Int'l affairs, EU, Middle East. Head of media
@portlandcomms
. Ex
@Reuters
in Jerusalem, Paris, Brussels, Jo'burg, Rome, Baghdad. Tar Heel. Views my own.
Hamas using civilians as 'human shields'. It happens. I've witnessed it. But the main point here is this: media organisations should look at themselves in the mirror and ask "how do I know what I know?" And if the answer is "because a Hamas-run health ministry official told me"
These numbers are vast AND almost entirely uncheckable. The only source news organisations have for them is Hamas. Most news outlets are now citing "the Hamas-run health ministry" as the source, but not all.
@Reuters
still refers to "Palestinian officials", which is misleading
And were professional about it. But Hamas has now been in charge in Gaza for 16 years. It has squeezed the life out of honesty and probity. Any health official stepping out of line and not giving the death tolls that Hamas wants reported to journalists risks serious consequences
At all, including many children. That's verifiable. What is not verifiable are the numbers that emerge throughout the day from Gaza of new death tolls -- 700 killed in the last 24 hours, 500 killed in the Ahli hospital car park blast, 5,000 killed since Oct. 8th, etc., etc.
So at least a modicum of scepticism is needed with respect to the rapidly updated, and frequently round figure, death tolls. Journalists and UN officials know this, but still they repeat the numbers pushed out by Hamas, or by officials with Hamas breathing down their necks
In the extreme. I oversaw Reuters' coverage of the Palestinian Territories in 2006 and again as Jerusalem bureau chief from 2014-17. There was a time when the figures from the ministry could be relied upon. The doctors and administrators knew what they were doing
Again, painfully, there is no question that high numbers of civilians are being killed as Israel carries out air strikes on Hamas targets through Gaza. There are multiple reasons for that, including heavy handed tactics and weaponry, well-hidden targets, mistakes and, yes,
I don't know what happened in Gaza. But no one should seriously be relying on Hamas to give them an accurate version of events. No one should be using Hamas as a source and describing them as "Palestinian officials" -- proper Palestinian officials should be insulted
Fascinating insight from a British doctor who has worked at al-Shifa in Gaza, talking about the warnings to stay away from a certain area of the hospital run by Hamas or risk being shot
At its best,
@Twitter
was about being able to be on top of breaking news, comment, debates, etc. Now this ‘For You’ nonsense gives me tweets from four hours ago and no sense of a timeline. It’s utterly dreadful
The 20th anniversary of the
#Iraq
war is on March 20 and I’ve been going over old
@Reuters
notebooks. Fascinating to see how the seeds of chaos were sown within days and weeks of the invasion. Will tweet some photos and quotes from inside, including these first pages from 2003/4
@FT
has been leaving others in the dust on Russia-Ukraine, particularly when it comes to what China may be up to. A peace plan may only be in the early stages and could fall apart but the FT is on it
Great listening to
@GerardAraud
and
@campbellclaret
debate the geopolitical issues buffeting Europe and the wider world in Paris last night, and exciting to welcome Gérard as a senior advisor
@PortlandComms
, bringing unparalleled knowledge, experience and good humour. Bienvenue!
Fascinating. Macron on Boris Johnson (allegedly): "Boris speaks to me. He's full speed ahead. Everything's good, we have a grown up discussion. And then he sticks one on us in a completely inelegant way. It's a circus... He's a clown."
Russia's influence in Africa has withstood its botched invasion of Ukraine
Will food insecurity, war crimes allegations and secondary sanctions derail Russia's ambitions in Africa? Based on my forthcoming book on Russia in Africa, I share some thoughts /1
A lot of people outside
#Israel
are perhaps unaware that the political/social/economic crisis the government itself has caused because of its overreaching judicial reforms are the result (to a significant degree) of pressure from a think-tank -- the Kohelet Policy Forum
NYTimes and others cited "Palestinian officials" (Hamas-run Gaza health ministry) saying 500 dead. Some said 800 dead. The numbers always looked dodgy. Then everyone settled on 471, again citing "Palestinian officials". Now it looks like it could be between 10 and 50
#GazaHospital
. Alors que le
#Hamas
a évoqué la mort de 471 personnes dans une frappe sur un hôpital, une source européenne évoque « entre 10 et 50 » morts.
