the encampments at Columbia were great, some of the first moments of utopic breakthrough of the entire year--education could be a lot more free, in every sense of the word, if we wished it
Having children is the most meaningful thing you can do with your life. Intellectuals and creatives can't accept this because it means their vocations aren't supremely meaningful and any fool can have a more worthwhile life. But it's true and all the counterarguments are cope.
I stopped reading JD V*nce's book when he talked about how his Indian-American wife spends "too much money" on mangoes. Telling Indian people how much money they can spend on mangoes is a hate crime.
I promise u can go to Yale and be normal... you just have to believe that the relatively random event of getting into a college at age 18 is not the greatest accomplishment of your life past or future...
I read an ethnography many years ago (Life on Easy Street) that explained how because wealthy people have no real or structural difficulties, they seek to inculcate values in their children through manufacturing petty struggles like this...
we've started law review season, and as an Articles Editor for Columbia Law Review, I thought I might explain a few things that I think about--
1) abstracts matter tremendously; a bad abstract fails to make the stakes clear, fatal unless the editor cares abt the topic already
extraordinarily proud that my colleagues
@columlrev
and I were able to develop this exceptional Article on the Nakba and the need for more precise legal concepts in discussing world-shaping violence.
@thaqafatalhind
is this something that people are told about/can refuse? that is, can any of these individuals choose to boycott or is their being awarded the prize indicative of their choice to accept it?
this is a death spiral, right? overenforcing fares + raising fares + shitty service will probably decrease ridership, leading to worse ridership, etc. ad mortem
Depressing to see colleagues here trying to shame young historians for accepting the Dan David prizes. It's one thing to argue for BDS as a way of putting pressure on Israel (not that I agree with this). It's another to call people "complicit"...
In a show of solidarity with those facing the most extreme repression across the pro-Palestine movement, Hind's Hall arrestees who have been offered deals by the DA have chosen not to accept them.
Press conference at 4pm today @ 100 Centre St in Manhattan
As 100s of students were arrested for exercising their right to p/assembly in support of
#Palestine
, I remind
@Columbia
to respect academic freedoms and student’s fundamental rights. The right to p/assembly is key for people to speak out against injustices& to mobilise for
#peace
where you choose to live is so significant... my sister moved to the Bay area and started dating someone w a Tesla; I moved to New York and entered psychoanalysis
I may come back with more, but this sticks out to me at 11pm today. I hope this is helpful to folks submitting now or in the future. I love being an editor, and I am happy to talk to folks in my DMs with questions (though I cannot offer feedback, of course) .
Everyone is talking about the student protests. But *stunning* how little we've heard from student organizers themselves. We asked some to explain their aims and concerns. If you read one thing about the protests today, read this:
missing my friends from college... we were so generous with our attention then... it felt like the point of college was to focus our attention on each other and our relationships
i want to write an essay for a mag where i reflect on the CRT laws, being a kid of color in a 91% white community, and what i had to do with my bad and monstrous feelings--any ideas for a pub/takers?
2) word counts matter a lot too, unfortunately. for CLR, we look for pieces between 15 and 30k. 30k for me is a hard limit, not necessarily for others, but the sweet spot is really around 25k (we anticipate adding several thousand words in the editing process, mostly BTL)
will universities denounce the doxxing and violence that pro-Palestine students and student groups are facing? if not, universities' allegiances to Zionism and its financial/psychic investments in apartheid are stronger than their purported allegiances to students
on the one hand yes there's obviously irony here and also... treating an institution as monolithic, not made of actors, is what leads to facile eyerolling. the librarians and archivists are not the fascists, many are supportive... roll your eyes, but do it in a reasoned way
Columbia is already archiving banners, artwork, and other materials from Hind Hall, even as the students who occupied the hall are still suspended and facing possible expulsion.
all my experiences this year are just making me more of a historical materialist...your relationship to production really is The Thing that determines all the other things
presenting a paper on Wynter/Fanon/Derrida at this on Thursday evening! let me know if you are interested/can't wait to meet some of you as interlocutors
The Caribbean Philosophical Association Annual Conference XXI | Twenty Years of Shifting the Geography of Reason: Continuing the Struggle | June 22-24, 2023 | Online Conference | For more information, visit:
that's so shocking...someone who was invested in the cult of his own personality, founded on certain white-soothing pablum, did not have practices that actually served or supported people of color...i never would have guessed....
