Daniel DePetris
@DanDePetris
Followers
11K
Following
28K
Media
3K
Statuses
70K
@DefPriorities, syndicated foreign affairs columnist for the Chicago Tribune. Writer for Newsweek, the American Conservative and the Spectator. Lover of Mexico.
NYC & New Rochelle, NY.
Joined April 2014
We hear nothing about Afghanistan anymore. Some of the same people who were on a soapbox last August have quickly moved on. Just goes to show you that their concern wasn’t about the Afghan people per se, but about making withdrawal from a 20 year war as difficult as possible.
20
483
4K
Everybody complaining on Twitter about how humiliating and horrible the U.S. withdrawal is should direct their inquiries to the Pentagon, which had 18+ months to prepare an adequate retrograde and evacuation plan. If you gloss over this, you’re just playing politics.
110
556
4K
The dude has been writing the same op-ed for the last 15 years, and the case is as bad today as it was when he first made it.
93
455
3K
It’s decision time for Russia in Syria. Assad’s future looks more precarious than ever. The HTS-led coalition is on its way to Homs, and if that city is captured, the coastal areas—where Russia’s naval and air bases are located—are effectively cut off from Damascus. (1/7) 🧵
19
255
2K
Remember this the next time you hear Joe Biden, Antony Blinken or Samantha Power troll out the “rules-based order” pablum.
16
620
1K
The whole “U.S. troops can’t leave because Afghanistan will plunge into civil war” argument is kind of strange. It’s as if people have forgotten Afghanistan is currently in a civil war and arguably has been since the Soviet invasion in 1979.
66
203
1K
Literally everything Iran is doing right now—enrichment to 60%, assembling 10x the stockpile of enrichment, installing/using faster centrifuges, limiting IAEA access—wouldn’t be happening if the U.S. remained a party to the nuclear deal you think is horrible.
Iran in a position to produce fuel for a single bomb in “as short as one month.” So you’re saying that the JCPOA didn’t actually slow Iranian breakout time? Iran didn’t give up its nuclear capabilities? Sunsets were a good thing?
31
214
1K
Putin has managed to push Germany into spending 2% of its GDP on defense, pressure the Brits to crack down on Russian money, budge Switzerland toward reassessing its neutral-on-all-things status, and turn Viktor Orban into a supporter of refugees. Miracle worker.
20
214
1K
Dude has written the same piece, every week, for the last 15+ years.
It's beyond time that Biden acknowledges Iran is behind all the violence in the Middle East. It's clear to me that Iran will not stop unless they are held accountable. And that hasn't happened. Biden must stand up to Iran before it's too late.
52
163
1K
Just a reminder: NATO stands for North Atlantic Treaty Organization, not North Atlantic, South China Sea, and East Asia Treaty Organization.
61
220
1K
For those who want to keep U.S. troops in Afghanistan, I’m curious: until when? I keep hearing about “responsible withdrawals;” that the time isn’t right, etc. Please specifically define what the “right time” is. Because as far as I can tell, it’s based on unrealistic conditions.
58
118
997
Over the past 96 hours, hawks have come out of the woodwork. Lindsey Graham, Tom Cotton, Bret Stephens, and the WSJ editorial board have all come out for an aggressive U.S. response. All four have a horrendous record on foreign policy. Why should we even listen to them?.
50
249
930
21 years later:. Bush is painting. Wolfowitz is being interviewed by the Hoover institution. Frum is now a public intellectual. Bolton is on TV every 10 minutes. Cheney is viewed as an older statesman who is now palatable because he hates Trump. Such accountability.
It's 21 years since George W. Bush's infamous “mission accomplished” speech became a symbol of premature victory and Western hubris. From my archive this week, the chain reaction caused by Saddam Hussein's defeat in Iraq, and a warning from history about the “day after” in Gaza.
54
288
1K
Ukraine joining NATO is the reddest of red lines for Russia. It’s not about Putin. No Russian president would support it. We need to stop obsessing over Putin’s personality and start recognizing that Russian foreign policy is motivated by things like security & geography.
79
244
988
The weird thing about the strikes in Yemen last night is that while many officials recognize they’re unlikely to deter the Houthis or change their calculus, they still argue that “something” needed to be done. That, in a nutshell, is one of the problems of U.S. foreign policy.