From the point of view of democratic legitimacy and accountability, we should all be more aware and wary of these thinly-veiled pressure groups, that aren't acting as independent think-tanks at all. They are special interest policy pressure groups with narrow, selfish agendas
@TomMcTague
@GerardAraud
@EmmanuelMacron
That’s unfair. Europe/the EU is at the heart of this stand-off, geographically and in terms of events. The EU Association Agreement with Ukraine has spurred Putin’s actions since 2012. Macron is engaged, both as French president and as the holder of EU Council presidency
A few quick memories of covering Berlusconi 20-odd years ago. He once appeared on a nightly discussion programme. He asked the host to smell his cologne. “What do you think that is?” Berlusconi asked. The host shrugged and Berlusconi replied: “That’s the smell of sanctity”
@TomMcTague
@GerardAraud
@EmmanuelMacron
But it’s not just that. To presume that Biden is the only person who can engage or negotiate is shortsighted. US interests are not always European interests. In NATO the US is a critical decider, sure. But that shouldn’t prevent engagement by Macron, or Johnson for that matter
🧵 Interesting listening to UK debate on the rocket strike at the Gaza hospital last night. The fact is, nearly all international media took it as read, quoting Palestinian officials, which is Hamas in Gaza, that Israel was responsible. All headlines sourced it that way
This is gobsmacking. The Erez crossing is more than a kilometre of security fences, concrete enclosures, electronic gates, cameras, machine gun posts. Where were the Israeli forces ? Even if the cameras were disabled, it’s an astonishing collapse in security by Israel
In its own way,
#Israel
is having a Liz
#Truss
meltdown moment. Netanyahu may be a much better known quantity (he's had plenty of experience as PM), but his decision to pursue an extreme strategy to overhaul the powers of the Supreme Court is spooking markets
Missed this piece when it came out. Looks like
@TheEconomist
won
@secondmentions
hands down
the glutamate-rich goo
umami-rich condiment
the black elixir
the tar-like substance
the sticky industrial by-product
Six years ago today. Still one of the favourite photos I’ve taken.
#Easter
was early that year. He was using his Google maps to find his way to the Via
#Dolorosa
in the Old City of
#Jerusalem
Silvio Berlusconi has died aged 86. For all his self-obsession, political shenanigans and blingy grubbiness, few had such an impact on modern Italy in the past 40 years. From overhauling TV to football ownership, media influence in politics, redefining shamelessness even
The reason why it should matter more widely is that this trend (of think-tanks getting a tight grip on policy-making and having a profound impact without being democratically accountable) is happening ever more in developed democracies, but especially now in the UK
Nicked from a pub in London in October, my old iPhone spent a night in Essex, went to Cockermouth for a few days, took a flight to Dubai and is now hanging out in China, where goodness knows who "owns" it
Sir Tony Brenton, former British ambassador to Moscow, sounding very critical of the West in its dealings with Putin and delivering arguments to suggest Russia’s security concerns haven’t been addressed — speaking on
@SkyNews
It’s very good to hear lots of UK journalists starting to pronounce
#Kyev
more like Ukrainians do — sounds like Kieff — but it’s as if we all started calling Paris Paree, Florence Firenze and Rome Roma. Saying
#Kiev
is okay
In the UK, 55 Tufton Street has become shorthand for a number of think tanks, many of them right-leaning, euro-sceptic or climate-questioning, that are having a big impact on tax issues, green policy, voter ID issues, etc. They were influential in Liz Truss's economic car-crash
Unfortunately I have been in a place where several hundred people were killed at once (in Karbala, Iraq, 2004, suicide attack on Arbaiin), and you know it. Almost nothing in the pictures from the al-Ahli hospital car park blast indicated "hundreds dead"
What a fabulous, evocative essay. It won’t make much sense to anyone under 30, but still worth reading. Another age, another time. And let’s not get on to having to endear yourself to hotel operators as a journalist, or early, huge satphones
@TomMcTague
@GerardAraud
@EmmanuelMacron
And on issues like Iraq and the US drive to go to war in 2003, history has shown the French to have been wise (despite US slurs of ‘cheese-eating surrender monkeys’). The US has flip-flopped on international affairs repeatedly since Obama/Syria, so why presume now that Biden…
It's a well-financed think-tank with a specific agenda. It is organised and disciplined in its approach. It's actually remarkable the impact it has managed to have in a relatively short space of time -- it was only founded a decade ago and is reshaping Israel in its vision
Fair to say that former
@reuters
chiefs are not at all happy about Thomson Reuters signing the company up to the UK’s Armed Forces covenant. A breach of principles.
@glcarlstrom
"The easiest industry to spin up would simply be tourism — Gaza has a lot of nice beaches, plenty of historical sites, etc. In the future it would be a destination for investment from Turkey and possibly the Gulf states and Europe" 😂
I’m going to post a 🧵 of pictures from the invasion of
#Iraq
20 years ago. I was embedded with US troops for the invasion, so naturally these photos are from the US perspective. But I hope they give a sense of the absurdity of what went down, in various ways
There have been several touching moments in the Franco-German relationship over the years, but this is one of the most natural expressions of deep respect and affection
Tube on strike, I dawdled to Paddington on Friday. Passing the old wrought iron sign for Pizza Express, I was reminded of an event 30+ years ago, when I got caught up in a drama that resulted in a divorce, two marriages and many changed lives.
It began with a heart attack 🧵
#Biden
says it may be necessary to look into
#Musk
’s purchase of
@Twitter
which included the involvement of foreign capital (from Saudi). Asked how, he tells a news conference “there are ways”
Ahh, rediscovered the first royalty cheque from sales of my novel (Dateline Baghdad, available in all online bookstores…)
Moral of this story — don’t write a novel expecting to make any money 🤣
When I was Reuters bureau chief in Jerusalem from 2014-17, the Kohelet Forum regularly sought meetings and tried to shape my thinking/understanding on numerous fronts, from justifying occupation to the need for far-reaching judicial reform
I tweeted the other day about
@wizzair
dumping a plane-load of passengers at Doncaster-Sheffield airport when we were supposed to fly from Tel Aviv to Gatwick. I had to take a £480, 4-hour taxi home to London. Now Wizzair is refusing to reimburse the taxi ride! Unreal
This is a very strange move for a supposedly independent, global news organisation.
