Prof. C. K. Raju
@CKRaju14
Followers
13,093
Following
0
Media
784
Statuses
1,605
Honorary Professor, Indian Institute of Education, Short bio at .
India
Joined January 2022
Don't wanna be here?
Send us removal request.
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
Still There
• 135593 Tweets
Arath
• 119674 Tweets
PROTECT BINI AT ALL COST
• 77834 Tweets
写真・動画
• 67975 Tweets
Demokratie
• 48635 Tweets
BUMP
• 31614 Tweets
#แค่น้องชายbyDMDBOYS
• 27089 Tweets
JKIA
• 25640 Tweets
MCM MEW IN SEOUL
• 23195 Tweets
牛角半額
• 22641 Tweets
PrabowoJKW RUKUNkompak
• 22577 Tweets
Ergebnis
• 22441 Tweets
#احسمو_صفقه_موليرو
• 22206 Tweets
BekerjaBERSATU UntukNKRI
• 21839 Tweets
食べ放題
• 20637 Tweets
Melt Down
• 16362 Tweets
DANGEROUS NEXT DOOR
• 14834 Tweets
#DANGEROUS_OUT_NOW
• 14793 Tweets
ASSDMS
• 10451 Tweets
Dear Mr Shekhar Gupta,
(
@ShekharGupta
)
This refers to the article
"‘Einstein was a fraud, West stole calculus from India’ – mathematician’s claims slammed by peers" by Mohana Basu, ThePrint, 15 September, 2023, reporting on my lecture of 14 September at the Vivekananda
274
2K
4K
Brahmagupta (7th c) critiqued Aryabhata, and used a quadratic interpolation formula, with forward and backward differences, falsely called “Stirling’s formula”. See my Cultural Foundations of Math p. 141 (pic). Calculus texts + our NCERT school
#maths
texts spread
#FalseHistory
.
24
867
2K
I got a gold medal in Hungary in 2010 for correcting Einstein's mistake.(pic1, click ALT for link to video of prize ceremony, text of speech etc ).
My acceptance speech explained origin of Einstein's mistake: bcoz he STOLE special relativity from Poncaré.
My book on this was
Why do Indian journalists respond with LIES and censorship to ANY non-Western attempt to critically re-examine the Western history of science?
Church power is based on lies and superstitions, therefore it is common sense that the church told many lies to expand its power. Why
14
296
593
33
860
2K
“Christian discovery” doctrine alive: used to steal my calculus transmission thesis by G. G. Joseph, D. Almeida et al. Caught in 2004, but again plagiarised my 1999 paper near-VERBATIM in 2007. Related FRAUD front page news retracted only by HT.
295
922
2K
Q. How did a handful of Britishers colonize a vast country like India, for so long?
A. Using a false history of science to capture the education system! (But we never cross-checked that false history, and won’t do so today.)
Talk to Army War College: .
43
487
1K
Why is calculus theft important? NOT just for past glory! But for FUTURE generations and technology. Stolen knowledge is often misunderstood. Hence, current
#calculus
TEACHING is bad; must change How? NOT by we copying the US changes! . But can we do it?⁉️
15
341
938
Mr Jawhar Sircar (
@jawharsircar
), I respect ur democratic right as a Trinamool MP to oppose the BJP. But if u base ur opposition on a piece of trash yellow journalism from thePrint u work AGAINST ur party.
@MohanaBasu
@ShekharGupta
R u against S. N. Bose the most prominent
“Einstein was a fraud,
Church invented Euclid, West stole Calculus from India”
— so says Hinduist crank CK Raju at Vivekananda Foundation.
Just 2 days ago, everyone in Rajya Sabha seemed to agree, when I said fanatics should not make wild claims!
53
61
188
24
345
833
To prove West STOLE calculus, I applied criminal law. Opportunity (16th c. Jesuits in Cochin), Motive (European navigational problem), circumstantial evidence (e.g. Fermat), and documentary evidence (e.g. Matteo Ricci). (p. 29, 30). Guess what happened?
27
376
808
Why the name “Pythagorean theorem”? Why credit Greeks, why not Egyptians or Babylonians or Indians?
This false and twisted term “Pythagorean theorem” is repeated 32 times in the NCERT class X text. This repetition indoctrinates young children to believe in an extreme form of
(continued from quoted tweet)
The particular example of Pythagoras is very relevant because, as explained in my VIF talk (pic1, link in ALT) Pythagoreans, before Plato, were a religious cult who linked mathematics to the soul (pic2, source in ALT)
it is well known that (1)
0
45
88
14
374
750
Did the West accept theft of calculus? No. But it saw it is easy to STEAL from Indians. Hence the “theft of calculus thesis” itself was REPEATEDLY stolen. Colonial education teaches “trust the West”. The mentally enslaved cannot stand up to glorified Western thieves. HT9Nov2004.