45
218
949
If only we had a deal to keep Iran’s nuclear program somewhat restricted. Oh wait, we did. And these two thought it was the end of the world. I’m tired of seeing the same folks lecture us about a problem they made infinitely worse.
27
235
769
I tripped over my shoelaces and slammed by knee on the corner of the table. At first, I thought the Iranians succeeded in their plot to sideline me from biking for a week. But I then realized I’m a klutz. #SusanCollins.
12
82
723
The last time Congress voted to authorize war, the year was ‘02. At that time, GWB was President; Ashanti had the No. 1 song; & Fraser was still on TV. Yet when it comes to removing troops from countries as intractably violent as Somalia, some lawmakers have a freak out.
31
64
660
“The joint resolution, sponsored by two senators from opposite ends of the ideological spectrum. is a rare effort by Congress to claw back its war powers from the executive branch.” #SandersLeeYemen #Yemen
10
263
674
What Tom Nichols is implying here is that the 51% of Americans who voted for Trump don’t care about American democracy, which is an odd thing to say considering that casting a ballot for your preferred candidate is the biggest democratic act a citizen can engage in. But ok.
Americans appalled by Trump’s win have every reason to fear for our democracy. But they also have work to do, @RadioFreeTom writes.
193
161
756
An Israeli invasion of Gaza is going to be hell. It’s already hell. But what comes after could be just as worse, particularly if the Israelis find themselves sucked into re-occupying and administering a territory with 2.3m Palestinians. What’s the plan for the day after? 🧵.
71
186
671
I can totally understand President Zelensky’s anger about NATO refusing a No Fly Zone. The guy is under an extreme amount of pressure, is seeing his country attacked, and probably hasn’t slept in a week. But NATO is still right to rule it out. It’s not a responsible option.
57
88
661
The war in Gaza and all the depravities associated with it shows there is no rules-based order, despite what U.S. policymakers and establishment think tankers parrot on a daily basis. It’s Kool Aid we drink before going to bed at night.
30
278
672
Interesting. Ehud Barak once approached Hosni Mubarak and basically asked him if the Arab states would be able to take over Gaza once Hamas was crushed, perhaps for a short 3-6 month period. Mubarak’s response: Gaza is your problem.
29
274
692
-NATO’s eastern flank boosted. -EU moving away from Russian energy. -Russia more dependent on China. -Finland/Sweden flitting with NATO. -Nord Stream 2 dead. -Germany & Italy’s Russia policy hardened. -Germany shocked out of its defense malaise. Putin the “chess master.”.
13
139
576
Please tell me: what does “winning” in Ukraine look like? I’m asking because I sense a lot of officials, lawmakers, and pundits are throwing the word around without fully defining what it means in the context of Europe’s worst war in about 80 years.
75
113
612
We’re told that if Russia wins in Ukraine, Poland and the Baltics are next despite the fact that they’re all NATO members. We’re also told that the best way to safeguard Ukraine’s sovereignty is by granting them NATO member state status. There’s an inconsistency in the logic.
51
106
577
21 years ago today, the U.S. committed its worst foreign policy mistake in generations. That’s bad enough. But the fact that some of the architects of the Iraq War are still treated as authorities shows just how unaccountable the U.S. foreign policy industry really is.
21
160
561
Secretary Pompeo’s certification that Saudi Arabia and the UAE are doing everything possible to minimize civilian deaths in Yemen is not only grossly inaccurate. It also happens to be an insult to the American people’s intelligence. My piece.
23
213
465
The U.S. to Israel: we really don’t want a war in Lebanon and would like you to ceasefire. Israel to the U.S.: No. U.S. to Israel: Ok, here’s another $8 billion in military aid.
14
184
564
Zelensky has two choices, it would seem: 1) negotiate on Russia’s terms (basically a surrender) or 2) choose to fight and risk Kyiv getting destroyed. The first option is humiliating, but spares innocent life. The second is bold but reckless. That’s where we are.
105
109
551
As you continue to see columnists like Max Boot, Jennifer Rubin, David Frum, Robert Kagan, Bret Stephens, Kristol & Hayes ruminate about how terrible U.S. withdrawals from Syria & Afghanistan are, remember these were the same geniuses who thought we could turn Iraq into Germany.
25
161
499
If Nikki Haley decides to run for President in 2024, that’s her right. But be warned: her foreign policy platform is going to be an awful mix of reflexive humanitarian interventionism, maximum pressure & incessant references to “leadership” & “resolve.”