@reuters
employs hundreds of non-U.K. journalists around the world and expects them to stand apart from the armed forces in their countries.
This is pretty darned impressive. European commissioner for the Green Deal, Frans Timmermans, answers journalists' questions in Dutch, English, German, Italian and French without flinching
@TimmermansEU
via
@EC_AVService
The TikTok War: Why High School & College Kids Are Getting The Wrong Information about Hamas & Israel
I spent the weekend trying to reverse engineer the TikTok algorithm, as I am convinced this is the reason we're losing the information war with high school & college students.
4 hours and 42 minutes of play and Carlos Alcaraz won one more point than Novak Djokovic in his incredible five-set victory in the Wimbledon final. 167 points to 166
#Israel
is in the midst of a full-blown social and constitutional crisis with a showdown happening in parliament today. Is there anything on
@reuters
front page? Not a word. Just latest update on Israeli-Palestinian fighting in the West Bank.
@FT
has it high on front page
@liamstack
@NYTBlake
@blakehounshell
What terribly sad, devastating news. Blake was such a steady voice and fine observer, a dry wit and wise head. It’s really a shock
These notes from Nov 17, 2003, are fascinating. It was a briefing by Dan Senor, spokes for the Coalition Provisional Authority, and Brig-Gen Mark Kimmitt. They were talking about hunt for Saddam Hussein and Izzat Al-Douri, his chemical weapons guy. Some choice quotes
leading to a sharp sell-off in the shekel, concerns among investors, threats from big business (particularly in the tech sector) to relocate, and murmurings from ratings agencies. Messing around with the independence of the Supreme Court is a dangerous game and has consequences
@M_PaulMcNamara
More than anything else, PPE sets you up to sound confident, knowledgeable and authoritative on conference calls, a ticket to success these days, whether you actually know what you're talking about or not
It’s hard to work out what Putin’s longer term objective is. In the short term he may well be able to seize control in Ukraine, depose Zelensky and impose his own puppet ruler. But what does he do then? Does he plan to leave Russian troops in Ukraine — a vast country — for years?
@Reuters
Here’s reporting on an attack by US on the Palestine Hotel in Baghdad on April 8, 2003, which killed my
@Reuters
colleague Taras Protsyuk and severely wounded
@samianakhoul
. I had no idea they had been hit. US army denied responsibility, then tried to cover up, before admitting
On this day in 1066, Harold was crowned king of England, before being killed shortly after by William the Conqueror. 957 years on, Harold and William are at it again
#harry
Thoroughly enjoyed
#DontLookUp
, just an excellent skewering of the absurdist post-modern world we are living in, where reality hardly matters and narrative presentation is all. In politics, media, science and tech, the joke is on the earnest or insufficiently cynical
This time 10 years ago, I was in Copenhagen for the start of Denmark's 6-month
#EU
presidency. A great trip on many levels, memorable also because
@SpiegelPeter
and
@BrunoBrussels
convinced me to join
@Twitter
. A decade on, I'm flagging but still tweeting
@PrebenEUspox
Over the past 24 hours, thousands of TikToks (at least) have been posted where people share how they just read Bin Laden’s infamous "Letter to America," in which he explained why he attacked the United States.
The TikToks are from people of all ages, races, ethnicities, and
Things you find clearing out the folks’ garage — a jigsaw puzzle from the Cunard White Star Line, when the Queen Mary was its flag ship, probably late 1930s or 1940s
Love it that in Tel Aviv there are water fountains for dogs, too. And the excess water from the human fountains goes into the dog bowl as well.
@porttlv
On this day 20 years ago — the invasion of
#Iraq
began at 0230 Zulu time. Hours later, in the midst of the desert of southwestern Iraq, we passed this boy trying to sell cigarettes to the invading
#US
troops. Would love to know where he is now and what he thinks
The wheels have been coming off the Franco-German relationship for a while (with damaging consequences for the EU). The multiple strands of the breakdown brought together well here. And look out for warmer Franco-British ties under Sunak
This is quite a scoop — and
@JakeWSimons
has form after breaking details on the killing of Iranian nuclear scientist Fakhrizadeh by Israel using a remote controlled weapon well ahead of NYT and others
A map (marked SECRET) that the
#US
military distributed to drivers of armoured vehicles, supply trucks and Humvees ahead of the invasion of
#Iraq
20 years ago. Shows invasion routes from
#Kuwait
to Baghdad
Fascinating read — pro-Putin stooges working in Germany to convince Germans to back Russia and turn against Ukraine. It’s being allowed to happen, and is it working?
Israel's counter claims. And that has persisted throughout the day even as evidence has mounted that maybe Israel wasn't to blame and it really way a misfired Islamic Jihad rocket. The scepticism is fine, but it should have been applied to Hamas as well as Israel and if wasn't