To prove West STOLE calculus, I applied criminal law. Opportunity (16th c. Jesuits in Cochin), Motive (European navigational problem), circumstantial evidence (e.g. Fermat), and documentary evidence (e.g. Matteo Ricci). (p. 29, 30). Guess what happened?
27
376
808
11
316
622
Why do Indian journalists respond with LIES and censorship to ANY non-Western attempt to critically re-examine the Western history of science?
Church power is based on lies and superstitions, therefore it is common sense that the church told many lies to expand its power. Why
In the context of the indefensible report by ThePrint, on my VIF lecture, let us review the media blitz of 2007 related to the Indian origin of calculus.
Recall that in 1998 I took up a project, on the Indian origin of the calculus and its transmission to Europe, with the Indian
9
294
507
14
296
593
Since
@ShekharGupta
has not responded to my earlier tweet and has not published my rejoinder, let me summarize, in legal terms, all the wrongs in the malicious report by
@MohanaBasu
, referred to in the above tweet.
1. I did say that Einstein was a
Dear Mr Shekhar Gupta,
(
@ShekharGupta
)
This refers to the article
"‘Einstein was a fraud, West stole calculus from India’ – mathematician’s claims slammed by peers" by Mohana Basu, ThePrint, 15 September, 2023, reporting on my lecture of 14 September at the Vivekananda
274
2K
4K
28
272
518
In the context of the indefensible report by ThePrint, on my VIF lecture, let us review the media blitz of 2007 related to the Indian origin of calculus.
Recall that in 1998 I took up a project, on the Indian origin of the calculus and its transmission to Europe, with the Indian
Dear Mr Shekhar Gupta,
(
@ShekharGupta
)
This refers to the article
"‘Einstein was a fraud, West stole calculus from India’ – mathematician’s claims slammed by peers" by Mohana Basu, ThePrint, 15 September, 2023, reporting on my lecture of 14 September at the Vivekananda
274
2K
4K
9
294
507
Zero was never just a placeholder as Gerbert (Pope Sylvester II) wrongly assumed.
The Yajurveda 17.2 has numbers up to 1 trillion, Aryabhata up to 10^18, the Buddha up to 10^82 and so on.
Numbers so large cannot be generated just by the native European technique of primitive
I have a question about zero's history. If anyone can answer, I'd be appreciative! It's here:
28
17
182
8
257
505
Calculus began with a dalit, Aryabhata from Patna. His way essential to alt calculus teaching today. See pic from . Major obstacle? Bad philosophy of formal math based on church metaphysics. . Plagiarists help preserve that.
53
180
453
Ancient Indians used experimental method. Stood up to superstitions unlike Galileo who retracted.
In Vedanga "Jyotish" = timekeeping NOT astrology.
But
#Kepler
an astrologer, fudged Indian data. Murderer?
New articles on scientific temper in India .
Did British bring science to India? No! That’s a MacauLie!😁Indians had science and experimental method since when British were savages. . ALL early Indian schools of philosophy accept empirical proofs (प्रत्यक्ष प्रमाण). Bacon was superstitious n corrupt.
30
150
285
10
180
460
Why do so many Indian journalists respond ONLY with slander and censorship to ANY non-Western attempt to critically re-examine Western MATH and SCIENCE or its history?
I am not denying the reality of paid “journalism”, but a paid liar would be more careful to avoid wild lies and
I got a gold medal in Hungary in 2010 for correcting Einstein's mistake.(pic1, click ALT for link to video of prize ceremony, text of speech etc ).
My acceptance speech explained origin of Einstein's mistake: bcoz he STOLE special relativity from Poncaré.
My book on this was
33
860
2K
14
202
444
Have named 14th March “World Plagiarism Day” after Einstein, a con man now an i-con. 😃
He stole special relativity from Poincaré. (Short version: my acceptance speech for TGA award at Univ. of Pécs, Hungary, 2010.)
Einstein also stole general relativity from Hilbert (pic 4).
12
177
430
Aryabhata’s sine “table” has only sine DIFFERENCES. Recursive, NOT algebraic.
Same as “Euler” method of numerically solving differential equations. Cultural Foundations of Math p. 134.
Euler wrote on Indian calendar, made “Christian discovery”, not “independent rediscovery”.
6
165
407
Peter deSouza, in an article in Hindu, talks of saffronisation of education.
The real problem is Christianization of colonial education (including math) since Macaulay. No one talks of it, and this church propagandist hides it.
My response: .
7
200
412
How did Vasco discover even the sea route to India when he did not know how to navigate?🤣 Any nonsense fantasy possible to captured colonised minds.
Vasco crept along the African coast line, and came to India from Melinde with the help of an Indian navigator whom he shamefully
Yet another supporter of pope and genocide!
Vasco did NOT discover the sea route to India, which was known to West since the time of Alexander who send his general Nearchus to "discover" that trade route used from thousands of years before him, as also for later extensive trade
3
82
184
7
224
411
The biggest religious hate crime in all history was the genocide of 100 million native Americans.