350
97
484
A word to the wise. If you’re worried about what trillions of dollars in infrastructure spending will do to the national debt but are perfectly fine shoveling $750 billion (and counting) PER YEAR into the U.S. defense budget, then you really aren’t concerned about the debt.
4
96
451
The Saudi intervention in Yemen has entered its eighth year. Riyadh confidently predicted the operation would be over in weeks. Instead, it dragged out into what has long been the world’s worst humanitarian crisis, turning Yemen into a cauldron of death, poverty, and hunger.
7
186
464
The transcript of George Bush’s interview with the 9/11 Commission has been declassified. The man was out of his depth. “The President said he was worried about Saudi Arabia. He did not want it to become an al Qaeda country. Nor did he want it to form an alliance with Iran.”
23
152
441
• The “Biden defense budget” is $886 billion, the largest ever requested. • It’s moronic to think the U.S. needs $886 billion to defend itself. • A bigger defense budget doesn’t necessarily buy more security and could actually be an enabler of stupid policy.
39
88
419
-#Scaramucci doesn't like #Priebus.-Tillerson not getting along w/ WH.-McMaster isolated on NSC.-Trump doesn't like Sessions. Got it?.
45
82
388
The war in Afghanistan is deep into its 18th year—which is strange, because the U.S. basically won the war and achieved its objectives in the first few months.
31
142
379
Every time a U.S. official says anything remotely negative, the Israeli government gives this bogus explanation that it will hurt ceasefire talks. Meanwhile, Netanyahu is holding up the process by adding more conditions to a ceasefire at the last minute. Pipe down.
💥🇺🇸🇮🇱Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was upset by Vice President Kamala Harris' on camera statement after their meeting & is concerned it will harm negotiations over a Gaza hostage & ceasefire deal, per Israeli official. My story on @axios .
2
71
438
By my count, the U.S. has 4 regime change campaigns currently ongoing—Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, and Syria. All four have failed, yet all four continue. Are there any I’m missing?.
99
99
419
The U.S. wants the PA to control Gaza. Netanyahu says no. The U.S. wants Gaza’s territory to stay intact. Netanyahu approves buffer zones in Gaza. The U.S. wants more land routes into Gaza. Netanyahu throws up impediments. Channeling Clinton: Who’s the f— superpower here?”.
32
117
424
A new argument for supporters of continuing the forever war in Afghanistan: we have to stay. Otherwise the Pentagon will be sued!
58
153
415
DoD and State knew a withdrawal would happen since Feb 2020. This was set U.S. policy. They knew a withdrawal was a possibility as far back as 2018, when Zal Khalilzad started his talks with the Taliban. What were U.S. officials doing at that time? Answer: apparently nothing.
5
65
421
Also, here’s some more F-35s and 2,000-pound JDAMs.
Blinken urges an impartial investigation into the Israeli strike on a World Central Kitchen convoy. "The victims of yesterday's strike join a record number of humanitarian workers who've been killed in this conflict. These people are heroes. They have to be protected.".
7
105
416
If a war erupts in Ukraine, then Ukraine loses. It would be a bloodbath for the Ukrainian people. The most pro-Ukraine position was always to prevent such a war from happening. Unfortunately, we chose to prioritize high-minded moralism over necessary geopolitical compromises.
26
88
421
Everybody has an opinion on the rebel offensive in Aleppo. Mine is relatively straightforward: the offensive is less a reflection of HTS’s strength and more an indictment of Assad’s extreme dependence on Russia, Iran and Hezbollah to keep his regime afloat. (1/5).
10
85
455
Then don’t bomb schools, don’t make a mockery of your own humanitarian “safe-zones” and don’t pile up aid bottlenecks along the various crossing points leading into Gaza.
12
98
403
Before Russia’s invasion, neutrality for Ukraine was spat upon and treated as the metaphorical skunk in the garden party. Now, it’s seen as a common-sense proposal to end the violence engulfing Ukraine. In reality, it was always a common-sense proposal.
28
74
388
The word "deter" has lost its meaning. For instance, when you claim that strikes will "deter" a group but then say in the next sentence that you expect the group to continue attacking targets, then you're not deterring anything. Read a dictionary.
27
74
420
Just for brevity: the U.S. has bombed Iraq, Yemen and Somalia in just the last 24 hours.
