أبي إسحاق
@AbuS7ak
Followers
58
Following
172
Statuses
14
Joined May 2024
@Ohio_caliph @Frajoti123 @ridvanmemishi38 «سؤالات حمزة للدارقطني» (ص263): «سئل الدارقطني وأنا أسمع عن سماع أبي حنيفة يصح قال لا ولا رؤية ولم يلحق أبو حنيفة أحدا من الصحابة»
0
0
1
@ShahSuleimanI @TheEaste2 @Frajoti123 So are Imam Ahmad, Malik, al-Bukhari and Abu Zur'ah zanadiqah or kuf.far according to you?
0
0
1
@GuyReadingBooks @h4q3r @Abo_rebey @Ishaq3015 @Raaaatiba Your friend dismissed the claim that Malik Ahmad and Shafi'i criticized Abu Hanifa and said the narrations are weak, he should either retract that statement or show the weakness in all of the athars I sent
1
0
0
@GuyReadingBooks @h4q3r @Abo_rebey @Ishaq3015 @Raaaatiba So, they're authentic right? Imam Malik and Ahmad said these things about him?
1
0
1
@GuyReadingBooks @h4q3r @Abo_rebey @Ishaq3015 @Raaaatiba Hi now don’t respond to a question with another question, are these athars weak?
1
0
1
@ProAdil_27 @abd_allaah_1 @spirit_pool @JustALaymen @FawaidAlUlama Amazing response, but before you log off would you mind telling me what's the ruling on saying the Islam of Abu Hanifa is differed upon, or what's the ruling on someone who makes such a claim?
0
0
1
@ProAdil_27 @abd_allaah_1 @spirit_pool @JustALaymen @FawaidAlUlama I am aware of Ibn 'Abd al-Barr's attempts at defending Abu Hanifa, this doesn't change the fact that Ibn al-Jarud transmitted an ikhtilaf on his Islam (not even on him being an Imam, just him being a Muslim lol), how can you claim he was accepted by the entire Ummah after that?
1
0
3
@Iftiininka I'll post everything against soon along with some new stuff, just wanted to clear my profile
0
0
1
@ProAdil_27 @abd_allaah_1 @spirit_pool @JustALaymen @FawaidAlUlama "The whole Ummah acknowledges al-Imām al-A'zam" Not exactly...
1
0
2