Central paradox: how was this horrifying crime
regarded as an ethical and moral imperative by Christians, and then declared legal in US?
My midnight 10 min talk
17
231
403
1. Calculus=solution of differential equations=Newtonian physics
2. Aryabhata’s method="Euler's" method a general way to solve (pic1)
3. Euler wrote on Indian calendar, knew Indian texts.
4. HENCE solved Fermat’s challenge problem.(pic2,3) “Independent Christian (re)discovery”🤣
9
138
376
Europeans knew navigation? No. Vasco hired Indian navigator in Africa. Called him Malemo Cana (=mualim, cana=kanaka/ganaka). Took back his instrument, kamal. American coast line too big to miss. But Columbus wrote he was in China when at Cuba! Then India, hence “Red Indians”!
11
134
353
Before filing a criminal and/or civil defamation case against the Print, I have sent a letter by registered post giving them 7 days to publish an apology or publish my clarification. The letter was delivered on Friday, 20 October (pic1,2)
The fake + fraud report by
@MohanaBasu
Dear Mr Shekhar Gupta,
(
@ShekharGupta
)
This refers to the article
"‘Einstein was a fraud, West stole calculus from India’ – mathematician’s claims slammed by peers" by Mohana Basu, ThePrint, 15 September, 2023, reporting on my lecture of 14 September at the Vivekananda
274
2K
4K
14
182
364
Yes, plastic surgery to repair the nose (rhinoplasty) was used in ancient Egypt and India.
My friend Claude Alvares in his PhD thesis documented how the British acknowledged taking it from Poona.(pics1,2,3)
Do read what serious scholars have written, before dispensing gyan.😄
@jacobabrah1
@CKRaju14
I hope you have read about sushruta. He is the father of plastic surgery.
3
1
16
6
134
353
After a stroke, can’t sign. Gave affidavit to
@AxisBank
Yelahanka, Bengaluru to use thumb print.
Operations Mgr wants me to sign insulting form below. Branch Mgr asked how I write books, but didn't help. Can a PhD say he is illiterate?
@AxisBankSupport
Hindi for illiterates?😬
60
162
346
Europeans were bad even at navigation, when they first came. Their priests stole knowledge from India: calendar for latitude (1582 reform), calculus, trigonometry for loxodromes, longitude. Then falsely claimed it (e.g. calculus to Newton). Church education stabilised Brit rule.
22
142
341
PS. Indians well knew earth was round and calculated its radius accurately by measuring (a) the height of a mountain, then (b) the dip of the horizon
Described in my book Rajju Ganita etc (pic1)
My HPS students did this, at sunset on sea shore near equator, near equinox (pic2)
After Aryan Race Conjecture, racist historians falsely attributed all Egyptian achievements to White Greeks.
Egyptians knew earth was round NOT Greeks with their silly myth of earth resting on shoulders of Atlas/Hercules.
(Hence, Eratosthenes from Alexandria, in Africa.)
3
62
127
6
137
348
Let us be quite clear. I am on record that Egyptians and Babylonians and Indians knew of the "Pythagorean" calculation long before the purported date of Pythagoras. (pic1, )
The question "who did it FIRST?" is irrelevant! Because my concern is math
Thus, I have raised a demand for EVIDENCE not only for "Euclid", but also for "Pythagoras".
I have offered a similar prize of ₹2 lakhs for serious evidence of Pythagoras, as elaborated in the tweets below (or pic1,2)
And, even
1
88
176
11
165
352
Neta can’t change
#maths
or
#calculus
teaching. Can at most ask babu, who will ask an “expert” =
#math
PhD from Cambridge etc. who will ONLY copy what is done abroad. India does NOT control its
#MathEducation
. . शिक्षा में स्वराज first. How to achieve it?
17
142
326
(2/3) Brits fooled us for 3 centuries lying Newton discovered calculus.
I first investigated theft starting 1997/8 (pic)
Manchester U fooled us again pretending Brits discovered theft. Kept FRAUD news release for 15 years, WITHOUT any paper to back it
Std. of Brit ethics!
(1/3) FRAUD news release from Manchester AGAIN! 😣Paper it mentions NOT published even in 15 years. Why?
Bcoz it VERBATIM copied MY paper. CHEATS George Joseph and Dennis Almeida knew they would be caught if they published,
Fraud approved by Manchester ethics committee n Prez.
3
71
105
5
168
317
Ricci's handwritten letter (pic).
Speaks of learning Indian ways of timekeeping (cronicos dos tempos) from an "honourable Moor" or an "Intelligent Brahmin".
Written from Cochin 1581 just before the Gregorian reform of the Christian calendar.
Source: Jesuit archives, Rome.
@GemofIndologies
@GemsOfINDOLOGY
@CKRaju14
Per CFM, pope Gregorian calendar reform committee head Christoph Clavius student Mattio Ricci was sent to Southern India (then the hub of Indian mathematics) to look for Indian Calendrical manuals.