10
198
403
Damn. Timber Sycamore, the CIA’s covert program to support Syria’s rebels, was a disaster. Jordanians and Turks were caught stealing weapons from the pile and selling them on the black market. Arms were seized by jihadists. CIA-supported units were wiped out.
16
145
367
McMaster on TV. Bolton on TV. Robert Kagan with a feature in one of America's top newspapers. Paul Bremer writing about state-building. Thiessen writing nonsense. Petraeus engaging in revisionist history. Condi Rice given a platform. And you wonder why we keep making mistakes?.
12
118
359
I want to congratulate Mike Pompeo, John Bolton, Nikki Haley, Donald Trump, Brian Hook, and all those think tankers in Washington, D.C. who were so confident that replacing the JCPOA with maximum pressure would push Iran into “a better deal.” Well done, folks.
12
71
350
Well, sure, if you don’t count Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Somalia, and the Sahel. What is a war, anyway?
9
88
364
“Donald Trump wants a deal with North Korea. His national security adviser thinks the North Koreans can’t be dealt with. And North Korea thinks he’s “human scum.” Via @michaelcrowley & @elianayjohnson.
89
89
264
I realize this is unpopular to say, but U.S. sanctions are definitely having an impact on global energy prices. You can’t sanction three huge crude producers (Russia, Iran, and Venezuela) and think it’s not going to have an adverse effect at the pump. It’s silly to say otherwise.
14
107
358
He advocated for invading Iraq. It was a disaster. He advocated for killing the Iran nuclear deal. It was a disaster. He advocated for a strategy that used Hamas as a counterweight to the PA. It was a disaster. Stop treating Netanyahu as if he’s a savant. He has no clue.
11
92
346
To those outside of Ukraine who are concerned with what the Ukrainian government may give up in talks with Russia, I respectively say: it’s not your call. It’s easy to criticize “giving into Putin” when you’re sitting in a nice conference room in Washington, DC or London.
8
54
320
I don’t know what kind of budget deal Biden and House Rs will strike. But the notion that the Defense Dept should be insulated from any spending cuts is absurd, and proponents of this position need to do better than the customary “the world is dangerous” pablum we so often hear.
8
75
309
Giving a U.S. defense guarantee to Saudi Arabia in the hope it will normalize relations with Israel is the diplomatic equivalent of trading your house for a nice pair of sneakers. It’s a dumb thing to even consider. For @TIME.
11
76
322
Vilify the Iran deal as terrible. Withdraw from the deal. Slap sanctions lifted under the deal. When Iran responds, say they are violating the deal. Invoke snapback for Iran’s breaches, even though you stopped complying with the deal over 2 yrs ago. Get laughed out of room.
4
73
306
Translation: U.S. and European officials are suspicious of calls for peace talks that do not include a demand that Russia first lose the war before any talks take place. Brilliant.
29
63
320
11
9
316
One of George H.W. Bush’s best decisions was not marching on Baghdad after Iraqi forces were kicked out of Kuwait. Here’s his Secretary of State James Baker in 1996 explaining why Bush 41 made the right decision.
54
81
275
There really is no excuse for this. If I was working in some inspector general’s office, I would probe the whole process in the lead up to the evacuation, the timeline for developing the plan, who was responsible for it, and whether bureaucracy slowed it down.
10
29
304
It turns out we don’t need thousands of U.S. troops in Afghanistan to kill bad guys.
26
66
279
This guy has about as much self-awareness as a 2 year-old at a funeral. I’m almost envious about it.
13
54
272
Iraq owes Iran billions in unpaid electricity bills. But Baghdad is unable to pay Iran due to U.S. sanctions. Iran, tired of getting stiffed, decided to cut the power. Now Iraqis will have to deal with 120 degree heat. For the U.S., an example of unintended consequences.
15
108
298
We pay close to $82 million for a single F-35 joint strike fighter. So give me a break with the “ventilators are expensive, they cost $50,000 apiece” garbage. If we can purchase the world’s most advanced fighter-bombers, we can purchase more ventilators.
16
91
278
I can’t overstate how great Biden’s “forever exit” line was. He won’t admit it publicly, but this was a direct shot at the Pentagon and the Joint Chiefs of Staff, which for years and years had a knack of convincing presidents the U.S. could leave Afghanistan “eventually.”.
0
33
271
How is Vladimir Putin going to resurrect the former Soviet Union with a military that can’t keep gas in their tanks, whose commanders are evidently incompetent at warfare, and whose troops are sabotaging their own vehicles so they don’t have to fight? Answer: he can’t.
