosophy behind how it works and very little in the way of esotericism or mysticism.
@_WOMBATMAN_
Rowling obviously can create interesting characters, but she's one of those people who got too popular, too fast and instead of growing creatively, just sort of stagnated. Those movies really picked up a lot of the slack.
@TutusNTinyHats
@AnaMardoll
I don't know, it seems like it should be very easy to avoid working for a defense contractor. This isn't like working for a fast food company with a homophobic owner.
@markpopham
Agreed but there's also a significant amount of it that's basically "my precociousness as a child masked a developmental/psychological condition and I suffered as a result".
@emilymodo
@JaeTheeWarpony
@AlHendiify
It was to get white women to wake up to the enroaching conservatism and misogynistic backlash of the Reagan era. The book isn't a prophecy; it's a reaction to the social conservatism of the 80s.
@telushk
I don't even think it's so much sociopathy as it decades of placidly accepting whatever narrative America uses to justify it's crimes. I think they genuinely believe they have the right to drop bombs on whoever they want because "America is exceptional".
@badgyalpinky
@Imani_Barbarin
Like, I feel bad for saying this, but I kind of wonder if some of those women actually feel some small relief when their husbands leave them. Because now they can actually prioritize themselves for once.
@T_L_Seigler
@Spearhafoc_
That's true. But the problem with this comic isn't that it's trying to divorce Poe from the material, it's that it has an absolutely braindead superficial reading of the text that makes no sense.
Do you guys not get how useless this framework is in practice? You can argue that all sex work is technically rape until you're blue in the face but it never does anything to actually materially protect sex workers like Wuornos from actual fucking rapists!
Every John is a rapist & Aileen Wuornos did nothing wrong. Leveraging economic power over impoverished women to extract sex from them that they otherwise would not have is coercive sex, and we have a word for that!
Honestly, I think the way so many people are infantilizing Ana Mardoll and absolving him of any responsibility is super ableist. Sometimes disabled people just do shitty things because they aren't very good people.
No it fucking hasn't! Do you guys just consume nothing but porn all day? Kink has not been half as normalized as you're imagining it! And yes sex should be a beautiful experience but it can't always be that, and whether it's actually pleasurable depends on what you like!
sex should be a beautiful experience filled with tenderness and emotions and laughter and care and cuddling but society has convinced women that it's weird to NOT like being choked and brutalized and degraded during sex
@IwriteOK
@AdamBlumenau
Lovecraft was also a deeply isolated mentally unhealthy and impoverished man who died at 46 and not a wealthy billionaire who lives in a castle.
@majorlady
@sadydoyle
My autism went undiagnosed for years, so I spent my childhood being screamed at by nearly every adult I came into contact with, even my parents who would have done anything to help me. And I still don't think Sanders' yelling is bad.
@corporatecake
Reminds of me of how I would read those criticisms of The Shining that called Shelley Duvall annoying and unsympathetic, and just be very confused. Like her husband was chasing her with an axe?
@xandra_spud47
@Hezbolsonaro
@jets_headache
Israelis also aren't a monolith. The really ideological Zionists and the "just moved from Brooklyn so I can larp as a pioneer" settlers might leave, but a good portion of Israeli citizens just don't have any where else to go.
@HugoThePinkCat
@Stairfax
@GeorgeSquares
Apparently his dad named the cat. Although Lovecraft himself was a massive racist. I mean the guy was afraid of anything different so minorities were just one of his many phobias. Like the sea. And air conditioning.
@hunktears
The biggest problem with "your fave is problematic" culture was that it wasn't really a means to hold bad people accountable. It was usually just calling out fans for daring to like something that wasn't "pure".
I'm sorry I just don't think lesbian desire is "purer" or more "wholesome" and I think trying to conceptualize sexual desire through a framework of moral purity borders on fascism.
@majorlady
@sadydoyle
My experience isn't relevant to you? So what did "No one who got to miss out on being terrified into silence with anger gets to say word one here" mean? I was terrified into silence by anger, that means I get a say, right?
@appuntito160
@della_morte_
Was South Park really pushing anything new though? It seems like it was more a product of Gen X cynicism that lasted way too long.
Oh for fuck's sake nothing she's saying is remotely new, and is stuff that feminists have been talking about for decades. She's talking about the way femininity and suffering under patriarchy are so conflated that not being abused makes you feel like a failure as a woman.
@JennyENicholson
Am I the only one who thinks Barbie is just a scapegoat for much more systemic issues involving body image? I thought I was ugly when I was 8 because boys bullied me for having arm hair, not because I grew up playing with Barbies.
Anne Hathaway's character was not actually supposed to be considered fat in The Devil Wears Prada. The film was a satire of the fashion industry and the whole joke is that she's a thin woman but because she's not a size zero she's considered fat by her coworkers.
@BudrykZack
@Artists_Ali
People thought she was an ally because she acknowledged that the gay subtext between Dumbledore and Grindelwald was intentional, even though their relationship is portrayed as wholly negative.
@ShinyFrontz
@CaramelKaiteki
And that's not in the books or the movies, it's just something Rowling said she envisioned happening. And the house elves are literally slaves. The only way to improve their rights is to free them.
@TutusNTinyHats
@AnaMardoll
If they've been working at Lockheed Martin for 15 years, they likely had ample time and skills to find a job that wasn't directly contributing to the deaths of millions of people.