0
23
48
4
156
321
Neither relativity nor calculus was the central topic of my VIF talk. My topic was “Practical ganita vs religious math”: the intrusion of church dogma into school mathematics.
To this end, I gave 5 arguments.
1. Plato connected mathematics to the SOUL, using Egyptian mystic
Why do Indian journalists respond with LIES and censorship to ANY non-Western attempt to critically re-examine the Western history of science?
Church power is based on lies and superstitions, therefore it is common sense that the church told many lies to expand its power. Why
14
296
593
3
145
318
Fermat’s challenge problem unsolved by Europeans until Euler. BUT a solved example in 12th c. Bhaskara’s Bijaganita (pic) Numbers too large for coincidence. “Christian discovery” of Bhaskara made both Fermat and Euler initially famous. My article p 1021.
7
156
302
This
@dhruv_rathee
spells Aryabhata wrong (not typo).😒 Conclusion: he never saw ANY original source. Spouting this ignorance as "educational"!😀
Pingala used zero. Decimal place value used in Yajurveda 17.2 and ललितविस्तर: (chp. 12).
E.g. my MIT talk:
9
135
312
Stephen Hawking scammed millions: using bad calculus to claim "science proves truth of Xtian dogma of creation".
To "save" that scam his co-author GFR Ellis started
The Conspiracy-theory polemic when I visited Cape Town.
5 min video+article on Medium.
5
120
307
Einstein was not the subject of my VIF talk but Euclid was.
Once again, YOU, Mr Sircar (
@jawharsircar
), are the crank advancing wild claims, for
(1) you did not claim my 2011 Euclid prize of Rs 2 lakhs for serious evidence of Euclid (pic1/ALT),
(2) you did not contest a single
Mr Jawhar Sircar (
@jawharsircar
), I respect ur democratic right as a Trinamool MP to oppose the BJP. But if u base ur opposition on a piece of trash yellow journalism from thePrint u work AGAINST ur party.
@MohanaBasu
@ShekharGupta
R u against S. N. Bose the most prominent
24
345
833
6
144
308
Before computers, 100s of IITians I met were all in managerial roles. Only 1 interested in engg.
Moreover, many go abroad (pic). Indian taxpayer is funding supply of skilled labor to West! They laugh!
Colonised REFUSE to design. Mostly imitate, as I found out in C-DAC.
10
113
304
The current relevance to India of Dogma of Christian Discovery
The dogma, used for land grab in Americas, was used for KNOWLEDGE grab from India.
E.g. as in our class XI school-text claim "Newton 'discovered' calculus". No! Europeans stole calculus from India using doctrine of
The biggest religious hate crime in all history was the genocide of 100 million native Americans.
Central paradox: how was this horrifying crime
regarded as an ethical and moral imperative by Christians, and then declared legal in US?
My midnight 10 min talk
17
231
403
3
197
301
When I learnt this in school, I did ask "where did Indians live before India was discovered?"
My teacher replied, "we lived right here!"
He did not respond to my next question, what then did Vasco discover?
That's Western "scholarship" to which colonial education taught us
@CKRaju14
Text books told us Vasco de Gama discovered India in 1498. As students we read Ramayan and Mahabharat and we realised it was a lie. We failed to understand if our educators, principals and teachers also realised this and why did they continue teaching misinformation?
5
16
48
13
150
306
Attacking Indian ganita (by falsely claiming it had no proof or reasoning) a key part of colonial math education. Done through math “experts” like Narlikar, Sinclair both PhDs from Cambridge (a church institution), to better implant colonial math thru “Euclid”. Evidence? Debate?
6
132
289
My mail, quoted below, said: “The ‘peers’ she consulted are not competent to speak on either issue of Einstein or calculus and didn’t.” A small correction.
Certainly, neither “peer” spoke on Einstein, but one, while saying he lacked knowledge of Indian ganita, cited his
Dear Mr Shekhar Gupta,
(
@ShekharGupta
)
This refers to the article
"‘Einstein was a fraud, West stole calculus from India’ – mathematician’s claims slammed by peers" by Mohana Basu, ThePrint, 15 September, 2023, reporting on my lecture of 14 September at the Vivekananda
274
2K
4K
4
147
302
Finally, the religious origin of White supremacy is being recognized in this conference to be held in Syracuse U. (pic1)
My accepted abstract for the conference explaining how this evil claim of supremacy is kept alive today through false history such as that of “Pythagoras
4
150
295
No, no, Nyaya is the term he added, and is the right term as in रज्जू-सर्प न्याय. It is the term I liked, compared to term rule=नियम.
"Pythagorean theorem" FAILS for triangles on a sphere (pic1) such as the earth, as Indians knew long before the advent of "non-Euclidean"
0
0
0
5
117
299
Did British bring science to India? No! That’s a MacauLie!😁Indians had science and experimental method since when British were savages. . ALL early Indian schools of philosophy accept empirical proofs (प्रत्यक्ष प्रमाण). Bacon was superstitious n corrupt.