25
39
268
Wtf.
Trump says it was good to let the Turks attack the Kurds. "Sometimes you have to let them fight like two kids,” he tells rally in Dallas. “Then you pull them apart.".
22
68
241
That former George W. Bush officials are now rolled out as courageous, patriotic-loving authorities on how the rule of law works, how stable democracies function and what U.S. foreign policy should look like is beyond disturbing. We have short memories.
5
76
305
Gut the Constitution. Lobby for a preventive war based on imaginary Iraqi WMD and a fabricated Saddam-Bin Laden alliance. Institute torture. Establish a prison camp at Gitmo where the law doesn’t apply. Make a mockery of separation of powers. Thank you for your service.
Kamala Harris to Liz Cheney: 'I also want to thank your father, Vice President Dick Cheney, for his support and what he has done to serve our country.'.
8
66
276
Russia has invested a significant amount of capital in keeping Assad afloat, who is viewed in Moscow as an annoying but relatively pliable partner. Indeed if it wasn’t for Russian air power, Assad would have been dead or in exile a long time ago. (3/7).
2
14
307
This is unacceptable. The wind current is violating U.S. sovereignty and enabling China to peer into the private lives of Americans. We need another $50 billion in our $858 billion defense budget to address it—plus sanctions on wind, which is obviously China’s ally at this point.
16
70
280
According to the Center for Public Integrity, Ari Fleischer made 109 false statements on the Iraq War.
8
36
268
If Asian countries who depend on the Strait on Hormuz far more than the U.S. refuse to participate in this maritime initiative, Trump should make it clear that Washington will no longer serve as the primary security guarantor of this choke-point.
22
64
247
It’s the height of irony that Pakistan, which sheltered and armed the Taliban insurgency for decades, causing so much pain and misfortune to Americans and Afghans alike, is confronting the now-Taliban government for hosting anti-Pakistani militant groups like the TTP.
7
56
290
The Russian response has been tepid thus far. The Kremlin is giving statements that it continues to support the Syrian government in its fight against terrorists and has launched some airstrikes in support of Assad’s forces. But the rebel advance southward continues. (2/7).
2
13
298
One of most serious errors in U.S. foreign policy, committed again and again, is assuming other countries—friends and foes alike—view the world as we do.
21
54
255
Navarro says the U.S.-China trade deal is dead. Larry Kudlow says no, it isn’t. Trump tweets that the deal is intact 20 minutes later. Meanwhile, Mnuchin says Trump is considering decoupling the U.S. and Chinese economies. What is happening?.
42
107
244
Sanctioning the ICC on the one hand and actively supporting an ICC war crimes investigation against Russia on the other will smack as blatant hypocrisy to about 80% of the world’s population. Somehow U.S. officials will argue this is still in keeping with the rules-based order.
10
114
271
War has become so normalized within the confines of the U.S. national security apparatus that we don’t even consider months-long air campaigns as worthy of the W-word label anymore (see Libya 2011; Red Sea/Yemen 2023-2024). It’s astounding if you think about it.
Israel Attack on Iran Is What World War III Looks Like by @kenklippenstein, @DRBoguslaw
3
58
274
How many times do we have to defer to the "experts" before we realize they are wrong?
22
53
260
Prigozhin will try to spin this entire episode as a victory of sorts. But the guy is going to spend the rest of his life looking over his shoulder. If Putin can ice enemies of the Kremlin in the U.K. and Germany, he can certainly do it in Belarus.
19
54
247
John Yoo giving legal advice. Mike Pompeo giving Iran policy advice. Lindsey Graham giving Afghanistan policy advice. John Bolton giving advice about how to handle intelligence. What world are we living in?.
8
34
230
I’ve read what seems like a billion pieces on Trump’s withdrawals from Syria and Afghanistan & I’ve noticed a pattern: a lot of the experts quoted are establishment people who have been in Washington for decades. Are reporters allergic to restrainers (or a realists)?.
19
68
211
Yet the situation is fast deteriorating. I suspect Russian officials might be debating whether a change in policy is warranted. Do we throw everything we have to save Assad’s skin yet again, even if it means taking some assets away from the Ukraine? (4/7).
6
12
274
Wait, hold up. Biden was thinking about resigning as VP in protest of Obama ordering 30,000 more troops into Afghanistan?
15
63
259