The mismanagement of this center was one of the worst kept secrets at BU, and not only did it hurt the cause of social justice and “anti racism” but also people who worked in a toxic environment or were fired unceremoniously (and not just now). A sad mess.
hello, go read my piece (and many, many others) in Lux!!
@elsdor
's book is an exceptionally rich account of how violence has conceptually developed in the West, and it was such a pleasure to spend time with her rich critiques.
Violence: it's cool when they do it, it's a problem when I do it 🗣️
New online,
@antibhadrata
reviews Elsa Dorlin's new book, Self-Defense: A Philosophy of Violence for Lux and calls for a genealogy of self-defense that we can actually use
The Columbia Law Review board of directors tanked the site after it published their first Palestinian.
Directors said they'd restore it if students agreed to put a disclaimer on the essay.
Students said no & pledged a work strike if the piece stays blocked.
I could write a book about how the culture rn is opposite the hipster culture of a generation ago, where only liking popular things and incuriosity are seen as virtues but knowing a lot/having eclectic tastes/becoming an expert are seen as pretentious and even immoral.
hello--i am very fortunate to have my Note on gender-affirming care (GAC) forthcoming in
@ColumLRev
; i have posted a pre-print on SSRN.
I do a couple of things in this paper:
@HugeHatLogan
@charlie_victr
people should read derrida's monolingualism of the other, which argues the same--which i think are correct! even as we cannot see each other plainly or have perfect knowledge of each other, this only makes our need to connect and developing the faculty to do so more urgent!
.
@NYCMayor
has been briefed on the incident involving former President Trump in Pennsylvania & continues to get updates.
Out of an abundance of caution, the NYPD will be increasing its presence across the city, including at Trump Tower, 40 Wall Street, Foley Square, & City Hall.
students were arrested and evicted from the encampment--at least one appears to have been beaten; other students have begun to occupy the other lawn--in awe of undergrads' courage
7) we look for work that will make a lasting impact, which usually means analyzing a single court case (even if it seems to signal a trend, in your view) will not be very compelling. more compelling work is less speculative/forecasting and more analytical.
3) strong pieces are clear about the stakes of the intervention, as I said, which usually means it clearly explains why the doctrine/practice is affected and how it'll affect real people, especially if some impacts will be felt harder than others
plans for today--eat some leftover beans from yesterday's friendsgiving, read a novel or two, light a candle i made some months ago, revise a paper, wear my pearls
claims on the basis of identity are Over! now we are making claims on the basis of Being Right!
(why? because identity has proven thin moral grounding if any, easily metabolized by neoliberalism)
I haven't felt optimistic re universities in a long time but the density and cowardice of white faculty members--the unwillingness to go on strike (why not? all your students just got beaten up, arrested, and held in jail, so why pontificate to an empty room?) still shocks me
5) for interdisciplinary pieces (legal history, law & econ, etc.) it is important to explain (in the piece or in the cover letter) why law rev is the appropriate place for your piece-- "lawyers will find it interesting" is insufficient, it should impact legal thinking or practice
9) we read 10+ pieces daily in the thick of the cycle, and many more abstracts/intros. we appreciate authors submit polished pieces that accord w our guidelines and thought abt why CLR is the right fit. even if we can't accept you, you will likely get a faster decision.
Okay so, yes! Dissents do not have force of law like majority opinions. But do people understand why lawyers care about dissents? It's not just outrage--dissents offer alternative legal reasoning, and furnish arguments that lawyers will make in challenging the court's decision.