30
150
285
Glad u agree Fermat’s challenge taken from Bhaskara 2. So, 17th c. Europeans knew about Indian
#math
.
Infinite series then claimed by Newton and Leibniz also known earlier in India; stolen by Jesuits to solve European navigational problem.
So, why credit N or L with calculus?
@Soph8B
@CKRaju14
Thanks Sophie. I think Prof.
@CKRaju14
raises several interesting points in his body of work (for example, the Bhaskara II / Fermat example), and his general point is valid: Indian mathematicians have made tremendous contributions that deserve to be better recognized in the West.
7
41
120
4
126
278
Famines in India a REGULAR part of British rule from Hastings till Churchill.(pic1)
GENOCIDE of tens of millions of Indians by Brits who killed far MORE Indians even in WW2 than ALL Jews by Hitler.
But we fought on THEIR side! Never accused Brits of Crimes against Humanity.😬
@Sangeeta190909
Now, I get it.
I did not know about Rothschild. Indians have been deracinated and only now we realize the wealth of our ancestors.
@CKRaju14
has bust the Newtonian Myths.
Rakhigari will finally bust the AIT.
So, truth shall prevail.
3
11
27
3
132
279
West got arithmetic ("Arabic numerals") from India. De Morgan banned − ve numbers (pic1) 🤣
Russell gave 378 p. proof of 1+1=2 (pic2). That clearer?
West got calculus too from India (pic3). Made it UNCLEAR so California cancelled calculus in schools. .
Correct.
I have long been writing about Indian philosophy as the source of "Western" scepticism. And economics before Adam Smith. Yet, we must acknowledge that the West made it all much more systematic and clearer.
Except now - both India and the West have become fascist.
0
0
6
6
102
276
Let us be consistent. Bakshali mss is only the first PHYSICAL source of use of a symbol for zero.
If we go consistently by this standard of evidence, then we should date the “Euclid” book to 888 CE which is the earliest physical source for it.
Also,we should erase all
10
139
274
PS. How exactly do we know Einstein was NOT a fraud?🤔
Can we believe ALL of his numerous claims that he had not read and reproduced earlier works identical in content? (E.g., his special relativity paper of 1905 had 0 references, tho he had surely read SOME of Poincare's
Mr Jawhar Sircar (
@jawharsircar
), I respect ur democratic right as a Trinamool MP to oppose the BJP. But if u base ur opposition on a piece of trash yellow journalism from thePrint u work AGAINST ur party.
@MohanaBasu
@ShekharGupta
R u against S. N. Bose the most prominent
24
345
833
8
113
267
Physics done using calculus invented in India (pic1).
But falsely attributed to Newton who failed to understand it fully. (Hence, Dedekind invented axiomatic "real" numbers, which did not exist in Newton's time.)
Teaching/doing calculus the Indian way makes it easy (pic2) hence
Start with math needed for physics.
Bcoz of the false term "Pythagorean theorem" (pic1) the gullible believe this is a "Western contribution" to math.🤣
But PRACTICAL value comes from the "Pythagorean" CALCULATION (NOT theorem) (pic2).
As in Manava sulba sutra (pic3),
1
11
24
3
139
268
(continued from post quoted below)
2. I did say the calculus was stolen from India.
But, again, I have PUBLISHED an enormous amount of evidence for this since 1999. Key publications include a 2000/2001 keynote/article in the 8th East-West conference Hawai’i (pic1). This was
Since
@ShekharGupta
has not responded to my earlier tweet and has not published my rejoinder, let me summarize, in legal terms, all the wrongs in the malicious report by
@MohanaBasu
, referred to in the above tweet.
1. I did say that Einstein was a
28
272
518
5
157
261
As regards the Indian origin of calculus, and its theft by Europeans, once again you have not contested a single line of my over 500-page book Cultural Foundations of Mathematics (pic1), or any of the numerous other related publications or even this video
Einstein was not the subject of my VIF talk but Euclid was.
Once again, YOU, Mr Sircar (
@jawharsircar
), are the crank advancing wild claims, for
(1) you did not claim my 2011 Euclid prize of Rs 2 lakhs for serious evidence of Euclid (pic1/ALT),
(2) you did not contest a single
6
144
308
0
120
255
Nonsense! This claim about Archimedes is the height of Christian chauvinistic history! Greeks and Romans were ignorant even of elementary fractions.😀
Volume of cylinder known to Egyptians (Ahmes "Rhind" papyrus 41, 42 etc., pic1), over 1000 years before Archimedes.
Correct
7
138
252
Bcoz space is curved.