@LindaFothergill
@nameshiv
He killed like five underprivileged women in an extremely impoverished part of London in the 1880s, long before forensics was a thing. It's even possible he didn't even exist and it was just a string of unrelated murders.
@cryaboutitbabe
It's not explicit but he's pretty clearly from the only non-white family around, it's obvious that exoticism and adultification is a major factor.
I'm fascinated how Holocaust deniers are obsessed with trying to disprove things that, even if they were hoaxes, wouldn't actually do anything to disprove the Holocaust. Like nothing in that diary actually documents her time in concentration camps.
I know misandry doesn't exist as a real systemic social prejudice but there really needs to be a way to talk about how the kind of performative man-hating radfems engage in just ends up luring women into reactionary ideologies.
a fun little game you can play with these viral man-hating radfem posts is clicking on the profile and seeing how far down you get before you run into absolutely vicious transphobia
@TutusNTinyHats
@AnaMardoll
You know what? I'm disabled myself. I've never even had a real job, because it's taken me a long time to get my degree and I'm bad at multi-tasking. And I'm still going to judge the shit out of this person.
@TrillPilled
@LuxAlptraum
I swear some people's brains would short circuit if they knew that Tippi Hedren's response to Hitchcock torturing her for years was to call him a "fat pig".
@ddara24
@IvanaE
There's rarely physical proof of sexual assault. That's why the doctor put her through several tests to make sure she wasn't malingering or falsifying anything. Testimony is it's own form of evidence.
This is probably a hot take, but I think a lot of domestic abusers do love their victims. It's just that love isn't enough to stop them from hurting them and controlling them. Because love isn't some magic force that makes you a good person.
re: some replies, just bcuz *YOU* felt no sympathy for ernest doesn’t mean the film wasn’t from his perspective; we were shown he felt coerced into his actions & repeatedly told he “loved” mollie. that is a sympathetic portrayal, whether or not that’s the emotion *YOU* felt
the straight men trying to roll back divorce rights are clearly ignorant of or too arrogant to take seriously the fact that before no-fault divorce, women would literally murder their husbands.
"my husband died under mysterious circumstances" did NOT used to be a joke
Like you can engage with the criticism! Don't just repost it and tell everyone "Well you have to respect the perspective". Like you clearly don't respect the perspective if you think it's not worth actually discussing.
I know the prosthetic nose is getting all the controversy, but it occurs to me that this is yet another biopic of a gay men that centers his heterosexual marriage.
Discover the fearless love story between cultural icon Leonard Bernstein and Felicia Montealegre Cohn Bernstein.
Maestro — starring Carey Mulligan and Bradley Cooper — is in select theaters November 22 and on Netflix December 20.
@RedRedSuit
I do not think it will fail on a financial level. I meant more on an artistic and cultural level. The Fantastic Beasts films made a lot of money- but they were widely seen as inferior to the original series.
@BudrykZack
@Artists_Ali
Like, the subtext is absolutely there in Deathly Hallows but nothing about it suggests that Dumbledore's sexuality is a positive thing. His infatuation with Grindelwald is portrayed as a weakness he had to overcome.
@2Generalrusty78
@Tranarchic
The Manson Family and the actual Nazis. Really amazing he managed to blow that amount of sympathy. Dude could have gotten away with being a prickly sadistic asshole after all that he had to deal with, but I guess he just had to start fucking little girls.
@jelani_estelle
@shadowandact
Cleopatra was Macedonian Greek and that's why she's the only African monarch who ever gets Hollywood movies made about her. It's an excuse to see a white woman in an "exotic" setting.
The disinformation campaign against Heard has been going on since their divorce. People believe she's the abuser because no one really countered it. It took me until about 2021 to really figure out what was actually going on.
@likelyjanlukas
@e_urq
She's mistaking her internalized misogyny (which is pretty apparent from the Harry Potter books alone) for gender dysphoria. She doesn't hate being a woman; she just hates all the terrible things she thinks being a woman must entail and assumes that's how trans men feel.
@saturnsinmania
What movies are you even watching that do this? The only popular American media besides porn that regularly features sex scenes is like prestige HBO shows. The vast majority of media does not contain any sex whatsoever!
The Spielberg/Tony Kushner partnership is fascinating because Kushner is clearly deeply disillusioned with Zionism, but I really can't get a handle on whether Spielberg genuinely believes in liberal Zionism or just doesn't want to rock the boat.
@wyntergirl2
@BudrykZack
Well those same people are often the ones to post "Friendly reminder that mental illness is no excuse for bad behavior" as if mentally ill people are just regularly excused for their behavior.
@christapeterso
I feel like this is hypocritical to say as an American, but it never fails to shock me just how deeply in denial so many British people seem to be about their history.
@hannaswork
@awilderthing
@ganglads_
Yep. Although the thing is I do have a mom and dad who've supported me and I still took years to get a bachelors. And I'm really lucky, because I genuinely don't know what I'd be doing if my family was less financially secure.
@Shawdes29
@TByrne75
I mean that was more of a joke about the fashion industry body standards; Andie's only a size six but the people at the magazine treat that like she's incredibly fat.
This is kind of the end result of all the discourse about how "mental illness/addiction is never an excuse for anything" which usually presumes some imaginary world in which people with mental illness are given a free pass to do whatever they want.
not only is this untrue, it is offensive to people who have dementia patients in their lives whose personalities have absolutely been changed by this disease.