The fawning over dissents is so embarrassing because it’s literally all y’all got. No guts, no plan, no protest, no action, no strategy. They out-planned, out-organized, out-couraged you for decades and no lesson has been learned.
i don't claim to know anything about the students in the encampment but these kids are fucking tough...they've been arrested and suspended and i just don't think arresting them again is going to faze them
8) we get a lot of work on some areas (statutory and constitutional interpretation, antitrust), but we try to publish in diverse areas, so your piece may be extremely strong, but we already took one in your field earlier in the cycle. our Aug cycle has far fewer slots than Feb.
6) your analytic method should be superior to others for the purposes of your argument. often I see empirical pieces where the empirical analysis does not seem to add to the piece, though I could see this happen with other methods as well.
interesting... my friends and I talk about how much money we are making all the time. it lets us know if we're being undervalued and helps us decide who is taking the check
we all make within a fairly narrow range and are educationally homogenous, so that plays a role no doubt
very grateful to friends and comrades like
@TaliaRothstein
for their work and attentive listening.
@ColumLRev
's strike is ongoing and should be a major focus of attention in discussions of academic freedom at law schools. Academic freedom is a working condition.
.
@TaliaRothstein
puts the
@ColumLRev
strike for editorial independence in context of a nationwide movement to see student law review work as work that should be paid. I especially like their point that organizing itself is politically useful.
"neurotypical" and its oppositions ("neurodiverse," "neuroatypical," etc.) seem to me to have outlived their utility...the frame has become so generalized as to fail to describe much of anything, and people use it in the most self-adulating ways...
I am seeing ppl in the comments calling books "lazy pedagogy"... i am astounded! I would like to remind everyone that BOOKS have been one of the primary drivers of social transformation for literally many centuries
Yesterday we were notified by our University president that starting fall 2024 that we will no longer be allowed to assign any resources (books etc) in any class in an effort to reduce cost burden on students.
submitted a comment in support of clarifications to the
@ABAesq
standards on academic freedom and journal work on behalf of the (still striking!!) editors of
@ColumLRev
!!
had a Very Racist incident w a professor at the law school and nobody is either a) offering meaningful support or b) trying to provide an actual meaningful solution :^)
"Withholding is not just the structure of seduction — it structures desire itself."
@antibhadrata
reviews Hilton Als's memoir-essay, MY PINUP (
@NewDirections
):
extraordinarily proud that my colleagues
@columlrev
and I were able to develop this exceptional Article on the Nakba and the need for more precise legal concepts in discussing world-shaping violence.
so what is the remedy? besides--apartheid is, i think, the least of Israel's violations of international law; they have been extraordinarily explicit about their genocidal intent
International Court of Justice advisory opinion on Israel’s regime in the occupied Palestinian territory: colonisation, annexation, racial discrimination, denial of self determination. Israel’s presence is unlawful. Restitution, reparation, dismantlement of the settlements/wall.
Canadian b*rder patrol officer was so annoying to me... I just said I've never been to Montréal so I just want to see everything and he said "it's a big city... how will you see everything??"
man im just a silly goofy guy trying to decompress from school and bank runs
courage is a muscle... I think there are many reasons student power matters (and many reasons it does not) but teaching students to recognize the "non-opacity of their agency" through the practical work of advocating for one's principles does seem to have clear knock on effects
We have reviewed the paper, authored by Professor Sanjay Reddy, about university finances. We want the community to be aware that this paper includes information that is misleading or incorrect:
it's cool or interesting that law schools offer courses on crt/race but my experience is that law students, being narrow thinkers and deeply self-interested, cannot have very interesting or transformative conversations about race and i would rather take blackletter law
this 🤡 teaches at a california cc; i asked my dad, who just retired from ~30 years at a csu, what he thought about DEI at the CSU:
"There are seven white people who tell us what they think we should do. Why should I listen to them?"
“I’m a professor of chemistry. How am I supposed to incorporate DEI into my classroom instruction?” asked Reedley College professor Bill Blanken. “What’s the ‘anti-racist’ perspective on the atomic mass of boron?”
will never forget when my 6th grade teacher said "tomorrow is clash day. apparently it means you should wear clothes that don't go together. but when I look around, it seems like you all treat every day as clash day."