Light rays r our best "approximation" to imaginary straight lines. (Know ANY other way to draw a straight line? The path of a pencil on paper is jagged under a microscope, never EXACTLY straight! Of course, the paper itself is only IMAGINED as a plane,
10
83
253
ERROR to talk of शुल्ब सूत्र before breaking the पूर्व पक्ष (“Pythagoras gave a proof”). So FIRST ask for EVIDENCE for (1) Pythagoras (2) WHERE he stated the theorem, (3) HOW he proved it? And watch “expert” jump from one myth to next since no evidence. .
6
126
240
Correction: same CKR who wrote 3 books, n articles and lectured in univs in 6 continents on why Newton and Einstein were not just thieves, but were wrong!
No one refuted ANY of his points in 30 years, BUT top Westerners like Atiyah tried to steal credit for what he said. ../2
3
0
3
5
86
243
Wrote to
@RajVedam1
about the slide at 21:47.
Newton brazenly stole calculus, on the vile Dogma of Christian Discovery. On the same dogma (still a US/Brit law), George Gheverghese Joseph verbatim stole my calculus theft thesis.
RV replied he has corrected it since (pic).
4
121
237
(continued from post quoted below)
3. Ganita is practical because it accepts the empirical (प्रत्यक्ष), hence inexactitude, while axiomatic mathematics (=Western ethnomathematics) is religious because it prohibits the empirical, and superstitiously believes mathematics is
(continued from post quoted below)
2. I did say the calculus was stolen from India.
But, again, I have PUBLISHED an enormous amount of evidence for this since 1999. Key publications include a 2000/2001 keynote/article in the 8th East-West conference Hawai’i (pic1). This was
5
157
261
4
121
227
Mutual back-patting by Ramchandra Guha and Pervez Hoodbhoy (pic1) who is neither brave nor brilliant.
My earlier response to Hoodbhoy's "gobar" comments in Dawn on Darwin during Covid. (pic2)🤣
But excrementivorousness and "fecal transplants" are acceptable to him since part
An important piece by the brave and brilliant Pervez Hoodbhoy:
“India’s descent into a Hindu rashtra generates a kind of smug satisfaction in Pakistan, a vindication of the two-nation theory that Hindus and Muslims cannot ever live together. But then, how shall the Muslims of
1K
484
2K
7
87
227
Neta-s fear controversy. Babu-s stonewall. “Experts” lie, NOT publicly accountable.
No change in
#math
education possible?!
Welcome to colonial slavery 75 years after “freedom”!
Solution?
Attacking Indian ganita (by falsely claiming it had no proof or reasoning) a key part of colonial math education. Done through math “experts” like Narlikar, Sinclair both PhDs from Cambridge (a church institution), to better implant colonial math thru “Euclid”. Evidence? Debate?
6
132
289
12
92
209
Let's be clear: calculus was STOLEN from Kerala but NOT invented there.
Calculus originated 1000 years EARLIER with Aryabhata (आर्यभट), in 5th c., who first gave the 24 sine (अर्ध ज्या) differences accurate to the 1st sexagesimal minute (कला) (pic1).
The Aryabhata school
@CKRaju14
Per Dr Raju these manuscripts from Kerala were sent to the Vatican by padres seeking to fix the messed up Julian calendar. Thence to newton and liebnitz, and behold! Calculus just one further step.
1
5
7
4
121
235
To repeat: issue is not ONLY that "we did it first".
We did calculus DIFFERENTLY and did it BETTER! So, we should CHANGE the way we teach calculus. That would be real disruption!
But Govt says only Western-approved "experts" can tell which is better. So, we stay colonized!😒
If there is a formal, concerted effort from Indian institutions and the Ministry of Education with the guidance of
@CKRaju14
, we can establish this disruptive truth:
"Mathematical knowledge from Kerala was exported to catholic colleges of Portugal & Italy in the 16th century"
1
62
136
9
101
216
Here is a challenge for a public debate to
@NarainNandita
(ex-president DUTA), to publicly justify how she teaches
#Calculus
and “real analysis” in Stephen’s, DU. Even offered to waive the precondition to prove 1+1=2 in reals. Let us wait and see if she picks up the challenge.
To make
#math
experts publicly accountable, repeatedly tried to organize a PUBLIC debate on ganita vs formal math since 2015. Failed. Only one (Padma Bhushan) confident enough to discuss even over coffee. . Running away = loss in शास्त्रार्थ. Trying again.
6
70
155
6
94
206
Case of calculus was repeated with probability and statistics. Europeans stole from India without acknowledgment and FAILED to understand.(pic1) Still hiding it, eh? This paper deliberately not mentioned in your "review"!
Europeans tried the calculus trick of limits with
Thanks for the reference to the article by
@johnarmstrong5
. Very probably a deliberate political stunt to try to derail the decolonisation of math not by serious arguments but by misrepresentation, as I warned years ago.
In Indian tradition, such gross misrepresentation was
3
59
119
1
112
214
This is a key argument: West stole Indian
#calculus
, HENCE failed to understand it fully.
West "corrected" its bad understanding, by inventing "real numbers" (no practical use), on the CHURCH method of axiomatic proofs (falsely attributed to Euclid).
Math teaching must change!
@stevenstrogatz
Sure. Nor did you read mine & don't seem to know that I TEACH calculus based on 5th c. Aryabhata and Brahmagupta, not Madhava or Kerala school.
European contribution negative. They suppressed past work hence made stolen calculus needlessly difficult. .
3
59
127
5
82
203
Easy church tricks fooled Indians for 175 years.
1. Did u ask: evidence for Euclid?(pic1) NCERT says believe for Western texts say it!
2. Did u check: whether "Euclid" book has axiomatic proofs?(pic2)
3. Did u object? Reasoning from प्रत्यक्ष SUPERIOR to reasoning from axioms?
How did church infiltrate math? Simple:
1. Concocted myth of “Euclid” as “Greek” author of book Elements
2. Lied that church method of “reasoning without facts” (=axiomatic proof) in this book which has NO axiomatic proofs.
3. Taught this church way of reasoning as superior (pic)
0
53
97
5
112
202
History Cong chair interviewed (pic1,2). Says Aryans and Veda-s origin outside India.
My book settles 250 yr old issue: Veda-s originated in India bcoz arithmetic in Veda-s found only in India. (Much later it spread from India.)
Historians: learn basic history of arithmetic!😀
9
100
207
3. While the church wanted "reason", it could not use scientific reason or reason as used in science or in Indian ganita (reason PLUS facts).
Why not? Because church dogmas are all contrary to facts.
Therefore, the church invented religious reason (reason MINUS facts) which
Neither relativity nor calculus was the central topic of my VIF talk. My topic was “Practical ganita vs religious math”: the intrusion of church dogma into school mathematics.
To this end, I gave 5 arguments.
1. Plato connected mathematics to the SOUL, using Egyptian mystic
3
145
318
2
101
206
E. C. G. Sudarshan took solace in my point about how Einstein stole from top academics. (In Sudarshan's case, it was the top Western academics who stole.)
My article "A singular Nobel" (pic, link in Alt) also explains how the religious (church) bias in axiomatic math creeps into
@CKRaju14
@jawharsircar
Not to digress from this topic but on a related note, Prof Raju, what is your take on the plagiarism of ECG Sudarshan's work, by Feynman, Murray-Gellman and Roy Glauber? Sudarshan, a supreme genius if there was one, was brutally passed over for the physics Nobel not once or twice
6
14
25
4
97
200
Reminder: My talk today on why Newton etc. failed to understand Indian-origin
#calculus
, hence West invented metaphysical (=unreal) real numbers and limits, which make it hard but add no practical value, only a religious bias.
But that is how we teach it today. Can't change.😒
6
90
205
Judging "experts" ONLY by foreign degrees/awards not OK. E.g. Nobel to Amartya Sen an easy way to influence Indian economic policy. Ditto for education policy. Hence, insist on public debate, and my 1+1=2 pre-test, to make math "experts" accountable to Indian public.
Prove 1+1=2 in REAL numbers, my Cape Town/JNU challenge (pic, ). A test to join PUBLIC debate (शास्त्रार्थ) on Q. "Should COLONIAL/formal math continue to be taught?" “Experts” who fail test should leave formal math or their jobs (or just die of shame).
6
85
164
10
77
197
As ECG Sudarshan said to me: "if
#Einstein
could steal from [the famous] Poincare, who am I?"
Atiyah stole my correction to Einstein, and the American Mathematical Society DEFENDS the theft to this day! .
Awards a political weapon, like false history.
6
83
199
Doctrine of Xtian discovery not limited to genocide to steal LAND.
Was/Is still used to steal KNOWLEDGE: e.g. by lying "Newton discovered calculus" not 5th c. Aryabhata.
Will pope also revoke such lies? No way! Such lies used (in NCERT text) to glorify West and belittle us.😣
Sounds like a sick April-Fool joke!
Will the pope perform a miracle?🤔 Bring back to life the 100 million+ people killed on this genocidal church doctrine? Those enslaved?
Will lands in the 3 continents of North and South America, Australia then be given back to the indigenes?
4
51
99
4
84
185
“Experts” the choke point.
To successfully introduce even parallel university courses in
#math
, first make “experts” publicly accountable. How?
Revive tradition of PUBLIC debate (शास्त्रार्थ): ask “expert” to DEMONSTRATE expertise and defend existing
#math
curricula openly.
Solution? Parallel courses possible in autonomous universities, not schools. But VC will ask experts!😀
So, for freedom, must BREAK existing colonial system propped by "experts".
How?
1st step: Make
#math
“experts” accountable to Indian public not foreign patrons alone. How?
6
60
164
6
67
174
Yes, facts and evidence do NOT matter to colonised fanatics like
@MohanaBasu
.
But Pavlovian reflex DIFFERS from Orosian reflex, built on false STORIES/HISTORY the church told to teach canine loyalty to humans.
See his 5th c. "History AGAINST the Pagans" (pic) Pagans=us!
For the mind-colonized, facts/evidence doesn't matter. Their minds are programmed to react in a Pavlovian sense & react as this Sircar has done. They are incapable of understanding the evidence offered by
@CKRaju14
, let alone critiquing it! This explains the pedestrian response.
2
38
87
0
84
184
Yet another supporter of pope and genocide!
Vasco did NOT discover the sea route to India, which was known to West since the time of Alexander who send his general Nearchus to "discover" that trade route used from thousands of years before him, as also for later extensive trade
@adventuresmalik
@CKRaju14
What? He found the route to India, not India, by encircling Africa. They were looking for alternative trade routes to India as the land routes were all blocked.
4
1
3
3
82
184
Pathetic Crusading lie to glorify Greeks as proxies for Christians, later Whites/West.
Source for Hipparchus? How did Greeks state fractions?
Never found in ERRONEOUS Greek/Roman/Christian calendar till 16th c.
Real Greek calendar of 375 days🤣by Solon. See book (pic)
One year is exactly 365.2422 days long.
More than two thousand years ago a Greek astronomer called Hipparchus calculated the length of a year to within 0.005 of that figure.
And he didn't even have a telescope...
431
8K
93K
5
68
187
Feynman’s physics mistake in his PhD thesis. My correction in mine.(pics)
Alas, for most Indians, scientific truth=Western approval.
So they think it delusional for an Indian to correct a famous Westerner. Rarely read to decide.
Feynman’s biographer Jagdish Mehra did read!😀
Feynman is wrong! He uncritically repeats the same church NONSENSE, also spread by our school texts. (pic1)
Fact: Not 1 axiomatic proof in the “Euclid” book.(pic2)
Fact: 1st axiomatic proof found in church theology. (pic3)
My 1st paper on Feynman's PHYSICS mistake!(pic4).../2
1
67
112
3
104
187
Name give by Brahmagupta (whom al Khwarizmi badly translated in his "Al jabra waal Muqabala") was avyakt ganita (अव्यक्त गणित, "unexpressed arithmetic")
Since 2x+3, say, acquires a value only after a value is assigned to x.
The unknown "x" was called "yaavat-taavat" ever
3
98
189
Of course virgin birth is central to Xtian ethics on the dogma of original sin. If Jesus were himself born of sin, how could he save others from sin?
We must study this "ethics" bcoz of all the evil it has led to. (pic1, link in ALT)
But since u abuse u are blocked!
@CKRaju14
You can be good in physics and Math, but leave religion. You're so dumb in that field. I won't be surprised if you're using Hume's argument for the impossibility of miracles. That has been debunked by his contemporaries. By the way, the virgin birth is not central to ethic🥱
0
0
0
4
100
179
Wishing all a happy Republic Day!
Alas, in secular India, this secular festival is defined ONLY on the Christian calendar, which forces people to recite the SUPERSTITIONS AD and BC.
As the ARC book explains, such RECITATION was the 1st lesson Jesuits taught to Akbar's grandson!
6
102
183
1k univs, 40k colleges. All teach formal
#Math
, not ganita. Can we find 5 "experts" to debate: “Formal math is neither useful nor beautiful, but only adds a church RELIGIOUS bias to usable normal math"? Yes, in secular India, school math, a compulsory subject, is not even secular
3
80
173
Blog (Hindi) on Jaipur talk. Notes and video: .
Calculus stolen from us. West fooled us saying it is Newton's: NCERT teaches it (pic).
Limits need real numbers, but our "experts" unsure why 1+1=2 in reals (pic2,3).
So won't even publicly DISCUSS change😫
1
97
184
Most Indian historians think it is OK to be ignorant of math:🤣(agreeing with West, where they hope to make money).
Govt agrees: not a single dept of history and phil. of science (HPS) in India. I have asked for 22 years!
African students loved my two HPS courses (pic) which
A mathematician can refute the Aryan theory but not the Indian historians. It shows the pathetic condition of the so-called Indian historians.
1
14
29
4
64
178
My old tweet on Pythagoras (pic1) & articles (pic2,3).
If journos want to save this trash RACIST and Christian CHAUVINIST "history", they should give the evidence as demanded! But no concern for truth!
So, they act like colonial terrorists to defame those who want a change!
1
77
175
Thus, I have raised a demand for EVIDENCE not only for "Euclid", but also for "Pythagoras".
I have offered a similar prize of ₹2 lakhs for serious evidence of Pythagoras, as elaborated in the tweets below (or pic1,2)
And, even
As stated in the tweet quoted below “Why does she lie to preserve the false story of “Euclid”, the starting point for church intervention in school math? What is her vested interest in pro-church propaganda which adversely affects millions of our children?”
Let us understand why
1
63
127
1
88
176